How the NFL’s All-Pro voting system needs to be fixed

The 50 media members who vote for the NFL’s All-Pro team seem to need a little help getting it right. Here are a few suggestions.

There are those who will tell you that the votes for Pro Bowl and All-Pro selections aren’t a big deal. It’s just a popularity contest, right? Well, not really. A lot of players have bonuses built into their contracts based on their nominations on those teams. Hall of Fame voters absolutely take the number of Pro Bowl and All-Pro selections into account when deciding who is given the NFL’s greatest honor.

The All-Pro vote is supposed to be taken more seriously because there is not a fan element involved, but when looking at the selections from a panel of 50 media members, it’s hard to say that every vote should be given equal weight. And that, for all the reasons listed above, is a real problem. Here’s the list for the 2019 team; see what you think, and give these five suggestions for improving the process a look-see.

Give every voter a subscription to an advanced metrics website.

Frank Clark’s one defensive tackle vote was not well-deserved. (Jay Biggerstaff-USA TODAY Sports)

Whether it’s Pro Football Focus, Sports Info Solutions, or Football Outsiders, there are websites which, for a nominal subscription rate, give anybody a much better look at who’s doing what in the NFL. I’m not talking about PFF’s grades, per se — I find them far less accurate than their charting stats. But those charting stats have a lot of merit, as do the SiS and FO numbers. With these subscriptions, you can do everything from deducing which quarterbacks and receivers are the best on which routes, which outside cornerbacks and slot cornerbacks are the most effective in coverage, which teams run which defenses most effectively, and which pass-rushers are the most disruptive beyond just sack numbers. There are too many votes that are obviously skewed to old-school box-score thinking, and we should be way past that at this point in time. We have better metrics, and the game has exploded in both complexity and positional specificity.

PFF also has positional snap counts, which would have helped the one voter who wanted to add Chiefs defensive end Frank Clark to the list of interior linemen. Per PFF, Clark has 718 defensive snaps this season, and six of those are inside — one at left defensive tackle, four at right defensive tackle, and one at nose tackle. We don’t know what this voter was thinking, but we’d sure like to.

And speaking of that…

The worst Pro Bowl picks — and the players who should replace them

The worst Pro Bowl picks — and the players who should replace them

 

The worst Pro Bowl picks — and the players who should replace them

Every year, a group of undeserving players are named to the Pro Bowl. Here’s this year’s list, and the players who should replace them.

If you think the Pro Bowl is a meaningless exercise, don’t tell the fans, players, and teams when somebody on their side is snubbed in the process. Every year, there are deserving players who aren’t voted to the Pro Bowl roster, and every year, there are players who get on more through previous reputation than current performance.

Here are the most egregious omissions in the 2019 voting, with thought on which players these unfortunate snubs should replace. Because if you’re going to complain about a player who’s wrongly off the Pro Bowl roster, you should be able to find a guy who’s taking up space. That’s where things get a bit more difficult!

Quarterback (NFC)

In: Dak Prescott or Kirk Cousins
Out: Aaron Rodgers

(Matthew Emmons-USA TODAY Sports)

Either Prescott or Cousins would be a better fit on the NFC roster than Aaron Rodgers, who had just three games with more than 300 passing yards this season, three games with less than 200 yards passing, and eight games with one or zero touchdowns. Cousins has been on fire after a rough start to the season, and Prescott ranks first in Football Outsiders’ opponent-adjusted efficiency metrics. Not that Rodgers has had a bad season, but this seems much more like a reputation pick than anything else.

Receiver (AFC)

In: Julian Edelman
Out: Jarvis Landry

(Winslow Townson-USA TODAY Sports)

Landry has been one of Cleveland’s few bright spots on offense this season, but it’s kind of ridiculous to have him in over Edelman, who was part of a total snub of New England offensive players that hasn’t happened since 2003. Yes, Landry has 74 catches on 1,018 yards and five touchdowns, but Edelman has 92 catches for 1,019 yards and six touchdowns in an offense so broken, opposing defenses can bracket him on just about every play. Edelman has faced more double teams than at any other point in his career, and he’s having arguably his most productive season.

Alabama football: 7 former Tide standouts voted to NFL Pro Bowl

Alabama has become a factory for NFL teams looking to add high-quality talent through the draft. The recent voting for the 2019 Pro Bowl is a perfect representation of that notion. On Tuesday night, the rosters were revealed and included seven …

Alabama has become a factory for NFL teams looking to add high-quality talent through the draft. The recent voting for the 2019 Pro Bowl is a perfect representation of that notion.

On Tuesday night, the rosters were revealed and included seven former Crimson Tide standouts, including:

  • Derrick Henry, RB, Tennessee Titans
  • Mark Ingram, RB, Baltimore Ravens
  • Julio Jones, WR, Atlanta Falcons
  • Dont’a Hightower, LB, New England Patriots
  • Marlon Humphrey, CB, Baltimore Ravens
  • Minkah Fitzpatrick, S, Pittsburgh Steelers
  • Eddie Jackson, S, Chicago Bears

In addition to those players, other former Alabama standouts, such as Raiders rookie running back Josh Jacobs and Colts offensive center Ryan Kelly, were named as Pro Bowl alternates.

The Crimson Tide continues its takeover of the NFL.

[lawrence-auto-related count=3]

2020 NFL Pro Bowl: Which Ravens should be selected

The Baltimore Ravens sit atop the NFL and with the 2020 Pro Bowl rosters to drop tonight, several players should get recognized for it.

The NFL is set to announce the 2020 Pro Bowl roster later this evening. And with the Baltimore Ravens sitting at 12-2 and leading several respective positions in fan voting, it got me wondering which players should actually make their way into the Pro Bowl this season?

Of course, the ultimate hope is Baltimore has to have all their players turn down the event as they prepare for Super Bowl LIV. But regardless, this is a golden opportunity for many players to get their very first Pro Bowl nod and for some others to continue their streak. So let’s take a look at the 13 Ravens players I believe should be selected to the 2020 Pro Bowl.

QB Lamar Jackson

Photo by Scott Taetsch/Getty Images

A Pro Bowl appears to be nothing more than a formality at this stage. Jackson led every NFL player in fan votes by a wide margin. And given his MVP-caliber season on top of it, Jackson not making the cut would be worthy of a headline all its own.

But just in case anyone is unsure why Jackson should get a Pro Bowl nod, Neil Dutton went through all the Ravens franchise records Jackson has already set. Add to it breaking Michael Vick’s single-season rushing record, leading the league in touchdown passes, TD% and QBR seems like good enough reasons by themselves for Jackson to get his first Pro Bowl nomination.

Behind enemy lines: Bills Q&A preview with Ravens Wire

The Bills host the Broncos in Week 14 at New Era Field.

The Bills host the Broncos in Week 14 at New Era Field. To learn more about Sunday’s visitors, we spoke to Matthew Stevens, Ravens Wire’s Managing Editor, to learn more about Ravens:

We all see Lamar Jackson’s amazing playmaking skills, but what about his passing? Five touchdowns in a game, twice, is no easy task.

Don’t forget his two perfect 158.3 passer rating games this season — tying Ben Roethlisberger and Peyton Manning as the only quarterbacks to have more than one in a single season. Jackson has grown leaps and bounds as a passer this season and I feel like that’s because of the work he put in this offseason. Jackson worked with two quarterback gurus on his mechanics and that shows in games when he’s far more consistent in his accuracy. Coming into the league, Jackson was underrated in being able to read a field, defense and in his football IQ, and with his accuracy improved, we’re seeing it all come together for him as a complete package.

I think it would be a mistake to ignore how his rushing ability and that of the Ravens’ offense as a whole impact Jackson’s elevation in throwing the football. The threat of Baltimore to run the football — either inside with power or outside with speed — cause defenders to keep their eyes in the backfield. That half second of indecision and less than 100% focus on their own responsibility has opened up passing lanes and helped receivers get wide open at times. More than I ever remember in the Ravens’ history, this offense is finally starting to see some pitch-and-catch completions that don’t require the ball to be thread into a football-sized hole between three defenders. While some of Jackson’s detractors have used this notion to downplay his success, I don’t think you see this same level of success without a player of Jackson’s athleticism throwing the football.

Like any quarterback, he isn’t perfect in every game. But his five interceptions this season have come in just two games and three of them were on effectively hail mary passes or what should have been called defensive pass interference. So he’s done a great job limiting any errors that he does have to simple incompletions instead of turnovers, which has been a large reason Baltimore has done so well offensively. Even if his other stats aren’t fantastic, not making game-breaking mistakes can often be enough to squeak by in any close games they have, much like they did last week against the 49ers.

Which do the Ravens struggle with more, if at all: Covering slot receivers or outside receivers? Aka: Should the Bills look to Cole Beasley or John Brown more?

Without a doubt, it’s the slot receivers that can kill this defense. Baltimore has more than enough talent at cornerback to completely shut down a passing attack with the combination of Jimmy Smith, Marlon Humphrey, Brandon Carr and Marcus Peters, along with safeties Chuck Clark and Earl Thomas. But where they get bit so often this season is in zone coverages or if a slot receiver gets into a bubble where he’s covered by a linebacker. If you look back to the first four weeks of the season, it was those transition points that saw receivers so wide open a Ravens player wouldn’t even be on the same television screen in the broadcast. They’ve settled down quite a bit in this area by adding linebackers L.J. Fort, Josh Bynes and Peters at cornerback but that’s still absolutely the area to attack, especially if you can get the run game going a bit as well.

The Ravens only allow an average of 1.9 sacks per game. So how well does the Ravens’ O-line pass block? That’s a low number, but the question is, are they blocking well, or is it more Lamar escaping would-be sackers?

Baltimore has an odd mix of guys that I think are underrated. Most people know of Marshal Yanda or at least will when he eventually dons a golden jacket in the Hall of Fame, but Ronnie Stanley is arguably the best left tackle in football right now while right tackle Orlando Brown Jr. is solid and steadily improving as well. Center Matt Skura is on injured reserve now but he was playing really good football alongside guard Bradley Bozeman. Even Patrick Mekari, coming in to replace Skura, has done well in limited action. It would be unfair to say Jackson is the reason for their success when they’ve played so well by themselves.

But at the same time, it would be unfair to Jackson to say he doesn’t help bail them out at times. Where other quarterbacks get stuck holding onto the ball for too long and taking coverage sacks, Jackson is often able to find open field in front of him and won’t hesitate to take advantage of it if he’s not seeing anyone open. Where young quarterbacks often struggle to feel pressure at the correct times and move around the pocket in the correct direction, Jackson seemingly has radar in his brain and does an excellent job of moving just enough from within the pocket to buy extra time, even if he never takes off running.

But just like with Jackson’s success as a passer has to do with defenders being a little cautious with him, that’s the same when trying to bring him down. No one wants to be on a highlight reel tackling thin air thanks to a quick cut by Jackson that sees him bolt for 30 yards and a touchdown, even though we’ve still seen it happen A LOT this season alone. Pass rushers often are left playing more contain as the defense tries to shrink the pocket in an effort to not get burned by Jackson’s legs. So even super talented pass rushers are hobbled a bit because they can’t be as aggressive as they might want to be.

As a defense as a whole, how do the Ravens defend the run? Currently No. 6 in terms of yards allow, but also have allowed 11 rushing scores and allow 4.5 yards per carry. Is that No. 6 because teams can’t run against them, or because they can’t slow down the offense?

I think it’s a little of both things. Baltimore defenses pride themselves on shutting down the run and have since forever, so it’s something that gets ingrained into every defender from the second they put on a Ravens helmet to run downhill and hit the ball carrier as a swarm. Baltimore has one of the few defenses where you’ll actually see all 11 players try to make a tackle on every single play — something defensive backs around the league are well known to try and avoid when possible. That goes a long way towards at least being solid against the run, even if not spectacular in a given year. But you’re also right that the offense putting up points early and often has forced opponents to completely abandon the run in an effort to keep up.

The Ravens have seen the fewest rushing attempts against them this season but they allow the 11th-most (tied) rushing yards-per-attempt, which ultimately evens things out a bit overall. If a team has a fast running back that can hit the edges quickly and some good outside blocking, Baltimore is going to struggle. Just look at Week 13 for a prime example of the Ravens failing to stop that style of run as Raheem Mostert kept breaking off huge runs until the fourth quarter when Baltimore finally brought down some help to compensate. I don’t think it’s something that can or will last for a full game but the Ravens love keeping in extra defensive backs and that can bite them in the run game at times.

What’s your predict and a little analysis on how you think this one will turn out?

Since Week 7, Baltimore has been unstoppable and has looked the part too. While Jackson and this offense have been getting all the credit, the defense has stepped up massively since Week 5 and it’s allowing the Ravens to get out to large early leads. This might sound cocky but quite a few times this season when Baltimore gets out to a 14-point lead, I’ve told my editing counterparts the game is already over — whether that be in the first quarter or later has been irrelevant.

The Ravens might be the most well balanced team in football right now and that makes beating them tough. You need to have an defense that can at least limit Jackson and what he can do without overselling in any one area. The second a defense has to sell out to stop the pass or the run is the moment offensive coordinator Greg Roman attacks the hole where those defenders just came from. So that requires a stout defense all all three levels, which is asking a lot. But even if you have that, you still need to have an offense capable of running over Baltimore’s defense with a quarterback that can been efficient and careful. The Ravens’ defense has played aggressive football and they’ve been snatching takeaways (they have the fifth-best turnover percentage in the league). That gives Jackson and this prolific offense a short field and only increases their chances of putting up points. It ends up being a vicious cycle if an opponent messes up in any way, which applies so much pressure to a team to play clean football but still be aggressive.

While I like what the Bills have going on, I don’t think there’s a player on that defense that can stop Jackson one-on-one. Which means they’ll either have to use more defenders to play the run which will open up the pass or they’ll allow Jackson and the running backs to run all over them while they try not to get beat downfield. That’s not sustainable for 60 minutes without giving up points and long, time-consuming drives, which has been the killer of most of Baltimore’s opponents this season. So I’m picking the Ravens and by a wide margin this week.

Ravens 34 – Bills 10

[lawrence-related id=50341,50295,50321,50315]

Ravens vs. Bills: Who’s playing and who isn’t in Week 14

The Baltimore Ravens have no players already ruled out but with four listed as “questionable,” there could be some concern in Week 14.

The Baltimore Ravens and Buffalo Bills will enter Week 14 against each other fairly healthy. Both the Ravens and Bills have very few names on their final injury reports and even fewer with their game status in question.

For Baltimore, they have just four players listed as “questionable.” While seeing Marlon Humphrey and Marquise Brown among them is concerning, there’s some upside for both. Humphrey had been limited in the first two practices but returned to full participation today. Brown wasn’t even on the injury report on Wednesday and was also a full participant on Friday. If Friday’s final injury report is any indication, all four players should be able to suit up this week.

Baltimore Ravens game status:

WR Marquise Brown (ankle) – Questionable
CB Marlon Humphrey (thigh) – Questionable
LB Patrick Onwuasor (ankle) – Questionable
WR Seth Roberts (knee) – Questionable


Buffalo Bills game status:

T Ty Nsekhe (ankle) – Out

Nsekhe is Buffalo’s backup left tackle, so being ruled out already isn’t exactly a killer. But Nsekhe has played a decent number of snaps every week he’s been healthy, seeing no fewer than 27% of the offensive snaps in a game this season.

That could end up affecting how the Bills run the football, something they’ll need to do effectively to keep up with the Ravens. But with Baltimore being able to sack quarterbacks 15 times over the last five games, quarterback Josh Allen won’t like missing a key blocker in front of him either.

Ravens Week 13 snap counts: Lamar Jackson actually plays entire game

The Baltimore Ravens were in a dogfight in their 20-17 win over the San Francisco 49ers. We analyze the Ravens snap counts for Week 13.

The Baltimore Ravens found themselves in a dogfight in their 20-17 win over the San Francisco 49ers in Week 13. Any debate about whether or not the Ravens are the best team in the NFL can be put to rest.

Baltimore is on an eight-game winning streak, but this game was by far their toughest during that stretch. After winning five straight by at least two touchdowns, and the last three games with a margin of victory over 30 points, the 49ers battled with the Ravens until the final whistle. The talk of this being a potential Super Bowl LIV preview was justified.

With San Francisco keeping this game tight, it was the first time in a few weeks in which the Ravens starters played the whole game. Quarterback Lamar Jackson and the entire offensive line played every snap. The significance of the big guys playing all 65 offensive snaps is escaping with no injuries upfront. Jackson gets all the attention, but Baltimore’s beef on the line is not getting the love they deserve.

It is also worth noting tight end Nick Boyle was the only other Raven on offense to see at least 90% of snaps. Wide receiver Marquise Brown was next in line but was on the field for just 57% of the offensive plays. That goes to points towards a more heavy front Baltimore used in an effort to combat the fearsome 49ers front, including Nick Bosa.

Boyle is often used as an extra blocker and rarely makes the stat sheet, but his share of playing time is significantly higher than the other two tight ends. Boyle was in on 60 plays, while Mark Andrews (28) and Hayden Hurst (23) combined for 61 snaps. The latter two each caught three passes to tie for the team lead, while Boyle had just one reception.

Baltimore Ravens offensive snap counts:

Player Position Snaps %
Ronnie Stanley OT 65 100%
Orlando Brown OT 65 100%
Bradley Bozeman C 65 100%
Patrick Mekari OG 65 100%
Marshall Yanda OG 65 100%
Lamar Jackson QB 65 100%
Nick Boyle TE 60 92%
Marquise Brown WR 37 57%
Mark Ingram RB 36 55%
Seth Roberts WR 32 49%
Mark Andrews TE 28 43%
Patrick Ricard FB 26 40%
Miles Boykin WR 25 38%
Gus Edwards RB 25 38%
Willie Snead WR 25 38%
Hayden Hurst TE 23 35%
Justice Hill RB 4 6%
James Hurst OG 4 6%

Click on the next page to see the defensive snap counts for the Ravens’ Week 13 win over the 49ers.

[vertical-gallery id=38029]

4 cool stats from Ravens’ win over 49ers

The Baltimore Ravens beat the San Francisco 49ers in Week 13. But they also managed to find several franchise records in the process.

The Baltimore Ravens have taken down yet another foe, this time the San Francisco 49ers in Week 13. In beating the 49ers, 20-17, the Ravens continue their winning streak as they march towards the postseason.

If you weren’t playing close enough attention, you might have missed some pretty amazing stats from this game.

Lamar Jackson climbing the charts

Photo by Patrick Smith/Getty Images

With his 101 rushing yards, Jackson moves firmly into second on the NFL’s most single-season rushing yards by a quarterback list. His 977 rushing yards through 12 games is just 62 fewer than Michael Vick’s total from 2006. That means Jackson needs to average just 16 yards in each of the four remaining games to take the record by the end of the season.

In this process, Jackson has broken yet another record. Week 13 marked his fourth 100-yard rushing game this season, beating a tie between Vick and Russell Wilson at three.

But that’s not all folks. Remember all the people that said Jackson can’t throw the football? Well, after 13 weeks, here’s where Jackson ranks in a number of key passing stats:

Passing TDs: 1st (25)
Passing TD%: 1st (7.8%)
Passer rating: 4th (109.6)
Long pass: 4th (83 yards)
Passing yards per attempt: 9th (7.9 yards)
Interceptions: 2nd fewest among quarterbacks with 12 starts (5)
INT%: 7th (1.55%)

Jackson is a top quarterback in every major category outside of passing yards. When combined with how prolific he is on the ground and the trail of broken records behind him, it’s clear Jackson is something special.

[vertical-gallery id=38029]

7 studs, no duds from Ravens’ 45-6 win vs. Rams

The Baltimore Ravens blew out the Los Angeles Rams in Week 12 but these seven players are deserving of special recognition for their play

The Baltimore Ravens once again were doubted entering the week. And once again, they handled their business by beating the Los Angeles Rams 45-6 in Week 12.

With such a lopsided score, I can’t in good conscience say any player on Baltimore’s roster was a dud. Even if I could pick out a player that didn’t have an amazing game, not a single Ravens player had a dud-worthy performance. So I present, the seven biggest studs of Baltimore’s Week 12 win over Los Angeles.

Stud: QB, Lamar Jackson

Jackson started the game 9-of-9 for 87 yards and three touchdown passes. His first six runs went for 80 yards and yet another highlight-reel addition. Jackson being perfect to start the game was why they got out to such a large lead and were able to coast.

Jackson finished the game early in this blowout, giving way to backup Robert Griffin III in the fourth quarter. Jackson’s night ended with him completing 15-of-20 passes for 169 yards, five touchdown throws, no interceptions and a 139.4 passer rating. He added 95 yards on just eight runs.

Against a very talented defense, Jackson made sure he’ll earn a unanimous MVP award this season.