Searching for fantasy football value among Houston’s receivers

Are there any diamonds in the rough to be uncovered in Houston’s WR corps?

Not much went right for the Houston Texans in 2022, and that included their passing offense. With quarterback Davis Mills stumbling through an unremarkable sophomore campaign, the Texans finished 31st in total offense and 25th in passing with 196.7 yards per game through the air. It should come as no surprise that their leading receiver finished with 699 yards, which ranked 53rd in the NFL.

While that certainly wasn’t impressive, it’s worth noting the wideout who accumulated those 699 yards was Brandin Cooks, who was traded to the Dallas Cowboys during the offseason, removing the one proven upper-tier target on the club. To help soften the blow, Houston signed a pair of veterans in receivers Robert Woods and Noah Brown. It then spent a couple of draft picks on WRs Nathaniel Dell and Xavier Hutchinson. They’ll also be counting on the return of WR John Metchie III, who missed his entire rookie season after being diagnosed with leukemia.

Of course, the biggest addition might be that of QB C.J. Stroud, who was selected second overall. The Ohio State product is considered a polished commodity coming out of college, and the hope is that he can hit the ground running. Let’s see what all that means for fantasy owners looking for some value at the receiver position in Houston.

Fantasy football preview: Houston Texans wide receivers

What should fantasy owners expect from the Houston receiving corps?

There were times last season that the Houston Texans scarcely resembled a professional football team, lowlighted by an eight-game losing streak during which they were outscored 237-91 (that’s a whopping 11.4 points per game). Then-rookie quarterback Davis Mills took his lumps filling in for an injured Tyrod Taylor, now on the New York Giants, but those hard lessons may have paid off as Mills played fairly well over the final five weeks and will enter 2022 as the starter.

While it’s too early to call the passing game rejuvenated, it at least has the potential to generate some respectable fantasy football producers, particularly if Mills continues to show improvement. With that in mind, let’s look at the top of Houston’s wide receiver depth chart.

Brandin Cooks

Wherever he goes and from whomever he catches balls, Cooks delivers. To that end, the well-traveled wideout posted a 90-1,037-6 line serving as the primary target for Mills and Taylor. It was the sixth 1,000-yard effort in eight NFL seasons, and his second in a row since joining the Texans. There was some belief that Houston would trade Cooks as part of their rebuild, but the team handed him a lucrative, two-year extension instead with the expectation he’d be their No. 1 receiver.

[lawrence-related id=466104]

Improvement from Mills and better talent around him should prevent defenses from focusing too much of their attention on Cooks, who at 29 should still be in his prime. He may not be the flashiest receiver, and it’s easy to forget he’s out there when he’s languishing in Houston, but it’s hard to find fault in Cooks’ long-term durability and consistency.

John Metchie III

Had he not torn his ACL during the SEC Championship Game in December, Metchie likely would’ve been drafted in the first round. Instead, he fell to the Texans with the 44th overall selection. While the injury is the big news, let’s start with the scouting report. At 5-foot-11, 187 pounds, Metchie isn’t a big target, nor is he someone who is going to take the top off coverage. The Alabama product is more a possession receiver with refined route-running skills, good hands, and some elusiveness after the catch.

The rookie will likely slide into the No. 2 role whenever he’s healthy, but just six months clear of his injury it’s too early to nail down when that’ll be. For his part, Metchie has stated he’ll be ready to practice in July when training camp opens, but the team hasn’t put a timetable on it. Given the status of the Texans as a non-contender it’d be surprising (and short-sighted) to rush Metchie back on the field. As such, his rehab could certainly linger into the regular season.

Nico Collins

A third-round pick in last year’s draft, Collins (33-446-1) finished second on the club in receptions, receiving yards, and yards per catch (13.5) as a rookie. Compared to Cooks and Metchie, Collins (6-foot-4, 215 pounds) is a giant, and he has enough speed to get deep down the field.

While his physical credentials are impressive, Collins still has work to do with consistently catching the ball. His youth and upside should give him a clear advantage over retreads like Chris Conley and Phillip Dorsett to serve as one of the top-three wideouts for Houston this year.

Fantasy football outlook

If you’re looking for a steady producer to plug into your lineup as a low-end WR2 or really strong WR3, Cooks is your man. He’s never had a true monster season, but he’s finished with between 1,025 and 1,225 yards in six of his last seven years.

Metchie will be a desirable get in dynasty formats, but those in single-year leagues should view him as a late-round curiosity with modest upside.

Collins is interesting based on how different his body type is, which could make him a popular red-zone target, but he probably tops out as watch-list fodder.

Rookie Rundown: WR Nico Collins, Michigan

Collins brings size and plus-speed to the NFL ranks.

Michigan Wolverines wideout Nico Collins did himself a solid at his school’s pro day, running a faster time than expected and showing fluidity some may not have expected from such a large target.

Collins sat out the 2020 season, due to COVID-19 concerns, so teams have two full seasons of tape to rely on to assess just what to expect at the next level.

Height: 6-foot-4
Weight: 215 pounds
40 time: 4.42 seconds

Collins proved to be a downfield weapon in his time at U of M. He was hardly involved as a true freshman before showing efficiency and a knack for scoring touchdowns as a sophomore.

In his final season in Ann Arbor, Mich., he went on to earn the school’s Offensive Player of the Year Award. No Big Ten receiver averaged more yards per catch in 2019 than Collins.

Table: Nico Collins NCAA stats (2017-19)

Year
School
Class
Gm*
Receiving
Rushing
Rec
Yds
Avg
TD
Att
Yds
Avg
TD
2017
Michigan
FR
2
3
27
9
0
0
0
0
2018
Michigan
SO
13
38
632
16.6
6
0
0
0
2019
Michigan
JR
12
37
729
19.7
7
0
0
0
Career
78
1,388
17.8
13
0
0
0

*includes postseason/bowl games

There will be some teams intrigued enough by Collins to consider selecting him in the late second round, but he is a more likely Round 3 choice. There’s an off-chance the former Wolverine doesn’t get his name called until Round 4, since it’s a deep class at the position.

Pros

  • Possesses an advantage in 50/50 situations with height, vertical jump (37 1/2 inches), timing and aggressiveness
  • Tracks deep ball well and displays late hands to keep defenders guessing
  • Quality speed down the field — not a burner but has accessible build-up speed
  • Hands catcher and does so with authority
  • Plenty to work with as a blocker — size and willingness to improve
  • Can create last-minute separation with body control and size — with a window is a foot or so, every bit helps, and Collins can really shine with accurate ball placement
  • Efficient production in 2018 and ’19
  • Considerable upside after sitting out 2020

[lawrence-related id=458080]

Cons

  • Tough to find film of him without a defender in his back pocket on intermediate and shorter routes
  • Struggles to escape press coverage against more physical corners
  • Lacks polish as a route runner and could use more disciplined footwork
  • Will be limited in routes available to match his traits at the next level — best utilized as a situation player early on with a chance to develop into a capable No. 2
  • With upside of being raw comes downside of being raw — potential worry in a league that has shortened the third- and fourth-year breakout bell curve to a season or two before teams grow impatient

Fantasy football outlook

It’s hard to not see a more powerful version of current Detroit Lions wide receiver Tyrell Williams when watching Collins work. Both are tall deep threats whose speed is just enough to make them dangerous in a straight line. Collins is a better jump-ball receiver and has more strength in his game, though Williams (6-foot-3 1/2, 204 pounds) demonstrated greater consistency in shedding defenders.

Collins probably will have an extremely limited role as a rookie, and his career could find him manning the No. 2 spot in an offense at split end over the next couple of seasons. He will carve out a role early on in the red zone and on go routes. Don’t expect to utilize him much in 2021, if at all, and it may take a couple of years before has routine lineup worthiness for those in dynasty formats.