The six players who shouldn’t have made our ’50 most dominant’ list — but did

Here are six players who made the NFL Wires’ recent 50 Most Dominant Players list… but probably shouldn’t have.

For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. Issac Newton wasn’t alive when people were making lists of the NFL’s best and most dominant players, but he had that statement right, and it applies to any subjective list about anything, whether we’re discussing NFL players or different brands of bug spray.

So, when it comes to the list of the NFL’s 50 most dominant players in the game today, put together by out estimable group of editors and writers, there are arguments for an against some of the people who made the cut, no matter how great they may be. I’ve already made my case for six players who I think should have made this Top 50 but didn’t, and to make things entirely fair, here are six players who did make the Top 50 that maybe should not have.

You can read both parts of the list right here!

50 most dominant NFL players of 2023, Nos. 50-26

50 most dominant NFL players of 2023, Nos. 25-1

The 101 best players in the NFL today, Nos. 101-51

Touchdown Wire’s Doug Farrar and Mark Schofield list the 101 best players in the NFL today.

Midsummer of every year is when we all make lists in this business. We’re not quite at the point of training camps in full bloom, free agency and the draft has eased off from a newsworthiness angle, and there’s still a need for clickable content. Ergo, we’re all ranking the NFL’s players in all possible ways.

Here’s how we’ve done it at Touchdown Wire over the last few seasons. Doug Farrar and Mark Schofield begin by ranking as many players as possible at as many positions at possible. This year, we ranked players at quarterback, running back, slot receiver, outside receiver, tight end, offensive tackle, offensive guard, center, interior defensive line, edge defender, linebacker, slot defender, outside cornerback, and safety.

We’ll get to long snappers next year, we promise.

The NFL’s top 13 safeties

The NFL’s top 12 slot defenders

The NFL’s top 12 outside cornerbacks

The NFL’s top 11 linebackers

The NFL’s top 11 edge defenders

The NFL’s top 12 interior defensive linemen

The NFL’s top 12 centers

The NFL’s top 11 offensive guards

The NFL’s top 11 offensive tackles

The NFL’s top 12 tight ends

The NFL’s top 11 slot receivers

The NFLs top 16 wide receivers

The NFL’s top 11 running backs

The NFL’s top 12 quarterbacks

What this allows us to do when it’s time to rank the NFL’s best players in a year, regardless of position, is to avoid overloading our list with certain positions. Because we’re limited to 12 quarterbacks (or however many Mark decides to list in a given year), we can’t throw 20 quarterbacks in the 101 at the expense of other positions.

All 12 of Mark’s quarterbacks made the top 101 list, because quarterback is the most important position, but we’re not going to throw Jimmy Garoppolo or Jared Goff in here just because. We also have 12 outside receivers, 11 outside cornerbacks, nine safeties, eight edge rushers, eight interior defensive linemen, seven linebackers, seven offensive guards, seven offensive tackles, seven running backs, six tight ends, three centers, three specific slot defenders, and one specific slot receiver. 

Perhaps that tells you which positions we think are most important in the NFL today, if nothing else. 

The methodology for this list (and all our positional lists) was this: We took what we remembered from the 2021 season and what we accentuated with offseason tape study. Then, we pored over the advanced metrics at Sports Info Solutions, Pro Football Focus, and Football Outsiders. From there, we put together our positional lists based on additional tape study, just to make sure the numbers, and our memories, aligned with what the tape told us over the summer.

Sometimes, it did, Other times, not so much. 

There are also all kinds of new players on this Top 101 list that weren’t here last year – a massive influx of young players who are seeing the light come on. Occasionally, that happens in a player’s rookie season. More often, it’s a multi-year process for a player to reach the elite at the highest possible level of football. Either way, it bodes well for the future.

As for the guy up top… well, we’ve seen him quite a bit before. But to avoid your phone blowing up when you’re trying to read this, we’ve split the Top 101 into two parts: Here are the players we ranked from 101 to 51, all their important metrics, and the most compelling tape examples we could find to prove their excellence. We’ll put up our top 50 players tomorrow.

So here, without further ado and in two parts, are Touchdown Wire’s 101 best players in the NFL today. 

(All advanced metrics courtesy of Sports Info SolutionsPro Football Focus, and Football Outsiders unless otherwise indicated).

The NFL’s best players at every position

From safeties to quarterbacks, Touchdown Wire’s Doug Farrar and Mark Schofield rate the best players at every position.

Last season, Touchdown Wire’s Mark Schofield and Doug Farrar assembled their lists of top 11 NFL players at every position, and then rolled that into their list of the top 101 players in the NFL. They’re doing it again this year, and here are the lists heading into the 2021 season. From safeties to quarterbacks and everything in-between, here are the NFL’s best players at every position.

Touchdown Wire’s countdown of the NFL’s best players

This summer at Touchdown Wire we are naming our top players at each position, working towards the Top 100 in the league.

This summer here at Touchdown Wire we are counting down the best players at every position, starting on the defensive side of the football. At the conclusion of these positional lists, we will unveil our own version of the NFL’s Top 11.

For each position, the players are ranked based on both extensive film study as well as taking advanced player metrics into account. Players that appeared for 50% of their team’s snaps at a given position are considered, meaning players that were absent last season for numerous games due to injury are ineligible for inclusion.

In addition, for many positions the “Honorable Mentions” are listed, that include players that just missed the cut or players you might expect to see, but were ineligible due to injuries or other reasons. Some of the best “units” are also discussed for various positions.

Here are the position lists to date. This will be updated as more position groups are announced.

Defense

(Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports)

Slot Cornerbacks – Given the prevalence of nickel and dime packages in today’s game, the slot cornerback is a starter in the modern NFL. As such, teams need talented players at this position. Here are the best the game has to offer.

Safeties – Offenses in the NFL rely on creating – and exploiting – matchups. As such, defenses in today’s game need players that can handle various responsibilities. That tends to fall on the safeties, where versatility is the name of the game.

Outside Cornerbacks – What players do you trust on an island in man coverage? You could probably start with this list.

Linebackers – With today’s emphasis on getting lighter and faster on defense, linebackers are becoming almost a dying breed. That does not diminish, however, what the players on this list bring to their units.

Edge Defenders – Offensive coordinators face some sleepless nights in the days leading up to playing these pass rushers.

Interior Defensive Linemen – Sure, Aaron Donald is the clear man at the top. What about the rest of the bunch?

Notre Dame in NFL: Four Irish Named to PFF’s Top 50

PFF ranked the 50 best players entering the 2020 NFL season. Four Notre Dame players made the list and one star QB shockingly didn’t.

Who are the 50 best players in the National Football League?  If you ask 100 people then likely nobody of that 100 shares the same 50 names.  However, there are some obvious ones that’d be on all lists if they’re done honestly.

Pro Football Focus released their list of the top 50 NFL players entering the 2020 season and some obvious names made it and at least one name that most would probably have in their lists was nowhere to be found.

More on that last part later but for now let’s look at Notre Dame’s representation as four former Fighting Irish players found themselves listed while one player made a run at the top overall spot.

For the entire list – check out Pro Football Focus.

No. 48 – Ronnie Stanley, OT, Baltimore Ravens