Fantasy football preview: Philadelphia Eagles running backs

Durability concerns cloud Philly’s talented backfield.

The Philadelphia Eagles have been one of the most prolific rushing teams in the NFL – finishing first in rushing yards in 2021 and fifth in 2022. But the organization never seems fully satisfied with its running game and made some big moves in the offseason.

Miles Sanders was coming off the best season of his career with 1,269 rushing yards and 11 touchdowns, but he was allowed to leave via free agency. He was replaced in free agency with the signing of Rashaad Penny, and then the Eagles cut a trade with Detroit to acquire D’Andre Swift.

Both of the new acquisitions have significant injury histories, but the talent runs deep in Philly with holdovers Kenneth Gainwell and Boston Scott proving to be reliable role players.

Fantasy football: Philadelphia Eagles running back breakdown

Will any of Philly’s running backs fly high in 2022?

One would be hard-pressed to come up with a team that went through more of a philosophical about-face in 2021 than the Philadelphia Eagles. Through the first seven games, Philly’s game plan seemed to be to put as much on Jalen Hurts’ right arm as possible. To that end, Hurts averaged 35 passing attempts per game over the first seven as the Eagles opened the year 2-5.

After that, the focus shifted 180 degrees to the ground game as Hurts averaged just 24 passes per outing across his final eight with Philadelphia posting a 6-2 mark — Gardner Minshew made two starts down the stretch as well, including a meaningless Week 18 loss to the Dallas Cowboys. When the dust settled, the Eagles had rushed for an NFL-leading 2,715 yards despite not having anyone reach 800 yards on the ground (Hurts led the club with 784 yards and 10 TDs).

Three of the top four backs from last year return; Jordan Howard (86-406-1 in seven games) remains a free agent and appears unlikely to be re-signed, though obviously preseason injuries could change that math in a hurry.

Miles Sanders

In terms of talent, Sanders is the standard-bearer. He has good speed and is a quality receiver out of the backfield, making him one of the focal points of the offense … when healthy. Durability has been a real issue in his young career, however, missing nine games combined over the past two years. In 2020 he suffered a pair of knee sprains, and last season he dealt with a sprained ankle for months and then broke his hand.

Tired of losing your league every season? Be sure to sign up for The Huddle today to gain an award-winning edge on the competition! We have 26 years of experience online building fantasy football champions.

Sanders’ struggles to remain on the field are doubtless a big part of the reason that Philly’s most talented back has rarely been used like a featured player. In 24 games over the last two seasons, Sanders has reached the 20-touch plateau just four times. He’s a little like Green Bay Packers RB Aaron Jones in that way, though Jones consistently reaches the high teens while Sanders had six games with fewer than a dozen opportunities last year. It’s hard to consistently produce when you’re not getting the ball.

Kenneth Gainwell

As a rookie last season, Gainwell logged 101 combined touches for 544 yards and six touchdowns, though his role really dried up over the season’s final two-plus months — only twice during that stretch did he log more than five touches in a game, and one of those was that glorified exhibition in Week 18.

The thinking here is that a full year in the system, combined with his strong receiving skills, should allow him to function as the top passing-down back. Whether he has the size (5-foot-9, 200 pounds) to see an expanded role in case of injury is Sanders is debatable.

Boston Scott

Scott is a stocky back (5-foot-6, 203 pounds) who has shown the ability to find the end zone in his career (13 career TDs on 228 carries) due to his athleticism and deceptive power. He’s a solid receiver as well, though perhaps not on the same level as Sanders or Gainwell.

Scott saw double-digit carries in six of his final seven games last year and projects as the more likely backup in case Sanders gets hurt. He should battle it out with Gainwell for the No. 2 job during training camp.

Fantasy football takeaway

When factoring in an intended increase in passing volume following the addition of wide receiver A.J. Brown, along with potential to lose ground scores to Hurts, this backfield may be more detrimental than beneficial to fantasy lineups many weeks.

Having three backs with similar skill sets makes them interchangeable, which in turn makes it tough to determine the roles they’ll fill — there is currently no one of Howard’s bruising disposition on the depth chart, but someone is like to pick up his nearly 90 touches.

Sanders has RB2 upside, but his low usage and injury history make him better suited as an RB3. Gainwell seems to have a higher weekly ceiling than Scott, but neither player is worth more than late-round consideration as roster depth.

Rookie Rundown: RB Kenneth Gainwell, Memphis

This explosive running back lives up to his name.

Is there a better running back to represent Kenneth Gainwell’s surname than the Memphis wonder? Just about as explosive as they make ’em, Gainwell was among the nation’s most impressive dual-threat running backs in 2019 prior to opting out of the 2020 season due to COVID-19 concerns — more than understandable after losing four members of his family to the virus.

Height: 5-foot-11
Weight: 190 pounds
40 time: 4.42 seconds

Memphis has churned out several NFL backs in recent years, including Dallas’ Tony Pollard, Green Bay’s Patrick Taylor, and the Los Angeles Rams’ Darrell Henderson. All three backs were ahead of Gainwell as a true freshman in 2018, so he decided to settle on a redshirt year after 10 total touches — 10 really impressive touches (four carries, 91 yards, 1 TD, six catches, 52 yards).

Table: Kenneth Gainwell NCAA stats (2018-19)

Year
School
Class
Gm*
Rushing
Receiving
Att
Yds
Avg
TD
Rec
Yds
Avg
TD
2018
Memphis
FR
4
4
91
22.8
1
6
52
8.7
0
2019
Memphis
rFR
14
231
1,459
6.3
13
51
610
12.0
3
Career
235
1,550
6.6
14
57
662
11.6
3

*includes postseason/bowl games

Gainwell earned first-team All-American Athletic Conference honors and was named AAC Rookie of the Year in 2019. His versatility and combustible nature will make for an interesting weapon in the NFL, but finding the right home is a must.

Pros

  • Dangerous threat to score every time he touches the ball
  • Super productive in his one season of meaningful work
  • Enough strength to run through arm tackles
  • Effective spin move and contact balance to collect himself for more yardage
  • Experienced out of the backfield running more complex routes
  • Naturally gifted receiver, understanding techniques to better position his body and allow him to catch on the run
  • Seamlessly flexes out wide and into the slot
  • Great fit for a zone-blocking system that allows him to utilize his vision and cutback ability — patiently plays off of his blocks with unpredictable fluidity
  • Recognizes how to manipulate a defender’s momentum to work in Gainwell’s favor
  • Gives an earnest effort in blitz pickup
  • Not much dancing behind the line — has a north-south mentality not often seen in backs of his stature

[lawrence-related id=458012]

Cons

  • For as explosive as he is, it’s tough to find much tape with a second gear — hits the hole fast and rarely shows the ability to kick it up a notch
  • Limited creativity in the open field — quite a bit of film of his skills behind the line and in the heart of the trenches, but second- and third-level moves tend to be basic
  • Gravitates toward contact — admirable trait, but it’s more often than not a career-killer for a back of his size
  • A one-year wonder?
  • System-dependent — most of his carries and catches came from manufactured plays in a spread, wide-zone concept
  • Lacks physical strength to be more than a “get in the way” blocker

Fantasy football outlook

While it isn’t a perfect comparison by any means, Indianapolis Colts running back Nyheim Hines comes to mind when evaluating Gainwell. Both have the speed, hands, and route-running skills to thrive in the correct role.

Due to his limitations and a depressed need for the position, Gainwell figures to be a third-round pick. He could move into the late second, and there’s not going to be much shock if he falls into Round 4, but he’s bound to be selected in the first five rounds.

Teams in need of a back with similar traits: Jacksonville, Atlanta, Denver, San Francisco, Arizona and Tennessee. Arizona sort of has that in Chase Edmonds, but he’s not an every-down guy. Tennessee doesn’t like taking Derrick Henry off of the field, but improved depth is a must.

The best fits for immediate impact would be the Jaguars, Broncos and 49ers. San Fran would be fun to see, due to creativity and a need, but fantasy football owners could become frustrated by erratic involvement from week to week. Gainwell deserves attention for roster depth in 2021 single-year drafts, and he has weekly flex potential in long-term PPR formats.