Penn State quarterback Drew Allar has already committed to return to the Nittany Lions for another season. He made that declaration weeks ago and has never publicly wavered from that stance.
Despite that, many NFL Draft analysts and college football media have not exactly taken Allar’s statement seriously. There’s been a strong undercurrent of doubt that Allar would ignore the potential to be a top-15 overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft and renege on his commitment to Penn State.
Some of that was predicated upon an expected playoff run that would spotlight Allar’s outstanding arm, smartly aggressive decisions with the ball and triumphant performances in the CFP spotlight that would reflect his relative NFL readiness in a very underwhelming quarterback class. Alas, that’s not what happened for Allar in the Nittany Lions’ semifinal loss to Notre Dame.
Allar was tentative and inaccurate most of the night. He missed several open throws early, effectively proven unable to complete anything longer than a screen pass. The game ended with a very bad interception from Allar, who was under pressure but had options.
He had a few performances in 2024 that made Allar look unready for the NFL. The physical tools are definitely there, but his overconfidence in his arm and his struggles against well-coached, talent-laden defenses (Illinois, Ohio State and Oregon come to mind) revealed a young player with very serious concerns if entering the next level.
Under the bright lights and against an NFL-style defense, Allar wilted. There will still be folks who advocate for Allar to change his course and declare for the 2025 NFL Draft before the deadline in two weeks for players who participated in the CFP. Their case lost a lot of luster on Thursday night in Miami. A return to Happy Valley for more development, more consistency of performance, should suit Allar very well in his eventual NFL dreams.
Recent Comments