Anyone who has watched Penn State tight end Tyler Warren should recognize his uniquely diverse skill set. What you may not know is how naturally it comes to him as a three-sport prep standout, lettering in basketball, baseball and being a three-star footballer. He also was born to student-athlete parents.
After a dominant senior performance, the Virginia native took his top-20-ranked game to Happy Valley in what wound up being a slower path to stardom than many may have expected.
Warren would see action in only two games during the pandemic-shortened 2020 season, which gave him an extra year of eligibility, and he mustered only four receiving touchdowns over the next two campaigns before showing legit potential as a redshirt junior.
In 2023, he’d catch seven TD passes and assert himself as one to watch entering Warren’s final year with the program. Penn State, which boasts a few pro-grade TEs in recent years, now has a new leader in all-time catches at the position, and Warren’s phenomenal 2024 performance earned him just about every honor imaginable for a tight end. He’d win the John Mackey Award (nation’s best TE), along with Second-team All-American, First-team All-Big Ten, and Big Ten Tight End of the Year recognition. Heck, he even finished seventh in Heisman voting.
Height: 6-foot-5 1/2
Weight: 256 pounds
40 time: 4.68 seconds (estimated)
Table: TE Tyler Warren, Penn State (2020-24)
*includes postseason/bowl games (stats from Sports Reference)
Pros
- Dynamic skill set that allows him to play all over the field doing anything a coaching staff asks of him — can play H-back/fullback, classic Y, flexed into the slot, and direct-snap QB in wildcat
- Elite production in 2024 not only as a receiver but rusher — set the program’s record for career TE receptions
- Excellent hands, especially in traffic — concentration is impressive
- Top-end upside in the NFL — easily could develop into a top-three player at the position in no time
- Fluid route runner who understands how to manipulate defenders with subtly
- Fits any system and scheme in the pros — will be at his best in a creative West Coast design
- Talented blocker out of the backfield
- An unteachable passion for playing that comes through the screen
- High-character guy who will serve as an energetic team leader early on
[lawrence-related id=500397]
Cons
- Occasionally gets sloppy or lackadaisical in his routes
- In-line blocking as a true Y is inconsistent — minor mechanical issues to address
- Much better within the first two levels of the route tree than as a vertical threat — capable of the latter, but it’s clearly not where he shines
- Takes a lot of contact with his playing style — could open him up to elevated risk of injury
- Only one year of dominant production, despite flashing earlier in career
Fantasy football outlook
All of that paints an idyllic picture for fantasy football owners looking ahead. Before we go down that road, trying to identify where Warren will land is a prudent course to take. It will be shocking if he slides out of Round 1, for starters. Narrowing it down to teams with a significant need at the position, the Los Angeles Chargers, Los Angeles Rams, Indianapolis Colts, and New York Jets make the most sense, barring a team trading up.
Denver could be a sneaky option, but it seems improbable after picking up Evan Engram in free agency … Stranger things have happened of late (see Vegas drafting Brock Bowers with Michael Mayer in the wings). Chicago makes sense but also has higher priorities to address.
While this won’t instill much confidence in fantasy gamers, Hayden Hurst is a fair comp. The athletic, versatile former South Carolina standout’s NFL career hasn’t been particularly successful — one would argue that’s being generous given his first-round draft placement — so it’s easy to feel a certain way about the comparison.
Nevertheless, Warren is too gifted to let this deter you from viewing him as a TE1 by Year 2 and likely no worse than a matchup play in his rookie season, regardless of where he lands.