Jack Fox is the NFL’s top-graded punter through two weeks

Fox has also been flawless as a holder

Looking for a silver lining from the Detroit Lions’ dreadful start to the 2020 season? Through the first two weeks, the Lions appear to have found themselves a great punter.

Jack Fox has played quite well in both Detroit losses. Fox, who spent much of the 2019 season on the Kansas City Chiefs’ practice squad before coming to Detroit’s own practice squad in December, is off to an amazing start as Sam Martin’s replacement.

Fox is the top-graded punter through the first two weeks in Pro Football Focus’ play-by-play grading. And it’s not particularly close either. Not bad for a guy who eked out the job after a summer-long battle with Arryn Siposs to succeed Detroit’s long-time punter, now in Denver.

His position coach, new Lions special teams coordinator Brayden Coombs, is similarly impressed. After a stellar Week 2 under heavy pressure in Green Bay, Fox earned this praise from Coombs in the coach’s press conference,

“Jack, obviously, he’s kicking the crap out of the ball. He’s doing a great job in that phase.”

He’s also been good on kickoffs and flawless in his important duty as holder for Matt Prater’s placekicks.

Jack Fox wins Lions punter battle, Arryn Siposs waived

Jack Fox wins the Detroit Lions punter battle, as Dave Birkett of the Free press reports that the team is waiving rookie Arryn Siposs.

Jack Fox has apparently won the Detroit Lions punter battle, as Dave Birkett of the Free press is reporting that the team is waiving undrafted rookie Arryn Siposs.

It was a heated training camp battle at punter and with no preseason to help separate performances between competitors, the Lions went with Fox who had a more consistent leg during camp. Fox has had more time in the NFL — just a year, but it makes a difference — and it surely helped him beat out the Australian rookie.

But don’t count Siposs out just yet. He showed enough pop in his leg that he may have earned a spot on the practice squad which would, in theory, keep this competition going into the regular season.

After an earlier report that the team was releasing long snapper Steve Wirtel, the Lions kicking specialist group has now been set with Matt Prater (kicker), Don Muhlbach (long snapper), and Fox getting the nod to start the season.

Matt Patricia masters the filibuster answer when asked about the Lions punting competition

Patricia gave a very long answer to a question about the Lions’ punting competition

We normally think of filibusters in the political realm. They’re intentionally long and unnecessarily detailed orations on a topic designed to fill time and prevent further questioning or progress into other topics.

Matt Patricia gave a great example of a filibuster in a football context during his Thursday Zoom session with reporters.

Patricia has always been verbose and prone to giving elaborately long and occasionally off-focus answers throughout his coaching tenure in Detroit. It’s his personality; coach Patricia is a talkative guy and when he’s interested in something, such as a good question, he likes to talk through his thought process.

Anyone who has heard me on the radio or a podcast knows I’m the same way. So when I say that Patrica’s lengthy answer to a question about the Lions punting competition is an epic example of a football filibuster, I say so with a self-aware admiration and observational tone more than a critical one.

Here is Patricia’s full answer from the question about the battle between Jack Fox and Arryn Siposs to handle the team’s punting duties,

“Two great guys, really, and good question because today you’re actually going to see some coverage stuff. So as you’re watching that, you’ll see some kickoff coverage. We’re working towards this week also the punt coverage aspect of all that too. That’ll be up this week. We’ll get a little bit more live reps at that – or not live – but as close as we can in pads, which will be nice. As far as the two punters, I think they’ve both done an outstanding job. I think they both have extremely outstanding leg talent.

Jack was here with us last year, and we saw his ability, the ball just explodes off his foot just when he drives into it. Certainly with Siposs, a guy that’s a little bit older even though he’s just coming out of college, very calm, another really strong leg, very consistent. I think for both of those guys they’re doing a great job. They’re competing.

Certainly as we go through camp we’re going to have to turn up the pressure a little bit just on some of the different looks they’re going to see and get them a feel for what that rush looks like when it’s coming at them and see how they perform under pressure. Certainly try to do it in the safest manner possible – it’s always a little bit interesting when you’re trying to do that with the punt and the punt protection, but we have to see that the best we can without the preseason games to see how that goes.

Two guys that are doing a great job of competing back and forth. One of the really awesome parts about all of it is (that) they’re back there helping each other. I think when you have competition on a football team, but the players put aside that competition and just try to help each other out, especially with the guys – the specialists and the kickers – because there’s so many details involved there with the snap and the timing of the footwork, the drop angle and the way the ball comes off the foot. They’re helping each other so that’s pretty cool to see.”

That’s one heck of a long answer, 368 words to be exact, for what seemed to be a fairly standard and anticipated question.

[lawrence-related id=48670]

Establishing the 53: Landing on a punter

Examining the Detroit Lions special teamers and debating who and how many players they will keep on the 53-man roster.

It’s never too early to examine and speculate about the Detroit Lions roster. Currently, the Lions have 90-players on their roster, and come September, there will likely be some difficult decisions to make when determining their final 53-players.

Previously, in this series of articles at Lions Wire, I identified the first 50 players in my projection by rounding out the running backs group, declaring a winner in the fullback versus H-back competition, adding an offensive weapon, narrowing down the offensive line, breaking down the defensive line, establishing the top options at linebacker, and sorting the defensive backs. In this piece, I will fill out the final three spots on the projected roster by examining the specialists in the kicking game.

Placekicker

Matt Prater sits alone on the placekicking depth chart with no threat to his roster spot — if there was any doubt. 

Erik’s take: Not only is Prater kicking unopposed, but he is in the final year of his contract and is a real contender for a fall contract extension.

Long snapper

Don Muhlbach will split long snapping duties in camp with undrafted rookie Steve Wirtel, who will be looking to show off his potential for 31 teams in the NFL. But unless Muhlbach suffers an injury, Wirtel won’t knock off Muhlbach for the Lions job.

Wirtel was likely added to the roster for four main reasons. First, Wirtel was on the Lions roster at the Senior Bowl and likely established a solid relationship with the staff. Second, he was widely considered the second-best long snapper in this class — the first was drafted by the Dolphins — and has NFL talent. Third, Muhlbach will turn 39-years-old during training camp and will require rest periods as not to be overworked. And lastly, Muhlbach could retire in the next few years and the Lions could be building the groundwork to bring back Wirtel in the future.

Erik’s take: The goat Muhlbach isn’t going anywhere. 

Punter battle

The Lions have two punters on the roster, Jack Fox and Arryn Siposs. Let’s take a closer look at each to see if either can separate from the other.

Fox went undrafted out of Rice in 2019 and signed with the Kansas City Chiefs. He played so well during the last years training camp and preseason that the Chiefs initially placed him on the practice squad before eventually moving on when they need more space. The Lions seized the opportunity to sign Fox to their practice squad in early December and when he showed well during practices, they signed him to a futures deal in January.

Fox has a very big leg, averaged 45.5 yards per punt at Rice, and has the ability to flip the field with any kick. Behind the scenes of Allen Park, Fox has been held in such high regard that Dave Birkett of the Free Press suggested the “Fox may be good enough that the Lions don’t need to draft a punter this offseason” — which indeed came to fruition.

While they didn’t draft a punter, immediately following the draft the Lions added Siposs to compete with Fox. The addition of Siposs isn’t just as a camp leg either, he is plenty talented enough to play in the NFL, and he is a bit different than your average rookie punter.

Siposs was drafted by the Saints at age 17 — that’s the St. Kilda Saints of the Australian Football League — where he played Australian rules football professionally for five years before shoulder injuries forced him from the league. In 2017, Siposs pivoted to American football and earned a scholarship to Auburn for the last two years.

A natural athlete, Siposs offers the Lions a different kind of punter. One who is comfortable kicking both traditionally and in creative/unique ways — including punting on the move, cross body, and directionally unique angles.

While training camp will ultimately decide Fox and Siposs fate, each offer Lions new special teams coach Brayden Coombs something special to work with.

Erik’s take: This is a true camp battle but based on the Lions approach this offseason, most indicators point to Fox being in the lead for now. I’m penciling him into my 53-man roster.

Lions have several options at punter to replace free agent Sam Martin

Lions have several options at punter to replace free agent Sam Martin

Sam Martin has been a reliably above-average punter for most of his seven NFL seasons, all with the Detroit Lions. But Martin is a pending free agent and in all likelihood will not be back for an eighth year in Detroit.

The Lions will have several options to replace Martin, who ranks 10th all-time in average yards per punt at 46.0. In fact, the solution might already be in Detroit.

Earlier this offseason the Lions signed two free agent punters to reserve/future contracts. Jack Fox and Matt Wile deserve to compete for the job, and both are familiar with the team already. Fox and Wile both had stints on the team’s practice squad in 2019.

Fox gets a leg up (no pun intended) because, like Martin, he’s capable of also being the kickoff specialist. That’s important because placekicker Matt Prater does not handle kickoff duties all that well.

In free agency, veterans Britton Colquitt, Matt Bosher and Lac Edwards are all on the market with Martin. Edwards led the NFL in both punt attempts and yards in 2019 while booming kicks at a 45.9-yard average for the New York Jets. Colquitt, 35, spent last season with the Minnesota Vikings and has earned his reputation for being the best coffin-corner punter in the NFL over his long career.

It’s unlikely the Lions will draft a punter, though that was also said back in 2013 when then-GM Martin Mayhew tabbed Martin in the sixth round. Some of the top-rated punters in the 2020 NFL Draft include Joseph Charlton of South Carolina, Texas A&M’s Braden Mann and Arryn Siposs from Auburn, whom the Lions saw in person at the Tigers pro day last week.