It didn’t go over well on NBA Twitter when The Ringer’s CEO tried to argue that Luka Doncic was a superior passer to James Harden.
Veteran NBA writer and podcaster Bill Simmons drew criticism Monday after an odd comparison involving the passing abilities of Houston Rockets star James Harden and Dallas Mavericks guard Luka Doncic.
Doncic had 36 points, 19 assists, and 14 rebounds in his team’s overtime victory over Milwaukee on Saturday night, and his late pass to Maxi Kleber for the pivotal dunk has understandably drawn attention.
For Rockets fans, the play probably looked familiar. After all, there’s a reason the 21-year-old Doncic has regularly drawn comparisons over his first two NBA seasons (in a positive way) to the 30-year-old Harden.
Both guards are in the NBA’s Top 10 in assists per game this season, with Doncic at 8.9 and Harden at 7.5. Harden is the better scorer, at 34.3 points per game as compared to 29.1 this season for Doncic.
Overall, the two All-Stars appear to have somewhat similar playing styles and abilities. On paper, that should be quite a compliment to the second-year Doncic, considering that Harden has been an MVP finalist for four consecutive years — including his victory in 2018.
[lawrence-related id=35885]
Simmons, however, felt the need to go a step further. During a new podcast with Ryen Russillo, The Ringer‘s CEO said this as part of a discussion comparing Doncic to Hall of Famer Larry Bird:
The thing with Luka is the assists aren’t, like, cheap assists. He has the typical James Harden type of assist, where he brings the second guy over and hits the guy in the corner, the cross-court, all the stuff he’s doing to get guys open threes. But he’s also creating these cutter passes.
Guys learn how to play with him and they’re more active, more engaged.
That opinion was widely condemned on social media, including by numerous fans with no connection to Harden or the Rockets.
As shown in the video compilation, Harden actually had a pass similar to the Doncic highlight barely over a week earlier — in an epic comeback by the Rockets against (of all teams) Doncic and the Mavs!
Harden finished with 49 points and eight assists in their head-to-head battle, while Doncic had 28 points and 10 dimes. Most notably, Harden dominated the “clutch” minutes when the game was in the balance.
[lawrence-related id=35213]
Over the final five minutes of regulation and overtime, Harden had 13 points (75% FG), seven rebounds, and just one turnover. Meanwhile, Doncic scored 2 points on 1-of-7 shooting (14.3%), and he had just one rebound and three turnovers. The Rockets outscored Dallas over those 10 game minutes by a 30-18 margin, which turned an eight-point Houston deficit into a stunning 153-149 victory (box score).
Harden even took on the extra responsibility of guarding Doncic on several of the most impactful defensive possessions.
That July 31 win led to Houston clinching the Southwest Division title shortly thereafter. The second-place finish for Dallas largely resulted from a pair of head-to-head losses to Harden’s Rockets in their final two regular-season meetings of the 2019-20 season.
None of that is meant to slight Doncic, of course. The fact that the conversation is even being had, when Doncic is just 21 years old and still improving in only his second NBA season, is a testament to his remarkable ability and potential. Harden is already a Hall of Fame lock, and Doncic drawing that type of analogy should be looked at favorably.
Somehow, though, Simmons seemed to argue that Doncic has already surpassed Harden — at least from a passing standpoint.
It should be noted that Simmons’ view isn’t necessarily a mainstream belief. For example, Harden topped Doncic on Saturday as the NBA’s third MVP finalist (as determined by national media voters), joining Milwaukee’s Giannis Antetokounmpo and LeBron James of the Lakers.
Harden led the NBA in assists per game in the 2016-17 season, which Doncic has yet to do, and he’s also directed his Rockets to the playoffs in all eight of his seasons as the primary ball-handler in Houston. By contrast, this year is the first playoff appearance for the Mavs since 2016.
[lawrence-related id=20087]
Even though his unique playing style is at times controversial, Harden has clearly earned respect from NBA media and his own rivals over the years. That’s what made the latest take from Simmons so perplexing, and it understandably prompted significant pushback on social media.
Simmons can certainly have his personal preferences, but there doesn’t seem to be much in the data or results to back up that value judgment.
[lawrence-related id=35914]