NFL Player Prop Bet Payday: Divisional Round

Five of our favorite NFL Divisional Round prop bets.

Not sure I’ve ever seen a Divisional Round week where such a strong case can be made that each of the road teams has a legitimate chance to win. While history tells us the home team should win three of these games (if not all four), they’re going to be competitive – nothing could be worse than last week’s blowouts.

Here are five players we’re convinced have a great chance of sending you to the playoff pay window.

Odds provided by Tipico Sportsbook (updated Friday, Jan. 21 at 7:40 p.m. ET) … If you’re in CO or NJ, place all of your legal, online sports wagers with Tipico Sportsbook

Oh, Henry!

The Tennessee Titans found a way to lock down the No. 1 seed in the AFC without their most potent weapon, RB Derrick Henry. Now he’s back, and there’s going to be a lot of pregame debate about whether he’s the Henry that was a legitimate MVP candidate or a running back being forced back too soon with a foot injury – an RB killer. By his standards, he has a low Over/Under (80.5 rushing yards at -114 for both the Over and Under). The fact the Titans activated him lends itself to giving Henry a heavy workload. He’s the centerpiece of the offense, and the team has been built around him for a reason. Take the Over (-114).

Runnin’ with the Devil

The San Francisco 49ers have a big job ahead of them traveling to Green Bay. Their QB has a thumb problem on his throwing hand. In cold weather, it hurts much worse. The 49ers are likely to lean on RB Elijah Mitchell … again. Over his last six games, he has more than 20 carries in all of them. His Over/Under for rushing attempts is less than that (18.5 carries at -118 Over, -110 Under). The only way he doesn’t make it seven in a row with 20-plus carries is if the Packers blow out the Niners early, or he gets injured during the game. Take the Over (-118).

Brady’s Bunch

The deeper the Tampa Bay Buccaneers go in the playoffs, the more the injury to Chris Godwin and the release of Antonio Brown are going to stand out. QB Tom Brady has had absurd Over/Under numbers all season, and this week is no exception (290.5 passing yards at -114 for both). Brady has more than proved what he is capable of in the postseason and many see a shootout type of game. While I don’t disagree with that, if the Los Angeles Rams defense can effectively limit Mike Evans, Brady will need to complete 30 passes to hit that number with dink-and-dunk passes. The Bucs may win, but it shouldn’t be through an aerial attack. Take the Under (-114).

Swinging for a Single

Just as many who are projecting the Rams-Buccaneers game to be a passing festival, the same is true in the Buffalo Bills-Kansas City Chiefs matchup. In this case, I see that happening. Bills RB Devin Singletary is playing the best ball of his career of late, reflected in his Over/Under (15.5 rushing attempts at -105 Over, -123 Under). For a standard featured back, that’s not a lot, but for Singletary, that’s a pretty stiff number. If he struggles early, his carries will suffer. The Bills may just come out throwing and not look back. Zack Moss may get some looks. Too many factors are against it. Take the Under (-123).

Hail to the Chief

There are always two players for the Chiefs that get bettors expecting huge games – WR Tyreek Hill and TE Travis Kelce. The Bills linebackers are decent, but not great. Kelce is great. Hill is likely to garner double-coverage on most plays. Kelce will likely be locked up one-on-one more times than not. Who will Patrick Mahomes choose? The star in single coverage. He has a pretty big number for a tight end (69.5 receiving yards at -116 Over, -111 Under) for a reason. He’s going to top it. Take the Over (-116).

Gannett may earn revenue from Tipico for audience referrals to betting services. Tipico has no influence over nor are any such revenues in any way dependent on or linked to the newsrooms or news coverage. See Tipico.com for Terms and Conditions. 21+ only. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER (NJ), 1-800-522-4700 (CO), 1-800-BETS-OFF (IA).

Betting the NFL Line: Divisional Round

The best bets to make for the NFL Divisional Round.

This is my favorite weekend in sports, much less the NFL. Six teams that have survived and advanced look to take the next step, including the two teams that earned a bye week by virtue of their strong start.

A case can be made for all the underdogs on the spread and none of the home teams are seen as locks to win and advance. Before laying down their starters in Week 18, the Cincinnati Bengals were 5-2 on the road. The San Francisco 49ers have blown out Green Bay in two of their last three games. Despite losing in Week 3 this season, San Francisco overcame a 17-0 deficit to take a lead with 37 seconds to go – only to have the Packers drive 42 yards in 34 seconds to kick a game-winning field goal as time expired.

The Sunday games hold just as much drama. The Los Angeles Rams have beaten Tom Brady in both of their meetings since he joined the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, including a 34-24 win in Week 3. The same goes for the Buffalo Bills. Buffalo went into Kansas City in Week 5 and throttled the Chiefs 38-20. They return to the scene of the crime Sunday looking to do the same.

Typically, the Divisional Round of the playoffs sees the cream rise to the top. The home teams held serve in five of six games in the Wild Card Round, but that will be a much tougher road than usual in the Divisional Round this season given the success of the road teams in recent matchups.

Odds provided by Tipico Sportsbook (updated Wednesday, Jan. 19, at 7:45 p.m. ET) … If you’re in CO or NJ, place all of your legal, online sports wagers with Tipico Sportsbook.

NFL Betting Odds and Lines: Divisional Round

Cincinnati Bengals (+155) at Tennessee Titans (-190)

It isn’t that often that a team that gets a bye week has more question marks than the Titans have coming out of their bye week. The anticipation is that Derrick Henry will be back and doing what he does best – pound the ball and control the clock. The Bengals are one of the most balanced teams in the league, but, when things are going their way, they also like to run the ball 25 times or more. This sets up to make the Over/Under a little ambitious (47.5 points at -105 Over, -115 Under) if the game goes as scripted. Both offenses have the horses to put up points, but this could be an old-school game typified by 12-play drives and as many field goals scored as touchdowns. Take the Under (-115).

San Francisco 49ers (+205) at Green Bay Packers (-260)

There are some teams that match up well with an opponent, and the 49ers are one of those teams when it comes to playing the Packers. Jimmy Garoppolo is 2-1 against Aaron Rodgers. The teams played twice in the 2019 season and both were blowout wins for the Niners – 37-8 in the regular season and 37-20 in the playoffs. However, all three of his career meetings came in California, not in Green Bay, where wind-chill temperatures are expected to be at or below zero. You can’t replicate frigid cold in practice. The Packers are solid favorites (5.5 points at -103 49ers, -117 Packers). San Francisco has the personnel to take out the No. 1 seed, but this has all the earmarks of a classic January game at Lambeau for the Packers – their quarterback makes the big plays that open up a lead and the defense seals the deal late in the game. Take the Packers and lay the 5.5 points (-117).

Los Angeles Rams (+120) at Tampa Bay Buccaneers (-145)

This is another game where a strong case can be made that the road team is the better team. For the second time in four years, the Rams have mortgaged their future (in terms of elite draft picks) to make a Super Bowl run. The first time they did, they made it to the Super Bowl – only to lose to Tom Brady and the Patriots. The point spread clearly indicates that the Rams are the better team despite being an underdog to the Buccaneers (2.5 points at +102 Rams, -125 Buccaneers). While I don’t believe the Bucs will make it to the Super Bowl because of a depleted elite receiver corps for Brady, I don’t believe it will be just yet. Nobody blitzes more than Todd Bowles and Bucs defense, and Matthew Stafford struggles when he has heat in his face. Bet against Brady at your own peril in this one. Take the Buccaneers and lay the 2.5 points (-125).

Buffalo Bills (+100) at Kansas City Chiefs (-120)

The final game of the week has two teams with a rich recent history that featured one team dominating the other early and managing the lead from there. Last year in the AFC Championship Game (in Kansas City), the Chiefs erased a 9-0 first quarter deficit to outscore the Bills 31-6 over the next two quarters. In Week 5 this season (at Kansas City), the Chiefs led 10-7 with 10 minutes to play in the second quarter, but entered the fourth quarter trailing 31-13. The Bills have the No. 1 ranked overall defense and the No. 1 scoring defense in the league. While not consistently dominant, when you combine the defensive ability with the offensive explosiveness – Josh Allen completed just 15 passing in the Week 5 meeting but averaged 21 yards per completion (315 yards). The Chiefs have represented the AFC in the Super Bowl the last two seasons, but the Bills will make sure the third time is not a charm. Take the Bills on the Money Line (+100).

Gannett may earn revenue from Tipico for audience referrals to betting services. Tipico has no influence over nor are any such revenues in any way dependent on or linked to the newsrooms or news coverage. See Tipico.com for Terms and Conditions. 21+ only. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER (NJ), 1-800-522-4700 (CO), 1-800-BETS-OFF (IA).

NFL Picks: Office pool pick’em – Divisional Round

Use our staff’s weekly pick’em against the spread and straight up for the win.

The Huddle staff makes its weekly NFL game picks every Thursday.

NFL picks are provided for straight up (moneyline) and against the spread (ATS) NFL pick pools.

Each week’s spread picks are graded by the line as of when the person entered their picks. This will create situations in which a movement of the line can result in two participants having the correct pick but with different teams chosen during an individual game.

Odds provided by Tipico Sportsbook … If you’re in CO or NJ, place all of your legal, online sports wagers with Tipico Sportsbook

NFL Divisional Round picks: Moneyline & Against the spread


Season-to-date results: Moneyline

Congratulations to Ken Pomponio for winning the season-long results for straight-up picks.

Note: Playoff picks will not count toward the season-long or all-time results tracker.


Season-to-date results: Against the spread

Pomponio also won the ATS pick challenge for the 2021-22 NFL season.


NFL all-time picks leaderboard: Moneyline

Note: Playoff picks will not count toward the season-long or all-time results tracker.

Straight Up DMD SG KP HS CC CJB HCG
2021 Record 167-104-1 159-112-1 179-92-1 176-95-1 175-96-1 176-95-1 174-97-1
2020 Record 161-94-1 161-94-1 165-90-1 164-91-1 174-81-1 166-89-1 172-83-1
2019 Record 162-93-1 156-99-1 161-94-1 161-94-1 164-91-1 157-98-1 163-92-1
2018 Record 167-87-2 158-96-2 179-75-2 153-101-2 165-89-2 157-97-2 n/a
2017 Record 168-88 161-95 171-85 165-91 180-76 160-96 n/a
2016 Record 157-97-2 149-105-2 156-98-2 152-102-2 156-98-2 139-115-2 n/a
2015 Record 154-102 137-119 156-100 155-101 165-91 n/a n/a
2014 Record 166-89-1 158-97-1 164-91-1 163-92-1 177-78-1 n/a n/a
2013 Record 163-92-1 160-95-1 170-85-1 153-102-1 n/a n/a n/a
Accuracy entering 2022 1,465-846-9
(63.1%)
1,399-912-9
(60.3%)
1,501-801-9
(64.7%)
1,442-869-9
(62.2%)
1,356-700-8
(65.7%)
955-590-7
(61.5%)
509-272-3
(64.9%)

NFL all-time picks leaderboard: Against the spread

ATS DMD SG KP HS CC CJB HCG
2021 Record 141-130-1 142-129-1 154-117-1 136-135-1 152-119-1 143-128-1 151-120-1
2020 Record 118-138 122-134 123-133 129-127 130-126 143-113 130-126
2019 Record 121-135 133-123 133-123 139-117 121-135 137-119 139-117
2018 Record 132-124 131-125 145-111 133-123 132-124 130-126 n/a
2017 Record 129-127 136-120 135-121 132-124 136-120 131-125 n/a
2016 Record 110-146 125-131 127-129 124-132 132-124 127-129 n/a
2015 Record 125-131 121-135 126-130 123-133 141-115 n/a n/a
2014 Record 122-134 124-132 143-113 132-124 123-133 n/a n/a
2013 Record 115-136-5 119-132-5 117-134-5 117-134-5 n/a n/a n/a
Accuracy entering 2022 1,113-1,201-6
(48.1%)
1,153-1,161-6
(50.7%)
1,203-1,111-6
(51.9%)
1,165-1,149-6
(50.2%)
1,067-996-1
(51.7%)
811-740-1
(52.3%)
420-363-1
(54.1%)

DMD – David Dorey, SG – Steve Gallo, KP – Ken Pomponio, HS – Harley Schultz, CC – Cletis Cutts, CJB – Cory Bonini, HCG – HC Green

Gannett may earn revenue from audience referrals to betting services.  Newsrooms are independent of this relationship and there is no influence on news coverage.