The 5 best NFL Wild Card Weekend prop bets

The five best NFL player prop bets to make for the upcoming week.

It’s kind of sad that the season-long struggle to make it to the playoffs can be negated by weather. Record-setting low temperatures are expected in Kansas City, talent can be negated by Mother Nature, which isn’t fair, but those are the rules you play by in January. Buffalo-Pittsburgh was moved to Monday to avoid weather-related emergency concerns.

For Super Wild Card Weekend, we have a couple of veterans going under their number, a couple of emerging young stars going Over, and the most reliable postseason scorer finding the end zone again.

Odds provided by BetMGM Sportsbook

NFL Picks: Office pool pick’em – Wild Card Round

Use our staff’s weekly pick’em against the spread and straight up for the win.

NFL picks are provided for straight up (moneyline) and against the spread (ATS) NFL pick pools.

Each week’s spread picks are graded by the line as of when the person entered their picks. This will create situations in which a movement of the line can result in two participants having the correct pick but with different teams chosen during an individual game.

BetMGM Sportsbook $1,500 First Bet Offer!

New BetMGM customers can sign up today and get a First Bet Offer up to $1,500 using bonus code USAT. Just download the BetMGM app, deposit at least $10 and place your first wager on any game. If your first bet loses, you will receive bonus bets in the amount of your bet (up to $1,500). Just make sure you use bonus code USAT when you sign up. Bet Now!

Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. CO, DC, IL, IN, KS, LA, MD, MS, NJ, NV, OH, PA, TN, VA, WV, WY. Call 877-8-HOPENY or text HOPENY (467369) (NY). Call 1-800-327-5050 (MA). 21+ to wager. Please Gamble Responsibly. Call 1-800-NEXT-STEP (AZ), 1-800-BETS-OFF (IA), 1-800-270-7117 for confidential help (MI), 1-800-981-0023 (PR). In partnership with Kansas Crossing Casino and Hotel. Visit BetMGM.com for Terms & Conditions. US promotional offers not available in DC, New York or Ontario.

2023 Wild Card picks: moneyline & against the spread

Odds provided by BetMGM Sportsbook


2023 Season-long rankings: moneyline


2023 Season-long rankings: ATS


NFL all-time picks leaderboard: moneyline

Moneyline DMD SG HS CC CJB HCG KH
2022 184-98-2 172-110-2 172-110-2 181-101-2 174-108-2 190-92-2 178-104-2
2021 167-104-1 159-112-1 176-95-1 175-96-1 176-95-1 174-97-1 n/a
2020 161-94-1 161-94-1 164-91-1 174-81-1 166-89-1 172-83-1 n/a
2019 162-93-1 156-99-1 161-94-1 164-91-1 157-98-1 163-92-1 n/a
2018 167-87-2 158-96-2 153-101-2 165-89-2 157-97-2 n/a n/a
2017 168-88 161-95 165-91 180-76 160-96 n/a n/a
2016 157-97-2 149-105-2 152-102-2 156-98-2 139-115-2 n/a n/a
2015 154-102 137-119 155-101 165-91 n/a n/a n/a
2014 166-89-1 158-97-1 163-92-1 177-78-1 n/a n/a n/a
2013 163-92-1 160-95-1 153-102-1 n/a n/a n/a n/a
All-time 1,649-944-11 1,571-1,022-11 1,614-979-11 1,537-801-10 1,129-698-9 699-364-5 178-104-2
accuracy (63.5%) (60.5%) (62.2%) (65.7%) (61.7%) (65.4%) (63.0%)

NFL all-time picks leaderboard: ATS

ATS DMD SG HS CC CJB HCG KH
2022 136-142-6 132-148-4 143-136-5 132-150-2 145-136-3 142-134-8 127-152-4
2021 141-130-1 142-129-1 136-135-1 152-119-1 143-128-1 151-120-1 n/a
2020 118-138 122-134 129-127 130-126 143-113 130-126 n/a
2019 121-135 133-123 139-117 121-135 137-119 139-117 n/a
2018 132-124 131-125 133-123 132-124 130-126 n/a n/a
2017 129-127 136-120 132-124 136-120 131-125 n/a n/a
2016 110-146 125-131 124-132 132-124 127-129 n/a n/a
2015 125-131 121-135 123-133 141-115 n/a n/a n/a
2014 122-134 124-132 132-124 123-133 n/a n/a n/a
2013 115-136-5 119-132-5 117-134-5 n/a n/a n/a n/a
All-time 1,249-1,343-12 1,285-1,309-10 1,308-1,285-11 1,199-1,146-3 956-876-4 562-497-9 127-152-4
accuracy 48.2% 49.5% 50.4% 51.1% 52.2% 53.0% 45.6%

DMD – David Dorey, SG – Steve Gallo, HS – Harley Schultz, CC – Cletis Cutts, CJB – Cory Bonini, HCG – HC Green, KH – Kevin Hickey


The 5 best bets for NFL Wild Card Weekend

The five smartest wagers to take to the pay window for Wild Card Weekend.

For Wild Card Weekend, we have two road teams winning, two high-octane games going Over, and a coach helping another game go Under.

Odds provided by BetMGM Sportsbook

Betting the Line: NFL Wild Card Round

A league-wide view into the best wagers to make for NFL Wild Card Round action.

It’s a three-day Wild Card Weekend and we’re going to ignore moneyline bets and focus on the point spreads and Over/Under bets for all six games.

Odds provided by BetMGM Sportsbook

Cleveland Browns (-145) at Houston Texans (+120)

The Browns are a small road favorite (2.5 points at -120 Browns, +100 Texans). The Browns hammered the Texans 36-22 in Week 16, but the Texans were without QB C.J. Stroud. Cleveland has been on fire with veteran QB Joe Flacco, and the Browns are rested at a lot of key positions in a short preparation week. Take the Browns and lay 2.5 points (-120).

The Over/Under is pretty average (44.5 points at -110 for both Over and Under). The Browns have been putting up a ton of points lately, but Cleveland has the No. 1 defense in the league and the Texans have been improving as the year went on. The defenses will have something to say in this one. Take Under 44.5 points (-110).

Miami Dolphins (+170) at Kansas City Chiefs (-210)

The Chiefs are decent home favorites (4 points at -110 for both teams). Miami lost 21-14 to the Chiefs in November and are 1-5 against playoff teams – and that was with their full complement of players. The Dolphins have too many injured players to hang with the Chiefs in Kansas City in January. Take the Chiefs and lay 4 points (-110).

The Over/Under is deceptively low given the offenses (44 points at -110 for both). The two teams combined for just 35 points in their first meeting and one touchdown was a defensive score. Miami’s defense is too beaten up to keep up, and Tyreek Hill will do enough on his own to keep Miami close. Take Over 44 points (-110).

Pittsburgh Steelers (+400) at Buffalo Bills (-550)

The Bills are huge favorites (10 points at -110 for both). Given how hot the Bills have been recently, this makes sense. But double-digit favorites in the playoffs are rare. Buffalo is capable of blowing out the Steelers, but if they’re up 17 points, they’re working the clock. Buffalo should win this game, but giving 10 is a lot. Take the Steelers plus 10 points (-110).

The O/U is the lowest of the week (36.5 points at -110 for both teams). Whether or not you’re willing to lay 10 points and the Bills vs. the spread, there doesn’t take a lot to hit this small number. 24-13 covers. Take Over 36.5 points (-110).

[lawrence-related id=486901]

Green Bay Packers (+275) at Dallas Cowboys (-350)

The Cowboys are strong favorites (7.5 points at -110 for both teams). They have a history of blowing out opponents at home – six of their eight wins at home have been by 20 points or more. The Packers are the youngest team in the league, and that will show in a playoff game against a time-tested team. Take the Cowboys and lay 7.5 points (-110).

The Over/Under is very big (50.5 points at -110 for both). Dallas has played two playoff teams at home in the last month (Philadelphia and Detroit). One was a blowout. One wasn’t. Both didn’t hit 50 points. Take Under 50.5 points (-110).

Los Angeles Rams (+150) at Detroit Lions (-185)

The Lions are the smallest home favorite of the week (3 points at +100 Rams, -120 Lions). Detroit’s run started last year. It likely ends next week, not this week. Take the Lions and lay 3 points (-110).

The Over/Under is the highest of the week (51.5 points at -110 for both). One thing that can be said about both teams is that, while their running games are prolific, they do damage through the air. If one team gets up by double-digits down, it’s on. Take Over 51.5 points (-110).

Philadelphia Eagles (-160) at Tampa Bay Buccaneers (+135)

Despite their epic collapse – five losses in their last six games – the Eagles are road favorites (3 points at -110 for both teams). They’re favored for a reason. If they lose again, it’s on them … again. Take the Eagles and lay 3 points.

The Over/Under is relatively low (43.5 points at -110 for both Over and Under). The Eagles defense has struggled recently, allowing 27 or more points in six of their last seven games. If the Eagles are going to win, they will likely need to put up a score in the high 20s. Take Over 43.5 points (-110).