Lions vs Giants: Best and worst PFF grades from Detroit’s preseason win

Here are the standout performances from this week’s best and worst PFF performers for the Detroit Lions against the New York Giants.

The Detroit Lions kicked off their season with a 21-16 victory over the New York Giants in their first preseason game. Despite many of the team’s key players sitting out, the Lions’ management was able to evaluate potential roster candidates.

The game started off slowly, with the offense struggling, but the defense saved the day by repeatedly stepping up to the challenge and shutting down their opponents. Although some areas showed promise, others may require further evaluation by the Lions’ management.

Here are the standout performances from this week’s best and worst Pro Footbal Focus (PFF) performers, highlighting those who impressed and those who fell short in their bid for a coveted roster spot.

Lions rookie report: Strong showing from Detroit’s rookies in win over Giants

The Lions beat the Giants 21-16 and relied heavily on contributions from the rookie class

The Detroit Lions came out victorious from their first preseason game of 2023. Not only did they come out with a win, but they got early returns on their investments from their rookie class.

You can’t talk about this game without mentioning the wide receivers. Detroit has three first-year receivers on the team and all three made an impact against the Giants.

Chase Cota, undrafted out of Oregon, played for most of the game and had quite the professional debut with four catches for 60 yards. Seventh-round pick Antoine Green aided early on in the game with three catches of his own for 36 yards. Dylan Drummond, who has picked up some attention throughout training camp, had a quieter game but still contributed nonetheless. The former Eastern Michigan wideout earned 12 yards on two receptions and also took one kick return for 19 yards.

Undrafted rookie quarterback Adrian Martinez came in for Nate Sudfeld in the fourth quarter and showed some flashes of potential. Known for being mobile in college, he ran the ball 5 times with his longest gain being 10 yards. He capped off his day with a rushing touchdown to take Detroit into the lead. He didn’t look as good as a passer, only completing four-of-seven attempts for 37 yards, but his performance should earn him more playing time in the remaining preseason showings.

Tight end Sam LaPorta saw the field plenty in the first half of the game, but did not contribute much to the box score. He was utilized often in 12-personnel sets alongside Brock Wright and the two even lined up side-by-side at times. LaPorta was targeted once but dropped the pass.

First-round pick Jahmyr Gibbs impressed early on despite some poor offensive line play up front. The shifty running back showed an ability to find his way upfield in situations that would normally be a loss of yardage. He also briefly flashed his skills as a receiver with one catch for 18 yards. He also proved himself to be a team player as he is credited with a tackle on New York’s Jason Pinnock following an interception from Sudfeld.

Fellow rookie running back Mohamed Ibrahim did not share the same successes. Ibrahim averaged 2.3 yards per carry on his four touches and had to briefly go to the locker room wit the trainer after suffering a minor injury.

On the offensive line, fifth-round pick Colby Sorsdal started the game at right guard and it became evident that there would be a learning curve for the former William & Mary lineman. Undrafted rookies Brad Cecil and Connor Galvin served as the respective second-team center and right tackle.

On the other side of the ball, defensive lineman Brodric Martin may have stood out size-wise, but his one tackle on the day leaves us waiting to see what made the Western Kentucky product worthy of a costly trade-up in the third round. Fellow rookie linemen Chris Smith and Cory Durden saw limited action against the Giants but did not do anything noteworthy.

First-round pick Jack Campbell had a very impressive debut for the Lions. The former Iowa Hawkeye had four tackles and a pass defense on the day and seemed to bring life to the team’s run defense. With Alex Anzalone not suited up, Campbell got the start alongside Derrick Barnes.

Undrafted linebacker Trevor Nowaske had his name called on the broadcast a few times, and for good reason. The Saginaw Valley State standout also put up four tackles in this matchup against New York.

The four rookies in Detroit’s secondary were some of the biggest playmakers of this group. Safety Brandon Joseph made impactful plays everywhere on the field. On top of his game-sealing interception, he also played well against the run and even made a tackle-for-loss.

Nickel defender Brian Branch got his first start as a Lion and immediately made plays. Not even four minutes into the game, he sniffed out a screen to veteran Cole Beasley and quickly took him down for a loss of yardage.

Undrafted rookie Starling Thomas has been the training camp darling of 2023, and he continued to impress against the Giants. His biggest contributions were on special teams, where he excelled as a gunner on the punt team and also put up some key blocks on kick and punt returns throughout the game.

Look: Top photos from the Lions preseason win over the Giants

Quick takeaways from the Lions preseason win vs. the Giants

Here are a few things that stood out for the Lions in the preseason opening win vs. the Giants

Football returned to Ford Field on Friday night when the Detroit Lions hosted the New York Giants in the preseason opener for both teams. After two days of spirited joint practices, the two teams took their action to the exhibition field.

The Lions wound up winning the game, 21-16, when rookie QB Adrian Martinez scored a late rushing TD. The game outcome doesn’t matter, it’s the path to the outcome and the play of the Lions players that means everything. Even so, the 48,000-plus fans enjoyed the exhibition victory.

Here are a few things that stood out in watching the game live in the stadium.

Lions UDFA profile: Saginaw Valley State LB Trevor Nowaske

Breaking down Lions UDFA LB Trevor Nowaske from Saginaw Valley State and what he offers to Detroit

[connatix div_id=”3f8b015acdd24c648befc5d5dac47469″ player_id=”afe1e038-d3c2-49c0-922d-6511a229f69c” cid=”7cbcea0d-4ce2-4c75-9a8d-fbe02a192c24″]

The Detroit Lions stayed pretty close to home with some of their undrafted rookie free agent signings in 2023. One Lions UDFA fits that bill for both high school and college.

Linebacker Trevor Nowaske is a graduate of Canton Salem High School in the Detroit area and played collegiately at Saginaw Valley State. The D-II standout earned acclaim with an outstanding workout at the GLIAC pro day, enough that the Lions signed him after the 2023 NFL draft.

It took a little time, but I finally obtained access to more SVSU game tape to properly evaluate Nowaske. I had only seen highlight videos, which were impressive but don’t paint anything close to a complete picture of a player.

Nowaske’s tremendous athleticism definitely shows on Cardinals film.

Nowaske was an outside backer, playing much the same role that Alex Anzalone currently does for the Lions. He’s very quick to click-and-close on the ball on run plays outside the tackles. Nowaske is adept at keeping his feet clean and generally anticipates blocking well. It allows him to take good angles, and his speed suits him well to make plays. He’s also got strong body control to not overshoot the point of attack.

He is a finisher. There is excellent tackling power and pretty good form; Nowaske sinks his weight well as he wraps and has the shoulder and core strength to drop bigger runners. He has shorter arms than ideal for his position, which shows when he needs to reach outside his frame to initiate a tackle.

It’s clear Nowaske understands how to quickly process what he sees, and he generally does so without a lot of wasted motion. There were instances in coverage where he was caught looking into the backfield too long and losing awareness of his coverage mark, something Lions fans lament about Anzalone too.

The football IQ is what will give Nowaske a chance to stick in Detroit. Against Ferris State, the eventual D-II national champs, Nowaske had a monster game. His ability to anticipate, diagnose and react quickly leapt off the game film. He was credited with 15 tackles — it felt like more — as well as an interception. Ferris State runs a complex, inside-zone run scheme with multiple options on nearly every play. Nowaske stayed clean and attacked very well. It nearly led to an upset win for the Cardinals.

At the very least, Nowaske should make the Lions’ practice squad as a rookie and as fellow rookie LB Jack Campbell’s understudy. The athleticism, football IQ and vocal leadership are all there. If Nowaske can adapt to the superior speed and strength of the NFL game, he’s got a real chance to follow in Anthony Pittman’s footsteps and convert a strong GLIAC career to a lengthy NFL career.