Did James Franklin ice his own kicker against Michigan State?

Did James Franklin ice his own kicker against Michigan State? Franklin explains why he called timeout before missed FG

[mm-video type=playlist id=01ey902ehrs6e9bvhw player_id=none image=https://nittanylionswire.usatoday.com/wp-content/plugins/mm-video/images/playlist-icon.png]

Penn State was on the wrong end of a three-point game on the road against Michigan State on Saturday, and Penn State kicker Jordan Stout certainly doesn’t need to be reminded of that fact. Stout, who had been so reliable all season long, missed an extra point attempt and a short field goal in the game played in snowy conditions.

Making things even worse is the idea head coach James Franklin may have frozen Stout all by himself.

Michigan State jumped out in front of Penn State quickly in the first quarter with a 14-0 lead after two offensive possessions, but the Nittany Lions clawed their way back to even the score at 14-14 early in the second quarter. Michigan State then went on a 15-play drive that was forced to settle for a field goal, the only time in five red-zone trips the Spartans did not reach the end zone in the game, regaining the lead at 17-14 with about six minutes remaining in the first half. But Penn State had their own productive drive that looked as though it was setup to either take the lead or tie the game once more before halftime. But as Stout lined up on the snowy turf for a 27-yard field goal with just under a minute left in the first half, Franklin called a timeout.

Naturally, Stout then proceeded to miss the 27-yard field goal attempt.

So, did Franklin freeze his own kicker, in Big Ten snowy conditions on the road? If you believe in freezing the kicker, then there is certainly a strong argument to be made on this particular moment. After the game, Franklin was asked about the decision to even bother calling a timeout in that spot, and he stressed the clock management as the reason for the timeout.

“We were just trying to burn as much time off of the clock as possible, so after we kick the field goal we leave them with the least amount of time as possible,” Franklin explained in his postgame comments, according to Lions 247.

This feels like a poor response, or perhaps it was just poor coaching execution in that particular moment. If franklin was determined to call a timeout at the last possible second, then why even line up the field goal team on the field just standing around and lining up as if to kick the field goal? Why not allow the kicker to remain on the sideline getting himself mentally prepared for the moment before even having to send him on the field?

This is some hindsight being a 20/20 reaction, of course, but Franklin may have brought that on himself on this one. Franklin, and many coaches, will call a timeout at the last possible second before punting the ball away, but calling a timeout as the play clock is expiring on a field goal attempt with the kicker already on the field is not common. And that it happened in the weather conditions Penn State and Michigan State played in is even more puzzling.

Had there been 10 men on the field, or 12, the timeout would make sense. But Franklin said he was only focused on how much time would be left for Michigan State just before halftime. Sometimes a coach can overthink the situation, and Franklin may have done that here.

Of course, Stout missing on four possible points in the game certainly leaves you a reason to direct blame at the kicker for the loss, but there were plenty of other reasons Penn State lost to the Spartans on Saturday as well. But when you play on the road against a quality team like Michigan State, you cannot afford to make the many mistakes Penn State did and expect to come home with a win.

[vertical-gallery id=10568]

[listicle id=10590]

[lawrence-related id=10617,10567,10587,10563,10565,10561]

Follow Nittany Lions Wire on Twitter and like us on Facebook for continuing Penn State coverage and discussion.

James Franklin comments on Joey Porter’s pass interference penalty issues

What James Franklin said when asked about the number of costly penalties by Joey Porter Jr. this season

[mm-video type=playlist id=01ey902ehrs6e9bvhw player_id=none image=https://nittanylionswire.usatoday.com/wp-content/plugins/mm-video/images/playlist-icon.png]

Whenever a team loses a game by just a small handful of points, as Penn State did on Saturday at Michigan State, coaches will go back and take a hard look at the numerous moments that could have led to a much different result. For Penn State, there were a handful of moments James Franklin and the Nittany Lions would love to have back in their 30-27 loss to the Spartans. Joey Porter Jr. being flagged for pass interference in a key spot should be high on the list.

Porter Jr. was flagged for pass interference on Michigan State’s top receiver, Jayden Reed, on a 3rd-and-Goal play late in the third quarter. It is unknown if Michigan State head coach Mel Tucker would have taken his chances with a field goal from the 13-yard line with a walk-on back-up kicker in snowy conditions or considered that four-down territory, so just how costly the penalty was could be undetermined.

Regardless, the penalty on Porter gave Michigan State a fresh set of downs from the Penn State two-yard line, and three plays later Michigan State quarterback Payton Thorne got a push up the middle for a go-ahead Spartans touchdown. Instead of potentially preserving a 20-17 lead, Penn State was now down 23-20, and the Spartans would not lose the lead for the rest of the game.

After the game, Franklin was asked about the concerns with Porter and his abundance of costly penalties this season. The head coach of the Nittany Lions didn’t come right out and single out Porter in his response, but instead seemed to focus on how the coaching staff can work with the entire secondary to improve their technique moving forward.

“We’ve got to help them with not using his hands and not be so grabby,” Franklin explained in his response, according to Lions 247. “Obviously, when you get a number of penalties like that, just like we do, people turn it in ahead of time and you’ve got a bull’s eye on you.”

Needless to say, Porter seems to have a bullseye on him.

Porter’s pass interference certainly wasn’t the only reason Penn State lost to Michigan State on Saturday. The defense, which had been excellent in the red zone all season long, gave up four red zone touchdowns on five red zone opportunities for the Spartans. everyone can take some blame in that. Penn State also lost the turnover battle, 2-1, and rushed for just 61 yards as a team. The defense simply could not get off the field enough either, giving up 9 third-down conversions in 18 attempts and three of four fourth-down conversion attempts by the Spartans.

For Porter, he has had some really good moments this season and has been a steady player when put on the field. But the costly penalties tend to stick out the most, and he has been called for far too many this season.

Add that to the list of things to work on in the offseason.

[vertical-gallery id=10568]

[listicle id=10590]

[lawrence-related id=10617,10567,10587,10563,10565,10561]

Follow Nittany Lions Wire on Twitter and like us on Facebook for continuing Penn State coverage and discussion.

James Franklin defended Penn State’s commitment to the run against Michigan State

James Franklin defended Penn State’s decision to commit to the run against Michigan State

[mm-video type=playlist id=01ey902ehrs6e9bvhw player_id=none image=https://nittanylionswire.usatoday.com/wp-content/plugins/mm-video/images/playlist-icon.png]

Shortly after Penn State came up short in the final game of the regular season, a 30-27 setback at Michigan State, head coach James Franklin was relatively short in his responses to questions from the media. Answering questions with the media is always more tolerable for any head coach after a win, but this particular loss led to some hard questions for Franklin to address and he wasn’t exactly in the mood to do so.

Despite playing a Michigan State team that entered the week ranked 130th out of 130 in FBS against the pass, Franklin defended Penn State’s desire to try running the football as much as it did in the snowy elements in East Lansing.

“It’s important,” Franklin said when asked about the importance of not having a single 100-yard rusher this season (via Lions 247). “I want to be able to run the ball.”

Penn State had three Doak Walker Award watch list players prior to the start of the season; Noah Cain, Keyvone Lee, and John Lovett. None of those three players, or any other player for that matter, managed to rush for 100 yards in a single game all season long. Of course, Franklin is adamant there is still a chance for that to happen.

“The year is not over,” Franklin tensely said when asked about not having a 100-yard rusher this season.

Lee carried the football 15 times for a total of 79 yards, 33 of which came on one play. Cain had one rushing attempt for no yardage and Devyn Ford carried the football twice for seven yards. Sean Clifford was unable to contribute to the ground game as well. As a team, Penn State rushed for 61 yards when taking into account sacks of Clifford by the Spartans defense.

Perhaps the weather played a factor in deciding to try gutting out yards on the ground, but that was never an area where Penn State should have felt comfortable establishing itself after the way the previous 11 games of the season had gone. Penn State’s dedication to the run led to a 4th-and-1 stuff by Michigan State on a day when the best play was to trust Sean Clifford getting the ball into the hands of Jahan Dotson. And Penn State’s decision to run three straight plays down three points midway through the fourth quarter came back to haunt them as well when Lee fumbled the football. Michigan State would go on to score a touchdown, on 4th-and-15 from the 20-yard line, to extend the lead to 30-20.

Penn State’s struggles on the ground were frustrating to see on a weekly basis this season. The offensive line could not create running space and the potential of a three-headed monster on the ground never matched the hype it had going into the season.

But, as Franklin says, the season is not over yet. There will be one more game to try and figure things out on the ground with a bowl game to look forward to. But figuring out the running game should be among the top items on the offseason to-do list for Franklin and his staff.

[vertical-gallery id=10568]

[listicle id=10590]

[lawrence-related id=10617,10567,10587,10563,10565,10561]

Follow Nittany Lions Wire on Twitter and like us on Facebook for continuing Penn State coverage and discussion.

Report Card: Grading Penn State’s loss to Michigan State

Report Card: The grades are in for Penn State’s performance in the regular-season finale loss at Michigan State

Penn State fell to Michigan State late, 30-27, in the final game of the regular season. The Nittany Lions fought to the end, but they started to fall apart in crunch time, losing in a nail-biter.

Let’s take a more in-depth look and grade the performance of the Nittany Lions today.

Quarterback: B+

Raj Mehta-USA TODAY Sports

Despite the loss, Clifford played very well today. His performance was a major reason why Penn State was able to keep it so close for all four quarters. He came into today after battling an illness a week ago but was 100% healthy as this week progressed.

Next: Running Backs

Inside the box score: Key stats in Penn State’s loss to Michigan State

Inside the box score: Some of the key stats from Penn State’s loss to the Spartans in the snow

Penn State’s final game of the regular season game went down to the wire against Michigan State, but Spartans running back Kenneth Walker III really shined today for the Spartans.

Penn State had a very productive passing game, but their run game still struggled through their season-long woes.

Here are some of the key stats that lead to the outcome of Penn State’s loss at Michigan State in the snow.

5 takeaways from Penn State’s loss to Michigan State

5 takeaways from Penn State’s road loss at Michigan State

Penn State never packed it in in some classic Big Ten weather at Michigan State, but the Nittany Lions ended their disappointing regular season on the losing end of a 30-27 final in East Lansing on Saturday. Penn State dug an early hole, battled back from it, and even held a lead thanks to a defensive score in the third quarter. But Penn State just didn’t have enough in the tank to hold off the Spartans in the regular-season finale

Here are five takeaways from Penn State’s fifth setback of the season.

Why did Penn State shy away from the passing game?

Raj Mehta-USA TODAY Sports

The game plan for Penn State should have been pretty simple. Throw the football, throw the football, and throw the football. With receivers like Jahan Dotson and Parker Washington, each making big plays in the first half, at your disposal against the nation’s worst pass defense in the country (Michigan State entered the game 130th out of 130 FBS teams against the pass), this should have been as easy a gameplan to execute as they come.

So why did Penn State back away from it in the second half? Was it purely because of the snow? There were some times when it appeared the ball may have been a bit slippery for Sean Clifford, but there was no good reason to abandon the pass as much as Penn State did in key spots.

A season without a 100-yard rusher is unfathomable

Raj Mehta-USA TODAY Sports

I have personally been harping on this storyline for a few weeks now, only because I find it absolutely incredible that Penn State managed to pull off this ridiculous feat. Penn State went a full 12-game regular season without recording one game with a player rushing for 100 yards. That is practically unheard of, yet it was very much the story of the season.

And that makes Penn State’s playcalling leaning more on the run in the second half even more perplexing against a Michigan State defense that was shredded by Purdue and Ohio State in recent weeks.

If I had to bet a $1 on it right now, I would count on Penn State having at least one game with a 100-yard rusher in 2022. This was just bizarre for a team with three preseason Doak Walker Award watch list players.

What was wrong with the red zone defense?

Raj Mehta-USA TODAY Sports

Penn State’s defense in the red zone had been tough as nails all season long, but Michigan State didn’t get the memo. The Spartans scored two touchdowns in the red zone on their first two possessions and Michigan State left five red-zone trips with four touchdowns. No team has had that kind of success against Penn State inside the 20-yard line all season long.

The biggest of the red zone conversions for Michigan State came in the fourth quarter on a 4th-and-15 conversion from the 20-yard line to Jayden Reed for a key score. The touchdown extended Michigan State’s lead to 30-20 on a day when there was no kicker to rely on for the Spartans.

Things fall apart in the fourth quarter

Raj Mehta-USA TODAY Sports

One of the consistent criticisms of James Franklin over the years has been the decision-making in the fourth quarter. It’s fair to add this one to the list for those keeping track of this trend. Penn State opted to run on 4th-and-1 from the Michigan State 16-yard line in a three-point game and was stuffed for no gain. On the next drive, instead of attempting any passes, Penn State handed off to Keyvone Lee three consecutive snaps and he fumbled on the third, leading to a decisive touchdown.

Penn State’s reluctance to make the biggest plays through the air against this defense was suspect and deserves some questioning.

At least the snow looked great

Raj Mehta-USA TODAY Sports

A snow game in the Big Ten is always fun, and this game did pack plenty of entertainment for viewers. Penn State blended more and more into the scenery with their road white uniforms and the teams did go back and forth for stretches.

[vertical-gallery id=10568]

[lawrence-related id=10587,10563,10565,10561]

Follow Nittany Lions Wire on Twitter and like us on Facebook for continuing Penn State coverage and discussion.

Instant Reaction: Penn State falls to Michigan State late, 30-27

Instant Reaction: Penn State goes down swinging against Michigan State, 30-27

Penn State has been defeated by Michigan State 30-27, but this team did not go down without a fight.

Michigan State’s secondary has been the most struggling part of their team all season, especially in the second half, and it showed today early. Penn State quarterback Sean Clifford came into this game after battling the flu and being benched last week for freshman quarterback Christian Veilleux. Clifford played well. Other than the defense, he and Jahan Dotson were a big reason why Penn State kept the game so close today.

Dotson got work done early, putting up two touchdowns in the first half alone.

[lawrence-related id=10565,10561]

The run game struggled, but the passing game made up for it, and the defense made up for it even more.

Many were pretty high on the Nittany Lions coming into the game. Whatever the outcome was, a close game was predicted, and they weren’t wrong.

Michigan State quarterback Payton Thorne had a decent game, but he has definitely had better performances. Spartans running back Kenneth Walker III did Kenneth Walker III things today. He struggled last week against Ohio State, but he really made up for this week.

The way the second half has been for both teams has made this game less lopsided coming into today.

Both teams now await their bowl game after an up-and-down season.

[lawrence-related id=10563,10565,10561]

Follow Nittany Lions Wire on Twitter and like us on Facebook for continuing Penn State coverage and discussion.

WATCH: Daequan Hardy’s pick-six puts Penn State on top of Michigan State

WATCH: Daequan Hardy’s pick-six gives Penn State the lead at Michigan State

Penn State’s defense has been making some big plays all season long. Early in the second half in snowy East Lansing, it was Daequan Hardy adding his contribution to the success of the defense. Hardy intercepted a pass by Michigan State quarterback Payton Thorne and returned it 17 yards for a go-ahead touchdown.

Hardy’s second interception of the season could not have come at a better time. After Penn State was forced to punt on the opening drive of the second half, Michigan State took over deep in their end. That set the stage for a big play on defense that didn’t have to travel too far.

Hardy’s interception return gave Penn State its first lead of the game. Penn State started off the game trailing 14-0 in the first quarter but battled back to tie the game at 14-14 in the second quarter. Michigan State led 17-14 at halftime after Jordan Stout missed a late first-half field goal that would have evened the score shortly before halftime.

Unfortunately for Penn State, Stout had another miss on the PAT on the pick-six. That kept the game a three-point difference with Penn State up 20-17.

[lawrence-related id=10565,10561]

Follow Nittany Lions Wire on Twitter and like us on Facebook for continuing Penn State coverage and discussion.

WATCH: Parker Washington makes one-handed catch to setup Dotson’s 2nd TD

WATCH: Parker Washington’s one-handed catch sets up a big TD play by Jahan Dotson

The big plays are coming through the air for Penn State, and it helped lead to the Nittany Lions tying the game up early in the second quarter at Michigan State. Jahan Dotson scored his second touchdown of the game to tie things up for the Nittany Lions, but Parker Washington made the play of the drive with a fantastic one-handed snag of a pass from Sean Clifford.

Penn State started the drive in great field position, from the Michigan State 46-yard line. On the second play of the quick scoring drive, Clifford got some air underneath a pass to avoid a Michigan State defender, but it required Washington to make a great effort to come down with the football. Fortunately for Penn State, Washignton was able to get enough lift on his jump and extension to get one hand on the ball to come down for a 16-yard gain.

This catch was so nice, you will want to watch it twice…

On the very next snap, Clifford went back to his primary wide receiver, Dotson, for another big play through the air. Clifford found a streaking Dotson get into enough open space for a pretty easy 30-yard touchdown strike to bring Penn State within an extra point of a tied ballgame after falling behind 14-0 in the first quarter.

Penn State took advantage of Michigan State’s poor pass defense by bunching up three receivers in one spot before the snap. Then it was just  matter of finding the open man once the play unfolded. That man, somehow, became Penn State’s No. 1 receiver.

Penn State did tie the game up at 14-14 with an extra point kick by Jordan Stout. Clifford shrugged off a tough opening drive to quickly amass 150 passing yards with the two touchdown plays to Dotson against a Michigan State defense that entered the week last in the FBS against the pass.

[lawrence-related id=10561]

Follow Nittany Lions Wire on Twitter and like us on Facebook for continuing Penn State coverage and discussion.

WATCH: Jahan Dotson makes terrific catch for TD vs Michigan State

WATCH: Jahan Dotson makes two great catches on consecutive plays to get Penn State on the board

Penn State got off to a rough start on the road against Michigan State on Saturday afternoon, but Jahan Dotson came up with a couple of big catches to help get the Nittany Lions on the scoreboard. Dotson made back-to-back catches along the right sideline to keep a drive alive and to get in the end zone to cut into an early deficit against Michigan State.

Sean Clifford, on 3rd and 12, put the ball where only Dotson was going to make a play along the sideline. After coming down with the catch, Dotson picked up some yards after the catch for a gain of 18 yards to the Michigan State 27-yard line.

On the very next play, Clifford gave Dotson another chance to make a play, and Dotson delivered. Dotson had some separation from his defender on the play down the sideline, but Dotson still had to make a play to get his hands on the football, and he continued to do so as he moved the ball across the goal line before potentially going out of bounds on the play.

Michigan State jumped out to a 14-0 lead on the Nittany Lions with two long touchdown drives on their first two possessions, including a 99-yard march down the field powered by two big runs by running back Kenneth Walker III. Penn State’s red zone defense entered the game as the best in the nation in red-zone scoring defense, and Michigan State scored the first two first-quarter touchdowns against Penn State in the process.

Michigan State led Penn State 14-7 at the end of the first quarter, with Penn State in control of the football.

Follow Nittany Lions Wire on Twitter and like us on Facebook for continuing Penn State coverage and discussion.