2025 Bucs Offseason Preview: Quarterback

The Bucs found their quarterback in Baker Mayfield, but questions remain about the offense as a whole and who will back him up.

When Baker Mayfield resurrected his NFL career in Tampa Bay last year, there was not much expectation that he would be much more than a viable starting quarterback. He shattered those expectations in 2024 by playing like a top-five quarterback and leading one of the best offenses in the NFL.

Just in terms of raw statistics, Mayfield was the best he has ever been. He set career highs in completion percentage (71.4%), passing yards (4500) and touchdowns (41) as well as rush yards (378) and rush yards per attempt (6.3). His raw passing numbers were only surpassed by Joe Burrow and Jared Goff.

Mayfield’s advanced metrics also hit career highs. He averaged 0.209 EPA per play and a 3.6 completion percentage above expectation. These were both top-five figures in the league in 2024 and the best of any Bucs quarterback not named Tom Brady.

Mayfield owes a significant portion of his 2024 success to offensive coordinator Liam Coen, who engineered the Bucs offense to be a top-five unit in the league and turned one of the NFL’s worst rush offenses into one its best.

Mayfield and Coen collaborated to keep the passing offense alive after the Bucs lost Chris Godwin for the season and Mike Evans for a brutal stretch, finding new weapons and leveraging Mayfield’s quick release. While this resulted in the second-lowest average depth of target of Mayfield’s career, it propelled the Bucs into its fourth straight NFC South division title.

Given how effective Mayfield was in 2024, there is not a major issue that he needs to work on this offseason. While he did throw a career-high 16 interceptions this season, his interception rate (2.8) was as far from being his career worst as it was from being his best. Another year in Coen’s offense would help as would having a healthier receiver corps next season, but all things being equal, there will likely always be some variance in Mayfield’s ball security. He is a gunslinger through and through.

The biggest question facing Tampa Bay’s quarterback room and the offense as a whole is whether Coen stays in Tampa Bay or leaves for one of the many head coaching vacancies across the league. His departure would put the Bucs in the familiar, if unenviable, position of installing a new offense, which is unlikely to be quite as potent or variable as the 2024 incarnation.

In any case, Baker Mayfield will be the Bucs’ starting quarterback in 2025. He is under contract through 2026, and with another season even resembling his 2024 performance, Mayfield could be looking at a massive extension as early as next year. His $35.7 million cap hit in 2025 is modest for a starting veteran quarterback, but the Bucs will be looking for savings after next season with key players like Mike Evans, Luke Goedeke and Cade Otton hitting free agency.

The only other real question facing the Bucs’ quarterback room is who will be backing up Baker Mayfield next year. 2021 second-round draft pick Kyle Trask has been Tampa Bay’s backup quarterback for the entirety of his rookie contract and has just 32 regular season snaps under his belt. Trask offers little upside at this point in his career, and his lack of live action reps will limit his asking price to continue on as the Bucs’ backup QB.

Keeping Trask makes a lot of sense for the Bucs at the right price. The next 10 quarterbacks earning more than Trask per season are all making less than $3 million per year, a modest raise from Trask’s $1.7 million 2024 cap figure.

The only other quarterback on the roster is undrafted rookie Michael Pratt, who spent the entire season on the practice squad. While he did sign a futures contract with the Bucs, he simply does not have the experience to enter the 2025 season as the presumptive primary backup.

The Bucs could opt for more upside and the continued discounts a rookie contract offers by letting Trask walk and targeting a rookie quarterback in the draft. While the Bucs certainly will not want to spend a premium draft pick at quarterback, there could be some enticing options in the middle rounds. 

Notre Dame QB Riley Leonard is still a work in progress as a passer, but his running ability gives him a high floor to come into a game and give the offense some answers should Mayfield go down. Syracuse QB Kyle McCord showed a gunslinger mentality of his own after transferring from Ohio State this season. Both Leonard and McCord could be options for the Bucs from the third round to possibly the fifth.

The Bucs will not go into the offseason looking for an heir apparent to Baker Mayfield, who has earned the title of franchise quarterback in Tampa Bay. While the future of the offense as a whole is a little less certain, the Bucs now go wherever Mayfield leads them.

Rookie QB Michael Pratt poses as an exciting option for Buccaneers

The Tampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback position has seen some wild ups and downs in the last decade but they have a stable group now.

The Tampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback position has seen some wild ups and downs in the last decade. Some lows have included Mike Glennon and Josh Freeman, but the highs will never be higher than Tom Brady. The team has recently won a Super Bowl and has that momentum in its sails.

They hope the current quarterback situation can give the same results.

The team signed Baker Mayfield for the long term after his successful 2023 campaign, which included a divisional title. They also have former second-round pick Kyle Trask in their back pocket. To top things off, they have now added a highly talented UDFA quarterback, Michael Pratt.

Pratt played his collegiate career at Tulane, where he started as a true freshman. His first start came on the road in Norman, Oklahoma. Throughout his career, he showed a talented arm, the ability to pick up extra yards with his feet, and the ability to make sound decisions.

While we haven’t seen enough of Trask to make a decision about him, Pratt presents himself as an interesting alternative.

Former Packers QB Michael Pratt signs with Buccaneers practice squad

Former Green Bay Packers quarterback Michael Pratt signed with the practice squad of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers on Thursday.

Former Green Bay Packers quarterback Michael Pratt signed with the practice squad of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers on Thursday.

The Packers drafted Pratt in the seventh round of the 2024 draft but released him at final cuts on Tuesday. Instead of keeping Pratt on the practice squad, the Packers went with second-year quarterback Sean Clifford as the No. 3 behind starter Jordan Love and newcomer Malik Willis.

Pratt completed 22 of 35 passes for 178 yards, one touchdown and one interception. Among his best throws was a 23-yard completion to Julian Hicks in the preseason opener and an 18-yard touchdown pass to Bo Melton in the preseason finale.

However, when neither Clifford nor Pratt proved capable of being the top backup behind Love this summer, the Packers had to make a move — and sending a seventh-round pick to the Titans for Willis was it. Clifford, who was the backup behind Love last season, made more sense as the practice squad option given his experience in the offense.

Pratt never looked ready to be the backup, and he threw a poor interception in the preseason finale.

Packers general manager Brian Gutekunst said the team discussed keeping Pratt as the fourth quarterback but eventually went with just three based on the logistics of adding Willis, who will need time before he’s fully up to speed in the Packers offense.

Gutekunst said he thinks Pratt has a “bright future” in the NFL.

In Tampa Bay, Pratt will replace John Wolford as the No. 3 quarterback behind starter Baker Mayfield and backup Kyle Trask. Also, he will be reunited with Royce Newman, who was claimed off waivers by the Buccaneers on Wednesday.

Report: Packers want Sean Clifford, not Michael Pratt, back on practice squad

A twist: the Packers want Sean Clifford, and not Michael Pratt, back on the practice squad after releasing both QBs on Tuesday.

A bit of a curveball in the construction of the Green Bay Packers’ quarterback room to start the 2024 season: the team wants Sean Clifford back on the practice squad, not rookie Michael Pratt.

The Packers will release both Clifford and Pratt during final cuts on Tuesday. The team agreed to trade with the Tennessee Titans for 2022 third-round pick Malik Willis on Monday.

According to Bill Huber of SI.com, the Packers want Clifford — and not Pratt — back on the practice squad.

While Pratt, a seventh-round pick in the 2024 draft, appears to have more throwing talent and overall potential than Clifford, the Packers likely see Willis as the new developmental quarterback, and Clifford — the more experienced quarterback — is needed as a backup while Willis gets up to speed with the offense early in the season. Clifford can be elevated from the practice squad while the competition behind Jordan Love continues into the regular season.

Per Huber, Pratt will go from being in the mix to be the Packers’ backup to looking for a new home, likely on a new team’s practice squad.

Pratt was a seventh-round pick out of Tulane, where he started all four seasons. He threw one touchdown pass and one interception during the preseason. At no point did he look ready to be the No. 2 quarterback for a team with Super Bowl aspirations, but his arm looked NFL-caliber.

Clifford struggled for much of his second summer in Green Bay. He threw multiple interceptions during training camp practices and was ineffective during the preseason, completing only 22 of 43 attempts.

Of course, the Packers’ plans could change if Clifford is claimed on waivers. It’s also possible some team will see the potential in Pratt and claim him on waivers on Wednesday.

While Pratt is probably a better fit as the No. 3 quarterback on the practice squad, the logistical challenges of getting Willis ready with only days before the start of the regular season will likely necessitate keeping Clifford.

Packers waiving rookie QB Michael Pratt during final cuts

The Green Bay Packers are waiving rookie quarterback Michael Pratt during final roster cutdowns on Tuesday.

The Green Bay Packers are waiving rookie quarterback Michael Pratt during final roster cutdowns on Tuesday, per Tom Pelissero of NFL Network.

Pratt, a seventh-round pick out of Tulane, failed to win the job as the backup quarterback behind Jordan Love during training camp. So did Sean Clifford, who was also released on Tuesday. The Packers agreed to a trade with the Tennessee Titans for 2022 third-round pick Malik Willis, who is now expected to be the backup.

If he clears waivers on Wednesday, Pratt is a prime candidate to return on the practice squad.

Pratt mostly operated as the No. 3 quarterback throughout training camp. During three postseason games, Pratt completed 22 of 35 passes for 178 yards, one touchdown and one interception. His interception in Saturday’s preseason finale was a poor decision under pressure.

While Pratt has arm talent, he was clearly unprepared to be the primary backup quarterback for a Super Bowl contender.

The rookie’s best throws were a 23-yard back-shoulder completion to Julian Hicks in the preseason opener and an 18-yard touchdown pass to Bo Melton in the finale.

Pratt was a four-year starter at Tulane. The Packers made him the 246th overall pick in the 2024 draft.

Exploring 5 backup QB options for the Packers

Five potential backup QB options for the Packers in 2024.

While the Green Bay Packers have their starting quarterback figured out, not much can be said for the backup position. While Jordan Love is primed to have a big season and there’s no questions surrounding his ability, injuries can occur, and having a solid backup is essential for keeping the team’s season on track.

With free agency still offering a few viable options and some in-house candidates competing for the role, the Packers have a range of choices. Here’s a look at some key names that could provide the necessary support behind Love:

1) Ryan Tannehill

(Photo by Maddie Meyer/Getty Images)

Ryan Tannehill brings a wealth of starting experience to the table, and his connection to Packers head coach Matt LaFleur makes him an intriguing option. Tannehill enjoyed a career resurgence with the Tennessee Titans in 2019 under Arthur Smith, who took over for LaFleur as offensive coordinator and ran a similar scheme. His ability to thrive in a play-action-heavy system mirrors much of what the Packers do offensively, making him a seamless fit should he return to that style of play.

With the poor play from Sean Clifford and Michael Pratt, the Packers could use a veteran quarterback in case Love goes down, especially if the roster is built to win. If Green Bay can strike a deal that fits their cap situation, Tannehill could serve as a reliable safety net behind Love.

2. Trevor Siemian

Isaiah J. Downing-USA TODAY Sports

Trevor Siemian has become a well-known name in the backup quarterback ranks. With starting experience and a knack for stepping into challenging situations, Siemian could provide the Packers with a dependable and cost-effective option. Over the years, he has proven to be a steady hand for teams like the Denver Broncos, New York Jets, and Chicago Bears.

Siemian’s experience in various offensive systems would make him a valuable asset to Green Bay, especially in a backup role where reliability and game management are paramount. He understands the role of a backup quarterback and has shown he can deliver when the pressure is on, making him an ideal candidate for the Packers if they’re looking for an experienced yet affordable option.

3. Blaine Gabbert

Dec 30, 2018; Nashville, TN, USA; Tennessee Titans quarterback Blaine Gabbert (7) talks with Tennessee Titans offensive coordinator Matt LaFleur before the game against the Indianapolis Colts at Nissan Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Christopher Hanewinckel-USA TODAY Sports

Blaine Gabbert has carved out a solid career as a backup quarterback and could be a strong addition to the Packers’ quarterback room. Gabbert has spent time with several teams, including the Kansas City Chiefs and Tampa Bay Buccaneers, where he gained valuable experience as a reliable second-string option. In 2018, Gabbert was the backup for Marcus Mariota while Matt LaFleur was the offensive coordinator for the Titans.

Gabbert is known for his preparation and ability to step in when needed, making him a good fit for a Packers team looking for stability at the position. While Gabbert hasn’t been a regular starter, his extensive experience as a backup could help provide depth behind Love.

4. Michael Pratt

GREEN BAY, WISCONSIN – MAY 03: Michael Pratt #17 of the Green Bay Packers participates in drills during the rookie minicamp at Ray Nitschke Field on May 03, 2024 in Green Bay, Wisconsin. (Photo by Stacy Revere/Getty Images)

Michael Pratt had a standout college career and brings athleticism and playmaking ability to the quarterback position. His raw talent and potential make him an exciting prospect for the Packers, and he could develop into a reliable backup with the right coaching and experience.

While it’s unlikely that Pratt would be thrust into action early in his career, his presence in the quarterback room adds depth and a long-term option for the Packers. If they’re willing to develop Pratt, he could be a future backup but there could be growing pains and the inexperience if he’s ever thrown into a situation.

5. Sean Clifford

Aug 10, 2024; Cleveland, Ohio, USA; Green Bay Packers quarterback Sean Clifford (6) runs the ball as he looks for a downfield receiver during the first quarter against the Cleveland Browns at Cleveland Browns Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Scott Galvin-USA TODAY Sports

Sean Clifford is already in Green Bay as a developmental quarterback and could be a wildcard option for the backup role. Clifford is still adjusting to the NFL but has struggled so far this preseason.

Clifford’s familiarity with the Packers’ system gives him a head start on competing for the backup spot. If he turns it around at some point during preseason, the Packers could opt to keep Clifford in-house as the primary backup for Love.

The Packers have a range of options to fill the backup quarterback role. Veterans like Ryan Tannehill, Trevor Siemian, and Blaine Gabbert bring experience and a steady hand, while in-house options like Sean Clifford and Michael Pratt provide developmental potential. The decision ultimately depends on whether the Packers prioritize veteran experience or choose to cultivate younger talent behind Jordan Love.

Whichever direction they choose, the Packers need to ensure they have a reliable option behind Love to navigate the challenges of the 2024 season.

Contract details for Packers seventh-round pick QB Michael Pratt

The Green Bay Packers have officially signed seventh-round pick Michael Pratt and Over the Cap has the contract details.

The Green Bay Packers have officially signed seventh-round pick Michael Pratt. Over the Cap now has the details on what Pratt’s rookie deal will look like.

Pratt earned a standard four-year rookie contract that totals $4.106 million with a signing bonus of $86,940.

Pratt will receive the full signing bonus up front, but from a salary cap perspective, that $86,940 can be pro-rated over the life of the contract. Or, in short, the cap hit in 2024 from that bonus is just $21,735.

That pro-rated signing bonus amount plus a base salary of $795,000 makes up Pratt’s cap hit for this season, which totals $816,735.

Moving forward, beyond 2024, a $21,735 cap hit from the pro-rated signing bonus will be on the Packers’ books all four years of the contract, along with Pratt’s base salary increasing each year as well.

In 2025, Pratt’s base salary will be $960,000. In 2026 it increases to $1.075 million, and then $1.190 million in 2027.

Here is a look at what Pratt’s cap hit will be each season:

2024: $816,735
2025: $981,735
2026: $1.096 million
2027: $1.211 million

Although the Packers just drafted Sean Clifford in the fifth-round of last year’s draft, Brian Gutekunst mentioned at the NFL Combine that he wanted to get back to drafting and developing quarterbacks.

My interpretation of this addition is that it was more so about getting back to an organizational philosophy that prioritizes developing this position rather than the team feeling they had to find an upgrade for Clifford. By all accounts, the Packers are quite bullish on what they saw from Clifford last season.

Of course, the Packers will embrace any competition that Pratt provides, but with Clifford having a year of experience in Matt LaFleur’s system under his belt, he will have a clear leg up in any potential competition that may or may not ensue.

Pratt was a team captain at Tulane and improved his completion percentage each season. He has a big arm and as LaFleur has pointed out, he’s comfortable hanging in the pocket when pressure is around.

“Obviously a winner,” said Gutekunst of Pratt. “He really turned that program around. Started a lot of games for them. I think he won 21 or more games over the past two years. He’s a good athlete. He’s got a pretty live arm. Very accurate.

“Just like the way he handled himself. He had some big wins, so we’re excited. I wanted to add a quarterback and a bunch went early, so there wasn’t a lot of guys available in the mid-rounds. So as we got later and later he was kind of the only left that we wanted to target, so that was kind of nice.”

Green Bay Packers 2024 seventh-round pick: QB Michael Pratt

The Packers selected Tulane quarterback Michael Pratt in the seventh round of the 2024 NFL draft.

The Green Bay Packers selected quarterback Michael Pratt in the seventh round (No. 245 overall) of the 2024 NFL draft.

Height: 6-2
Weight: 216
Age: 22
From: Boca Raton, FL

College profile

Breakdown: Threw a school record 90 touchdown passes and ran in 28 more over 45 games. as a four-year starting quarterback. Also set the school record for passing yards and quarterback efficiency. Three-time team captain. Threw at least 20 touchdown passes and fewer than 10 interceptions during all four seasons at Tulane. Also increased his completion percentage each season as a starter. The Packers like his toughness and poise and were surprised he was still available in the seventh round. While a seventh-round pick, he should get a chance to win the backup job as a rookie.

Dane Brugler’s scouting report: “A four-year starter at Tulane, Pratt thrived in former offensive coordinator Slade Nagle’s scheme. After not playing football until high school, he showed steady improvements each season with the Green Wave, throwing a touchdown pass in 44 of his 45 games and breaking Patrick Ramsey’s school records for passing yards and passing touchdowns. Pratt is very clean in his setup and delivers a quick, accurate stroke, showing the ability to feather passes in between levels of the defense. Though he operates with rhythm from the pocket, he needs to continue developing his feel to spot the rush and hasten his process when needed. Overall, Pratt might not have the high-level physical traits to carry an NFL offense, but you don’t see panic in his game, and he has natural sense for where to go with the football. He projects as a quality NFL backup with starting upside in the right role.”

Lance Zierlein’s scouting report: “Highly experienced and a respected team leader, Pratt has shown consistent improvement from season to season. Pratt has done a nice job of making safe decisions instead of reckless ones and throws with touch over all three levels. He struggles to throw with consistent accuracy and placement on intermediate throws. Also, he appears to lack the anticipation and field awareness to beat NFL coverage across the field. Pratt has Day 3 potential but will be in a battle to win a future backup role.”

They said it: “I think he’s a guy that he definitely is a tough, fearless thrower and that to me is a prerequisite with the position. You gotta be able to stand in there and throw in muddy pockets, throw in the face of pressure and I think he exhibited that. I think he’s a winner, so we were excited. We were kind of shocked that he was still there in the seventh.” — Matt LaFleur

New uniform

RAS card

Highlights

In established QB room, Packers rookie Michael Pratt focuses on controllables

In a well-established quarterback room, Packers rookie Michael Pratt focuses on controlling the controllables.

Green Bay Packers quarterback Michael Pratt will be stepping into a bit of a unique situation as a rookie. However, his approach will remain the same: control the controllables.

“Just controlling what I can control,” said Pratt on Friday. “Just controlling my attitude and my effort. Getting better every day but also elevating all the people around me. You know whatever my role is here, fulfilling it to the best of my ability and just taking it day by day.”

The Packers have a well-established quarterback room. After playing at an extremely high level during the second half of last season, Jordan Love cemented himself as the long-term solution at the position and will receive an extension this offseason.

The Packers also used a fifth-round draft pick just last year on Sean Clifford, who was the team’s backup and someone they remain quite “excited” about. An added wrinkle to all of this is that Pratt and Clifford are actually fairly good friends.

“I believe it actually started at the Manning Passing Academy a couple of years ago,” said Pratt about his friendship with Clifford. “And then we’ve got like a group chat, just other quarterbacks and other people that Sean and I have stayed in touch.”

So where does all of this leave Pratt?

Well, as both Brian Gutekunst and Matt LaFleur have harped on all offseason, competition within every position group is crucial to the overall growth of the team. If Pratt is able to provide that and push Clifford for the backup role, I’m sure the Packers would be thrilled.

But realistically, with Pratt as a seventh-round rookie and Clifford not only having a year of NFL experience but a full year in LaFleur’s offense under his belt, Clifford is going to have the leg up in any potential positional battle that may unfold in the coming months.

Gutekunst’s decision to draft a quarterback is largely rooted in the organizational philosophy that the Packers have around drafting and developing quarterbacks–the most important position in the game.

Pratt comes to the NFL with a “big arm” as Gutekunst mentioned following the draft, something that could be seen on the practice field Friday with the zip that Pratt was able to put on the ball. He is also a three-time team captain, steadily improved his accuracy each season at Tulane, and as LaFleur pointed out, he isn’t afraid to hang in the pocket to deliver the ball.

“Just more years of experience,” said Pratt about his growth in college. “I think knowledge of the defense, understanding coverages, understanding our offense, as well. I think the more reps you have under your belt, the more coverages you’ve seen, more blitzes you’ve seen, getting into different protections to keep yourself safe, being able to get the ball out, keeping the back out on his route. There’s a lot of factors that can play into that.”

The traits and tools are there with Pratt, but like any late Day 3 pick, refinement is needed, especially at a position with such a steep learning curve.

Ultimately, what takes place during training camp and the preseason will dictate how the chips fall and, more specifically, how the Packers’ roster is constructed.

For the time being, Pratt is just taking it one day at a time and, of course, controlling the controllables–learning the playbook, commanding the offense, having high energy, a good attitude, and elevating the play of those around him.

“At this level, I think the intangibles,” said Pratt on what it takes to be a good quarterback. “Everybody at this level has the talent. I don’t think anybody would be here if they didn’t have the talent to be at this level.

“It really comes down to leadership, how you get the guys around you to elevate, getting the locker room to buy in, being a leader – all those kind of things because, essentially, you can’t do everything by yourself. At lower levels – in high school and sometimes in college – you can make stuff happen by yourself. At this level, it’s about what you do, what you get the guys around you to do.”

Packers sign seventh-round picks Michael Pratt, Kalen King

The Green Bay Packers announced the signings of seventh-round draft picks Michael Pratt and Kalen King on Friday.

The Green Bay Packers announced the signings of seventh-round draft picks Michael Pratt and Kalen King on Friday.

Pratt, a quarterback out of Tulane, was the 245th overall pick in the seventh round. King, a cornerback out of Penn State, was the 255th overall pick.

According to Over the Cap, Pratt’s deal is slotted in at four years and roughly $4.1 million. He will get a signing bonus of around $86,000. King’s deal is slotted in at four years and roughly $4.1 million with a signing bonus of around $80,000. Their cap numbers in 2024 will be roughly $817,000 for Pratt and roughly $815,000 for King.

Pratt and King were both in Green Bay for the start of rookie minicamp on Friday. Rookie contracts are four years long and scheduled on a wage scale under the NFL’s Collective Bargaining Agreement, leaving little room for negotiation, especially for late-round picks.