4 Lions free agents who should not return in 2025

4 Lions free agents who should not return in 2025

The Detroit Lions fizzled out sooner than they wanted in the 2024-25 season, in large part because the roster was running on fumes by the time they reached the playoffs.

The defense missed upward of 20 players at a time toward the end of the regular season, putting more pressure on the bodies remaining on the field.

However, just because the roster struggled to stay healthy this season yet still saw a lot of success doesn’t mean they should necessarily run it back with the same guys.

There are a handful of contributors that the Lions would likely be better off moving on from in 2025.

Kindle Vildor

The much-maligned Kindle Vildor is probably the easiest Lions free agent to let go this offseason.

Vildor occupied the impossible space of being a fine special teams player who was thrust into extended time as a corner on a team with championship aspirations. Unfortunately, he did not excel in that role, ranking 115th of all qualifying cornerbacks in the league according to Pro Football Focus’s Player Grades.

There isn’t much of an argument to be made in Vildor’s favor. He’s just not worth signing.

Allen Robinson

Add another player to the “He’s still in the league?” radar.

Outside of devout Lions fans, it’s hard to imagine many people knowing Allen Robinson has actually seen the field on occasion this season. It’s possible Robinson is a good locker room guy or a nice practice player at this point in his career, but at age 31 without any recent tangible success, it wouldn’t hurt to let him walk and focus on the possibility of bringing back Tim Patrick who excelled in that third wide receiver role.

Emmanuel Moseley

I spent all season yelling to the skies, “Where is Emmanuel Moseley?”

Moseley was active for only two games all season after a fairly pedestrian 2023 compared to the success he saw in San Francisco before the Lions picked him up.

Despite being reportedly healthy for parts of the season and the rest of the defense falling around him, he still didn’t get into the game. He was recovering from a knee injury he sustained before the 2024-25 season, but at several points, he was said to be healthy and saw some snaps on special teams.

There may still be a future for Moseley in this league, but the Lions clearly needed corners who could consistently contribute this season and he wouldn’t necessarily be missed.

Ifeatu Melifonwu

Despite some key moments for the Lions over the last couple of seasons, Ifeatu Melifonwu is not ranked high on the list of free agents that the Lions need to focus on bringing back.

Melifonwu played in only four games this season due to injuries, a chronic issue for the safety. In those games he played at or below league average, including a dismal performance in the team’s loss to the Commanders.

Following a stellar 2023 season, 2024 did not do Iffy any favors, and the Lions could likely afford to focus on re-signing Carlton Davis and lean more on assembling elite pass rushers than investing long-term in a league-average player who doesn’t carry any specialization to the positions he plays.

Lions postgame injury report after season-ending loss to Commanders

Lions postgame injury report after season-ending loss to Commanders, with updates on Amik Robertson, Penei Sewell and more

Defensive injuries were a major issue for the Lions this season. Unfortunately, that bad luck continued in the playoff game vs the Commanders.

An early injury to Amik Robertson hurt a secondary that was already missing Carlton Davis. Later on, the loss of Ifeatu Melifonwu forced the Lions deep into the LB depth chart possibly directly contributing to a self-immolating 12-men-on-the-field penalty.

Fortunately, none of these injuries should impact next season.

Here are the injuries I saw during the game along with suspected diagnoses:


Jared Goff – concussion evaluation, 2q 5:19

Goff took a hard blow to his facemask during the pick-6. The helmet shake appeared to absorb much of the force, and his head fortunately did not whiplash into the ground.

There were no obvious signs of concussion on video such as loss of consciousness, ataxia, or dazed appearance. He presumably passed the concussion check on the sideline and returned to the game after missing a few plays.


Penei Sewell – left knee, 2q 7:44

Sewell gets bent over on a flexed knee. He finished the game wearing a left knee brace. Hopefully, this is just a mild patella or quad tendon strain, and there is no joint involvement like cartilage damage.

Assume he’ll get an MRI and hope for no surprises.


Amik Robertson – left humerus fracture, 1q 13:10

A direct blow to the left upper arm resulted in a visible deformity. He was sent to the hospital and has already had surgery for the humerus fracture. The mechanism here was very similar to Alex Anzalone’s fractured forearm where the arm took a direct blow from a teammate and was trapped.

Hopefully, this is an isolated mid-shaft bone fracture that does not involve the elbow or shoulder joint. If there is joint damage, that would prolong recovery.

An early report by Tom Pelissero states that he likely will be ready for OTA’s which hopefully implies no complications such as neurovascular damage or joint damage. He is signed with the Lions through next season.


Ifeatu Melifonwu – right hamstring strain, 3q 6:38

Melifonwu pulled up and reached briefly for the hamstring. He stayed in for another play before leaving the game for good.

He should be ready for OTA’s but likely not with the Lions as he is an unrestricted free agent.


Brian Branch – calf cramps, 3q 5:59 & 1:53

Branch missed a play as he was getting his calf leggings cut off. He appeared to be getting his right calf stretched by a trainer later in the quarter. Likely this was just simple cramps as he finished the game looking fine.

Of note, there have been visible signs at many points during the second half of the year that there may be a chronic/recurrent right leg injury. He was officially listed with a calf injury after week 15.


Jack Campbell – hit to head, 4q 8:18

Campbell took a hard hit to the right side of his head during a tackle. He was down very briefly and appeared to bounce up quickly. He stayed in the game and seemed to be fine. A stinger or concussion are possible. Hope for no delayed concussion symptoms.

Lions regular season injury video retrospective – Defense edition

Lions regular season injury video retrospective – Defense edition: Going over all of Detroit’s defensive injuries and how they occurred

The Lions head into the playoffs as the #1 seed with a 15-2 record. It’s an impressive feat. It’s even more impressive considering the absurd number of defensive injuries the team has had to overcome.

I’ve compiled a video retrospective (if available) of the most significant injuries to the defense. The list is ranked starting with the injuries most impactful to the season.

In parentheses are the number of full games missed during the regular season. Also noted are those players who are currently available.


Aidan Hutchinson, DE (12 full games missed)

Left tibia/fibula fracture, October 13


Marcus Davenport, DE (15)

Groin, September 8
Left elbow, September 22


Alex Anzalone, LB (7) – available

Concussion, September 15

Left forearm fracture, November 17


Derrick Barnes, LB (14)

Right knee MCL/PCL, September 22


John Cominsky, DE (17)

MCL, July 30


Alim McNeill, DT (3)

Shoulder, September 22

Suspected right TMJ, November 10

Concussion, December 5

Right ACL, December 15


Carlton Davis, CB (3)

Left thumb fracture, November 17
Left knee, November 24

Jaw fracture, December 15


Malcolm Rodriguez, LB (7)

Left ankle sprain, October 27

Right ACL, November 28


Ifeatu Melifonwu, S (14) – available

Ankle, August
Left hand, November


Jalen Reeves-Maybin, LB (7) – available

Neck, November 3


Kyle Peko, DT (13)

Left pec rupture, October 13


Josh Paschal, DE (3) – available

Shoulder mass excision, October
Right knee, November 28


Mekhi Wingo, DT (6)

Ankle, November
Right knee, November 28


Ennis Rakestraw, CB (9)

Hamstring, September
Hamstring, November 23


Brodric Martin, DT (10) – available

Right knee, August 24


Brian Branch, S (1) – available

Concussion/illness, September 22

Right calf/leg, December


 

Levi Onwuzurike, DT (1) – available

Left hamstring, November 28


Khalil Dorsey, CB (3)

Right ankle/leg fracture, December 15


Emmanuel Moseley, CB (15)

Pec rupture, August
Hamstring, November
Illness, January


Terrion Arnold, CB (1)

Groin, November
Right foot, January 5


Trevor Nowaske, LB (1) – available

Concussion, December


Pat O’Connor, DT (0)

Calf, January 5

Lions vs Vikings: Final injury report and medical analysis for Week 18

Lions vs Vikings: Initial injury report and medical analysis for Week 18

On Sunday night, the #1 seed is on the line which carries the extremely valuable bye week. With the Lions having the earliest possible NFL bye this year in week five, getting a bye before the playoffs could do wonders for team health.

Fortunately, the past two games were healthy ones for the Lions as there were no significant injuries. The team is even starting to add players with the return of Jalen Reeves-Maybin last week and the possible returns of Alex Anzalone and Kalif Raymond this week.

The Vikings will be missing pass rusher Pat Jones from last game, but the rest of their active roster is in good shape.

For the Lions, there was a downgrade over the week in Craig Reynolds. Otherwise, there were no unexpected downgrades over the course of the week for either team.

(Abbreviations: UL=unlisted, NP=no practice, LP=limited practice, FP=full practice)



DETROIT LIONS

Out – David Montgomery RB, knee (NP NP NP)

Montgomery hurt his MCL and possibly more on December 15 which was 3 weeks ago. The hope is he will be back by the 2nd round of the playoffs which is in 2 weeks.

The full week of NP’s was not unexpected so there is no implication of a setback. Ideally, we see him move to an LP before the first playoff game. He is not on IR thus can practice and play at any time.


Out – Emmanuel Moseley CB, illness (NP NP NP)

It’s unknown the severity of Moseley’s illness. Moseley was active last game but did not log a single snap on defense or special teams. He has yet to play a defensive snap all year.


Questionable – Alex Anzalone LB, forearm (LP FP FP)

Dan Campbell stated today: “No setbacks…. It’s about him getting comfortable…. We want to be smart, we got a playoff game after this…. The only way to trust it is to bang away in there.”

With Anzalone starting his 21-day practice window only 2 days ago, it seems unlikely he will play on Sunday.

Anzalone broke his forearm 7 weeks ago on November 17. The fracture can take around 8 weeks to heal. He probably could play before fully healed with a protective splint as seen with Dallas Goedert who returned in 5 weeks last year and Thomas Davis who returned in 2 weeks for the 2016 Super Bowl.

However, there is a risk of forearm re-fracture which happened to Rob Gronkowski in 2013 when he returned in 6 weeks only to fracture it again 2 weeks later.

An interesting revelation that Anzalone made on the Ross Tucker Football Podcast about a month ago is that he broke this same left forearm in college. So he has first-hand experience with this injury which is helpful.

If this was the playoffs, the reward of playing probably outweighs the risk as there may be no further games. But it’s not the playoffs, and as Campbell mentioned, there are more important games coming.

 


 

Questionable – Kalif Raymond WR, foot (FP FP FP)

Finishing up his second week of his 21-day practice window, I’m expecting him to be ready for the Vikings. He started his window immediately after his 4-week IR stint which means he medically may not need his entire window.

Raymond has not played since November 24.

 


Questionable – Craig Reynolds RB, back (UL UL NP)

The back injury must have happened during the week. Reynolds was an effective #2 RB to Jahmyr Gibbs last game with 7 rushes for 31 yards. If he can’t go, Jermar Jefferson who had 3 for 9 yards last game likely moves up. Sione Vaki is the other option but he got no carries last game.


In – Christian Mahogany OG, illness (UL NP FP)

Mahogany missed all of training camp and the first half of the season due to mono, but the current illness is very unlikely to be related. About 90% of mono is caused by the Epstein-Barr virus, and prior infection generally confers long-lasting immunity.

It’s estimated that 95% of humans worldwide by the age of 35 have immunity to the Epstein-Barr virus due to prior exposure. If you remember watching Barry Sanders, you’ve probably contracted mono in the past whether you knew it or not.

Here is my Mahogany article from September for more fun facts about mono. 


In – Jack Campbell LB, rib (LP FP FP)

Campbell played 100% of the defensive snaps last game. I rewatched the game and nothing jumped out. A rib fracture is not out of the question but can be played through. A rib strain or rib cartilage injury are possible also. Regardless, the 2x FP reassures it’s not too serious.

For reference, Anzalone played with 3 rib fractures last year in the playoffs.


In – Amik Robertson CB, calf (LP FP FP)

Robertson played 100% of defensive snaps last game. My rewatch of the game didn’t pick up anything. The 2x FP to finish out the week is a good sign it’s not serious.

 


IR LIST STATUS UPDATE

Mid-Late playoff return is possible

  • Ennis Rakestraw, hamstring 11/23 – His second hamstring issue of his year has turned into a long-term absence. He was eligible to return two weeks ago, but his 21-day practice window is still not open. This implies he is at least three more weeks away.
  • Carlton Davis, jaw fracture 12/15 – Initial estimated recovery of six weeks would put him at the NFC championship game, but Dan Campbell stated two weeks ago: “It doesn’t look optimistic to get him back”. He is an unrestricted free agent after this year.
  • Aidan Hutchinson, left tib/fib fracture 10/13 – Expecting very limited action in the Super Bowl which is in 5 weeks. Currently at 12 weeks post-injury, the bone is likely fully healed now. There is still leg atrophy as expected, but he is aggressively rehabbing. In 3rd year of 4-year rookie contract with 5th-year option. Expect an extension this coming offseason.

Not expected to return

  • Derrick Barnes, right MCL/PCL surgery – Unlikely to be back. Unrestricted free agent after this year.
  • John Cominsky, MCL surgery – On December 18, Dan Campbell stated he was unlikely to return this season. Unrestricted free agent after this year.
  • Alim McNeill, right ACL – Expect his return around October-November of 2025. Signed an extension this past offseason through the 2028 season.
  • Khalil Dorsey, right ankle/leg fracture – Unrestricted free agent this offseason.
  • Malcolm Rodriguez, right ACL – Expect his return around October 2025. Next season will be the final year of his rookie contract.
  • Marcus Davenport, left elbow – Unrestricted free agent this offseason.
  • Kyle Peko, left pec rupture – Unrestricted free agent this offseason.
  • Mekhi Wingo, unspecified right knee – In 1st year of four-year rookie contract.

IR return count (7 of 10 used)

  • Lions have returned Anzalone, Raymond, Brodric Martin, Moseley, Reeves-Maybin, and Ifeatu Melifonwu twice.
  • The last 3 returns will likely go to Rakestraw, Davis, and Hutchinson.
  • The Lions can use all 3 remaining returns in the playoffs if they choose.


MINNESOTA VIKINGS

Out – Pat Jones DE, knee (NP NP NP)

Last game, video suggested a right MCL sprain which is a difficult injury for an edge rusher to play through.

Jones has 7 sacks on the year so this could be a big loss for Vikings pass rush. He’s 3rd on the team in sacks behind Andrew Van Ginkel (11.5) and Jonathan Greenard (11).

Questionable – Kamu Grugier-Hill OLB, illness (NP NP NP)

Grugier-Hill is a backup who has not played a defensive snap the last two games.

Questionable – Fabian Moreau CB, hip (LP LP LP)

Moreau is a backup who has seen only limited action this year. He has missed the last two games.

In – Aaron Jones RB, quad (LP LP FP)

Jones is in despite a right upper leg issue. It may be an aggravation of an injury to a similar location back in week five. I don’t expect any limitations but there is a possibility of another aggravation.

It’s officially reported as a quad contusion, but it’s possible there is a mild soft tissue strain going on as well. Jones has not missed a game all year.

He has had a very productive year with 1093 rushing yards (4.5 per carry) and 46 receptions for 378 yards.

In – Harrison Smith S, foot/rest (LP FP NP)

This long-time starting safety played 100% of snaps last game and has missed only one game this year. He has two interceptions this year.

In – CJ Ham FB, quad (LP FP FP)

Ham plays a lot on special teams and is a part-time player on offense. He has 5 catches and 2 carries this year.

In – Ed Ingram G, back (UL LP FP)

Ingram is a backup who started the first nine games of the year before Dalton Risner returned from injury and took over.

In – Josh Oliver TE, wrist (FP FP FP)

Oliver has 20 catches for 242 yards this year.

In – Stephon Gilmore CB, rest (UL UL NP)

 

Lions vs Vikings: Initial injury report and medical analysis for Week 18

Lions vs Vikings: Initial injury report and medical analysis for Week 18

The Lions had no major surprises on the initial injury report which means two straight games with no significant injuries. The team is now in the process of adding players with Kalif Raymond and Alex Anzalone who should be ready soon.

The Vikings had a couple concerns coming out of last game in Pat Jones and Aaron Jones. Otherwise, their active roster is looking healthy.

(Abbreviations: UL=unlisted, NP=no practice, LP=limited practice, FP=full practice)



DETROIT LIONS

 

Alex Anzalone LB, forearm (LP)

Anzalone broke his forearm 6.5 weeks ago on November 17. Good news that his 21-day practice window opened today.

Being a veteran who has been with this team for four years, his mental game won’t be a limitation. It’s simply a matter of when he feels physically comfortable. Dan Campbell today stated: “Tomorrow is going to be a really big day for us to see where he’s at.”

Players have come back earlier than this with forearm fractures. Dallas Goedert last year was playing in 5 weeks with a protective splint. If Anzalone doesn’t play this Sunday, he’s almost certain to be ready for the playoffs.


 

Kalif Raymond WR, foot (FP)

Raymond has not played since November 24. He started his 21-day practice window last week which was immediately after his 4-week IR stint. That’s a sign he could be ready at any time. There is a very good chance he returns to action vs the Vikings.

 


David Montgomery RB, knee (NP)

Montgomery hurt his MCL and possibly more on December 15 which was 2.5 weeks ago. NP’s all this week would not be surprising. The hope is he will be back by the 2nd round of the playoffs which is in 2.5 weeks. He is not on IR thus can practice and play at any time.


Jack Campbell LB, rib (LP)

Campbell played 100% of the defensive snaps last game. I didn’t see any issue on my initial watch. A rib fracture is not out of the question but can be played through. The LP status suggests it’s nothing too serious, and he should be available Sunday night.

Amik Robertson CB, calf (LP)

Robertson played 100% of defensive snaps last game without sign of injury. The LP suggests it’s nothing major, and he should play vs the Vikings.

Emmanuel Moseley CB, illness (NP)

Moseley was active last game but did not log a single snap on defense or special teams. Hopefully, we see an upgrade in the next two days. He has yet to play a defensive snap all year.


Notables not on the report

Graham Glasgow had a knee issue last week.

Brian Branch appears to be playing through a right leg or calf issue over the past 3-4 weeks.

Penei Sewell left early for halftime vs the 49ers due to a thumb issue.

Amon-Ra St. Brown appeared to bang his left knee last game.

Jake Bates was seen massaging his left leg on the 49ers turf.


IR LIST STATUS UPDATE

Mid-Late playoff return is possible

  • Ennis Rakestraw, hamstring 11/23 – Was eligible to return two weeks ago, but his 21-day practice window is still not open. This implies he is at least three weeks away.
  • Carlton Davis, jaw fracture 12/15 – Initial estimated recovery of six weeks would put him at the NFC championship game, but Dan Campbell stated two weeks ago: “It doesn’t look optimistic to get him back”. An unrestricted free agent after this year.
  • Aidan Hutchinson, left tib/fib fracture 10/13 – Expecting very limited action in the Super Bowl. Currently at 11.5 weeks post-injury, the bone is likely fully healed. He has posted videos regularly showing gradual progress in activity. There is still leg atrophy as expected. In 3rd year of 4-year rookie contract with 5th-year option. Expect an extension this coming offseason.

Not expected to return

  • Derrick Barnes, right MCL/PCL surgery – Unlikely to be back. Unrestricted free agent after this year.
  • John Cominsky, MCL surgery – On December 18, Dan Campbell stated he was unlikely to return this season. Unrestricted free agent after this year.
  • Alim McNeill, right ACL – Expect his return around October-November of 2025. Signed an extension this past offseason through the 2028 season.
  • Khalil Dorsey, right ankle/leg fracture – Unrestricted free agent this offseason.
  • Malcolm Rodriguez, right ACL – Expect his return around October 2025. Next season will be the final year of his rookie contract.
  • Marcus Davenport, left elbow – Unrestricted free agent this offseason.
  • Kyle Peko, left pec rupture – Unrestricted free agent this offseason.
  • Mekhi Wingo, unspecified right knee – In 1st year of four-year rookie contract.

IR return count (7 of 10 used)

  • Lions have used 7 of 10 returns with Anzalone, Raymond, Brodric Martin, Moseley, Reeves-Maybin, and Ifeatu Melifonwu twice.
  • The last 3 will likely go to Rakestraw, Davis, and Hutchinson.
  • The Lions can use all 3 remaining returns in the playoffs if they choose.
  • During the regular season, the Lions can only use a max of 8 returns but that’s not an issue as Davis and Hutchinson won’t be ready until late playoffs.

 



MINNESOTA VIKINGS

Pat Jones DE, knee (NP)

Last game, video suggested a right MCL sprain which would make it difficult for him to be ready by Sunday

Jones has 7 sacks on the year so this could be a big loss for Vikings pass rush. He’s 3rd on the team in sacks behind Andrew Van Ginkel (11.5) and Jonathan Greenard (11).

Kamu Grugier-Hill LB, illness (NP)

Illnesses usually resolve in a couple days so there’s a good chance he’ll be available. He’s a backup who has not played a defensive snap the last two games.

Aaron Jones RB, quad (LP)

Jones had an issue with his right upper leg previously this year in week five. Last game, he had a wrap in a similar location which was reported as a quad contusion. There may be a mild soft tissue strain going on as well. Jones has not missed a game this year and that trend is very likely to continue.

He has had a very productive year with 1093 rushing yards (4.5 per carry) and 46 receptions for 378 yards.

Harrison Smith S, foot (LP)

This long-time starting safety played 100% of snaps last game. He’s probably playing vs the Lions.

CJ Ham FB, quad (LP)

Ham plays a lot on special teams and is a part-time player on offense. He has 5 catches and 2 carries this year.

Fabian Moreau CB, hip (LP)

Moreau has seen only limited action this year and has missed the last two games.

Josh Oliver TE, wrist (FP)

Oliver has 20 catches for 242 yards this year.

 

Lions vs 49ers: Final injury report medical analysis

Lions vs 49ers: Final injury report medical analysis for Week 17

The Lions may be facing off Monday night against the only team with worse injury woes than them this year.

The bad injury situation exacerbated for the 49ers during the week with multiple downgrades – Colton McKivitz, Charvarius Ward, and Ji’Ayir Brown. Two of those are starting secondary players which would hamper the 49er pass defense. Meanwhile, the Lions got an upgrade with Terrion Arnold.

The Lions active roster is in pretty good shape. Scroll down for the lengthy IR-list update though.

At offensive line, the Lions starters will be intact with the return of Graham Glasgow. Conversely, the 49ers offensive line which was already hurting, is going to be even worse off this week:

  • Starting RT, Colton McKivitz, is trending out with 2 NP to finish the week.
  • Their 3rd starting LT of the season, Spencer Burford, is out.
  • Starting LG, Aaron Banks, is out.

Here is the list of other woes for the 49ers this season:

  • 1st-round rookie WR Ricky Pearsall took a gunshot wound to the chest and missed six games.
  • Christian McCaffrey RB missed much of the year with bilateral Achilles tendonitis and is now on IR with a PCL. He only appeared in four games. Backup RB Jordan Mason is also on IR with a high ankle sprain.
  • Trent Williams LT played 10 games before an ankle ended his season. His backup Jaylon Moore is also on IR with a quad.
  • Brandon Aiyuk WR tore his ACL in week seven.
  • Brock Purdy QB missed one game with a shoulder.
  • Dre Greenlaw LB tore his Achilles in the Super Bowl. He returned for two games but is now shut down for the year.
  • Fred Warner LB has been playing through a fractured ankle bone since week four.

(Abbreviations: UL=unlisted, NP=no practice, LP=limited practice, FP=full practice)



DETROIT LIONS

Out – Kalif Raymond WR, foot (FP FP FP)

Raymond started his 21-day practice window this week which was immediately after his 4-week IR stint. That’s a sign he could be ready very soon, but it won’t be this week. Hope to see Raymond in the final regular season game vs the Vikings or the first game of the playoffs.

 


Out – David Montgomery RB, knee (NP NP NP)

Montgomery has an MCL sprain and possibly more. The hope is he will be back by the 2nd round of the playoffs which is in 3 weeks. He is not on IR thus can practice and play at any time.


Questionable – Jalen Reeves-Maybin LB, neck (FP FP FP)

Currently, at day 9 of his 21 day practice window, I don’t expect him to be available vs the 49ers which will be on day 11. Expect him either the final regular season game vs the Vikings (day 17) or the playoffs.


In – Terrion Arnold CB, illness (NP LP FP)

Arnold upgraded his status over the course of the week which is good news that the illness was benign.


In – Graham Glasgow OG, knee (FP FP FP)

The Lions must feel good about Glasgow’s health as they could have chosen to start Christian Mahogany for a 2nd straight game after his strong performance.


IR LIST STATUS UPDATE

Early playoff return is likely

  • Alex Anzalone, left forearm fracture 11/17 – I thought his 21-day practice might have opened last week, but now another week has passed without his window opening. Hopefully this is not a sign of a setback. The forearm was expected to take 6-8 weeks. Six weeks is the 49ers game which won’t happen. Seven weeks is the final regular season game vs the Vikings which seems unlikely at this point. The playoffs start at the 8-week mark which is only 14 days away.

Mid-Late playoff return is possible

  • Ennis Rakestraw, hamstring 11/23 – Was eligible to return last week vs the Bears, but his 21-day practice window is still not open. This implies he is at least three weeks away.
  • Carlton Davis, jaw fracture 12/15 – Initial estimated recovery of six weeks would put him at the NFC championship game, but Dan Campbell stated last week: “It doesn’t look optimistic to get him back”. Unrestricted free agent after this year.
  • Aidan Hutchinson, left tib/fib fracture 10/13 – Expecting very limited action in the Super Bowl. Currently at 11 weeks post-injury, the bone is likely fully healed. His return will depend on how quickly he can regain his leg strength, burst, and flexibility. In 3rd year of 4-year rookie contract with 5th-year option. Expect an extension this coming offseason.

Not expected to return

  • Derrick Barnes, right MCL/PCL surgery – Unlikely to be back. Unrestricted free agent after this year.
  • John Cominsky, MCL surgery – On December 18, Dan Campbell stated he was unlikely to return this season. Unrestricted free agent after this year.
  • Alim McNeill, right ACL – Expect his return around October-November of 2025. Signed an extension this past offseason through the 2028 season.
  • Khalil Dorsey, right ankle/leg fracture – Unrestricted free agent this offseason.
  • Malcolm Rodriguez, right ACL – Expect his return around October 2025. Next season will be the final year of his rookie contract.
  • Marcus Davenport, left elbow – Unrestricted free agent this offseason.
  • Kyle Peko, left pec rupture – Unrestricted free agent this offseason.
  • Mekhi Wingo, unspecified right knee – In 1st year of four-year rookie contract.

IR return count (6 of 10 used)

  • Lions have used 6 of 10 returns with Kalif Raymond, Brodric Martin, Emmanuel Moseley, Jalen Reeves-Maybin, and Ifeatu Melifonwu twice.
  • At this point, the last 4 will likely go to Anzalone, Rakestraw, Davis, and Hutchinson.
  • The Lions can use all 4 remaining returns in the playoffs if they choose.
  • During the regular season, the Lions can only use a max of 8 returns but that’s not an issue as Davis and Hutchinson won’t be ready until late playoffs.

 



SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS

Out – Spencer Burford LT, calf (NP NP NP)

Burford was hurt while starting at LT last week for Jaylon Moore who was filling in for Trent Williams. With all three of them out, the 49ers will turn to their 4th starting LT of the season.

Out – Aaron Banks LG, knee (NP NP NP)

On video, this starting LG sprained his MCL last week and is reportedly done for the season.

Out – Dre Greenlaw LB, calf (NP NP NP)

Kyle Shanahan stated on Thursday that Greenlaw will be out for the year.

Out – Robert Beal DE, ankle (NP NP NP)

Beal is a part-time defender who also missed last week.

Questionable – Colton McKivitz RT, knee (LP, NP NP)

A downgrade over the week may cost the 49ers their starting RT who has played every game this year. With 2 NP’s to end the week, that suggests he will be out.

Questionable – Ji’Ayir Brown S, ankle (LP LP NP)

Brown is a starting safety who has played every game this year.

Questionable – Charvarius Ward CB, personal (UL UL NP)

Ward is a quality starting CB, so he would be a big loss.

Questionable – Tatum Bethune LB, knee (FP FP)

Bethune, a 7th-round rookie, has missed the last five games with an MCL. He started his 21-day practice window just this week.

In – Leonard Floyd DE, shoulder (LP LP FP)

Floyd has been productive pass-rusher this year with 8.5 sacks.

In – Isaac Guerendo RB, foot/hamstring (LP LP FP)

With the injuries to McCaffrey and Mason, Guerendo has been called on in recent weeks. He’s 2nd on the team in rushing yards with 381 behind Mason.

In – Kyle Juszczyk FB, illness (UL NP FP)


In – FP all week

Nick Bosa DE

Jordan Elliott DT

Talanoa Hufanga S

Dee Winters LB

 

Lions film review: Ifeatu Melifonwu returns with a strong season debut

Lions film review: Ifeatu Melifonwu returns with a strong season debut in Week 16 against the Bears

It’s been a long time coming but last Sunday against the Chicago Bears, the Detroit Lions finally saw defensive back Ifeatu Melifonwu return to the field. Fortunately for the Melifonwu and the Lions, he didn’t disappoint with his performance either.

One season ago, the Lions saw Melifonwu have the best season of his career. He finished with 33 tackles, three sacks, four tackles for loss, two interceptions and 8 pass deflections. Last year, much of his success came from week 13 through the end of the season.

Now the hope for the Lions defense is that Melifonwu has the same late season impact he did from a year ago. Let’s dive into some tape to look at where he will impact the Lions the most on defense.

 

By having Melifonwu on the field, it provides the Lions defense some versatility it didn’t have a few weeks ago. This allows the Lions to place Melifonwu as one of the safeties in a two-high shell or they could play him closer to the box.

Either way, I’d expect him to play interchangeable roles with Brian Branch. Ultimately, we should see the Lions have three safeties (Joseph, Branch and Melifonwu) on the field at the same time.

Looking at the play above, we get exactly that. The Lions come out with an inverted Cover-2 look on defense. Prior to the snap, you’ll see the Chicago Bears in a 2×2 bunch set on offense. In the process, you’ll see Melifonwu (No. 6) in a press alignment on the left side of the defense (bottom of the screen).

Once the ball is snapped, you’ll see the Lions send a 6-man pressure and the first player in the backfield is Melifonwu. Unfortunately, he isn’t able to stay square or keep his feet and he ends up on the ground rather than the quarterback. That said, it doesn’t give Bears quarterback Caleb Williams a clean pocket and forces him out, and he ends up having to throw the football away.

 

Moving onto the next play, we get into the later part of the game but Melifonwu is able to record his first sack of the season. Looking at the play above, we’ll see a similar type of blitz from Melifonwu and the Lions defense.

Sending a 6-man pressure with the point of emphasis coming from the middle, the Bears max protect with the running back to prevent any pressure coming from that area. That said, the speed and pursuit from Melifonwu is too much and it leads to the sack.

Overall, it was a strong season debut for Melifonwu. He registered four total tackles, two total pressures and a sack. In coverage, he was only targeted once and no reception was recorded, per Pro Football Reference.

According to Pro Football Focus (PFF), Melifonwu earned a 64.5 run defense grade, 67.0 coverage grade and a 66.5 overall grade. Not bad for a player that hasn’t been healthy enough to play in the preseason or regular season this year. It’s worth noting that he led all safeties last season with a 47.4% pressure rate.

Having Melifonwu back is important for the Lions defense. We see the pressure he brings and he’s able to help consistently in coverage for the defensive backfield. That said, Lions defensive coordinator Aaron Glenn knows exactly how and when to use Melifonwu. Especially when it’s time to get the quarterback.

Lions vs 49ers: Initial injury report medical analysis and IR-list update

Lions vs 49ers: Initial injury report medical analysis and I.R. list update for Week 17

For the Detroit Lions, there were no major surprises on the initial report which is welcome news. This week, the team is expecting to be gaining health with the return of Graham Glasgow as well as the imminent returns of Kalif Raymond and Jalen Reeves-Maybin.

The only team more injury-ridden than the Lions this year might be the San Francisco 49ers, who were the NFC-favorites prior to the start of the season. A brutal run of injuries has led them to a 6-9 record:

  • 1st-round rookie WR Ricky Pearsall took a gunshot wound to the chest and missed six games.
  • Christian McCaffrey RB missed much of the year with bilateral Achilles tendonitis and is now on IR with a PCL. He only appeared in four games.
  • Trent Williams LT played 10 games before an ankle ended his season.
  • Brandon Aiyuk WR tore his ACL in week seven.
  • Brock Purdy QB missed one game with a shoulder.
  • Dre Greenlaw LB tore his Achilles in the Super Bowl. He returned for two games but is now shut down for the year.
  • Fred Warner LB has been playing through a fractured ankle bone since week four.
  • Jordan Mason RB is on IR with a high ankle sprain.


DETROIT LIONS

Kalif Raymond WR, foot (FP)

Raymond started his 21-day practice window today which is immediately after his 4-week IR stint. This means he could be ready to play right now from a medical standpoint.

However, Dan Campbell today stated “I don’t feel as confident with [Raymond] as [Reeves-Maybin]… but it’s good to get him back running around.” Thus, hope to see Raymond in the final regular season game vs the Vikings or the first game of the playoffs.


Terrion Arnold CB, illness (NP)

Arnold played 98% of snaps last game vs the Bears with no issue. Presumably, an illness started after the game. Cold and flu season has hit America so that could be the cause.

NFL players are often able to recover from routine illnesses within 2-3 days so hope for an upgrade in his status over the course of the week.


Graham Glasgow OG, knee (FP)

Glasgow missed last game with the knee injury but is on track to return to the starting lineup vs the 49ers. The starting offensive line will again be intact.


Jalen Reeves-Maybin LB, neck (FP)

JRM was hurt November 3, placed on IR, and started his 21-day practice window on December 19. The injury was initially reported by the Lions as a shoulder but ended up being a neck.

Currently, at only day 7 of his 21 day practice window, don’t expect him to be available vs the 49ers which will be on day 11. Expect him either the final regular season game vs the Vikings (day 17) or the playoffs.


David Montgomery RB, knee (NP)

Montgomery’s knee injury is an MCL sprain and possibly more. The hope is he will be back by the 2nd round of the playoffs which is in 3.5 weeks. He is not on IR thus can practice and play at any time.


 

IR LIST STATUS UPDATE

Returning soon

  • Alex Anzalone, left forearm fracture 11/17 – The forearm was expected to take 6-8 weeks, and the 49ers game is the 6-week mark. The playoffs start at the 8-week mark which is only 16 days away. Anzalone’s 21-day practice window has yet to open which raises eyebrows. Forearm fractures heal reliably so a setback is unlikely but not impossible.

Early playoffs at best

  • Ennis Rakestraw, hamstring 11/23 – Was eligible to return last week vs the Bears, but his 21-day practice window is still not open. This implies he is at least three weeks away.

Late playoffs is possible

  • Carlton Davis, jaw fracture 12/15 – Initial estimated recovery of six weeks would put him at the NFC championship game, but Dan Campbell stated last week: “It doesn’t look optimistic to get him back”. Unrestricted free agent after this year.
  • Aidan Hutchinson, left tib/fib fracture 10/13 – Expecting very limited action in the Super Bowl. Currently at 10.5 weeks post-injury, the bone is likely healed at this point. Hutchinson has significant expected atrophy in his legs so it all depends on how quickly rehab goes. In 3rd year of 4-year rookie contract with 5th-year option. Expect an extension this coming offseason.

Not expected to return

  • Derrick Barnes, right MCL/PCL surgery – Unlikely to be back. Unrestricted free agent after this year.
  • John Cominsky, MCL surgery – On December 18, Dan Campbell stated he was unlikely to return this season. Unrestricted free agent after this year.
  • Alim McNeill, right ACL – Expect his return around October-November of 2025. Signed an extension this past offseason through the 2028 season.
  • Khalil Dorsey, right ankle/leg fracture – Unrestricted free agent this offseason.
  • Malcolm Rodriguez, right ACL – Expect his return around October 2025. Next season will be the final year of his rookie contract.
  • Marcus Davenport, left elbow – Unrestricted free agent this offseason.
  • Kyle Peko, left pec – Unrestricted free agent this offseason.
  • Mekhi Wingo, right knee – In 1st year of four-year rookie contract.

IR return count (6 of 10 used)

  • Lions have used 6 of 10 returns with Kalif Raymond, Brodric Martin, Emmanuel Moseley, Jalen Reeves-Maybin, and Ifeatu Melifonwu twice.
  • At this point, the last 4 will likely go to Anzalone, Rakestraw, Davis, and Hutchinson.
  • The Lions can use all 4 remaining returns in the playoffs if they choose.
  • During the regular season, the Lions can only use a max of 8 returns but that’s not an issue as Davis and Hutchinson won’t be ready until late playoffs.

 



SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS

Spencer Burford LT, calf (NP)

Burford was hurt while filling in at LT last week for Trent Williams.

Dre Greenlaw LB, calf (NP)

Kyle Shanahan stated today that Greenlaw will be out for the year.

Aaron Banks OG, knee (NP)

On video, Banks appeared to sprain his MCL last week. That makes it unlikely he’ll play.

Robert Beal DE, ankle (NP)

Beal is a part-time defender who also missed last week.

Ji’Ayir Brown S, ankle (LP)

Brown is a starting safety who has played every game this year.

Isaac Guerendo RB, foot/hamstring (LP)

With the injuries to McCaffrey and Jordan Mason, Guerendo has been called on in recent weeks. He’s 2nd on the team in rushing yards with 381 behind Mason.


Here is the full 49ers report:

Lions postgame medical report following the second meeting with the Bears

Lions postgame medical report following the Week 16 meeting with the Bears is mercifully shorter than most weeks

On Sunday, Santa delivered an early Christmas present to OnePride nation in the form of a healthy game and an Eagles loss. Unfortunately, the Grinch stole away the Seahawks potential win over the Vikings. Regardless, the Lions are in better shape for the #1 seed today with the Eagles mostly out of the way.

I didn’t see any injuries, or even any potential injuries, during the Bears game so this will be a very positive post. Before I get to the Lions good news, here’s an update on the Bears LT Braxton Jones who was carted off in a vacuum splint.


Braxton Jones – left leg fracture

Video was concerning for a tibia/fibula fracture similar to Aidan Hutchinson and Khalil Dorsey, or a severe high ankle sprain with fibula fracture similar to James Houston.

Early reports by @RapSheet suggest only a fibula fracture, and he should be ready for next season.


Christian Mahogany

This 6th-round rookie missed all of training camp and the first half of the season due to mono. There were questions whether he would be physically and mentally ready to contribute this season. Those questions were laid to rest as he made a brief, 3-snap appearance two weeks ago and then started his first NFL game at LG yesterday. He played 100% of snaps, performed well, and has already outpaced expectations for this year.

With the health status of Graham Glasgow (knee) currently in question, Mahogany’s emergence is already paying dividends this year. With Kevin Zeitler an unrestricted free agent this offseason, dividends likely will be paid next year as well. Having a late-round rookie contract starting on the offensive line would help out the Lions salary cap significantly.

Mahogany was wearing a right knee brace throughout the game yesterday. He wore the same brace two weeks ago in his brief stint, so the brace may be precautionary. He has a history of a right knee ACL tear in 2022.


Ifeatu Melifonwu

Melifonwu had missed all of this year with ankle and hand injuries. He made his first appearance this year logging 80% of snaps and registering a sack. Multiple times he was sent on blitzes, and his productiveness in that role will be a key factor for the Lions going forward given their depleted defensive line.


Brian Branch

Branch entered the game questionable with a calf. This is presumably a calf strain which can easily get aggravated. He played 100% of defensive snaps without obvious aggravation which is great news going forward.

Here is video from the previous game vs the Bills.


Josh Paschal

Paschal is still wearing a right knee brace after hurting that knee in the first meeting vs the Bears three weeks ago. He looked fine throughout the game playing 70% of snaps which is in his normal range.

Here is the video of his knee injury from three weeks ago:


Emmanuel Moseley

Recovered from an August pec rupture, Moseley logged 14 special teams snaps vs the Bears in his second appearance of the season. In his only other appearance, he had 15 special teams snaps vs the Colts a few weeks ago. He has yet to play a defensive snap this year.

The Lions secondary stayed healthy throughout the Bears game so there may simply have been no snaps available for backups. Kindle Vildor, who has been the primary CB backup, also had no defensive snaps.

Moseley still may see an important role in the secondary this season with Carlton Davis (jaw fracture) and Khalil Dorsey (ankle fracture) out.

Lions inactive players vs Bears: Brian Branch will play, Graham Glasgow out

Lions inactive players vs Bears: Brian Branch will play but Graham Glasgow is among those who are inactive

Winter’s arrival sees the Detroit Lions blowing into the Windy City with a division title on their minds. The Lions face the Chicago Bears in Week 16 at 1 p.m., and Detroit faced the weekly challenge of figuring out which players on the active roster won’t play in Soldier Field.

The Lions had already ruled out two players due to injuries. Running back David Montgomery and linebacker Jalen Reeves-Maybin will not play, as expected. Reeves-Maybin technically still remains on the injured reserve, so he’s not a designated inactive for this game.

Three players were listed as questionable. Safeties Brian Branch and Ifeatu Melifonwu will both play against the Bears, with Melifonwu making his 2024 season debut after two separate stints on the I.R.

[lawrence-related id=117259]

The full inactive list:

RB David Montgomery
OL Graham Glasgow
OL Giovanni Manu
DL Brodric Martin
DL Jonah Williams
OL Colby Sorsdal
LB Kwon Alexander

It’s a demotion for Alexander after playing extensively the last two games.