How 12 football head coaches fared as the replacements for legends like Bill Belichick and Nick Saban

Who replaced Bear Bryant, Don Shula and John Madden and how did they do?

During one of the craziest weeks of football in recent memory, we saw the end of an era for legends like Bill Belichick and Nick Saban.

Belichick, 71, and Saban, 72, are easily two of the greatest coaches that the sport has ever seen. Next season, college football will look very different without Saban coaching Alabama. Meanwhile, the NFL will also look very different without Belichick coaching the Patriots.

Both teams will have huge decisions about how to fill these massive shoes. While there are some interesting candidates for the gig in New England and the job in Tuscaloosa, can either live up to the reputation that Belichick and Saban built?

We looked back at some of the most legendary coaches in football history, both in the NFL and in college football, to learn how these replacements have typically fared.

The results are a fairly mixed bag but if there is one thing we learned, it is that it is not easy to replace someone as accomplished as either of these two Hall of Fame-caliber coaches.

The best head coach in franchise history for all 32 NFL teams

Here are the best coaches ever for every franchise.

As one legendary NFL coach once put it: Leaders are made, they are not born.

In the rich tapestry that is pro football history, we’ve seen a lot of different personalities roam on NFL sidelines. The league has not been short on firebrands willing to start contentious feuds all over the country on a whim. It’s had more than its fair of eccentrics whose singular focus on football served them and their players quite well. More often than not, in fact, the classic “Football Guy” coach is who our obsessive American culture has lionized as a hero time and again.

There have also been a lot of awful coaches in NFL history. “Black Monday” doesn’t become a de facto “holiday” for the sport without a consistent churn of incompetence. Some folks just don’t deserve that famous headset. They are not leaders, and they can’t be made into them.

But, every now and then, we’ve seen a truly great coach rise from previous irrelevance. That person with an undeniable charm, drive, and a forward-thinking approach to the games. That person who resonates with their team and fans. These are the sideline leaders we revere. These people elevate the sum of their parts, wring out every last drop of talent and effort from their squads, and become a staple of their city’s history.

The list below breaks down the best-ever coach for all 32 NFL teams. It accounts for performance, cultural impact, longevity, and even whether someone was simply the most prudent pick of an otherwise forgettable litter. Some of these selections are obvious no-brainers, ones who are probably already on your mind. Others, there was a bit more debate.

Let’s dive in.

Also check out:

Bear Necessities: Bill Belichick ties George Halas for second most all-time NFL wins

Bill Belichick has a chance to pass George Halas when his Patriots face the Bears on Monday Night Football in Week 7.

This is our online morning newsletter, Bear Necessities. Subscribe to get the latest Bears news delivered to your mailbox every day.

The Chicago Bears haven’t fared well against New England Patriots head coach Bill Belichick.

Chicago is 1-5 against Belichick, and they’ve lost five straight games to the Patriots dating back to 2002. That lone victory came during Belichick’s first year as New England’s head coach, where the Bears won 24-17.

The last meeting between these two teams came in 2018, when the Patriots escaped Soldier Field with a 38-31 victory as a Hail Mary attempt fell short for Chicago.

The Bears will face off against the Patriots on Monday Night Football in Week 7, and both teams are trending in the opposite direction. New England is sitting at 3-3 and coming off a dominating 38-15 victory over the Cleveland Browns, which was a historical win for Belichick.

Belichick recorded his 324th victory as an NFL head coach, which tied Bears founder and legend George McCaskey for the second most all-time.

Belichick has a chance to pass Halas when his Patriots face the Bears on Monday Night Football in Week 7.

[mm-video type=playlist id=01eqbve7kb6he6scwe player_id=none image=https://bearswire.usatoday.com/wp-content/plugins/mm-video/images/playlist-icon.png]

[pickup_prop id=”28807″]

Matt Nagy fired: Every Bears head coach’s all-time record

From Matt Nagy to George Halas, we’re taking a look at every Bears head coach’s all-time record in Chicago.

The Chicago Bears have parted ways with head coach Matt Nagy after four years. It was a move that many expected over the last couple of months, and one that marks the first of perhaps several changes this offseason.

While Nagy has received his fair share of criticism, and rightfully so, he actually finishes his Bears tenure with a winning record. Granted, he benefitted from some great defenses, but his offense got worse with each passing season.

With that in mind, we’re taking a look at every Bears head coach’s all-time record, starting with Nagy and ending with George Halas.

*Records courtesy of The Football Database and include postseason

Andy Reid moves into fifth on all-time wins list

Andy Reid now has 230 career victories, one more than Curly Lambeau

It wasn’t as easy as expected but Andy Reid and the Kansas City Chiefs survived the Carolina Panthers, 33-31, on Sunday.

The victory was the 230th in Reid’s NFL coaching career, pushing him past Curly Lambeau into fifth place all-time.

Who is next? The great Tom Landry at 270. Although to be on this list, you have to have been a great coach.

This list includes playoff victories.

1. Don Shula 347

2. George Halas 324

3. Bill Belichick 306

4. Tom Landry 270

5. Andy Reid 230

6. Curly Lambeau 229

Throwback Thursday: George Halas and the Bears officially form the NFL

On this day in Bears history, George Halas and the Decatur Staleys join the American Professional Football Association.

Every Thursday throughout the 2020 regular season, Bears Wire will take a look back at some of the most memorable moments in Bears history that occurred on that given day.

September 17, 1920: George Halas and the Decatur Staleys join the American Professional Football Association

100 years ago today, before they were known as the Chicago Bears, the Decatur Staleys were entering their second season of existence with new player-coach George Halas joining the team. After playing one year as an independent team, the Staleys were invited to a meeting with other Midwest football teams to discuss the formation of a new professional league.

On September 17, 1920, the Staleys, represented by Halas himself, officially formed and joined the American Professional Football Association, renamed the National Football League in 1922. 14 teams in total joined the new league.

Nearly one month later, the Staleys played in their first NFL game. They would ultimately go 10-1-2 in the inaugural league season, finishing second behind the Akron Pros. Champions were decided by season record with no playoff games in existence. Halas’ Staleys would relocate north of Decatur to Chicago just one season later in 1921, then changing their name to the Bears in 1922. The rest, as they say, is history.

The Bears, still known as the “charter franchise,” are just one of two original teams still remaining from the 1920 formation of the NFL. The other team is the Arizona Cardinals, formerly of Chicago.

[vertical-gallery id=454581]

[lawrence-related id=454937,454929,454916,454923]

Forbes values Chicago Bears at $3.45 billion, 13th most in sports

According to Forbes, the Chicago Bears rank as the 13th most valuable sports team in the world and sixth most in the NFL.

The Chicago Bears have been around for a long time. One hundred years, to be precise, and they’ve cultivated a century’s worth of history. But Bears ownership also has some money to show for it.

According to Forbes, the Bears ranks as the 13th most valuable sports team in the world, valued at $3.45 billion. That’s good enough for the sixth most valuable team in the NFL.

George Halas purchased the then-Decatur Staleys for $100, which obviously makes the Bears an absolute steal. Then again, without Halas, there wouldn’t be a National Football League. The Bears remain one of only two remaining franchises from the NFL’s founding in 1920. The other being the Arizona Cardinals, who were originally in Chicago. The Bears remain in the Halas family, as the team is now owned by Halas daughter Virginia McCaskey.

With the uncertainties surrounding the COVID-19 pandemic, the Bears haven’t decided whether or not fans will be permitted at regular-season games. There won’t be season tickets this year, so the team has offered full refunds or offered to roll over the money to the 2021 season. If there are fans allowed at Soldier Field this season, only season ticket holders will be able to purchase individual game tickets with a smaller capacity allowed at the stadium.

According to Forbes, the Chicago Bears made $453 million in total revenue during the 2018 season. If NFL games were to be played without fans, the Bears would lose $166 million in stadium revenue, which is the 12th most in the league.

That would revenue from tickets, sponsors, parking, concessions and team stores.

[vertical-gallery id=449460]

[lawrence-related id=451642,451630,451465,451730,451658]

Cowboys Travis Frederick named 2020 George Halas Award winner

Former Cowboys center was selected by the PFWA as the 2020 George Halas Award winner.

Former Cowboys center Travis Frederick is the recipient of the 2020 George Halas Award, an honor given by the Pro Football Writer’s Association to an NFL player, coach or staff member who overcomes the most adversity to succeed.

Named after Chicago Bears legend George Halas, the award has been given yearly since 1969. Frederick is the second Dallas player to receive the George Halas Award (Roger Staubach, 1980), and comes after a season in which he played 16 high-quality games following a year-long absence due to Guillain-Barré syndrome. Frederick retired early this offseason following the valiant comeback campaign.

Frederick’s road to recovery has been well-chronicled, one that took a toll both mentally and physically. The ordeal likely cut short a prolific career for the 2013 first-round pick. Frederick started 96 games over six NFL seasons, was named to five Pro Bowls and earned three All-Pro honors. The only time he missed in his career was during that lost 2018 season.

Other finalists for this year’s George Halas Award included DT Everson Griffin, OT Russell Okung, TE Darren Waller, and Ravens TE coach Bobby Engram.

Who are the five most impactful people in Bears’ history?

With an NFL record 27 Hall of Famers, there is no shortage of talent in Chicago Bears’ history.

The Chicago Bears have a rich history in their 100 years of existence. With an NFL record 27 Hall of Famers, there is no shortage of talent in this franchise’s existence.

CBS Sports compiled a list of the five most impactful people in an NFL team’s history. The requirements include just one quarterback, one head coach and three non-quarterback players.

Given there is so many impactful figures in Bears’ history, there were many different directions this list could’ve gone. Although, there are three players that nearly everyone agrees belongs on this list.

When you’re talking about which head coach gets the nod for the Bears, there’s no other choice than George Halas. Especially considering that there would be no NFL without him. CBS Sports noted that Mike Ditka missed the cut at coach.

There’s a reason the winner of the NFC gets awarded the George Halas Trophy, a tradition that began back during the 1984-85 season. Halas isn’t just the Bears’ best-ever coach, he’s also one of the greatest coaches in the history of the sport. In his 40-year coaching career that began in 1920 with the Decatur Staleys — who would become known as the Chicago Bears in 1922 — and ended in 1967, Halas went a remarkable 318-148-31 with the franchise, leading them to six championships along the way.

The Bears don’t have a great history of quarterbacks, so this could’ve been really easy or really difficult in choosing which quarterback landed on this list. While Sid Luckman was the first one to spring to mind, CBS Sports went in a different direction with Jay Cutler.

Obviously, the Bears’ history of quarterback play is dreadful — so dreadful that Sid Luckman, who last played for the Bears in 1950, held most of the Bears’ passing records until Cutler came along — but Cutler departed Chicago as the team’s all-time leader in passing yards (topping Luckman by 8,757 yards) and touchdown passes (17 more than Luckman). Keep in mind that for most of Cutler’s prime, he was playing behind a terrible offensive line and throwing to receivers like Devin Hester, Johnny Knox, and Earl Bennett. He didn’t have much help. Matt Forte, a running back, was probably his most consistent weapon over the years.

When you’re thinking of the most impactful people in Bears’ history, the first one that comes to mind is arguably the best player to play the game in running back Walter Payton. You can’t have this list without Sweetness.

Payton meets all of the necessary requirements: He’s the best running back in franchise history and it’s not particularly close, won a Super Bowl, captured MVP in 1977, and is one of the best players at his position group in the history of football — only Emmitt Smith has Payton beat in career rushing yards.

If we were ranking the top three players in Bears history, Payton would lead the list. Just take it from those who played with and coached him. Ditka once called Payton “the very best football player I’ve ever seen, period. At any position.” Meanwhile, Dan Hampton once said Payton was “the best football player of our time. Bar none.”

Chicago’s history of linebackers needs no introduction, and another player that is a must-have on a list of all-time great Bears includes one of the most feared linebackers in NFL history, Dick Butkus.

In more than half of his nine seasons, Butkus was named first team All-Pro, made eight Pro Bowls, racked up 22 interceptions, and generated the ninth-highest approximate value among all Bears players ever. But Butkus’ importance to the Bears extends beyond the stats. He never won a Super Bowl, which would’ve enhanced his legacy, but he is regarded as one of the best and most feared linebackers in the history of the sport.

Keeping with the linebacker theme, there is some debate as to who ranks as the second-best linebacker in Bears history. Whether it’s Bill George, Mike Singletary or Brian Urlacher, you really can’t go wrong with your choice. CBS Sports went with Urlacher for the final spot on this list of five.

The Bears might not have ever had a truly great quarterback, but you can’t deny just how many great linebackers they’ve produced. If Butkus is 1A, then Urlacher is 1B. The recent Hall-of-Fame inductee wrapped up his career in 2012, retiring with the most solo tackles in franchise history. The beginning of his career was marked by a Defensive Rookie of the Year award. Along the way, he won Defensive Player of the Year in 2005, garnered four first team All-Pro selections, and eight Pro Bowl nods.

Who would be your top five most impactful people in Bears’ history?

[vertical-gallery id=445985]

[lawrence-related id=448199,448158,448177,448132,448061]