Mike Tomlin highlights what led to fake-punt decision in Week 10

Mike Tomlin shed additional light on the decision to call the fake-punt against the Washington Commanders in Week 10.

While taking risks on special teams has paid off for the Pittsburgh Steelers in the past, the team hit a snag in Week 10 against the Washington Commanders. A failed fake punt nearly cost them the game, leading to plenty of questions for Head Coach Mike Tomlin.

In Monday’s press conference leading up to the Week 11 matchup against the Baltimore Ravens, Tomlin explained what prompted the decision to attempt a fake punt in Washington: “We’re just not gonna allow people to do unorthodox and potentially unsound things against us. I’m not gonna allow people to over-stress our punt protection unit by leaving people uncovered when we have people capable of throwing and catching the football.”

Interestingly enough, though the play didn’t work as intended, Tomlin added that these special teams plays are a focus in 2024, and as routine as offensive or defensive calls.

Can fans of the Black and Gold expect more trick plays moving forward, or will Tomlin be forced to dial it back after the failed Week 10 attempt?

[lawrence-auto-related count=3]

Huge special teams mistake cost Steelers 7 points

Steelers’ fake punt misfire led to a Commanders TD, shifting momentum to Washington in their toughest game of the 2024 season.

It is safe to say Steelers’ CB James Pierre may be getting the cold shoulder from the Steel City, following what appeared to be a beautifully designed fake-punt call by Pittsburgh’s special teams coach Danny Smith—only for Pierre to drop the pass from special teams ace Miles Killebrew.

On fourth down, deep within the Steelers’ own 20-yard line, the shocking 18-yard pass from Killebrew seemed to catch Washington’s special teams unit off guard, and would have given Pittsburgh a crucial first down. However, due to Pierre’s botched execution, the Commanders took over in the red zone on downs.

A handful of plays later, this decision on special teams ultimately gifted Commanders RB Austin Ekeler a one-yard rushing touchdown, tying the game at 7-7 and shifting momentum away from Pittsburgh.

The special teams unit eventually rebounded in a big way, recovering a fumble off a muffed punt in the second quarter, immediately granting red-zone positioning to the Steelers offense.

Pittsburgh will need all three facets of their game to be near-perfect, as the 7-2 Commanders are their toughest opponent of the 2024 season so far.

[lawrence-auto-related count=3]

Saints punter Matt Hayball fools Panthers on fake punt

The New Orleans Saints got a little creative during Sunday’s game against the Carolina Panthers, and it paid off. Rookie punter Matt Hayball made the play of the day:


The New Orleans Saints got a little creative during Sunday’s game against the Carolina Panthers, and it paid off.

After a week in which head coach Dennis Allen pulled the trigger on the decision to punt the ball in one of the most cowardly manners we have ever seen in football history, the team actually made a smart special teams call here.

On 4th & 1 with just under nine minutes remaining in the third quarter, punter Matt Hayball faked it and carried the ball himself for the first down. Plays like this could be crucial in the ultimate outcome in what’s been perhaps an even closer game than anyone originally expected.

The Saints, despite hading into the game on an abysmal six-game losing streak, were still favored by a slight margin, with some going so far as to expect to New Orleans to record a double-digit victory.

If anything, that’s a testament to just how poorly both teams have performed this season.

The Saints currently trail the Panthers by just one point, 17-16.

[lawrence-auto-related count=5]

Chiefs DB Jaden Hicks explains the failed fake punt attempt vs. 49ers: ‘That didn’t work out’ 

Kansas City #Chiefs defensive back Jaden Hicks explains the failed fake punt attempt vs. the San Francisco #49ers: ‘That didn’t work out’ | @EdEastonJr

Kansas City Chiefs rookie defensive back Jaden Hicks addressed with reporters on Wednesday the failed fake punt attempt against the San Francisco 49ers in Week 7.

“Yeah. So throughout the week, we’ve been planning if it was a fourth and one, then we’re gonna run that fake,” said Hicks. “So the fourth and one came, and we decided to run it, but they clogged up the middle pretty much. And so, yeah, that didn’t work out too good.”

Hicks was unable to get any push when he received the ball on the fake and was immediately smothered by 49ers defenders. The turnover on downs occurred in the first quarter, stalling Kansas City’s drive.

“As soon as he said, it like, we’re running deep, that play, and I’m like, okay, so we had to get it,” said Hicks. “yeah, just seeing everything was closed up in the middle, that’s where the play was designed.”

The rookie redeemed himself with a clutch interception and was one of three on the day against Brock Purdy. The young defensive back continues to earn the trust of the coaching staff.

WATCH: Chiefs pull off tricky fake punt, convert on fourth down vs. Chargers

The #Chiefs used a fake punt to convert on a fourth down against the #Chargers in Week 18.

The Kansas City Chiefs resorted to trickery to keep a drive alive against the Los Angeles Chargers in Week 18.

Midway through the second quarter, the Chiefs’ offense stalled out on what seemed to be a promising sequence, and Andy Reid elected to send his punt unit out on fourth down.

Everything seemed normal until the ball was snapped and veteran running back La’Mical Perine took a carry for nine yards to get Kansas City back to first down.

Check out a video of the tricky conversion here:

While the Chiefs weren’t able to end this drive with a touchdown, they managed to march the ball near the goal line to set up kicker Harrison Butker with an easy field goal attempt.

Butker would nail his three-point try to give Kansas City a 10-point lead with a little over four minutes remaining before halftime.

Fans can expect Andy Reid to continue looking for unique ways to keep his offense on the field as the Chiefs rest their starters ahead of the AFC playoffs.

Kyle Shanahan didn’t call fake punt on negated Mitch Wishnowsky run

Did Kyle Shanahan call his first fake punt as a head coach?

It looked like 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan called his first special teams fake as a head coach. Early in the third quarter punter Mitch Wishnowsky took a snap, started to kick, then tucked and ran around the right edge for a 30-yard gain and a first down. Not only was the play negated by an illegal block call on wide receiver Ronnie Bell, it was also not Shanahan’s call.

Shanahan after the game in his press conference joked that he made the call because of his foresight on Seattle’s punt coverage.

“I just knew that it would work good right there,” Shanahan deadpanned. “So I just called my first fake punt.”

It didn’t take long after saying that for a wry smile to crack the head coach’s face.

“I don’t really know what happened on it,” Shanahan confessed. “I think he just hesitated a little bit. I haven’t gotten to talk to him personally. I don’t know if he thought it was going to get blocked, or if he bobbled the snap a hair, or if he just had a glitch, but it was a good one. Because when he paused and stuff and saw the edge, it was obviously a clean look and he didn’t hesitate for it. And I was just told he hit over 20 miles per hour on it, so, that’s real cool.”

Alas, Shanahan has still yet to call a special teams fake as a head coach. Now that he’s seen how his punter moves in that spot though he may be more inclined to give it a shot at some point.

[lawrence-auto-related count=3]

The Lions ran a fake punt from their own 17 and fans loved it

Lions coach Dan Campbell called a fake punt from their own 17 and Twitter loved it

It didn’t take long for Lions head coach Dan Campbell to live up to his reputation of being aggressively unpredictable. On the second Detroit drive of the Week 1 debut in Kansas City, Campbell made it known that he’s playing to win.

Facing 4th-and-2 from their own 17, the Lions dialed up a fake punt. A direct snap to reserve LB Jalen Reeves-Maybin caught the Chiefs off guard. It caught the fans in Arrowhead Stadium off guard. And the successful gamble caught social media off guard too.

The Lions capitalized on the gutsy call and wound up scoring the year’s first touchdown when Jared Goff found Amon-Ra St. Brown for a short TD strike.

Here are some of the best reactions to the Lions fake punt in Week 1.

(Or should I say, the first fake punt?)

Penn State tried the most ambitious fake punt of the season and it failed miserably

That could have gone a bit better, Penn State.

While some bemoan the deteriorating importance of non-College Football Playoff bowl games, these contests remain a great opportunity for teams to evaluate their depth and, more importantly for fans like us, to try out new plays and concepts.

It’s also a time to be more aggressive than you would be during the regular season, so it’s understandable why Penn State would choose to go for it on fourth down from the Arkansas 36 with a 10-7 lead in the Outback Bowl. However, the Nittany Lions had 13 yards to gain for a first down, and instead of running a play — a higher-percentage option — coach James Franklin opted for trickery.

He dialed up a fake punt, and while the idea was interesting, the execution left a lot to be desired. Rather than lining up in a normal punt formation, PSU lined up with five players on the outside, one near the long snapper and two on the right (one of which had his hand in the dirt, for some reason) while the upback came in motion and ran a screen.

Punter Jordan Stout took the snap, and with no protection up front, he immediately felt the heat. He actually made a nice move to juke out the rusher, but what happened next was… a choice.

Stout channeled his inner Patrick Mahomes and launched the ball as hard as he possibly could toward the end zone. It sailed more than 40 yards through the air, which would have been impressive if it went toward anyone in particular. But it flew past the receivers, hit an Arkansas defender on the hands and fell to the turf as Penn State turned it over on downs.

Look, I’m all for being aggressive in a bowl game, and punting from your opponent’s side of the field is among the most cowardly acts in football. But perhaps the Nittany Lions would have been better served to have quarterback Sean Clifford, the guy whose job it is to throw passes, attempt that conversion instead.

[vertical-gallery id=1368016]

McCarthy calls Cowboys fake punt ‘solid play call;’ Twitter disagrees

The Dallas head coach defended his decision to run a fake punt deep in their own territory; the play’s failure was widely mocked afterward.

On a Thanksgiving Day afternoon full of stomach-turning plays, none left as awful a taste in the mouths of Cowboys fans as the fake punt that went horribly sour early in the fourth quarter.

Down by four points, Andy Dalton and the Dallas offense had managed just 12 yards on six plays after starting on their own 12-yard-line. Facing 4th-and-10 on their own 24, most observers were undoubtedly expecting punter Hunter Niswander to boot the ball away in hopes of a defensive stand that would result in better field position on the team’s next possession.

Instead, this happened.

 

The gadget’s failure was the moment that broke the game wide open for the visitors from DC. But Dallas coach Mike McCarthy defended the play choice after the 41-16 loss.

“It’s definitely a big-play opportunity,” McCarthy told reporters in his postgame press conference. “The way you view it, there’s certain things you look for, tendency-wise, on when and where [to run such a play]. But obviously, we didn’t execute it. As those things go, ultimately, it’s my responsibility, particularly when a play like that doesn’t work. We were trying to generate a big play at that point in the game, the information that you look for going into it, it was a solid call.”

One would be hard-pressed, though, to find anyone else who agrees with that “solid call” assessment. Social media was quick to hang the Cowboys coaching staff out to dry over the doomed play.

 

On the play, Darian Thompson takes the snap and pitches to crossing wideout Cedrick Wilson, who has been at the center of several of the trick plays drawn up this season by special teams coordinator John Fassel. Wilson takes the ball and reverses the action, but retreats all the way back to the 10-yard-line before turning upfield. At that point, he is 24 yards away from the first-down sticks.

Niswander is out in wide-open space after making no attempt whatsoever to block the Washington linebacker bearing down on Wilson, and Wilson never seems to seriously consider passing to Niswander. The linebacker, rookie Khaleke Hudson, wraps Wilson up for a one-yard loss.

As designed, the fake seemed to have very little chance of picking up ten yards. As executed, it had no shot at gaining 24. When it, in fact, didn’t, Washington took over on the doorstep of the red zone. They scored on their very next snap, the first of a three-touchdown onslaught in the fourth quarter.

But after the game, McCarthy justified the call, despite a low likelihood of success in a dangerous part of the field and at a critical time in the game.

“You won’t get anywhere if you’re thinking about negatives all the time,” he said. “Obviously, it was a solid play call, good play design, their gunner made a good play; came off and put us in a high-low read for Cedrick. It’s a play that if we hit it, obviously, we’re sitting here applauding it. That’s the nature of those plays.  You can never convert them, obviously, if you don’t call them and if you don’t believe in them. I clearly understood the situation when it was called.”

The only thing more baffling than the play call in that situation was McCarthy’s insistence afterward that it was the right choice. When asked later in the Q-and-A session to clarify that he truly thought the fake punt was “a solid play call” and believed that factoring in the obvious risk would really be considered “negative thinking,” McCarthy took a long pause.

He seemed to be taken aback by the question. Incredulous. Offended, even.

“I’m fine with my answer before. There’s obviously film study that goes into the call, when to call it. But yeah, when you call it, you’re obviously looking to convert it. You obviously understand on fourth-down calls what your options are. You either convert it, or you don’t convert it. You always know that going in. There’s flow of the game. All those things are factored in that decision. I’m very confident in our players; I’ll put them in position to make big plays.”

But by greenlighting the fake punt so deep in their own territory, McCarthy and his staff ended up putting the Cowboys in an unwinnable position.

[listicle id=659051]

[lawrence-newsletter]

Chiefs’ Andy Reid, Patrick Mahomes commend Tommy Townsend’s fake punt

The offensive-minded head coach and quarterback had nothing but good things to say about Townsend’s pass.

[sendtonews_embed video_id=”yZiNElQnMr-1022064-7498″]

The Kansas City Chiefs executed the rare fake punt passing play during Sunday’s win against the New York Jets.

Chiefs rookie punter Tommy Townsend had a penchant for fake punts in college at the University of Florida. They always used his athleticism as a runner to get the job done, though. Andy Reid and Dave Toub would never be satisfied running the same old trick punts that Townsend ran in college. Instead, they called upon his days as a quarterback at Boone High School in Orlando, Florida.

Reid had high praise for the play and execution by Townsend following the game. It wasn’t perfect, but it was good enough to get the job done.

 “Yeah, well they’ve been working on it. I mean, they’ve been doing it the last couple, three weeks, and it’s been like clockwork,” Reid said. “That one did get a little high. It’s different when it’s in a game, and he’s as good a thrower as there is. So, he’s a real good athlete and he was able to show a little bit of that today. But it’s a little different in a game. Next time he does it, it’ll be better. It won’t be quite as high, but we’ll take it right there.”

As for Chiefs QB Patrick Mahomes, he was unaware that the fake punt was called. He was disappointed that he didn’t have an opportunity to pick up the fourth-down himself. Little did he know what was coming. After they called the fake, he was blown away by how it turned out, going out and scoring a touchdown on the very next play. After the game, Mahomes complimented his teammate on his arm and the coaching staff for the gutsy play call at a key point in the game.

 “I thought it was sweet, he ripped that thing,” Mahomes said. “It wasn’t a lollipop at all, I mean he caught it and he ripped it over there, so it was pretty impressive. I actually didn’t know it was happening. I was trying to go for it and Coach (Andy) Reid was – I should’ve known by the way he kind of just said go ahead and he sent the special teams out there. I was like, “man, you’re not even going to think about it?” I guess he already had things planned ahead. I think Toub (Coach Dave Toub) does a great job and he has for a very long time of having different tricks and having different ways to execute at a high level of that special teams group. It gave us a chance to have another play and we were able to score on it. It was a big point in the game.”

Mahomes, of course, is safe and won’t have to worry about Townsend coming for his job. New York, however, might want to call the Chiefs about acquiring Townsend to become their new starting QB. Townsend (118.8) finished the day with a better passer rating than Jets QB Sam Darnold (70.6).

[vertical-gallery id=79741]