Indiana coach Curt Cignetti is doing what everybody expected Luke Fickell to do at Wisconsin
Indiana continued its dream season with a 20-15 win over the Michigan Wolverines on Saturday.
The Hoosiers improved to 10-0 (7-0 Big Ten). The program’s instant turnaround in Year 1 under coach Curt Cignetti is the biggest story in college football.
Related: Big Ten Power Rankings after Week 11: Indiana remains undefeated
The why behind Indiana’s turnaround is pretty clear. Cignetti and his staff have done a phenomenal job, highlighted by reshaping the roster in the transfer portal over the offseason. That included many of Cignetti’s former players at James Madison, plus former Ohio quarterback Kurtis Rourke.
Cignetti reloaded the roster, assembled a strong coaching staff and is winning instantly. He is doing so at a program that went 3-9 in 2023 and hasn’t won more than eight games in any season since 1967.
Many point to the schedule. The Hoosiers have not faced Penn State, Oregon or Ohio State, and they will face only Ohio State this season (Nov. 23). But Saturday’s 20-15 win over Michigan was the team’s first game that wasn’t decided by two or more possessions. Light schedule or not, this season’s performance has been nothing short of amazing.
That brings up a comparison to Wisconsin under coach Luke Fickell. The Badgers are 5-4 (3-3 Big Ten) entering the final stretch of the season. They finished the 2023 season at 7-6.
The conversation surrounding Fickell’s hire involved the word championships, both from Wisconsin athletic director Chris McIntosh and from Fickell himself. The on-field results have clearly fallen far short of that self-imposed expectation.
In reality, Cignetti is doing what many expected Fickell to do upon arriving in Madison. He jumped from a successful Group of Five program, brought in a loaded transfer class, changed the culture and is winning instantly. Coincidentally, a significant piece of that success is longtime Badgers assistant Bob Bostad.
Wisconsin had a schedule similar to Indiana’s in 2023, if not easier. The difference in performance is striking. Wisconsin needed to work through substantial growing pains on both sides of the football while Indiana is a College Football Playoff contender.
This comparison will not do much to dictate Wisconsin’s future under Fickell or where Indiana goes under Cignetti. It’s worth pointing out, however, when it’s argued that more time is needed before success can follow.
That idea of more time is no longer a luxury in today’s era of college football. Most top coaches have zero trouble winning instantly at new programs. Cignetti, an ascending top coach in the sport, needed six months to turn a 3-9 team and bottom-tier program into a potential playoff participant.
2025, now, will be a critical season for Fickell and the Badgers to respond.
Contact/Follow @TheBadgersWire on X (formerly Twitter) and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Wisconsin Badgers news, notes and opinion.