49ers 1st-half MVP on offense looks to be entering a 2nd prime

Offensive MVP for the 49ers was a small surprise given the list of options:

There’s a clear-cut offensive MVP for the San Francisco 49ers through the first half of the 2024 season, but it wouldn’t likely have been a name atop the list of contenders to start the year.

It isn’t always easy to parse an offensive MVP for a team as loaded as San Francisco on that side of the ball. However, injuries and a handful of other factors made it easy to identify tight end George Kittle as the 49ers’ best offensive player through eight games.

Running back Jordan Mason was in the mix, but was slowed down by a shoulder injury in two out of the last three weeks. Quarterback Brock Purdy has had too many turnovers to win the spot despite a strong first half. Wide receivers Brandon Aiyuk and Deebo Samuel were too up-and-down in the first eight games to secure consideration.

That leaves Kittle, who leads the 49ers in targets (49), receptions (40), receiving yards (503), and total touchdowns (six), as the easy option.

There wasn’t a better display of Kittle’s value than his performance in Week 8 against the Dallas Cowboys. Aiyuk was out after suffering a season-ending knee injury. WR Jauan Jennings was also out because of a hip issue. Mason ended up leaving the game in the second quarter as well.

Purdy leaned on Kittle to be a playmaker in the passing game, and the 31-year-old TE delivered. He hauled in six of his seven targets for 128 yards and one touchdown. Kittle remains a tone-setter for the 49ers’ offense as a receiver, and with his work as a run blocker.

There is a ton of talent on the offensive side of the ball for San Francisco, and it wouldn’t be a surprise if the second half features a different MVP. For the first eight games, though, Kittle looked more like a player entering his prime than one in his early 30s. That’s why he gets the nod for our early offensive MVP award.

[lawrence-auto-related count=3]

49ers defensive MVP a fringe top-10 player in NFL Top 100 list

Is Fred Warner the 49ers’ defensive MVP?

Trying to pick an MVP of the 49ers on either side of the ball is difficult.

There are arguments to be made for several players on offense, but typically running back Christian McCaffrey gets the nod. San Francisco’s defensive MVP is less clear, but it’s getting harder to argue anyone besides linebacker Fred Warner deserves the crown.

Warner landed at No. 11 overall in NFL Network’s Top 100 players of 2024 – a four spot jump from last season.

Every year there’s some form of controversy around the NFL Top 100, which is a survey of active NFL players conducted by NFL Network. It’s not a definitive ranking by any means. It is, however, a good barometer for how certain players are viewed by their contemporaries.

That Warner was by far the highest-ranked 49ers defender speaks volumes about what he brings to the table for San Francisco. There’s not another 49ers defensive player on the list until No. 27 where defensive end Nick Bosa resides. While Bosa is the one with a Defensive Player of the Year award under his belt, it makes sense that Warner has separated himself amongst his peers.

Bosa’s holdout that lasted until Week 1 of the regular season last year had an impact on his play. While he was still dominant it was a discernible step back from his stellar 2022 campaign.

Meanwhile, Warner has been sensational on a regular basis over the last four years. In that stretch he’s been a First-Team All-Pro three times and he finished sixth in Defensive Player of the Year voting in 2023. His range allows him to bottle up run plays to either sideline, and his coverage skills take away a ton of easy throws modern offenses are built around. He’s also the vocal leader of San Francisco’s extremely talented defense.

Perhaps in 2024 Bosa puts together another DPOY campaign that bolsters his case to be the 49ers’ defensive MVP. Going into 2024, however, there aren’t many players on either side of the ball for San Francisco better than Warner.

[lawrence-auto-related count=3]

49ers MVP power rankings heading into Week 2

Our first edition of the #49ers 2023 MVP power rankings is here! We’ll update the rankings after each game:

The 49ers had a slew of outstanding performances in their Week 1 victory over the Steelers, which means there’s a cluster of strong candidates for the team’s Most Valuable Player.

We’ll be creating and updating the MVP power rankings throughout the season. This is what the ladder looks like following the season opener: