Al Horford, Florida 2005; 2006; 2007
Horford had a ton of success in his college career with the Florida Gators. He made the NCAA Tournament three times and he helped Florida win back-to-back titles in 2006 and 2007. He scored 14 points in the 2006 title win over UCLA and then scored 18 points with 12 rebounds in the 2007 win over Ohio State before being selected by the Atlanta Hawks. Overall, he averaged 10.8 points and 9.7 rebounds in 14 NCAA Tournament games.
Shake Milton, SMU 2017
Milton spent three seasons with the Mustangs, even spending some time with the legendary Larry Brown, but he only made the tournament once and that was in 2017. SMU fell to USC in a tough battle in Round 1 by a score of 66-65. Milton scored 11 points on 4-for-12 shooting, he was 3-for-8 from deep, and he had five assists. He spent one more season in college before being selected 54th by the Sixers in the 2018 draft.