The 5 most overrated players in Madden NFL 23, including the Eagles’ Darius Slay Jr.

Do the Madden folks even watch the games?!

Every year, during the summer doldrums, we undergo the same tired exercise.

The video game company Electronic Arts releases the player ratings for their annual pro football simulator, Madden. And, after diving through their lists, the football world collectively wonders: Have those people ever watched a game?

This year, the process was no different in advance of Madden NFL 23. While a few expected names headlined (Myles Garrett, Davante Adams, hello!), there was no shortage of overrated head-scratchers. These selections show that the creators are generally familiar with the NFL but maybe haven’t paid close attention for a while.

Yes, in case you were wondering: These ratings are totally worth getting angry about! Here are the five most overrated players in Madden NFL 23.