Defense
Defensive back
- Janzen Jackson (2010)
- Brian Randolph (2011-15)
- Cameron Sutton (2013-16)
- Prentiss Waggner (2010-12)
Linebacker
- Daniel Bituli (2016-19)
- A.J. Johnson (2011-14)
- Curt Maggitt (2011-15)
Defensive line
- Derek Barnett (2014-16)
- Malik Jackson (2010-11)
- Daniel McCullers (2012-13)
- Kyle Phillips (2015-18)
NEXT: Vols’ 2010s All-Decade Football Team (Special teams)