2020 Colts’ position review: Wide receiver

Reviewing the WR position for the Colts.

As the offseason begins for the Indianapolis Colts, we will begin a series of positional reviews, taking a look back at the 2020 campaign. We continue here with the wide receiver position.

[lawrence-related id=55774]

Starters: T.Y. Hilton, Zach Pascal, Michael Pittman Jr.
Depth: Ashton Dulin, Parris Campbell (IR), Daurice Fountain, Dezmon Patmon, DeMichael Harris

Position Overview

The Colts didn’t make major changes to the wide receiver position. They let Devin Funchess walk in free agency and added Pittman Jr. in the draft with the No. 34 overall pick. The production with the group was fine but ultimately underwhelming.

They didn’t have a wide receiver record more than 56 receptions, 770 yards or five touchdowns.

A new WR1?

While Hilton was certainly the top priority for opposing defenses given the way they rolled coverage his way, the Colts may have a new WR1 in Pittman Jr., who flashed some of that spark throughout the season. Though his season hit a bit of a rough patch when he suffered a serious leg injury, the USC product still showed promise.

It remains to be seen what will happen with Hilton in free agency, but the Colts are confident in what Pittman Jr. brings to the table even if that means he’s the alpha dog in the passing game next season and beyond.

Hilton’s future in question

The Colts have many decisions to make this offseason. What to do with Hilton is among them. He still has game left enough for a short contract to finish his career with the only team he’s ever played for but the money has to be right in order for him to return.

With Pittman Jr. expected to take a bigger step in 2021, Hilton’s future with the Colts is unclear.

Offseason preview

The Colts should be heavily involved in the wide receiver market regardless of what happens with Hilton. There are plenty of intriguing options for the Colts in free agency and in the 2021 NFL draft so this will certainly be a position to keep an eye on in terms of where Indy might make some moves.

[lawrence-related id=55545,55484]

Predicting the fate of Colts’ pending free agents in 2021

Who stays and who goes in 2021?

Even though the offseason doesn’t officially start until the new league year arrives in mid-March, the Indianapolis Colts can re-sign pending free agents ahead of that deadline before they hit the market.

Most of the pending free agents are likely to see the market. It’s just how it works. But the Colts will still be looking to re-sign a number of players before free agency officially starts.

The Colts have 19 pending free agents set to hit the market with 15 of them being unrestricted, two being restricted and two being exclusive rights free agents. It was 20 before the retirement of Philip Rivers.

Here, we predict the fate of every pending free agent for the Colts:

ESPN predicts Colts WR T.Y. Hilton will sign with Dolphins

Barnwell predicts Hilton goes down to South Beach.

Among the pending free agents for the Indianapolis Colts this offseason will be wide receiver T.Y. Hilton, who is hoping to finish his career with the only team he’s ever played for.

While the Colts are hoping the money will be right for Hilton their offer, there is a chance the two sides disagree on his worth. If that happens, Hilton would be a free agent and available to sign elsewhere.

In Bill Barnwell’s predictions for the wide receivers in free agency, he had Hilton signing with the Dolphins on a one-year, $6 million deal.

While the hope was that Hilton might return to form with Philip Rivers at quarterback, the Indy wideout didn’t get back to the 1,270-yard heights of 2018. Hilton seemed snakebit at times near the end zone, although he developed more of a rapport with Rivers in the second half of the season.

With no idea of who will be under center for the Colts in 2021, we don’t have a great sense of what the Indy offense will even look like. Michael Pittman Jr. should play a larger role in his second pro season, and the organization has high hopes for Parris Campbell, who had 71 yards in the opener before going down with what ended up as a season-ending PCL injury in Week 2.

Hilton was born and raised in Miami, and if the Dolphins don’t draft a wideout with the No. 3 overall pick, they would still have room in their wideout corps for one more addition, even after signing Smith-Schuster.

Projected: One year, $6 million from the Dolphins

This would be an interesting move. The Colts have a need at wide receiver and Hilton showed he still has something left in the tank even if his consistent game-breaking talent isn’t there as often.

The Dolphins would seem like the only logical spot given that’s where Hilton’s roots are but it wouldn’t be outlandish if he retired following a low offer from the Colts. That’s purely speculation but Hilton did say before the 2020 season he wanted to get another contract and then retire as a Colt. Maybe if he doesn’t like the offer from the Colts, he calls it a career?

Again, that’s speculation and it isn’t clear how Hilton is feeling in terms of how much longer he wants to play.

It should also be noted that Barnwell didn’t predict the Colts to sign any of the 43 wide receivers on his list. Given their need at the position, that seems unlikely but should make for an interesting offseason.

[listicle id=55740]

Jim Irsay would ‘love to see’ T.Y. Hilton re-sign with Colts

Ghost is a free agent in March.

Among the many decisions the Indianapolis Colts have to make this offseason will include the expiring contract of wide receiver T.Y. Hilton, who faces an uncertain future with the team.

Hilton, who has been with the Colts since they drafted him in 2012, will be a free agent when the new league year arrives in mid-March. Colts owner and CEO Jim Irsay told the media Wednesday that he would love to see Hilton back wearing the horseshoe.

But he also admitted there is a business side to the process, and that has to align in order for Hilton to return.

“We’d love to see T.Y. (Hilton) back, there is no question about it. He is such a great Colt. What a competitor and still has excellent skills and can take over a game,” Irsay said. “I think that the biggest thing at this point in a career for athletes and you see it all the time is the competitive nature is, look there is a business side to it. You want a guy back but it has to fit into what you view, what the marketplace dictates and what other teams and where someone’s value falls with the price sign. It really comes down to that.”

Hilton endured a down year in 2020. It took a while for him and Philip Rivers to get going. Once they did, Hilton showed he still has that high-upside on a weekly basis. But overall, his season was somewhat of a disappointment statistically speaking.

That’s not to say Hilton can’t still be a viable asset in the passing game. The way teams rolled coverage his way showed opposing defenses still believe he’s a threat. But as it happens with older wide receivers, their game may not be as consistent.

That said, Irsay still believes the team wants to re-sign the former third-round pick if the financials line up.

“You love to see someone like T.Y. be back because he is such a good man, he’s such an outstanding football player and a selfless player that you are just hoping that it works out that way,” Irsay said. “But the market usually dictates that. That’s the aspect of free agency.”

Chris Ballard has his process and he rarely goes over the value they have on a player so it will be interesting to see what happens when the negotiations begin.

This will certainly be a storyline to watch over the next month as free agency approaches.

[listicle id=55640]

5 questions the Colts face this offseason

Questions the Colts face this offseason.

The Indianapolis Colts have a big offseason ahead of them, including many questions at some big positions on the roster.

With an abundance of salary cap space and seven total picks in the upcoming draft, the Colts will have plenty of resources to better a roster that finished the season with an 11-5 record.

Here are five questions the Colts face this offseason:

Chris Ballard still believes in talent of T.Y. Hilton

Will T.Y. Hilton return?

Indianapolis Colts wide receiver T.Y. Hilton has enjoyed an illustrious career but now faces an uncertain offseason in which he will be a free agent unless a deal gets done.

With the way general manager Chris Ballard operates, we may not know about a potential deal until a month into the offseason. But Ballard said in his year-end press conference that he still values Hilton and believes the 30-year-old can play.

“As to his ability. T.Y. can still play. Whether it’s at the level it was 4 or 5 years ago, as you get older, you have to find different ways,” Ballard said last week. “But I’ll tell you this, T.Y. is smart, instinctive, knows how to get open and he still has value. We’ll see how it works out here over the long haul. But we value T.Y. and we think he can still play. And he’s been a great Colt.”

Hilton got off to a very slow start on the season, and it appeared free agency would be almost a guarantee. But his second half of the campaign was much better and included a stretch of dominant games.

But more than what Hilton brought to the field in terms of production, Ballard lauded the veteran for his leadership and his ability to lead a room.

“He’s always been a great player, but how he has grown, as a teammate, man, he’s really special dude. T.Y. Hilton is a really special dude. Before we played Buffalo, I walked up and I said, ‘I love you. I do.’ T.Y. is not the most emotional guy but he gave me a hug,” Ballard said. “He’s special man, as a person, and as a teammate, and as a competitor.”

It will be interesting to see what will happen with Hilton in the offseason but there’s a chance the Colts value him enough to bring him back on a short contract.

[listicle id=55300]

5 pending free agents the Colts should re-sign

Which free agents should the Colts bring back?

Now that the Indianapolis Colts’ 2020 season is over, it’s time to look at the offseason and with that, looking at which impending free agents the team should look to re-sign.

After the retirement of Anthony Castonzo, Indianapolis is projected to have over $60 million in cap space, which is among the leaders in the projections.

With 20 players becoming free agents (two were signed to extensions this week), there will be a lot of Colts that don’t return, but there could be some brought back.

Here are five pending free agents Indianapolis should re-sign:

PFF predicts Colts sign Bud Dupree, Jameis Winston in free agency

PFF has a big offseason in store for the Colts.

The Indianapolis Colts have a lot of decisions to make at some very crucial positions this offseason. Whether through the 2021 NFL draft or free agency, Indy has the opportunity to be an active participant.

When it comes to free agency, general manager Chris Ballard typically lays low through the first wave of signings. He feels it’s best to not overpay or get into a bidding war for the top players—most of the time.

But Pro Football Focus is predicting a pretty big offseason and free agency for the Colts. Among those additions include edge rusher Bud Dupree, quarterback Jameis Winston and tight end Jared Cook. That is to go along with re-signing quarterback Philip Rivers, wide receiver T.Y. Hilton and cornerback Xavier Rhodes.

Here are the predicted contracts for each player from PFF:

  • QB Philip Rivers: one year, $25 million (fully guaranteed)
  • QB Jameis Winston: one year, $5 million
  • WR T.Y. Hilton: three years, $28.5 million ($18 million guaranteed)
  • DE Bud Dupree: one year, $10 million ($7.5 million guaranteed)
  • CB Xavier Rhodes: three years, $24 million ($14.5 million guaranteed)
  • TE Jared Cook: one year, $5 million

That would be an awfully busy offseason and one that would come with some surprises. The Colts had their chance to sign Winston during the 2020 offseason but decided against it and went with Rivers.

The signing of Dupree would be an interesting one. Though he’s coming off a torn ACL, the Colts need help on the edge and he would be a nice addition to the unit assuming his health is in order.

It is a bit interesting to see three-year extensions for both Hilton and Rhodes, both of which should have competitive markets. It isn’t clear if Hilton will sign on with another team while Rhodes should be expected to test the market unless the Colts give him an offer like the one above.

The new league year doesn’t start until March, but it should be a fun offseason leading up to it debating on who the Colts might go after.

[listicle id=55220]

All of a sudden, Philip Rivers is throwing deep!

Philip Rivers had been one of the NFL’s more risk-averse quarterbacks this season, but he’s starting to turn it loose.

In the Colts’ 27-20 win over the Texans last week, the highlight play for Indianapolis quarterback Philip Rivers was a 41-yard deep pass to receiver T.Y. Hilton.

Why was this play notable? Because coming into that game, Rivers had been more risk-averse than at any other time in his career.

Through the first nine weeks of the season, only Derek Carr, Lamar Jackson, and Jared Goff had fewer deep passing attempts (20-plus air yards) than Philip Rivers in his first season with the Colts. Rivers was playing mostly quick game in Frank Reich’s offense, and he’d completed just 13 of 27 deep attempts for 372 yards, two touchdowns, two interceptions, and a passer rating of 88.1.

From Weeks 10-14, Rivers tied with Goff for the NFL’s fewest deep attempts with just 14, completing seven of those passes for 205 yards, two touchdowns, one interception, and a passer rating of 105.7. So, a bit better in quality, but about the same in quantity. And as Rivers averaged 2.30 seconds from snap to throw, per Pro Football Focus (only Ben Roethlisberger and Tom Brady have released the ball more quickly per attempt), you could say that the Reich-Rivers combination has been fairly reductive when it comes to the deep passing game.

As Rivers said after the Houston game, it was less a physical than a mental issue, as much as everyone wanted to throw dirt on his ability to create velocity.

“We’ve had him running down the middle a few times,” Rivers said after the game, regarding the connections downfield to Hilton. “One that comes to mind is against the Jets or Bengals that I didn’t throw just because there was a little uncertainty. I can say yes but not necessarily, but yeah. I think just each rep, each day that builds you build more and more comfortable together, all of us. That was obviously a huge play after getting backed up there. That was a big-time drive. Everybody contributed.”

Against the Steelers on Sunday, Rivers was confident enough to turn it loose in more constrained coverage than the Texans presented when they assigned linebacker Tyrell Williams to cover Hilton (one of the NFL’s fastest receivers) 40 yards downfield. On this 42-yard touchdown to receiver Zach Pascal, Rivers used his quick release and impressive juice on the ball to sink the ball over the head of Pittsburgh cornerback Joe Haden.

If the deep ball remains a key cog in Indianapolis’ offense, it’s tough to pinpoint a discernible weakness on this team heading into the postseason. They have a 21-7 lead on the Steelers at the half.

Anatomy of a Play: Philip Rivers’ big-time throw to T.Y. Hilton

Philip Rivers threw himself out of a season-long deep passing slump against the Texans. Here’s how his big-time throw to T.Y. Hilton worked.

Through the first nine weeks of the season, only Derek Carr, Lamar Jackson, and Jared Goff had fewer deep passing attempts (20-plus air yards) than Philip Rivers in his first season with the Colts. Rivers was playing mostly quick game in Frank Reich’s offense, and he’d completed just 13 of 27 deep attempts for 372 yards, two touchdowns, two interceptions, and a passer rating of 88.1.

From Weeks 10-14, Rivers tied with Goff for the NFL’s fewest deep attempts with just 14, completing seven of those passes for 205 yards, two touchdowns, one interception, and a passer rating of 105.7. So, a bit better in quality, but about the same in quantity. And as Rivers averaged 2.30 seconds from snap to throw, per Pro Football Focus (only Ben Roethlisberger and Tom Brady have released the ball more quickly per attempt), you could say that the Reich-Rivers combination has been fairly reductive when it comes to the deep passing game.

This has led to a reduced role for T.Y. Hilton, the Colts’ best deep receiver. Hilton came into Indianapolis’ Week 15 game against the Texans with just five deep receptions on 12 attempts for 155 yards and one touchdown. Not much different than the three deep passes he caught in 2019 with Jacoby Brissett as the primary quarterback, and a far cry from the 14 deep passes he caught in 2018, Andrew Luck’s last season.

The thought has been that the Colts have not utilized the deep passing game because Rivers is a shadow of his former self from a physical perspective, but it could have been that it took time for Rivers and Hilton to develop the right chemistry. Rivers’ 41-yard pass to Hilton with 2:29 left in the game, which put the ball at the Houston three-yard line and set up the game-winning five-yard touchdown pass from Rivers to Zach Pascal after a Jonathan Taylor two-yard loss, could be a defining point in the Colts’ 2020 season — and a possible shot in the arm for the playoffs.

“We’ve had him running down the middle a few times,” Rivers said after the game, regarding the connections downfield to Hilton. “One that comes to mind is against the Jets or Bengals that I didn’t throw just because there was a little uncertainty. I can say yes but not necessarily, but yeah. I think just each rep, each day that builds you build more and more comfortable together, all of us. That was obviously a huge play after getting backed up there. That was a big-time drive. Everybody contributed.

“Obviously, we get the fourth-down conversion. Jacoby did a good job on the sneak. Trey [Burton had a big third-down conversion. Jonathan [Taylor] made some good runs, T.Y. (Hilton) with the big time catch. Zach gets in the end zone. I think you’re seeing just as you have seen all year what a collective effort it is. What a team effort it is. I think we really exemplified that. What you talk about the ultimate team sport, I think we have shown that to be true all year long.”

So, everybody contributed, but it was the big-time play that made the difference. The Texans helped. Somehow, Hilton wound up with linebacker Tyrell Adams trailing him downfield, as the Colts’ four verts route concept stressed Houston’s defense. Rivers was champing at the bit to get the ball out at that point. Hilton was the inside slot receiver — the “three-read” — with Michael Pittman Jr. as the outside slot receiver and Pascal as the outside receiver. On the right side of the formation, tight end Mo Alie-Cox ran a deep route to the numbers from a “nub” alignment — tight to the formation to give the defense a run look to that side. Although, on second-and-20, the Texans weren’t exactly reading run.

“Yeah, there was a little communication with the backside safety and 50 [Adams] early kind of alerting 50 that T.Y. was the No. 3 receiver, and I did feel like that pre-snap they were going to two but when they started conversating I was like, shoot, they aren’t going to let it happen, but they did.,” Rivers said.

Alie-Cox’s route took A.J. Moore out of the defensive middle, and cornerbacks Eric Murray and Lonnie Johnson Jr. shaded to Pittman, leaving Adams all alone on Hilton through most of the route. Not the matchup you want if you’re the Texans.

“That’s a split safety defense that we have, and we hoped that we could get some overlap from a safety depending on what they see and which way they break,” Texans interim head coach Romeo Crennel said. “But T.A. has a lot of the responsibility of running with that through the middle and then hopefully we can get a safety to come over and help out.”

Again, if you have a linebacker trailing T.Y. Hilton 40 yards downfield, it is time to consider a difference.

“I think our outside guys, I’m not sure if it was Mo [Alie-Cox] or Trey [Burton] who was the nub tight end, did a great job of threatening this safety,” Rivers concluded. “I think it was Zach or Pitt (that did a great job of threatening that safety which put T.Y alone on 50 and it was huge to get down there. And then Zach, unbelievable effort to get in the end zone there on the second-and-goal.”

Reich definitely liked the way it looked, giving credit to his offensive coordinator.

“I really credit Nick [Sirianni] and the offensive staff,” the coach said. “That’s a play that we had put in, trying to get against the coverage that we ended up getting, and unfortunately, we were in a long-yard situation. It was just a gut feeling that we had to make a play and had to take a shot. There was one thought to just try to get back in field-goal range, but I really was just trusting Philip, trusting T.Y.  – ‘Hey, let’s take the shot if it’s there. Let’s see if we can get the coverage we want and get T.Y. isolated like we wanted to and if it’s there, let’s take it and if not let’s work underneath, try to get some yards and get back in field-goal range if that’s what we have to do.”

If the 10-4 Colts can continue these deep shots and still work underneath as they have all season, they’ll be a dangerous opponent once the postseason comes around.