Beloved humpback whale killed by ship strike off California

An adult female humpback whale nicknamed Fran, described by a prominent researcher as “the most popular whale in California,” has been killed by an apparent ship strike.

**Author’s note: It’s hoped that this story, which contains graphic footage, will raise awareness to the danger posed to whales and other marine creatures by large ships.

An adult female humpback whale nicknamed Fran, described by a prominent researcher as “the most popular whale in California,” has been killed by an apparent ship strike.

The 49-foot whale, who leaves behind a female calf with an uncertain future, washed ashore Sunday in Half Moon Bay.

A necropsy performed by the Marine Mammal Center and the California Academy of Sciences confirmed that Fran’s injuries – including a dislocated scull and fractured vertebra – were consistent with a ship strike.

The Associated Press on Monday, before the cause of death was confirmed, reported that Fran would become the fifth whale killed by a ship strike off Bay Area waters this year.

According to Happywhale, a website that identifies and tracks whales based on photo identification and input from citizen scientists, Fran was born in early 2005.

She migrated between summer feeding grounds off Monterey and winter breeding grounds beyond the Mexican state of Guerrero. She had a previous calf that did not survive the migration from Mexico to California.

Fran was named by Ferd Bergholz, though the Oceanic Society, in honor of his late wife, who lost a battle with cancer.

Bergholz late Monday wrote on Facebook: “I am very sad to report that “Fran,” the Humpback Whale that I named after my late wife Fran, was the victim of a ship strike and washed up on a beach in Half Moon Bay.

“There is no word yet about the calf she had this year. They were together in Monterey Bay a couple of months ago. A Very Sad Day.”

Whales of Guerrero, run by researcher Katherina Audley, added that Fran breached in front of Fred’s whale-watching boat on his wife’s birthday a year after she died.

Audley wrote on Facebook: “When we get to know our whales as individuals like this, their deaths affect us so much more profoundly and the good part of this is that we care more about their health.”

Happywhale, run by researcher Ted Cheesman, recorded 277 sightings of Fran before announcing her passing Monday on its website: “She was the most popular whale in California, encountered by many in Monterey Bay until her death from a ship strike in August of 2022.”

If there’s a positive note to this story it’s that Fran’s calf was observed attempting to feed on her own during a Fran sighting off Monterey in June.

Don Baccus, who was present during the sighting, commented on Facebook: “We saw the calf surface lunging, scattering anchovies every which way, ventral pouch filled with water and possibly fish, not that much later. The calf seemed well on its way to being able to feed.”

“This, of course, doesn’t mean that she was weaned or can feed on her own yet, or survive without Fran, but I am more hopeful than I would be with any other calf I think I’ve ever had the opportunity to watch over time.”

–Top image courtesy of ©Douglas Croft

Large whale killed by destroyer becomes feast for blue sharks

One of two fin whales struck and killed by an Australian destroyer last week off San Diego has become a feast for blue sharks.

One of two fin whales struck and killed by an Australian destroyer last week off San Diego has become a feast for blue sharks.

The accompanying graphic images and video, captured by Delaney Trowbridge of Pacific Offshore Expeditions, show sharks and gulls feeding on the whale carcass Thursday near San Clemente Island.

The fin whales, measuring 65 and 25 feet, were discovered lodged to the hull of the Australian Royal Navy vessel after it had pulled into San Diego last Saturday.

The 481-foot HMAS Sydney, a guided missile destroyer, had been conducting joint exercises with the U.S. Navy when it struck both whales at an unknown offshore location.

ALSO ON FTW OUTDOORS: Yellowstone grizzly bear charges reckless tourist; video

The larger whale was subsequently towed offshore; the smaller calf or juvenile was destined for a landfill.

https://www.instagram.com/p/CO1s286phf3/

“Obviously, so many people were upset that they killed it, but in my opinion it’s just a terrible accident,” Trowbridge told For The Win Outdoors. “But I hope those people can find some solace in the fact that the body is in the ocean contributing to the ecosystem. It’s not a wasted life by any means.”

Ship strikes are a leading cause of death for large whales and occasionally the mammals become lodged against the bows of enormous ships.

“Often times, [crews] don’t know until they come in and stop,” Justin Viezbicke, coordinator of NOAA’s California Marine Mammal Stranding Network, told the San Diego Union-Tribune. “That’s when the whale falls off and floats out.”

The incident remains under investigation by both military agencies and NOAA Fisheries, which collected samples in an attempt to determine, among other things, if they were mother and calf.

The Royal Australian Navy, in a statement, said it “takes marine mammal safety seriously and is disheartened this incident occurred.”

https://www.instagram.com/p/CO1pAgRBzS3/

Ryan Lawler, owner of Pacific Offshore Expeditions, told For The Win Outdoors that at least 12 blue sharks were feeding on the carcass Thursday as it floated 10 miles east of San Clemente Island.

Said Trowbridge: “We just saw this mass on the horizon, initially thought it was a boat or thought it was debris. Ryan got close enough to inspect it with binoculars and realized it was the whale.

“Then when we got up to it, we noticed the tow rope attached to the tail and that confirmed it was the same one killed by that Australian Navy boat from San Diego.”

Trowbridge shared more sentiments via Instagram:

“Most of you have probably heard the news that a pair of Fin Whales was recently struck and killed by an Australian Navy vessel in San Diego. Even in the vastness of the ocean, the wrong paths can still cross… resulting in terrible accidents like this one.

“While it’s sad to consider the context, at the very least this whale’s body has been returned to the sea where she belongs. She’ll now feed hundreds, if not thousands, of other marine species and return to the ecosystem.”