Giant muskie catch on icy lake may have ‘crushed’ 64-year-old record

A Minnesota angler appears to have broken a 64-year-old state record with the nighttime catch of a nearly 56-pound muskie.

A Minnesota angler appears to have broken a 64-year-old state record with the nighttime catch of a nearly 56-pound muskie.

“The rumors are true!” Nolan Sprengeler wrote on Facebook after his catch Monday of a 55-pound, 14.8-ounce muskie at Mille Lacs Lake.

The current record, 54 pounds, was set at Lake Winnibigoshish in 1957.

ALSO ON FTW OUTDOORS: Things go from bad to worse for man caught poaching salmon

Sprengeler, 27, of Minnetonka, told FTW Outdoors that he submitted his record application to the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources on Tuesday. As of the time of this post he had not heard back from the agency.

Sprengeler told KARE 11 that he and some buddies were enjoying perhaps the final night of fishing before the lake becomes too ice-covered to fish from a boat. The air temperature was 18 degrees as they broke through ice near the marina to access deeper water.

Sprengeler has been pursuing the catch-and-release record (57-1/4 inches) for weeks. But the muskie he landed Monday, “after a quick battle and a few ridiculous head shakes,” was deep-hooked and not responsive during the release attempt.

“I didn’t realize how giant this fish was until I pulled it out of the net and immediately called Kevin [Kray] over to assist with the buddy pictures,” Sprengeler wrote. “It measured an incredible 57.75” in length with a 29” girth.

“The next hour or so was spent trying to get her to release. Eventually we realized this was not going to happen and made the decision to bring it to a certified scale and crush the Minnesota State Record.”

On Tuesday, the fish was weighed at a UPS Store in Golden Valley.

For the sake of comparison, the International Game Fish Assn. lists as the all-tackle world record a 67-pound, 8-ounce muskie caught at Wisconsin’s Lake Court Oreilles in 1949.

–Top image shows Nolan Sprengeler (left) and Kevin Kray posing with the giant muskie

Watch: Ice fisherman pulls 50-pound fish through tiny hole

An ice fisherman fishing for pike in Minnesota got a surprise catch when he hooked a near-state-record muskie and somehow landed it.

An ice fisherman fishing for pike in Minnesota got a surprise catch when he hooked a near-state-record muskie—an estimated 50-pounder—and, amazingly, managed to pull it through a tiny hole in the ice.

While fishing on Mille Lacs Lake on Feb. 22, Jason Birke captured video of Mark Kottke—“my neighbor on the ice”—landing the 54-inch muskie, also known as a muskellunge.

“This was the biggest fish I’d ever seen caught and is only a few inches from the state record,” Birke told USA Today/For The Win Outdoors, revealing the fish’s girth as 27 inches. “Truly amazing to witness in person.”

For comparison, the Minnesota state record for a caught-and-released muskellunge is 57 1/4 inches landed at Lake Vermilion on Aug. 6, 2019 by Corey Kitzmann of Davenport, Iowa. The state record for a muskie on a certified scale is 54 pounds caught at Lake Winnibigoshish in 1957. That fish was 56 inches long.

Kottke used what is called a tip-up, an ice fishing devise that suspends a bait in the water column through a hole in the ice and detects when a fish strikes. He was using a sucker for bait and 80-pound coated tip-up line, as he stated on Facebook.

So, rather than reeling the fishing up with a rod and reel, he pulled up the fish by hand through the 10-inch-wide hole.

Also on FTW Outdoors: Spearfisherman dragged out to sea by great white shark

“The muskie was not the intended species, as the season is closed, and [I] have never seen one [caught] through the ice,” Kottke said on Facebook.

He said the muskie was only out of the water for about a minute and half before he released it back into the lake.

“Mille Lacs is the land of giants because people continue with CPR: catch, photo, release,” he wrote.

As for Birke, he told For The Win Outdoors that he landed plenty of walleye that day, but the catch of the day belonged to Kottke.

Photos courtesy of ViralHog and Jason Birke.

Follow David Strege and the outdoors on Facebook.