What was the Cardinals’ biggest disappointment in 2024?

The Cards Wire writers make their picks for the Cardinals’ biggest disappointment of 2024. They have differing picks.

The Arizona Cardinals are in their offseason and looking ahead to 2025.

But while we are in the offseason, it is time to look back at the 2024 season and give some recognitions for player performances.

On the podcast, we discussed player awards and superlatives. Now we will put our picks in written form.

We continue with the team’s biggest disappointment in 2024.

Who was the Cardinals’ biggest disappointment for 2024? Howard Balzer and I give our picks.

Cardinals’ biggest disappointment of 2024

Jess Root: DLs Justin Jones, Bilal Nichols

The Cardinals committed over $50 million to Jones and Nichols in free agency in an attempt to bolster the defensive line. Nichols had not missed a game in four seasons and Jones in the previous two.

Both suffered season-ending injuries. They combined for 14 tackles and as many sacks as I did (zero). The disappointment wasn’t about their play, as we saw struggles for a while in stopping the run after they got hurt.

But when they were added to be a big boost to the defensive line and they ended up giving you virtually nothing on the field, it is disappointing.

The Cardinals made a big investment in the offensive line, adding Jones and Nichols and then drafting Darius Robinson in the first round. With injuries to all three, the Cardinals got virtually nothing on the field from all three.

That is disappointing.

Howard Balzer: WR Marvin Harrison Jr.

Disappointment is in the eye of the beholder, but that’s what happens when you’re the fourth overall pick in the draft and one of the more heralded pass-catchers to enter the league in years.

The numbers weren’t bad, but the frustration was high because of what might have (should have?) been. It raises the stakes in 2025 for Harrison to get on the same page more often with quarterback Kyler Murray. Make a list of things that have to improve for the team to reach double-digit victories and that’s near if not at the top.

As for those numbers, it is important to note that although his 62 receptions tied for 49th in the NFL, the 14.3-yard average per catch was eighth in that group of 50 players. Only eight players had more than Harrison’s eight touchdowns.

Still, he averaged only 3.6 receptions per game and 52.1 yards game. Another two catches per game gets him to 96 and 6.8 yards per game gets him to 1,000 for the season. The surest way to reach those levels is improving on the percentage of 116 targets caught, which was 53.4 percent.

Get more Cardinals and NFL coverage from Cards Wire’s Jess Root and others by listening to the latest on the Rise Up, See Red podcast. Subscribe on SpotifyYouTube or Apple podcasts.

 

Who was the Cardinals’ rookie of the year in 2024?

The Cards Wire writers make their picks for the Cardinals’ top rookie of 2024. They have differing picks.

The Arizona Cardinals are in their offseason and looking ahead to 2025.

But while we are in the offseason, it is time to look back at the 2024 season and give some recognitions for player performances.

On the podcast, we discussed player awards and superlatives. Now we will put our picks in written form.

We continue with the team’s top rookie in 2024.

Who was the Cardinals’ rookie of the year for 2024? Howard Balzer and I give our picks.

Cardinals’ 2024 rookie of the year

Jess Root: WR Marvin Harrison Jr.

I don’t think there is a question he was their best rookie. While his first year wasn’t what many believed it could be — 90+ catches for 1,100+ yards — he still had one of the best rookie seasons a Cardinals player has had. He matched Anquan Boldin’s and Larry Fitzgerald’s touchdown production, a rookie record. He had the second-most receiving yards (885) for a rookie in franchise history.

There were plays left on the field, for sure. He did look like a rookie a lot. But he was still their best rookie. He had the best individual game of any rookie and piled up numbers, albeit not up to incredibly lofty expectations.

Those expectations do not minimize the fact he had a very solid season.

Howard Balzer: CB Max Melton and S Dadrion Taylor-Demerson

Call this a copout if you will, but a strong case can be made for both players.

Taylor-Demerson, the man everyone calls Rabbit, and Melton had similar numbers, although DTD did his in fewer snaps with Jalen Thompson ahead of him on the depth chart.

Melton plays the more challenging position, so let’s just call it a draw.

Each played all 17 games with Melton getting three starts and DTD two. The snap disparity was 565 (52 percent) on defense for Melton and 258 (24 percent) for DTD. The latter also played 286 special-teams snaps (65 percent) to Melton’s 212 (49 percent).

The numbers breakdown

Melton: 45 tackles (31 solo with two for loss), five passes defensed and one forced fumble.

Taylor-Demerson: 35 tackles (22 solo with three for loss) and also five passes defensed and one forced fumble.

Both should progress even more in 2025.

Get more Cardinals and NFL coverage from Cards Wire’s Jess Root and others by listening to the latest on the Rise Up, See Red podcast. Subscribe on SpotifyYouTube or Apple podcasts.

 

Marvin Harrison Jr., other Cardinals rookies, left off all-rookie team

Brian Thomas and Malik Nabers were named the two receivers on the PFWA All-Rookie Team and not Harrison.

Arizona Cardinals wide receiver Marvin Harrison had a comparatively great rookie season in terms of franchise history. However, the 2024 No. 4 overall pick was not considered one of the best rookies in the league.

The Pro Football Writers of America, comprised of scores of writers covering the NFL and its 32 teams across the country, announced their rookie of the year and all-rookie team awards.

Harrison was not included.

The two wide receivers to make the all-rookie team were Malik Nabers of the New York Giants and Brian Thomas of the Jacksonville Jaguars.

Nabers caught 109 passes for 1,204 yards and seven touchdowns in his rookie campaign.

Thomas had 87 receptions for 1,282 yards and 10 touchdowns.

No one is saying that Harrison should have been on the all-rookie team over them.

Even Ladd McConkey of the L.A. Chargers, who had 82 receptions for 1,149 yards and seven scores, was passed over.

Harrison finished his rookie season with 62 catches for 885 yards and eight scores.

While that might have been on the disappointing side, considering he was the No. 4 overall pick and most expected him to produce at the level of Nabers, Thomas and McConkey in his first NFL season, he was the only one of this group who wasn’t the team’s top pass catcher. He had Trey McBride as a teammate, who caught 111 passes.

It would have been fantastic if he had had a similarly impactful season statistically. There were plays left on the field. And being honored on the all-rookie team is not a be all, end all. It isn’t the point.

He had an impact. He looks like he will be great. But he wasn’t one of the best two rookie receivers in the NFL this past season.

Get more Cardinals and NFL coverage from Cards Wire’s Jess Root and others by listening to the latest on the Rise Up, See Red podcast. Subscribe on SpotifyYouTube or Apple podcasts.

 

Hall of Famer WR gives his thoughts on Marvin Harrison Jr.’s rookie season

Find out what Cris Carter had to say about Cardinals WR Marvin Harrison Jr. and his rookie season.

Arizona Cardinals receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. just completed his rookie season after being drafted fourth overall. He entered the season with huge expectations and with an impressive pedigree as the son of a Hall of Famer (Marvin Harrison Sr.).

He didn’t have a wildly productive season, catching 62 passes for 885 yards and scoring eight touchdowns. Many were disappointed in his season, especially as other rookie receivers around the league had more catches and over 1,100 receiving yards.

But Cris Carter, a Hall of Fame wide receiver, is not concerned. He called Harrison’s 2024 season “outstanding” in an interview with Kyle Odegard for Casino Apps.

Carter said he watched Harrison “an awful lot” in 2024.

“I thought he had a really good rookie season adjusting to pro football,” Carter explained. “A lot of times people don’t realize, especially for these high draft picks, that their season goes so long. Their offseason leads right into the Combine, so they don’t really have an offseason. They don’t really have an offseason, so these kids hit that wall. You could see in certain periods during the season that he looked a little bit fatigued, which we expect.

“But I thought he had an outstanding season for a rookie. Almost 1,000 yards. Tied the rookie Cardinal record for touchdowns there. All really good ways to start his NFL career there with the Cardinals.”

Harrison being fatigued at some parts of the season is an interesting observation. He notably passed on the predraft athletic training, not running 40s and such. He worked on football training, focusing on that and rest for his rookie season.

So can we expect a big jump from Harrison in 2025, perhaps even making the Pro Bowl?

” I think he’s a big-time player,” Carter said. “How long will it be until he makes the Pro Bowl? I don’t know that. Given the number of receivers we have in the NFC – AJ Brown, Deebo Samuel, Justin Jefferson – it’s hard to make the Pro Bowl. They throw those things on people like, ‘Next year he’ll make the Pro Bowl.’ Eventually he will make the Pro Bowl, but the measuring stick shouldn’t be Pro Bowl in his second year.”

The Cardinals believe in Harrison. Quarterback Kyler Murray believes in him.

What he looks like in 2025 will certainly be one of the biggest storylines to watch.

Get more Cardinals and NFL coverage from Cards Wire’s Jess Root and others by listening to the latest on the Rise Up, See Red podcast. Subscribe on SpotifyYouTube or Apple podcasts.

 

Marvin Harrison doesn’t make this All-Rookie First Team

ESPN picks Brian Thomas, Ladd McConkey and Malik Nabers over Harrison.

While the NFL playoffs have commenced and the divisional round is coming this weekend, it is the offseason for 24 of the 32 teams and that means end-of-season awards and honors and grades.

ESPN put together its all-rookie team for the 2024 season and there was a notable absence from the first team.

Arizona Cardinal receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. did not make the first team.

The three receivers named to the first team were Brian Thomas of the Jacskonville Jaguars, Ladd McConkey of the Los Angeles Chargers and Malik Nabers of the New York Giants.

Their numbers for the season:

  • Thomas: 87 catches, 1,282 yards, 10 TDs
  • McConkey: 82 catches, 1,149 yards, 7 TDs
  • Nabers: 109 catches, 1,204 yards, 7 TDs

Those are fantastic seasons.

What about Harrison?

  • Harrison: 62 catches, 885 yards, 8 TDs

That is a fine rookie season, but as the No. 4 overall pick and first receiver taken, many see this as a disappointment.

While Harrison does not make the first team, he is on ESPN’s all-rookie second team, which is perfectly reasonable.

It wasn’t as productive a rookie campaign as many would have hoped, but he was playing with tight end Trey McBride, who had over 100 catches and nearly 1,200 yards himself.

Only one Cardinals rookie receiver has had a better season than Harrison (Anquan Boldin in 2003). Harrison not being part of the first team isn’t a snub. It makes sense.

Get more Cardinals and NFL coverage from Cards Wire’s Jess Root and others by listening to the latest on the Rise Up, See Red podcast. Subscribe on SpotifyYouTube or Apple podcasts.

 

Marvin Harrison Jr.’s rookie season was one of best in Cardinals history

He finished with the second-most catches and receiving yards by a rookie and tied for the most rookie touchdown catches.

Arizona Cardinals receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. entered the 2024 season with extremely high expectations as the No. 4 overall pick. With other rookie receivers in recent years having monster seasons, many believed and expected that Harrison should, too. He should catch 90-plus passes for 1,100 or 1,200 yards.

That didn’t happen. He finished his rookie campaign with 62 receptions for 885 yards and eight touchdowns.

The truth is that was one of the best rookie seasons the Cardinals have ever gotten from a receiver.

His 62 receptions are second in franchise history for rookie catches, trailing only Anquan Boldin’s 101-catch rookie season in 2003.

His 885 yards are also the second-most receiving yards by a rookie, trailing Boldin’s 1,377.

He beat out Frank Sanders, who had 883 in 1995.

Harrison’s eight touchdown catches as a rookie tied the franchise rookie record, one he shares with the two best receivers in franchise history — Boldin and Larry Fitzgerald.

His rookie season was better Fitzgerald’s, having more catches and receiving yards and the same number of touchdowns.

Fitzgerald had 58 receptions for 780 yards and eight touchdowns in 2004.

Boldin’s performance came in a season when the Cardinals had nobody else doing much offensively. The second-leading receiver on that team was tight end Freddie Jones, who had 55 catches for 517 yards. They did not have a 1,000-yard rusher that season.

Harrison had Trey McBride as a teammate, who caught 111 passes for 1,146 yards. James Conner rushed for 1,094 yards. Michael Wilson had 47 receptions for 548 yards.

So comparing his season to Boldin’s doesn’t seem fair.

Comparing him to Fitzgerald’s rookie season is apt. Fitz came in as a rookie in 2004 with Boldin as a teammate. Boldin, who played in only 10 games that season, had over 600 yards and so did Bryant Johnson. Emmitt Smith had over 900 rushing yards.

So Harrison had better numbers than Fitzgerald with teammates who performed better.

And Harrison’s rookie season is comparable to his Hall of Fame father’s rookie year in 1996. Marvin Harrison Sr. had 64 catches for 836 yards and eight touchdowns.

Junior had six fewer catches than his father, but had almost 50 more yards and equaled him in touchdowns.

Head coach Jonathan Gannon was not disappointed in Harrison at all and considers him a “premier player.”

“I thought he had a good year,” Gannon said on Monday. “Coming in with the expectations that typically only get put on quarterbacks in the top three, I understand the expectation. He was a premier player for us. He’s going to continue to be a premier player for us and he hasn’t hit his ceiling yet. I look forward to the offseason that he’s about to go through. I look forward to him getting back in the building, playing to the level that I want him to play, that you guys want him to play and that he wants to play most importantly. I know he is going to get there.”

Fitzgerald had a league-high 103 catches in his second season with over 1,400 yards.

We can perhaps eye those sort of numbers for Harrison in 2025.

Get more Cardinals and NFL coverage from Cards Wire’s Jess Root and others by listening to the latest on the Rise Up, See Red podcast. Subscribe on SpotifyYouTube or Apple podcasts.

 

Marvin Harrison Jr.’s rookie season for Cardinals not historically disappointing

While not the historically dominant campaign many expected, his rookie number matchup well with other all-time greats in franchise history.

Many would say that the rookie season for Arizona Cardinals receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. has been a disappointment. After being drafted fourth overall, expectations were than he catch 75-plus passes for 1,100-plus yards.

That has not happened.

Through 16 games and entering the final week of the season, he has caught 57 passes for 822 yards and seven touchdowns.

That seems pretty pedestrian for someone who is supposed to be a star.

Historically speaking, it is good for rookie receivers for the Cardinals.

With one touchdown catch, his eighth, he will tie the franchise rookie record, held by two legends — Anquan Boldin and Larry Fitzgerald.

Harrison’s 822 receiving yards are the third-most by a Cardinals rookie, better than Fitzgerald’s 780. Fitzgerald has 58 receptions as a rookie.

In fact, with 62 receiving yards in the season finale, Harrison would pass Frank Sanders for the second-highest rookie receiving yards total in franchise history.

The record is held by Anquan Boldin, who had 101 rceeptions and 1,377 yards his rookie season in 2003.

With two catches, 64 yards and a touchdown in Week 18, Harrison’s rookie season will look like this:

  • Equalling Boldin and Fitzgerald in touchdown catches as rookies
  • More catches and receiving yards than Fitzgerald as a rookie
  • More receiving yards than any other Cardinals rookie not named Boldin

His Hall of Fame father totaled 64 receptions for 836 yards and eight touchdowns as a rookie. So with six catches, 14 yards and a touchdown, he can match his father’s rookie season.

Considering he did that while tight end Trey McBride surpassed 100 catches and 1,000 yards, his rookie season probably shouldn’t be considered disappointing. It just didn’t match the incredibly high expectations that people had for him.

Get more Cardinals and NFL coverage from Cards Wire’s Jess Root and others by listening to the latest on the Rise Up, See Red podcast. Subscribe on SpotifyYouTube or Apple podcasts.

 

Cardinals’ Marvin Harrison Jr. said a ref told him he wasn’t offsides before being flagged for it

Marvin Harrison Jr. should really know refs aren’t your friends.

The tone for the Arizona Cardinals’ tough loss to the Carolina Panthers on Sunday was probably set on the opening snap. And there’s likely nothing Marvin Harrison Jr. could’ve done to change a thing about it.

In the postgame, the rookie receiver clarified what happened when he was called for being offsides on the Cardinals’ first offensive play of the game. As almost every receiver usually does before each play, Harrison claimed he checked with a referee to ensure he was lined up correctly before the snap. The official apparently told Harrison he was all set and good to go, but … he still flagged him for being offsides.

What? That’s so weird. Why would the ref do that?

Whatever happened here, Harrison got the best lesson of all.

Contrary to any other possible belief, the refs are not your friends. They’re just there to officiate the game, man. Don’t expect anything else — especially if they pull a penalty out from under you. If anything, be prepared for that to happen now.

Does Marvin Harrison Jr. have to improve in areas where Trey McBride has?

Jonathan Gannon might have proffered a clue to why Harrison hasn’t taken the league by storm when he was talking about Trey McBride Friday.

While their draft slots were apart by 51, albeit in different years, there is one thing similar about Arizona Cardinals wide receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. and tight end Trey McBride.

Harrison was selected fourth overall this year and was the first wide receiver to go off the board.

While McBride lasted until the 55th choice in the second round in 2022, he was also the first at his position to be picked in that draft.

That doesn’t mean everything will be great immediately when adjusting to the NFL game no matter how many wish it were so.

Surely, the expectations are heightened for players chosen as high as Harrison, but where you’re picked doesn’t matter a lick when it comes to mastering the nuances of the NFL and getting on the same page as your quarterback when you’re a pass-catcher.

Without saying it, head coach Jonathan Gannon might have proffered a clue to why Harrison hasn’t taken the league by storm when he was talking about McBride Friday.

Especially when both Harrison and Murray alluded to having to get on the same page as each other in the offense.

Murray was asked Wednesday that even though Harrison has seven touchdown receptions, how much upside does he think is still left in his game and your connection, and how can you maximize it a little bit more?

Murray quickly emphasized, “A lot. A lot. That’s exciting and also frustrating when it comes to both of our expectations for each other together. Rookie year, you’re trying to get better each and every week. But I’m not in his mind. That’s where the communication comes from and what he’s thinking, what he’s feeling, what he’s seeing, allowing the game to slow down.

“But there’s also an element of what he’s getting in the room versus what Kyler wants. We’ve just got to get on the same page. We’ve just got to continue to get on the same page, continue to allow him to play fast.”

As for McBride, when Murray was asked about him getting 15 targets and catching 12 in Week 12 for 133 yards against the Seahawks, he had a three-word answer. “He was open.”

Last Sunday, McBride caught all 12 of his targets for 96 yards, so he has 24 receptions on 27 targets for 229 yards in the last two games.

Meanwhile, Harrison was targeted 12 times against the Vikings, but caught only five. For the season, he has 41 receptions on 78 targets (52.6 percent).

McBride has 32 more catches on only 14 more targets. His receptions/targets percentage is 79.3.

We all have to ask ourselves: Does it appear as if Harrison is consistently getting open that often? The answer seems to be no. Or is part of it Murray not totally where Harrison will be on each play.

Yes, defenses play Harrison differently than McBride, but the numbers should be better than 3.4 receptions per game. That projects to 58 for the season.

Vikings head coach Kevin O’Connell revealed after Sunday’s game about McBride, “I told him pregame — he came up to me pregame and said really nice things to me. I said, ‘Hey, man, I think you’re one of the best going right now in the NFL’ because he does it so many different ways. I think that’s where you saw the volume come into play today where maybe they want to be ready for pressure looks and things like that. At the same time, he’s essentially on many of those downs acting as the third wide receiver underneath; catch and run. Tons of yards after catch.

“When you really study them on tape, they’re designing ways to get him the ball, and he’s also a really good blocker. So it can really be a tough task as a defense because you’ve got to basically account for the whole playbook when he’s in there, based upon his skill-set. Really, really special player. I told him that before the game. I was kind of hoping he’d go easier on us than he did, which he did not. He was incredibly impactful today.”

So, let’s get to what Gannon said Friday that elicited this analysis while remembering issues there were at times between McBride and Murray last season when they weren’t on the same page. Read it and be thinking also about Harrison.

Asked where McBride has gotten better and if he has elevated his game, Gannon said, “Yeah. You guys watch the tape (not like coaches, of course!). Where he really has elevated his game is route detail. Just certain routes I think he’s gotten a lot better at running. There’s no indecision with the quarterback. How he’s gonna come out of things, when he’s gonna give him his eyes. That takes time. As good as he was last year, we sat down and said, ‘Hey, how do you become a better player?’

“One of the top things was just route detail. When I talk about detail guys, it’s like fourth outside step instead of fifth outside step. It’s minute (mi-noot). When you do those little things correctly, consistently, you should become a better player if we identified it right. He took it to heart. Ben’s (tight ends coach Ben Steele) done a really good job with him and he’s doing better.”

He surely is. And in time, Harrison will too.

Get more Cardinals and NFL coverage from Cards Wire’s Jess Root and others by listening to the latest on the Rise Up, See Red podcast. Subscribe on SpotifyYouTube or Apple podcasts.

 

James Conner must be used more in Week 13 vs. Vikings

Arizona Cardinals RB James Conner is a beast so OC Drew Petzing must avoid the error of limiting his carries in NFL Week 13.

The Arizona Cardinals were not themselves in Week 12. Not only did the team have countless errors last week in their 16-6 loss to the Seattle Seahawks, running back James Conner only had seven carries, and that has not been a recipe for team success in 2024.



Over the four-game winning streak that was snapped last weekend, Conner averaged 17 carries per game, recorded two 100-yard games and had two touchdowns. Yet, Cardinals offensive coordinator Drew Petzing found a way to alienate Conner from the game plan in their very important Week 12 matchup.

Against the Minnesota Vikings in Week 13,  Petzing needs to rely on Conner to keep the Vikings offense on the sideline. Running the ball and sustaining offensive drives will help the Cardinals to dictate the pace of the game and prevent the game from turning into an offensive shootout.

Ultimately, it’s not that Conner can’t occupy as a asset with lesser usage but his play style helps to balance out the teams’ passing attack. Vikings defensive coordinator Brian Flores will likely blitz Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray so Petzing would be wise to run the ball to play on the attrition of the Vikings defense. Allowing Conner’s physicality to weigh on the Vikings might be pivotal down the stretch of this contest.

Get more Cardinals and NFL coverage from Cards Wire’s Jess Root and others by listening to the latest on the Rise Up, See Red podcast. Subscribe on SpotifyYouTube or Apple podcasts.