According to one SEC columnist, the reputation that Kyle Field and the 12th Man hold is simply, in one word, a “myth.”
The SEC is among the most competitive Division I sports conferences, equating to housing some of the most daunting places to play for any college football team. No matter how talented or elite a program is, any team can be on upset watch when playing in a hostile environment.
Kyle Field, the home of Texas A&M football and the raucous 12th Man, has been no stranger to playing a role in some incredible upsets, such as last season’s win over No. 5 LSU. It’s been regarded as one of the most intimidating sports venues by sports writers, media outlets, and even rival fans alike.
But according to USA TODAY SEC columnist Blake Toppmeyer, the reputation that Kyle Field and the 12th Man hold is, in a word, a “myth.”
Toppmeyer looked at SEC team winning percentages since 2012 (when the conference expanded to 14 teams) to unearth the best home-field advantage. South Carolina (1), Florida (2), and Auburn (3) round out the top three, while heavyweights such as Georgia (8) and Alabama (12) are further down below.
As for the Aggies and Kyle Field, they ranked dead last at No. 14, behind the likes of Vanderbilt, who sit second-to-last:
“Kyle Field towers in size, but the Home of the 12th Man doesn’t create an advantage to equal its branding. When you include the Aggies’ neutral-site results against Arkansas, Texas A&M is the SEC’s only team that has a better record (27-22) in non-home conference games the past 11 seasons than it does in SEC home games (21-19).”
Below is Toppmeyer’s breakdown of the Aggies’ winning percentage at home versus on the road, including his quote that doubles down by calling the home of the 12th Man a “myth:”
SEC home winning percentage: .525
SEC road/neutral winning percentage: .551
Difference: Minus- .026
Toppmeyer’s take: “Kyle Field is an impressive venue, but the Aggies’ 12th Man advantage is a myth.”
I’m sorry, but name me one person that would rather go and play amongst the 102,733 crowd at Kyle Field versus the Commodores’ FirstBank Stadium, which is currently the smallest stadium in the SEC with a 40,550 seating capacity.
I would like to see the average winning margin of the Aggies’ home games layered onto these rankings because a three-point loss to Ole Miss in Week 8 last season hits differently than a 17-point loss to the Gators a week after. I’d venture to argue no SEC team is walking into the hostile crowd at Kyle Field and thinking the matchup will be a cakewalk, regardless of record.
The winning percentage alone can’t serve as a proxy for the hostility and pressure from over 100,000 fans screaming at you when trying to get a play call in. Aggie football may have had its recent struggles, but by no means is the 12th Man indicative of a last-place ranking among the other SEC fanbases.
Contact/Follow us @AggiesWire on Twitter, and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Texas A&M news, notes, and opinions. Follow Pete on Twitter: @PeteThreee.
[lawrence-auto-related count=3 category=5]