Charlie Smyth struck while the iron was hot in Saints preseason opener

Charlie Smyth struck while the iron was hot in the Saints’ preseason opener. The rookie kicker came through in the clutch:

What a way to start your career in American football. Not just the NFL — when Charlie Smyth took the field on Saturday night to attempt a 37-yard field goal for the win, he did so on his first kick in the American game. The rookie from Northern Ireland joined the New Orleans Saints through the NFL’s International Player Program this offseason, and he’s been turning heads all summer.

That included during pregame warmups. Smyth booted two tries from distances of 60-plus yards, then watched Blake Grupe go to work for three quarters. When his turn finally came, it was in the game’s final seconds, with the Saints trailing by a single point. And his coaches had full confidence in him in that moment.

“We would’ve kicked it from, I don’t know, sixty. You know? Depending on how much time was left in the game and whether I thought the down and distance was, what we thought the percentages was. So it’s a little bit of a hypothetical,” Allen mused in his postgame press conference.

At about the same time, the Irish rock band U2’s hit single “With You or Without You” could be heard echoing from the celebratory Saints locker room, per Nola.com’s Luke Johnson. Allen continued: “But I felt good about him hitting the distance. Wasn’t worried about that at all. And I thought that was awesome. First kick in not an NFL game a football game, in an American football game. For him to knock it through like that in a pressure situation, that was cool to see.”

That’s not to say Smyth has won the job just yet. He needs to keep up the good work and harness the power in his leg (he pushed a few warmup kicks wide to the right, as has happened at training camp practices) and improve his placement on kickoffs. He’s sent too many of those out of the field of play. But he may just need more experience. You don’t see many players with his raw talent. His status in the IPP has bought some time to better learn the sport, but Smyth just might end up pushing the envelope.

[lawrence-auto-related count=5]

Wil Lutz had a perfect reaction to D.J. Jones’ comment about kickers

Broncos defensive lineman poked fun at kickers earlier this week and Wil Lutz took notice.

During his media availability earlier this week, Denver Broncos defensive lineman D.J. Jones was asked if he has to prepare differently to get himself ready physically now that he’s in his eighth season in the NFL.

“Oh yeah,” Jones said. “If anyone tells you, ‘No,’ they’re lying — or they’re a kicker. You have to hone into the details as far as your body goes and if you’ve had any surgeries or anything. You have to take care of things before you come out here.”

Andrew Mason of DenverSports.com shared a clip of Jones making that statement on Twitter/X, and the video was spotted by Broncos kicker Wil Lutz, who had a perfect response:

Lutz (30) has been in the NFL since 2016, one year longer than Jones (29). Good-natured jabs aside, Jones realizes Lutz has to take care of his body to play in the NFL as well. We can’t blame him for poking fun at kickers, though, it’s one of football’s oldest locker room traditions.

[vertical-gallery id=620142]

Packers kicker competition takes a turn entering Family Night

Greg Joseph, the veteran challenger, has created some distance in the competition against Anders Carlson at Packers kicker.

On Tuesday, the Green Bay Packers kicker competition got whittled down to two. On Thursday, some distance was created between the two remaining competitors.

This is no longer a three-way competition. Rookie James Turner was released on Tuesday.

During the final practice before Family Night, veteran challenger Greg Joseph finished a perfect 7-for-7 — with makes from 41, 42, 45, 47, 49, 51 and 58 yards. Incumbent Anders Carlson, meanwhile, went 4-for-7 — with misses from 45, 47 and 49. Like Joseph, Carlson made the 58-yarder to end the practice.

Through nine practices, Joseph has taken a noteworthy lead in the on-field competition.

Joseph, who was the Minnesota Vikings kicker over the last three seasons, is 29-of-31, or 93.5 percent.

Carlson, who started strong as a rookie but went through miserable ups and downs late, is 25-of-31, or 80.6 percent. Overall, Carlson made 81.8 percent of his field goals last season.

Any distance Joseph has made ahead of Carlson could be made up Saturday night at Lambeau Field. Kicking inside the stadium creates a far different environment than practice, and it can be assumed those kicks will be weighed more heavily in the kicking competition. Thousands of fans will be in attendance and the winds blow differently inside the bowl of Lambeau Field.

Can Joseph stay steady and accurate at Family Night? And can Carlson pull out a mini-funk? Both are important questions, given some of Joseph’s inconsistencies during his NFL career and the repetitiveness of Carlson’s funks to start his own career.

Packers kicking competition tracker

Greg Joseph: 29-for-31 (93.5%)
Anders Carlson: 25-for-31 (80.6%)

How does Packers kicker competition look after 5 training camp practices?

Updating the kicker competition between Anders Carlson, Greg Joseph and James Turner through 5 training camp practices for the Packers.

The sample size isn’t necessarily significant yet, but the incumbent kicker and the veteran challenger look to be ahead of the rookie through five training camp practices for the Green Bay Packers.

James Turner, the rookie out of Michigan, got another turn during the Packers’ fifth practice on Saturday. He connected on 5-of-7 kicks, including back-to-back makes over 45 yards to finish the practice, per Bill Huber of SI. His misses came from 47 yards and 49 yards.

Overall, Turner is 13-of-19 on kicks — or 68.4 percent — to start training camp. The rookie must find some consistency* in the coming days or the Packers could decide to trim the kicking competition to two.

(* Actually, consistency might not be the right word. In a way, Turner has been remarkably consistent. He’s made 2-of-3 kicks during almost every one of his live kicking sessions. But 2-of-3 isn’t good enough at this level.)

Anders Carlson, now in Year 2 after an up-and-down rookie season with the Packers, made his first 11 kicks of training camp. His lone miss went off the upright from 50 yards out during Friday’s practice. Overall, he’s 11-for-12, including a 6-for-6 start in wet, rainy conditions on Wednesday.

“Carlson has been solid,” Packers Wire contributor Paul Bretl said. “Makes seem pretty pure down the middle. More power than the other two.”

Don’t forget about Greg Joseph, who was the Minnesota Vikings kicker during each of the last three seasons. After going 6-for-6 on Friday, Joseph is now tied with Carlson at 11-for-12 through five practices.

At some point, it won’t make sense for the Packers to roster three kickers. It’ll be tough to get enough live opportunities for all three, and the Packers will want to see enough competition during preseason games.

“Turner a distant third in this competition,” Bretl said.

Can Turner turn things around, or will strong starts from Carlson and Joseph eventually create a two-kicker battle?

Packers kicking competition tracker

Anders Carlson: 11-for-12 (91.7%)
Greg Joseph: 11-for-12 (91.7%)
James Turner: 13-for-19 (68.4%)

Rookie kicker Charlie Smyth has a big day at Saints training camp

Rookie kicker Charlie Smyth had a big day at Saturday’s Saints training camp practice, hitting all seven of his field goal tries:

Have a day, Charlie Smyth. The New Orleans Saints’ rookie kicker had a good day at Saturday’s training camp practice. Smyth connected on all seven of his field goal tries with his longest kick traveling 59 yards. Last year’s kicker Blake Grupe might be on notice.

Now that’s not to say he enjoyed a perfect morning of work at UC Irvine. Smyth struggled on his kickoff reps, sending too many of his tries out of bounds, as noted by Nola.com’s Luke Johnson. That’s not too surprising. He’s a former Gaelic football player from Northern Ireland who is still picking up the game and the responsibilities of his position. He’s going to make mistakes.

Still, performances like this are encouraging. Grupe was too inconsistent last season. While he did hit on each of his 40 extra point attempts, Grupe missed seven field goals from distances of 29, 29, 46, 47, 51, 52, and 54 yards. Those short-yardage misses are what’s most concerning.

If Smyth can keep growing and iron out his own inconsistencies, he might just put Grupe in a tough spot. Remember, Grupe himself was an undrafted rookie just one year ago. He displaced a former Pro Bowler in Wil Lutz. It shouldn’t shock anyone if Smyth pushes him aside by September, too. At the same time the Saints can afford to give Smyth a longer runway. He joined the team with an International Player Pathway exemption which means he can stay on the team with an extra practice squad spot until they’re confident he’s ready. We’ll just have to see how this battle plays out in the weeks ahead.

[lawrence-auto-related count=4]

Alabama lands commitment from 2025 kicker Peter Notaro

The Alabama Crimson Tide landed a commitment from 2025 kicker Peter Notaro on Wednesday. Notaro chose the Crimson Tide over Ohio State.

The Alabama Crimson Tide is rolling on the recruiting trail. On Wednesday, Alabama landed a commitment from 2025 kicker Peter Notaro. Notaro is ranked as a five-star by Kohl’s Kicking.

Alabama now has two specialists committed as a part of the ’25 recruiting class. 2025 three-star punter Alex Asparuhov is also committed to the Crimson Tide.

Notaro chose to commit to Alabama over other programs, such as the Ohio State Buckeyes, Pittsburgh, and West Virginia. He is listed at 5-foot-11 and 180 pounds. He plays for North Allegheny High School in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.

The following were Kohl’s comments regarding Notaro:

“Notaro scored 17 points on field goals and 116.43 points on kick offs at the Underclassman Challenge. He also won a field goal competition and looked like a D1 scholarship player. He flashed potential in the punting portion as well but his current strength are kickoffs and field goals.”

Roll Tide Wire will continue to follow the latest regarding the Alabama football program and its efforts on the recruiting trail.

Broncos roster series: No. 3, kicker Wil Lutz

Wil Lutz converted 88.2% of his field goal attempts and went 29-of-31 on PATs in his first season with the Broncos.

Broncos Wire’s 90-man offseason roster series continues today with a look at ninth-year kicker Wil Lutz, No. 3 (he switched from No. 16 this offseason). 

Before the Broncos: Lutz (29) signed with the Baltimore Ravens as an undrafted free agent out of Georgia State in 2016. After failing to make Baltimore’s 53-man roster, Lutz was claimed off waivers by the New Orleans Saints. He went on to spend the next seven years in New Orleans. 

Lutz sat out the 2021 season after undergoing core muscle surgery, but he played all other 97 games for the Saints from 2016-2020 and 2022. Lutz completed 84.6% of his field goal attempts during that time with a long of 60 yards.

Broncos tenure: After drafting Blake Grupe, New Orleans agreed to trade Lutz to Denver last summer in exchange for a seventh-round pick. In his first season with the Broncos, Lutz converted 88.2% of his field goal attempts with a long of 52 yards. He went 29-of-31 on extra point attempts.

Chances to make the 53-man roster: Near lock. Lutz is currently the only kicker on the 90-man offseason roster and unless he struggles significantly this summer, his job should be safe. 

[vertical-gallery id=620142]

Commanders miss out on UFL kicker Jake Bates, who is expected to sign with Lions

Jake Bates visited Washington, but is heading elsewhere.

The Washington Commanders desperately need a kicker after releasing veteran Brandon McManus earlier this month. The Commanders signed journeyman Ramiz Ahmed, but he’s never attempted an extra point or field goal in the NFL.

This week, Washington held tryouts with multiple kickers, with Lucas Havrisik and Andre Szmyt spending time with the team during this week’s minicamp. Havrisik has attempted 20 field goals in the NFL, while Szmyt spent the spring with the St. Louis Battlehawks of the UFL.

The Commanders also brought in All-UFL kicker Jake Bates for a workout. Bates quickly became a social media sensation for his big kicks this spring. Unfortunately for Washington, Bates is heading elsewhere, per Aaron Wilson of KPRC 2 in Houston.

Wilson reported on Friday that Bates is expected to sign with the Detroit Lions. This makes sense, considering Bates kicked for the Michigan Panthers in the spring. UFL players can’t sign official NFL contracts until Tuesday.

According to Wilson, Bates visited three NFL teams (Lions, Commanders, and Packers) and had interest from three other teams.

What does this mean for Washington now? Szmyt was equally as impressive as Bates in the UFL. The Commanders could sign him or Havrisik and have them compete with Ahmed during training camp. Washington could also sign a veteran, although the pickings are slim.

The Commanders went from feeling comfortable about their kicker to being concerned.

Packers request visit for standout UFL kicker Jake Bates

The Packers requested a visit for All-UFL kicker Jake Bates of the Michigan Panthers.

The Green Bay Packers are one of several teams interested in hosting UFL kicker Jake Bates on a visit, according to Aaron Wilson.

Bates, who spent time with the Houston Texans during the offseason in 2023, connected on 17 of 22 field goals during the regular season for the Michigan Panthers. He made 11 of 12 kicks between 20 and 49 yards and was 6-for-10 on kicks of at least 50 yards, including a long make of 64 yards. The 64-yarder — a game winner vs. St. Louis — was the longest made field goal in the UFL. Overall, Bates made three kicks over 60 yards.

During the postseason, Bates made 4-of-6 kicks, giving him a final total of 21 for 28. Among his postseason makes was a 53-yarder.

Bates was named an All-UFL kicker for 2024.

The Packers currently have a three-way competition going at kicker between 2023 draft pick Anders Carlson, veteran Greg Joseph and newcomer Jack Podlesny. If a visit happens, it’s possible the Packers could release one of the three kickers and add Bates to the mix ahead of training camp.

The Detroit Lions, Washington Commanders and Baltimore Ravens have also requested Bates for a visit.

During his collegiate career at Texas State and Arkansas, Bates was nothing more than a kickoff specialist. He has a soccer background.

Commanders to bring in UFL standout kicker Jake Bates for a tryout

Jake Bates is visiting Washington.

When the Washington Commanders released veteran kicker Brandon McManus last week, fans immediately began clamoring for UFL kicker Jake Bates. However, with Bates’ UFL team in the playoffs, he was unable to sign last week.

The Michigan Panthers, for whom Bates kicked, lost over the weekend, meaning Bates was free to visit NFL teams. According to Aaron Wilson of KPRC 2 in Houston, multiple NFL teams are lining up visits with Bates.

The Commanders are one of those teams, along with the Detroit Lions, Baltimore Ravens, and Green Bay Packers, who have also requested to visit with Bates.

Washington signed kicker Ramiz Ahmed last week and hosted at least two other UFL kickers, Andre Szmyt and Matt McCrane, for tryouts. The Commanders begin their three-day mandatory minicamp Tuesday.

The Commanders will likely sign one of the kickers and keep two for a competition in training camp, which begins late next month.

Bates made a name for himself this spring when he kicked a 64-yard game-winner — the longest in UFL history — and had one game in which he made two kicks of over 60 yards. He was named to the All-UFL team last week.

Bates, 24, spent part of training camp with the Houston Texans in 2023.

Per ESPN’s John Keim, Bates’ visit is on Tuesday.