Jerome Boger’s ridiculous roughing the passer call cost Ravens dearly in loss to Bills

Jerome Boger’s horrid roughing the passer penalty was among the things that allowed the Bills to beat the Ravens.

If there’s one thing we know about roughing the passer penalties, it’s that the NFL would prefer that they be called, whether there’s reason to call them or not. In the NFL rulebook, officials are told to skew to the presence of the penalty on a no-matter-what basis.

When in doubt about a roughness call or potentially dangerous tactic against the passer, the Referee should always call roughing the passer.

This particular phenomenon bit the Baltimore Ravens right in the collective posterior late in their 23-20 loss to the Buffalo Bills on Sunday. The Bills took the ball at their own 20-yard line with 4:09 left in the game, and the score tied 20-20, after Lamar Jackson threw an interception to Buffalo safety Jordan Poyer on a controversial go-fot-it call on fourth-and-goal from the Buffalo two-yard line.

After the game, Ravens head coach John Harbaugh said that he wouldn’t have done anything differently, and he wasn’t necessarily wrong.

One reason things didn’t work out for the Ravens on that 12-play, 77-yard drive the Bills executed to win the game with a Tyler Bass field goal with time off the clock was a roughing the passer penalty called on Baltimore cornerback Brandon Stephens with 2:06 left in the game. The Bills had first-and-15 on the Baltimore 41-yard line after a false start call on tackle Dion Dawkins, and Josh Allen threw an incomplete pass with Stephens bearing down on him from a free blitz.

Here’s how the play looked, and what referee Jerome Boger said after the game.

Well, that’s a tough one. There isn’t any head or neck contact, forcible or otherwise. Boger has a bit of a history regarding consistency of calls in his career, but when you are an official are told by the league to call roughing the passer if there’s even the appearance of it, and you then multiply that variance by Boger’s variance… well, weird things are going to happen.

With that penalty, the Bills went from second-and-15 at the Baltimore 41-yard line to first-and-10 at the Baltimore 26-yard line. That put the ball in Bass’ range, and after a couple of short plays and Allen kneeldowns, Bass made it ballgame.

Did the Ravens deserve to lose this game? Well, they were up 17-3, and for the second time this season, they lost a game in which they had a lead of at least 17 points — they blew a 35-14 lead to the Dolphins in Week 2 to lose 42-38.

But in close games, teams don’t need to be waylaid by bad officiating on top of their own issues. And in this case, Boger and his crew absolutely got the call wrong. The replay shows no contact to Allen’s head or neck, forcible or otherwise.

NFL refuses to hold officials accountable for erroneous whistle in Bengals-Raiders game

NFL Vice President of Officiating Walt Anderson tried to deflect the truth of an erroneous whistle in the Bengals-Raiders game. It’s a bad look for the league.

Whether you think the inadvertent whistle on Joe Burrow’s first-half touchdown pass to Tyler Boys affected the game or not in the Bengals’ 26-19 wild-card win over the Raiders on Saturday, there is absolutely no question that line judge Mark Steinkerchner, part of Jerome Boger’s “all-star” officiating crew, blew the play dead as the ball was in the air from Burrow to Boyd, because he thought Burrow stepped out of bounds before he threw the ball.

Raiders robbed by erroneous whistle on Joe Burrow’s TD pass to Tyler Boyd

That fact can’t be disputed, because the evidence is clear. The league itself tweeted out that evidence.

You can clearly hear the whistle before Boyd catches the ball, and you can also see Raiders safety Trevon Moehrig hold up on the play because he thought the play was over. After discussion, Boger and Steinkerchner discussed it, and Boger called it a touchdown despite the fact that it wasn’t the moment the whistle was blown.

Here’s the rule as it currently stands — Rule 7, Section 2, Article (o) of the NFL Rulebook:

When an official sounds the whistle erroneously while the ball is still in play, the ball becomes dead immediately.

  1. If the ball is in player possession, the team in possession may elect to put the ball in play where it has been declared dead or to replay the down.
  2. If the ball is a loose ball resulting from a fumble, backward pass, or illegal forward pass, the team last in possession may elect to put the ball in play at the spot where possession was lost or to replay the down.
  3. If the ball is a loose ball resulting from a legal forward pass, a free kick, a fair-catch kick, or a scrimmage kick, the ball is returned to the previous spot, and the down is replayed.
  4. If there is a foul by either team during any of the above, and the team in possession at the time of the erroneous whistle elects not to replay the down, penalty enforcement is the same as for fouls during a run, forward pass, kick, fumble, and backward pass. If the team in possession elects to replay the down, all penalties will be disregarded, except for personal fouls and unsportsmanlike conduct fouls, which will be administered prior to the replaying of the down. If the down is replayed, the game clock will be reset to the time remaining when the snap occurred, and the clock will start on the snap.

So. After the game, NFL Vice President of Officiating Walt Anderson met with pool reporter Paul Denher. And that’s when things got really weird. This is from the NFL’s officiating social media account.

For Anderson to say that the whistle blew after the ball was caught is absolutely wrong, and while we’re taught in journalism to avoid using the word “lie” unless we’re sure of somebody’s intent, there are two options here: Either Anderson didn’t care enough about his job to check and see when the whistle was blown, or he’s lying to protect this crew.

Either way, it’s a terrible look for a league that has had far too many officiating blunders. And if this is how bad calls are handled, it’s no wonder officials aren’t performing at an optimal standard.

Fans aren’t happy about overzealous foul that erased Saints interception, led to Titans TD

Fans aren’t happy about overzealous foul that erased Saints interception, led to Titans TD

The NFL’s overzealous officiating has struck again. Veteran referee Jerome Boger took away Marcus Williams’ extremely clutch end zone interception of Tennessee Titans quarterback Ryan Tannehill by claiming that New Orleans Saints linebacker Kaden Elliss committed a personal foul in roughing the passer, which both kept the ball in Tennessee possession and helped move them up into scoring position. A few plays later Tannehill dove into the end zone to put his team ahead.

It was, well, controversial to say the least. CBS rules expert Gene Steratore said on the game broadcast that no penalty should have been called; Elliss should have tried to atomize himself and teleport through Tannehill rather than collide with him incidentally, I guess. And NFL fans on social media weren’t happy with the game-changing decision:

NFL assigns referee Jerome Boger to Week 1 Saints-Bucs game

The New Orleans Saints and Tampa Bay Buccaneers will have Jerome Boger at referee when Drew Brees and Tom Brady go toe to toe in Week 1.

[jwplayer jS5cALhU-ThvAeFxT]

The first week of officiating assignments has been reported by Football Zebras, and the New Orleans Saints will have a familiar crew in place when they kick off against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers this Sunday. Veteran referee Jerome Boger and his crew will be on hand for this first matchup between Drew Brees and Tom Brady.

Boger refereed two Saints games last year, both on the road: Week 6’s 13-6 win over the Jacksonville Jaguars and Week 16’s 38-28 rout of the Tennessee Titans. He last visited the Mercedes-Benz Superdome in 2016, officiating the Saints’ 31-24 win over Tampa Bay on Christmas Eve. Boger worked two seasons as a line judge before being promoted to referee in 2006, and has held the position ever since.

Last season, Boger’s crew averaged 14.4 penalties and 119.1 penalty yards per game, calling exactly 50.0% of fouls on the home team; 2.6% above league average. They also averaged 5.7 penalty yards more than the league average.

The Saints didn’t receive much help from Boger and Co. last year. In their first game with the Jaguars, the Saints were flagged three times (for 35 yards) while the Jaguars drew two fouls (for 15 yards). But in their second meeting against the Titans, New Orleans was hit with 11 penalties (for 70 yards) while Tennessee was penalized six times (for 56 yards). That’s a small sample size, but it’s worth remembering.

One underrated storyline this year is going to be the performance of NFL officials without their usual preseason warm-up. While they have toured team training camps for practice, they won’t have the usual time to prepare and work through early-season jitters. Any crews adding new members have had less time to gel, which may lead to more blown calls and mistakes.

So hopefully Saints fans won’t see much of Boger on this week’s broadcast. At least he’s not Bill Vinovich.

[vertical-gallery id=37516]

Lions 2019 rewatch: Week 13 notes from the Thanksgiving loss to Chicago

The David Blough era kicks off with a tough loss on national television

Thanksgiving 2019 marked the beginning of the David Blough era as the starting quarterback for the Detroit Lions. Jeff Driskel had started the last three games, including a massive clunker of an effort in the Week 12 loss to lowly Washington. But Driskel is out for this one and in steps Blough, an undrafted rookie from Purdue acquired from the Browns after the preseason.

Blough’s performance in this matchup with the division rival Chicago Bears in the annual Thanksgiving national broadcast is the primary point of focus. We’ve reached the point of the season where the Lions, now 3-7-1, are playing more youngsters more frequently. It’s a chance to evaluate guys like Blough, RB Bo Scarbrough, CB Amani Oruwariye and TE Isaac Nauta in their more extensive playing time.

Pregame notes

Chicago enters the game at 5-6, having won two of its last three games. That includes the Week 10 win over Detroit in Chicago. The Bears defense is hot, allowing the 4th-fewest points of any team over the last six games.

In addition to Stafford and Driskel, starters Rashaan Melvin (CB), Jamal Agnew (RS) and Damon Harrison (DT) are all out with injuries. Chicago is missing regular starting RT Bobby Massie, replaced by ex-Lion Cornelius Lucas. Linebacker Danny Trevathan and wideout Taylor Gabriel are the other key missing Bears.

The Lions are in the all-silver color rush uniforms while the bears are in the road whites with blue pants

First quarter

You know you’re in for a turkey of a game when the opening kickoff has to get redone thanks to offsetting penalties. You really know it’s going to be a clunker when referee Jerome Boger points the wrong way when making the official calls on the penalties. Not a good start…

It doesn’t get any better once Chicago gets the ball. Cordarrelle Patterson blows past several Lions up the left sideline and returns Matt Prater’s kick to midfield. Mitchell Trubisky comes out throwing, and specifically throwing at Tavon Wilson. The safety makes the tackle on the first three plays, targeted twice in coverage and once on a terrible run fit by LB Christian Jones.

Allen Robinson scores the touchdown, beating Darius Slay on a simple slant he sets up beautifully with a false step outside. Slay steps in the bucket and it was all the room Trubusky needed to fit it in before Tracy Walker’s help could close in. Way too easy of an opening TD drive for Chicago.

Chris Lacy fields the Bears kickoff and kneels. It’s his first time back as the return man in place of the injured Agnew.

Blough comes out without fear. He’s overzealous on his first attempt, a worm-burner to T.J. Hockenson up the right seam where the TE has a step on the coverage. He did not miss on the next play, a 3rd-and-10:

That’s how to take advantage of a blown coverage! Prater’s knuckleball of a conversion ties the game at 7-7.

Jarrad Davis keys the Lions D on the ensuing 3-and-out possession. Two nice stops from the LB including an open-field corraling of shifty RB Tarik Cohen. Slay had perfect coverage on Robinson on the other play. No pass rush up front but still a nice series.

It didn’t even take two full drives before Blough demonstrates he’s a better passer and has superior pocket presence and field awareness than Driskel showed in his three starts. Strikes to Marvin Jones and Golladay move the chain nicely. Blough is stepping up in the pocket and climbing the ladder nicely, not panicking at pressure and keeping his eyes down the field.

Blough hits Jones on a well-designed inside crosser from a bunch formation from the 8-yard line for a TD. The Bears, notably Prince Amukamara once again, get lost in coverage. Great pass protection by the offensive tackles this entire drive. The extra point puts the Lions up 14-7.

Prater gets tricky with the ensuing kickoff. He drills a hard grounder to the shortstop and it strikes a retreating Bears blocker. Jalen Reeves-Maybin comes out of the scrum with possession. The spontaneous, exotic onside kick works! Lions ball inside Chicago territory.

The teams trade 3-and-outs with both QBs making poor choices into coverage. Dee Virgin gets a big thumbs up for his exceptional punt coverage on Sam Martin’s nice boot deep into Chicago territory.

Blough’s initial buzz wears off. He missed Hockenson on a well-covered out route and then makes a terrible choice in forcing a high throw to Danny Amendola in traffic. Had Blough held just a count longer he had Hockenson up the right seam uncovered but he opted to throw to the sticks on 3rd-and-5. The ball nearly got picked off when Amendola tries to tip it to himself, a poor choice for a short receiver in a crowd.

Second quarter

Controversy strikes on a play where Trubisky narrowly avoids a Devon Kennard sack and throws to WR Anthony Miller on the run. Miller catches the ball and then get popped by Justin Coleman. Several players from both teams fail to recover it before it winds up in a pile.

Two officials signal Bears ball. Two others signal Lions ball at various points. The initial call from Boger gave the ball to the Bears, but as FOX’s Joe Buck quizzically notes on the broadcast, “I guess they changed their mind.” Lions ball.

Not so fast. After a lengthy review–more than double the allotted time–Boger decides the pass was incomplete. It wasn’t, but that’s how a bad official covers his inept tracks. Oh yeah, Boger also missed an obvious blow to the head of Trubisky by Wilson that Boger is staring at from five yards away. Oy.

The level of play quickly descends to the level of officiating. Wilson badly misses an open-field tackle, another in-the-box attempt, and has an illegal contact penalty (he was guilty) declined. The Lions pass rush isn’t nearly as effective as Trubisky would have you believe it is, and his impatience and lack of accuracy bail out Oruwariye and Coleman in coverage on separate throws.

Troy Aikman’s not having a great game on as a color commentator, either. He enthusiastically notes that “this Bears offense is the same one Kansas City runs” and “they’re capable of scoring from anywhere”.  Going back to the Week 10 matchup, the Bears offense has gone 3-and-out on seven of its last 10 drives against the Lions defense, which entered this game ranked 30th. Chicago is 29th in scoring entering the game, 30th if you strip out defensive and special teams scores. He says the latter as it’s 1st-and-32 after two dumb penalties on the OL. But I digress…

The Bears opt to go for it on 4th-and-5 from the Lions 32, eschewing a 50-yard FG attempt. Trey Flowers surges past LT Charles Leno and Trubisky flings the ball at the feet of a receiver short of the sticks. The Bears also had an illegal formation but the Lions decline it and celebrate the nice stop. Davis was effective on a couple of A-gap blitzes on this drive and was in nice position in coverage on the final play too.

Some really nice run blocking from Frank Ragnow, Graham Glasgow and Taylor Decker gets the Lions rolling. Ty Johnson and Scarbrough are both effectively running downhill, not hesitating or dancing through the hole and it’s working. Boger’s crew once again interferes with the game with a truly baffling offensive pass interference call on Marvin Jones that wipes out an intentional defensive pass interference call against Buster Skrine on Golladay in the end zone (Skrine got beat and knew it). Boger quickly gives a make-up call, flagging (now Lions DT) Nick Williams for roughing Blough. It’s a flag that not even Aaron Rodgers gets most of the time.

The red zone offense sputters badly. Two Blough throwaways under pressure (rough set for Rick Wagner) and a pointless J.D. McKissic run smack into a stacked box stall the drive. The Lions kick a 25-yard field goal to surge out the lead to 17-7 with 3:00 to play in the half.

Poor containment on the kick return by Patterson sets the Bears up near their own 40, thanks in part to an egregious missed holding call on the player blocking Dee Virgin. The drive quickly becomes “let’s pick on Justin Coleman” as Trubisky targets him in coverage on his first three passes. Two are complete, the third (technically the first of the series) Coleman broke up nicely. Quick-hit completions on slants against Oruwariye (who missed the tackle too) and Slay set the Bears up in FG range.

Jarrad Davis is playing really well and there’s a play at the end of the drive here that needs appreciation. Trubisky takes off from the pass rush and is poised to get a first down with his legs. Davis explodes into the path Trubisky wants to take and it scares the QB enough that he veers sideways. That gives Walker time to close in and make a very nice open-field tackle. Davis doesn’t get any credit in the box score but he’s absolutely the reason the Bears’ drive fizzles and results in a field goal and not a TD. Lions lead 17-10 at the half.

9 things we learned from Week 16’s Sunday of the 2019 NFL season

One coach should be fired. One officiating crew needs to be suspended. And, playoff permutations! Here are 9 things we learned in Week 16.

With just one week left in the 2019 regular season, here are nine things we learned from Week 16’s Sunday.

In the end, firing Jason Garrett is best for all involved. 

(Bill Streicher-USA TODAY Sports)

As far as pure roster talent is concerned, it’s tough to top the Cowboys — especially on offense. Dak Prescott is one of the NFL’s best quarterbacks, and when that offense is humming, running back Ezekiel Elliott and receiver Amari Cooper can make the same claims. They do their work behind one of the league’s premier offensive lines, and on defense, there’s enough talent to be above-average.

So, when a team like that stands at 7-8 and loses a key divisional matchup as the Cowboys did to the Eagles on Sunday afternoon… well, maybe it’s time to isolate the coaching. In this 17-9 loss to the Eagles, many were wondering why Elliott and Cooper were on the bench at specific (and important) times in favor of guys like Tavon Austin and Tony Pollard. Per Jane Slater of the NFL Network, Dallas’ coaching staff didn’t bench Cooper per se — they wanted him off the field in specific instances because they felt the Eagles’ defensive backs were struggling more with smaller, quicker receivers. Cooper caught five passes for 106 yards the first time Dallas and Philadelphia met this season, but we digress. Austin finished the day with one catch for five yards, and while Randall Cobb did catch five passes for 73 yards, he was off the field on one crucial fourth-down situation. When the Cowboys went into hurry-up mode, they apparently had issues substituting the receivers they wanted back in.

As to why Dallas only ran the ball 16 times, well, we’ll just leave this here.

The Cowboys can still make the playoffs if they beat the Redskins and the Eagles lose to the Giants in Week 17, but if not, this will be the fourth time in Jason Garrett’s nine seasons that his team has lost what would be a division-winning game in Weeks 16 or 17. If Dallas doesn’t make the playoffs, it’s hard to imagine that Jerry Jones has a choice but to let Garrett go.