John McCarthy weighs in on judges’ scoring criteria, applies it to Adesanya vs. Romero

“Who’s the guy that created the most dangerous situations for their opponent?”

Perhaps MMA judging never has been a more controversial topic than it has in early 2020.

UFC 247 last month, headlined by Jon Jones’ controversial win over Dominick Reyes, shed light on just how big of an issue it’s become in the sport. UFC president Dana White is notorious for preaching to “never leave it in the hands of the judges,” because in most cases it can cost you half your purse.

Former referee and current Bellator commentator John McCarthy says judging is not easy, especially when the crowd plays a factor, as well as the angle from which the judge is watching the fight.

While the general notion is usually that the fighter who looks like they’re doing more is winning, McCarthy thinks it should be about the effectiveness and impact of what that fighter is doing.

“The biggest thing we have to have is the judges understanding the criteria that is given to them and how to use it and then understanding in a fight what is effective,” McCarthy told MMA Junkie Radio. “It’s not what is flashy. It’s not the guy that’s moving forward. It is what is the most effective element in that round. Who’s the guy that created the most dangerous situations for their opponent?

“It doesn’t matter if he’s chasing him down. It matters if he is doing the most effective damage during that round. That’s what the judges are looking for.”

[lawrence-related id=501006,500979,499131]

The middleweight championship fight between [autotag]Israel Adesanya[/autotag] and [autotag]Yoel Romero[/autotag] earlier this month at UFC 248 was one of the more difficult fights to judge due to the inactivity throughout 25 minutes. Adesanya was awarded the unanimous decision, winning three rounds on two judges’ scorecards and four on the other.

All three judges gave Romero the first round.

“Personally, I knew at the end of that (first) round, I knew that every judge, my son was one of those judges, I knew everyone was going to go with Yoel Romero because he landed the one big right hand,” McCarthy said. “You saw Israel rubbing his left eye, blinking his left eye because a knuckle caught him or something, but it showed that that punch had an effect. That’s what I’m talking about: Who affected the other the most?”

McCarthy admits that because the round was so uneventful, he wanted to score it as a draw, but knowing the judging criteria, he understands why it was given to Romero.

“I wanted to give it a 10-10 because neither, in my opinion, neither guy deserved to win that round,” McCarthy said. “You didn’t do enough to win that round. You didn’t do enough for me to say you actually get an advantage over your opponent now, having one point higher on the scorecard, but I knew when the round was over, they’re all going to give it to Yoel, and I probably would have to because that’s what the criteria tells me.”

In a lackluster fight, some argue that Romero should have won, but whether it deserves to go down as a robbery or controversial decision is firmly in question, as the lack of activity made it difficult for the judges to pinpoint the deciding factor.

[vertical-gallery id=497932]

Jon Jones throws shade at Israel Adesanya’s win over Yoel Romero

Jon Jones was not impressed.

Perhaps not surprisingly, you can consider UFC light heavyweight champion [autotag]Jon Jones[/autotag] is unimpressed by what he saw from middleweight champ [autotag]Israel Adesanya[/autotag] in his win over Yoel Romero.

Earlier this month at UFC 248, Adesanya and Romero put on what was widely considered a lackluster main event, with “The Last Style” bender retaining his title after earning a unanimous decision from the judges. Both men have blamed each other for why the fight failed to live up to expectations.

As far as Jones is concerned, it seems that – based on Adesanya’s performance – he’d rather not hear any more talk about a potential showdown against his fellow UFC champ.

Yoel is almost 10 years older than me and almost won that fight,” Jones wrote in response to a question on Twitter. “Without using his wrestling. That’s all I’ll say.”

[lawrence-related id=499131,498193,498464]

Jones and Adesanya have been feuding for months, leading many to believe a superfight could be down the line. Adesanya, who debuted with the UFC in February 2018, has gone so far as to say it’s inevitable – he just needs time to round into form. Jones, however, might not be too interested.

At least not anymore.

[jwplayer CFlFQLaC-RbnemIYZ]

[opinary poll=”who-would-win-a-fight-between-jon-jones-” customer=”mmajunkie”]

Dan Hooker: Seeing Israel Adesanya, Alexander Volkanovski with UFC belts makes it very attainable for me

City Kickboxing’s recent championship success has inspired Dan Hooker.

City Kickboxing’s recent success has inspired [autotag]Dan Hooker[/autotag].

Hooker (20-8 MMA, 10-4 UFC) was one of the first staples of the New Zealand MMA scene to make it to the UFC and now finds himself potentially a fight or two away from title contention.

He is currently projected to face former UFC interim lightweight title challenger Dustin Poirier in the main event of UFC San Diego in what would be his second straight headliner.

And while his own stock is on the rise, Hooker said watching teammates [autotag]Israel Adesanya[/autotag], the reigning UFC middleweight champion and [autotag]Alexander Volkanovski[/autotag], the current UFC featherweight champion, rise to the occasion gives him confidence that he is ever-so-close to his ultimate goal.

“Now I have two teammates, I have Alex Volkanovski and Israel Adesanya, walking around the gym with world title belts, and that makes it very attainable for me,” Hooker told MMA Junkie. “I know what I’m capable of inside the gym and my results inside of the octagon. I know that I can compete and beat the best guys in the world, so I just need the opportunity. So now, No. 5, I’m working my way towards that belt. You’re putting yourself and you’re now jockeying for position for title contention, and title contention is the next goal that I’ve set myself.”

[lawrence-related id=494762,495064]

Hooker, who’s won seven of his last eight, is coming off a five-round battle last month in Auckland, edging out Paul Felder in a “Fight of the Night” effort.

He’s called his shot before when he previously asked fort Felder, and it appears will get his wish once more with Poirier, as he continues to map out his next step one fight at a time.

“Me, like I’m a realist,” Hooker said. “Israel Adesanya is known from day one that he was going to be world champion, he’s going to be headlining pay-per-views but me, it’s whatever I can see in front of me is the next biggest goal. As I achieve those goals, I set something else in front of me, so my progression has always been incremental and very slow.”

Check out the full interview with Hooker in the video above.

[vertical-gallery id=493117]

MMA rankings report: Why one UFC 248 title-fight loser drops but not the other

Did Yoel Romero or Joanna Jedrzejczyk drop in their division in the latest USA TODAY Sports/MMA Junkie rankings?

UFC 248 this past weekend featured a pair of title fights on opposite ends of each other in terms of entertainment value, but their impacts on this week’s USA TODAY Sports/MMA Junkie rankings is definitely felt.

In the main event, [autotag]Israel Adesanya[/autotag] remained undefeated with a lackluster unanimous decision win over [autotag]Yoel Romero[/autotag] to retain the middleweight title. And in the co-main event, [autotag]Zhang Weili[/autotag] and [autotag]Joanna Jedrzejczyk[/autotag] had an instant classic, with the champion retaining the strawweight title after a narrow split decision.

One of those losing fighters dropped in their respective division’s rankings, while the other stayed put.

Hear from rankings chair “Gorgeous” George and “Goze” of MMA Junkie Radio as they discuss this and other UFC 248 results with rankings implications in the latest edition of the MMA rankings report.

[lawrence-related id=498464,498708,498115]

[vertical-gallery id=497846]

USA TODAY Sports/MMA Junkie rankings, March 10: Israel Adesanya keeps climbing

Israel Adesanya’s win over Yoel Romero won’t go down as his most memorable, but it was still enough to continue his climb through the pound-for-pound rankings.

It’s true: [autotag]Israel Adesanya[/autotag]’s unanimous decision victory over Yoel Romero at UFC 248 last Saturday won’t be remembered as the most thrilling main event in UFC history.

But here’s another truth: Every great champion had a fight or two along the way which doesn’t rate among their classics. Anderson Silva is rightfully remembered for his sensational wins over the likes of Chael Sonnen and Vitor Belfort, but his victories over Patrick Cote and Demian Maia are not often found on his highlight reels.

Likewise, Adesanya didn’t put on a show against Romero in his first defense of the middleweight title. He did, however, put on a smart display when presented with an opponent who seemed mainly interested in covering up and not doing much else. Adesanya adjusted to the unorthodox game plan by peppering Romero with leg kicks and thus found a path to victory.

[lawrence-related id=498464,498443,498309]

With that, Adesanya is 8-0 in the UFC in not much more than two years, and we’re willing to bet he returns to the sort of form he showed in victories over Kelvin Gastelum and Robert Whittaker sooner rather than later. So whether you found the Romero fight intriguing or not, he moves up in our men’s pound-for-pound list, taking the No. 6 spot.

No one has claimed a lack of action in the evening’s co-feature bout, as Zhang Weili and Joanna Jedrzejczyk put on one of the greatest fights in UFC history, with Weili eking out a split decision to retain her strawweight belt. As it turns out, though, even with such spectacular performances, neither competitor moves.

In the case of Weili, she stays at No. 4 in women’s P4P, where she’ll likely stay until someone ahead of her falls. As for Jedrzejczyk, would you really drop her after putting on such a fierce showing? She remains at No. 9 on the overall list after her tremendous showing in defeat.

There was plenty more worth pondering at UFC 238. So to find out where you favorite fighter falls in the current USA TODAY Sports/MMA Junkie rankings, click on the drop-down menu at the top of the page.

[vertical-gallery id=497932]

[vertical-gallery id=497846]

Spinning Back Clique: Agree with Dana White? Was UFC 248 main event letdown Yoel Romero’s fault?

So much to discuss coming out of UFC 248, and this week Eric Nicksick of Xtreme Couture joins the show to unpack it all.

Welcome to “Spinning Back Clique,” MMA Junkie’s weekly show that takes a spin through the biggest topics in mixed martial arts. In this week’s episode, “Gorgeous” George and “Goze” are joined by guest Eric Nicksick of Xtreme Couture to unpack the fallout from an eventful – and uneventful – UFC 248 and more.

SHOW RUNDOWN:

  • The UFC 248 headliner between middleweight champion [autotag]Israel Adesanya[/autotag] and [autotag]Yoel Romero[/autotag] was anything but the war we all expected, with Adesanya winning a bizarre snooze-fest by unanimous decision to retain his title. Afterward, UFC president Dana White placed all of the blame on Romero, who, at 42, received this title shot despite a two-fight losing streak. The way White sees it, it was on him to go all out and win the title. Do we agree?
  • On the complete opposite spectrum of the UFC 248 headliner was the co-main event, an instant classic that saw strawweight champion [autotag]Zhang Weili[/autotag] retain her title by winning a split decision against [autotag]Joanna Jedrzejczyk[/autotag]. What did we learn about both women after such an incredible and brutal title fight?
  • With UFC 248 out of the way, UFC 249 is the next pay-per-view, and you know what that means: [autotag]Khabib Nurmagomedov[/autotag] and [autotag]Tony Ferguson[/autotag] finally will attempt to meet inside the octagon after four failed bookings. Before they do, though, they came face to face at the first UFC 249 news conference in Las Vegas, and it was quite the intense experience. We share our takeaways.
  • [autotag]Sean O’Malley[/autotag] and [autotag]Neil Magny[/autotag] returned to the octagon at UFC 248 after dealing with lengthy ordeals involving the U.S. Anti-Doping Agency, which ultimately resulted in their exoneration. And both men looked good in claiming victories. What do we think is next as they try to get their career back on track?
  • In a story from out of left field, UFC featherweight [autotag]Brian Ortega[/autotag] allegedly attacked Jay Park, rapper and friend of “The Korean Zombie” [autotag]Chan Sung Jung[/autotag], while sitting cageside at UFC 248. The incident, which was caught on video, is so unlike anything we’d expect from Ortega given the character he’s shown through the years. We react to what transpired.

For answers to all of those questions, watch Episode 19 of “Spinning Back Clique” above.

[vertical-gallery id=497932]

Paulo Costa thinks UFC champ Israel Adesanya might find way to avoid fighting him

Paulo Costa doesn’t think UFC middleweight champion Israel Adesanya wants to fight him.

LAS VEGAS – [autotag]Paulo Costa[/autotag] doesn’t think [autotag]Israel Adesanya[/autotag] wants to fight him.

Adesanya retained his middleweight title this past Saturday at UFC 248 with a unanimous decision win over Yoel Romero, and all signs are pointing to a showdown with Costa next.

Costa (13-0 MMA, 5-0 UFC), who’s coming off a win over Romero, was initially meant to challenge Adesanya before a bicep injury forced him to the sidelines.

Now that he’s cleared to return and Adesanya (19-0 MMA, 8-0 UFC) came out relatively unscathed from his lackluster bout with Romero, the two finally can fight.

But Costa said just like Adesanya didn’t want to fight Jon Jones now, he won’t want to fight him.

“He’s not a (respectable) guy. The only problem (fighting) Adesanya is he’s afraid,” Costa said this past Saturday while a guest fighter at UFC 248 in Las Vegas. “I need to remember, he asked Jon Jones to fight against him. Jon Jones said, ‘Yes, let’s do it.’ Dana White agreed. And Adesanya said, ‘I need two years to train.’ So be careful, because he’s afraid. If he gets the win (against Romero), he can avoid this fight against me.”

The two have been going back and forth even before Adesanya captured the middleweight title, making it more than just a fight for Costa.

“Against Adesanya, it’s personal,” Costa said. “It’s not just to fight for the belt or the money or something like this. No, it’s personal.”

[opinary poll=”seeing-israel-adesanya-vs-paulo-costa_mm-i2jfQ7″ customer=”mmajunkie”]

[vertical-gallery id=433393]

UFC 248 medical suspensions: Israel Adesanya needs his feet checked out

Israel Adesanya is one of six fighters in need of further evaluation after UFC 248.

[autotag]Israel Adesanya[/autotag] is one of six fighters in need of further evaluation after UFC 248.

The UFC middleweight champion Adesanya (19-0 MMA, 8-0 UFC), who defended his title in a unanimous decision over Yoel Romero (13-5 MMA, 9-4 UFC) in Saturday’s headliner at T-Mobile Arena in Las Vegas, needs X-rays on both of his feet before obtaining clearance to fight again.

Monday, MMA Junkie acquired a list of medical suspensions from the Nevada Athletic Commission, the body that oversaw the event.

Complete UFC 248 medical suspensions include:

* * * *

Israel Adesanya: Needs X-rays of both feet. If injury discovered, must have doctor’s clearance or no contact until April 9; minimum suspension no contact until April 29.

[autotag]Zhang Weili[/autotag]: Suspended until May 5; no contact until April 22.

[autotag]Joanna Jedrzejczyk[/autotag]: Suspended until May 5; no contact until April 22.

[autotag]Beneil Dariush[/autotag]: Needs MRI on right knee. If injury discovered, must have doctor’s clearance or no contact until April 9.

[autotag]Drakkar Klose[/autotag]: Suspended until April 22; no contact until April 7.

[autotag]Li Jingliang[/autotag]: Suspended until April 22; no contact until April 7.

[autotag]Alex Oliveira[/autotag]: Suspended until April 22; no contact until April 7.

[autotag]Max Griffin[/autotag]: Needs MRI on left shoulder. If injury discovered, must have doctor’s clearance or no contact until Sept. 4; minimum suspension with no contact until April 7.

[autotag]Sean O’Malley[/autotag]: Needs X-ray on left foot. If injury discovered, must have doctor’s clearance or no contact until Sept. 4; minimum suspension with no contact until April 7.

[autotag]Jose Quinonez[/autotag]: Suspended until April 22; no contact until April 7.

[autotag]Mark Madsen[/autotag]: Needs X-ray on left foot. If injury discovered, must have doctor’s clearance or no contact until Sept. 4; minimum suspension with no contact until April 7.

[autotag]Rodolfo Vieira[/autotag]: Suspended until April 22; no contact until April 7.

[autotag]Gerald Meerschaert[/autotag]: Needs X-ray on left ankle. If injury discovered, must have doctor’s clearance or no contact until Sept. 4; minimum suspension with no contact until April 7.

[autotag]Deron Winn[/autotag]: Suspended until April 7; no contact until March 29.

[autotag]Giga Chikadze[/autotag]: Suspended until April 22; no contact until April 7.

[autotag]Danaa Batgerel[/autotag]: Needs X-ray on right foot. If injury discovered, must have doctor’s clearance or no contact until Sept. 4; minimum suspension with no contact until April 7.

[autotag]Guido Cannetti[/autotag]: Suspended until April 22; no contact until April 7.

[vertical-gallery id=497846]

UFC 248 salaries: Israel Adesanya takes home good chunk of total payout

UFC middleweight champion Israel Adesanya was the highest earner at UFC 248, taking home more than double that of the card’s other champ.

Middleweight champion [autotag]Israel Adesanya[/autotag] was the highest earner at UFC 248, taking home more than twice as much disclosed pay as the card’s other defending champ.

Adesanya (19-0 MMA, 8-0 UFC) made $500,000 with no win bonus for his main event title defense against challenger [autotag]Yoel Romero[/autotag] (13-5 MMA, 9-4 UFC) on Saturday at T-Mobile Arena in Las Vegas. Romero made $350,000 in defeat.

The other defending champion on the card, Zhang Weili (21-1 MMA, 5-0 UFC) netted $200,000 for beating [autotag]Joanna Jedrzejczyk[/autotag] (16-4 MMA, 10-4 UFC), who got $106,000 in the memorable title contest.

The total disclosed payroll for the event was $2.086 million.

[lawrence-related id=498140,498112,498098]

Complete disclosed salaries for UFC 248:

  • Israel Adesanya: $500,000 (no win bonus)
    def. Yoel Romero: $350,000
  • Zhang Weili: $200,000 (includes $100,000 win bonus)
    def. Joanna Jedrzejczyk: $106,000
  • [autotag]Beneil Dariush[/autotag]: $140,000 (includes $70,000 win bonus)
    def. [autotag]Drakkar Klose[/autotag]: $40,000
  • [autotag]Neil Magny[/autotag]: $152,000 (includes $76,000 win bonus)
    def. [autotag]Li Jingliang[/autotag]: $64,000
  • [autotag]Alex Oliveira[/autotag]: $128,000 (includes $64,000 win bonus)
    def. [autotag]Max Griffin[/autotag]: $35,000
  • [autotag]Sean O’Malley[/autotag]: $70,000 (includes $35,000 win bonus)
    def. [autotag]Jose Quinonez[/autotag]: $33,000
  • [autotag]Mark Madsen[/autotag]: $66,000 (includes $33,000 win bonus)
    def. [autotag]Austin Hubbard[/autotag]: $12,000
  • [autotag]Rodolfo Vieira[/autotag]: $28,000 (includes $14,000 win bonus)
    def. [autotag]Saparbek Safarov[/autotag]: $22,000
  • [autotag]Gerald Meerschaert[/autotag]: $60,000 (includes $30,000 win bonus)
    def. [autotag]Deron Winn[/autotag]: $12,000
  • [autotag]Giga Chikadze[/autotag]: $24,000 (includes $12,000 win bonus)
    def. [autotag]Jamall Emmers[/autotag]: $10,000
  • [autotag]Danaa Batgerel[/autotag]: $20,000 (includes $10,000 win bonus)
    def. [autotag]Guido Cannetti[/autotag]: $14,000

The figures do not include deductions for items such as insurance, licenses and taxes. Additionally, the figures do not include money paid by sponsors, including the official UFC 248 Promotional Guidelines Compliance pay. They also do not include any other “locker room” or special discretionary bonuses the UFC sometimes pays. They also do not include pay-per-view cuts that some top-level fighters receive.

For example, UFC officials handed out additional $50,000 UFC 248 fight-night bonuses to Dariush and O’Malley for “Performance of the Night,” and Weili and Jedrzejczyk for “Fight of the Night.”

In other words, the above figures are simply base salaries reported to the commission and do not reflect entire compensation packages for the event.

[vertical-gallery id=497932]

Sean Shelby’s Shoes: What’s next for Israel Adesanya, Zhang Weili and UFC 248’s key winning fighters?

See whom champs Israel Adesanya and Zhang Weili should fight next after their title defenses at UFC 248.

(ALSO SEE: Sean Shelby’s Shoes: What’s next for Yoel Romero, Joanna Jedrzejczyk after UFC 248 losses?)

After every event, fans wonder whom the winners will be matched up with next.

With another night of UFC action in the rearview mirror, it’s time to look forward, put on a pair of Sean Shelby and Mick Maynard’s shoes, and play UFC matchmaker for UFC 248’s key winning fighters.

Those include [autotag]Israel Adesanya[/autotag] (19-0 MMA, 8-0 UFC), who defeated Yoel Romero (13-5 MMA, 9-4 UFC) by unanimous decision to defend his middleweight belt in the main event at T-Mobile Arena in Las Vegas, [autotag]Zhang Weili[/autotag] (21-1 MMA, 5-0 UFC), who edged Joanna Jedrzejczyk (16-4 MMA, 10-4 UFC) by split decision to retain the strawweight belt in the co-headliner, as well as [autotag]Beneil Dariush[/autotag] (18-4-1 MMA, 12-4-1 UFC), [autotag]Neil Magny[/autotag] (22-7 MMA, 15-6 UFC) and [autotag]Sean O’Malley[/autotag] (11-0 MMA, 3-0 UFC).

* * * *

Sean O’Malley

Brian Kelleher

Should fight: [autotag]Brian Kelleher[/autotag]
Why they should fight: O’Malley returned to the octagon in resounding fashion after two years away and showed that he’s still a top bantamweight prospect by putting away Jose Quinonez with an impressive – and fast – first-round finish.

Now undefeated, it’s time for “Suga” to take a step up in competition and see if the talent really matches the hype. He’s able to show out against fighters who aren’t in his league, but what about against someone who should be far more competitive against him?

Sure, Kelleher (20-10 MMA, 4-3 UFC) hasn’t proven himself to be a worldbeater, but he has more experience than O’Malley, has fought better opponents and has better wins. He called for the fight after O’Malley’s win, and the UFC should give it to him.

[vertical-gallery id=497708]

Neil Magny

Michael Chiesa

Should fight: [autotag]Michael Chiesa[/autotag]
Why they should fight: After a 16-month layoff, Magny returned in fine form and picked up a solid unanimous decision win against Li Jingliang, who has been doing some good things in the welterweight division in recent years.

Immediately after the fight, Magny had a name ready to go for who he wanted next. That name was Chiesa, who is coming off a unanimous decision win over former champ Rafael dos Anjos at UFC on ESPN+ 25 in January that moved him to 3-0 as a welterweight.

Chiesa promptly took to social media and accepted to the callout, and with both sides invested, this one makes itself.

[vertical-gallery id=497764]

Beneil Dariush

Gregor Gillespie

Should fight: [autotag]Gregor Gillespie[/autotag]
Why they should fight: Dariush extended his winning streak to four fights with one of the best knockouts so far this year. He stopped Drakkar Klose with an absurd punch in the second round of their lightweight matchup, and now it seems Dariush is on the cusp of breaking back into the top 15 of the weight class.

Dariush has been in and out of the rankings over the years, but with three consecutive stoppage wins, he hasn’t seen this type of momentum before. It puts him in position to get a name opponent at 155 pounds, and Gillespie (13-1 MMA, 6-1 UFC) is available.

Gillespie is coming off a heinous knockout loss to Kevin Lee at UFC 244 in November, but from all indications is looking to book his next fight sometime in the coming months. Dariush said he’ll be ready to get back to work after his upcoming honeymoon, and it certainly has the ingredients for a solid fight.

[vertical-gallery id=497818]

Zhang Weili

Rose Namajunas

Should fight: [autotag]Rose Namajunas[/autotag] or [autotag]Joanna Jedrzejczyk[/autotag]
Why they should fight: Watch the video above to see why Weili should fight Rose Namajunas (if she wins at UFC 249) or rematch Jedrzejczyk next for her second title defense.

[vertical-gallery id=497846]

Israel Adesanya

Paulo Costa

Should fight: [autotag]Paulo Costa[/autotag]
Why they should fight: Watch the video above to see why Adesanya should fight Costa (12-0 MMA, 5-0 UFC) next for his second title defense.

[vertical-gallery id=497932]