Why did the Commanders lose to the Giants Sunday?

We look deeper into why the Commanders lost to the Giants in Week 15.

The quick knee-jerk reaction is to blame the officials, but the Commanders offense deserves most of the blame for the Commanders discouraging loss to the Giants in Week 15.

Yes, the defense gave up a 97-yard, 18-play scoring drive. But are you aware the other Giants possessions produced drives of 3, 19, -1, 17, 43 (field goal), 5, 33, 54 (field goal) and -2 yards (end of game)?

Consequently, the Commanders defense only yielded one touchdown and two field goals to the Giants offense for 13 points. How many NFL games do you think you should win if your defense and special teams only yields 13 points? 95 percent? 98 percent? Seriously.

On the other hand, the Commanders offense gave up a strip-sack touchdown when Taylor Heinicke was blindsided by Kayvon Thibodeaux and Thibodeaux returned the fumble one yard for a touchdown.

The Commanders offense produced a mere 12 points. In today’s NFL, isn’t this inexcusable? Looking at the scores of Week 15 games, only the Browns won with as few as 13 points and the Chargers won, scoring 17. Every other winner scored 20 or more, with six winners this week scoring 30 or more points.

The Commanders moved the ball several possessions, rushing for 159 yards on 26 carries and passing for 249 yards on 17 completions.  However, the Commanders yielded three quarterback sacks, fumbled on four offensive plays, losing two of them, and had a costly delay of game in the first half. After moving the ball, the Commanders repeatedly could not convert third downs, finishing the night 1-10.

One of 10 on third downs? Yes, the Commanders moved the ball several times, but repeatedly could not perform on third downs, whether it was protections, decision-making by the quarterback, pulling the trigger by the quarterback, receivers not effectively running routes, or catching third-down passes.

How many NFL games does a team win when they only convert third downs ten percent of the time?

[mm-video type=playlist id=01eqbykgy681k112p8 player_id=01eqbvhghtkmz2182d image=]

The Commanders were not ready to win a big game

Regardless of the ending, with everything going in their favor ahead of Week 15, the Commanders didn’t look ready for the big stage.

The Washington Commanders were simply not ready for the big stage.

The Commanders were coming off of a bye week. They were given plenty of time off away from the facility; they had plenty of physical rest.

They should have been sharp mentally; they should have been recovered physically. But they were not.

I love Terry McLaurin, but he is now paid to be a star, a league leader in performance. He is in his fourth NFL season. Why didn’t Terry get himself up on that line on Brian Robinson’s one-yard touchdown run? He has to own it and be a leader in the sense of taking accountability. (I’m writing this immediately following the game).

The offensive line exhibited massive protection issues against the same Giants team two weeks ago. Why wasn’t there more help applied to the offensive tackles tonight? Did coaches not use the bye week to prepare for this? Frankly, the coaching scheme and the offensive tackles’ execution made the Giants defensive ends look like Dexter Manley and Charles Mann out there Sunday night.

Early, the Commanders, after moving into Giants territory, suddenly Taylor Heinicke rushed an easy swing pass to Antonio Gibson that should have gained yardage. Then Heinicke (or the coaches) were not efficient or prepared, and the Commanders earned a delay of game penalty.

Why was the execution of each Curtis Samuel run so ineffective tonight? It was clearly part of the game plan to use him on quick-hitting runs, but every single Samuel run (five total) was ineffective, gaining a total of one yard.

The Commanders disappointed; it’s very discouraging. Why weren’t the Commanders ready for the big stage?

[mm-video type=playlist id=01eqbykgy681k112p8 player_id=01eqbvhghtkmz2182d image=]

Did the NFL scam the Commanders?

The NFL didn’t do the Commanders any favors by moving the Week 15 rematch to Sunday night. Why not Saturday night?

The NFL schedule-makers like their flexibility to rearrange the schedule in the later weeks of the season.

You probably are aware the Commanders’ Week 15 game against the Giants has been moved to the NBC Sunday Night Football game of the week at the 8 p.m. ET time slot. The game was previously scheduled for Sunday at 1 p.m.

The Commanders, of course, could use the prime time exposure, yet seeing the Commanders are already scheduled to travel in Week 16 to San Francisco for a Saturday game makes this an even tougher task for the Commanders.

With a Sunday night Week 15 game kicking off at 8:20 p.m., the game would not end until roughly 11:30 p.m. This means Commanders players will not be getting to their homes from Landover until at least 3 to 4 a.m., Monday.

What’s more, when one looks at the 49ers’ Week 15 schedule, there is absolutely no way the league office overlooked the obvious fact that the 49ers will be playing on Thursday in Week 15. Consequently, the 49ers will have three more days of prep time and rest for a game where they are also the home team. In addition, the visiting team is playing the Sunday night game and will travel three time zones. Way to go, NFL.

If the league office wanted to flex the Commanders and Giants Week 15 game bad enough, why didn’t they flex it to Saturday night? They are playing games that Saturday. They certainly could have, as they flexed Miami at Buffalo to Saturday night.

A December game in Buffalo, not while the sun is shining in the afternoon, but in much colder temperatures in the dark of night? Even more, when are the Bills playing a team from south Florida? Come on, NFL. How hard are you trying here?

Each and every season there are such examples of the NFL simply not caring enough about scheduling integrity.  We have written about this before here at Commanders Wire.

Why doesn’t the NFL care enough to make better efforts at a level playing field in scheduling?