Did Georges St-Pierre fight often enough to merit his No. 4 spot on our list? The MMA Junkie crew debates.
Deciding on the top 10 fighters over an entire decade is an invitation for an open-ended debate.
Throw in a mandate from MMA Junkie managing editor Simon Samano that each person on the staff was free to set their own criteria on what qualifies as worthy of consideration for the decade’s best list, and a staff that pulls from a wide variety of ages stationed all around the globe, and you have plenty of leeway for a diverse variety of selections.
The end result was a vibrant list, one that demands more conversation. So we gathered MMA Junkie’s Las Vegas crew — MMA Junkie Radio personalities “Gorgeous” George and “Goze,” fight analyst Dan Tom, and lead reporter John Morgan — to debate the results of our top 10 fighters of the 2010s in a roundtable format.
[lawrence-related id=475128,474694,474172]
In this segment, the guys talk about [autotag]Georges St-Pierre.[/autotag] While he’s undeniably one of the greatest fighters of all time, he competed just seven times in the decade and only once since 2013. On the other hand, that one fight saw him win a second division title, when he went up to middleweight and defeated then-champion Michael Bisping at UFC 217. Was that enough to merit his No. 4 position?
Watch the video above to hear the gang talk about GSP. And to watch the full roundtable, check out the video below.
The past decade has proven incredibly intriguing for the sport of mixed martial arts, and these moments explain why.
The past decade has proven incredibly intriguing for the sport of mixed martial arts.
While organizations continue to come and go across the global scene, the UFC remains the dominant brand, but the changes even the sport’s leading promotion has undergone over the 10-year span stand testament to how much the landscape continues to evolve.
In 2011, the UFC was still partnered with Spike TV for its U.S. broadcast deal, and prelim broadcasts bounced around between the likes of Facebook, Ion Television and UFC.com – if they aired at all.
The entirety of the UFC’s next broadcast deal, which saw the promotion move to network television courtesy of FOX, ran its course during the decade. And as the 10-year span closed, the UFC signed on with ESPN, one of the most recognized brands in sports and a leading digital distributor in the space.
And that’s without even speaking of what happened in the cage.
[lawrence-related id=475134,475128]
The decade started with the UFC hosting fights in five different weight classes. Ten years later, that number has grown to 12. Promotional stalwarts such as [autotag]Anderson Silva[/autotag] and [autotag]Georges St-Pierre[/autotag] gave way to names like [autotag]Conor McGregor[/autotag] and [autotag]Jon Jones[/autotag]. Women stepped into the octagon for the first time, and new markets around the globe were visited.
We could probably list 20 of the biggest moments from each year along the way, but you don’t have time for that, so here’s a sampling of 20 defining moments from 2010 through 2019.
Without further ado …
****
July 3, 2010: Brock Lesnar defeats Shane Carwin at UFC 116
Whether it’s boxing or MMA, there’s just something special about a heavyweight title fight. In MMA, you don’t get much heavier than [autotag]Brock Lesnar[/autotag] and Shane Carwin. Say what you will about the WWE star’s skills as a martial artist, the man moves the needle, and this was the absolute peak of his popularity, with Las Vegas’ MGM Grand Garden Arena absolutely buzzing for this battle of behemoths.
After a tense opening minute, Carwin hurt Lesnar and sent him toppling to the canvas, seemingly destined to wrap the belt around his waist. But Lesnar was able to stay just busy enough for referee Josh Rosenthal, somehow lasting until the bell. Carwin was clearly gassed, and Lesnar capitalized on it in the second, taking his opponent to the floor and cinching in an arm-triangle choke, scoring the submission win and adding to his legend – though it would be the last time he ever proved victorious in the octagon.
Aug. 7, 2010: Anderson Silva defeats Chael Sonnen at UFC 117
Every great fighter needs a rival to be pushed to the limit, and for longtime UFC middleweight champion and future Hall of Famer Anderson Silva, that man was very clearly [autotag]Chael Sonnen[/autotag], who in just four UFC appearances – and some 13 years into his professional career – went from relative journeyman to absolute star through an incredible ability to promote fights through his quick with and sharp tongue. Sure, it was his wrestling that helped propel him to victories in the cage, but it was his mouth that made him a star.
Sonnen went hard on Silva, bordering, at times, on a line of indecency, as he helped first to book the fight, then to promote it. Still, few thought he had a real chance to unseat the reigning pound-for-pound great. Then the unthinkable happened: Sonnen’s aggression saw him walk forward and take Silva down, time after time for four-and-a-half rounds. Then the really unthinkable happened, and Silva pulled off one of the most miraculous comebacks in UFC history with a fifth-round triangle armbar. The fight was one of the biggest of the year and made stars of both men.
Oct. 28, 2010: Dana White announces UFC-WEC merger
Old school fans will tell you all about the fantastic fights that took place on the blue canvas of the WEC, both before and after the promotion was purchased by the UFC’s parent company in December 2006. But running a secondary MMA brand proved to be only so effective. The real value of the company came when UFC president Dana White announced the brands would be merged, adding both the featherweight and bantamweight divisions to the UFC ranks.
Of course, this would later open the door to the addition of flyweights, as well. But the initial run saw [autotag]Jose Aldo[/autotag] crowned the UFC’s first featherweight champion, while [autotag]Dominick Cruz[/autotag] earned the first UFC bantamweight belt. Both remain marketable commodities to this day. So do names like [autotag]Joseph Benavidez[/autotag], [autotag]Donald Cerrone[/autotag], [autotag]Urijah Faber[/autotag], Chan Sung Jung, Ricardo Lamas, Anthony Pettis, Dustin Poirier, and Cub Swanson, who all came over as part of a massive talent migration to the UFC.
Feb. 5, 2011: Anderson Silva defeats Vitor Belfort at UFC 126
It’s a highlight that is still played ad nauseam, and it isn’t likely to disappear anytime soon. Anderson Silva’s front-kick-to-the-face knockout of [autotag]Vitor Belfort[/autotag] was one of the most stunning finishes in UFC history, and it had lasting ramifications. First, while front kicks had largely been used as pushing strikes and range setters, Silva showed what an effective concussive blow it could be. But the impact on the global MMA scene was massive as well.
This bout is largely recognized as the moment MMA gained modern mainstream notoriety in Brazil, one of the UFC’s biggest markets in terms of financial revenue, as well as talent creation. Consider this: Prior to this fight, the UFC had held one event in Brazil, a 1998 card that marked the organization’s only visit to South America until the octagon returned to Brazil six months after UFC 126. In the time since Silva’s iconic KO, Brazil has hosted 35 UFC cards, with the promotion also visiting Argentina, Chile and Uruguay.
March 12, 2011: UFC purchases Strikeforce
While the UFC has been the dominant name in MMA since the promotion’s launch in 1993, Strikeforce had acquired an impressive amount of talent despite operating on a much tighter budget. As the UFC looked to ramp up the number of events it was producing for prospective TV partners, the organization needed as many marketable stars as it could find, and the promotion’s parent company, Zuffa, made a major play.
Buying Strikeforce, which was shuttered less than two years later, gave the UFC access to a stunning number of athletes, including future UFC champions such as [autotag]Daniel Cormier[/autotag] and [autotag]Luke Rockhold[/autotag]. It also shut down the company’s chief rival at the time.
How did we reach our overall list, and did we get it right?
In pitching the MMA Junkie staff on coming up with a composite ranking of the top 10 fighters of the 2010s, I had people asking me about the criteria. My answer was simple: There is no criteria. Whatever you think it means to be among the 10 greatest fighters of the last decade, that’s the criteria.
To me, it’s better this way. I could’ve emphasized in-cage results, in which case No. 1 ends up being [autotag]Khabib Nurmagomedov[/autotag] without question. Same for emphasizing impact on the sport: [autotag]Conor McGregor[/autotag] comes out on top easily. But what fun would that have been? There’s so much more to consider when trying to pick the top 10 fighters of the last 10 years among a pool of talent that never has been better.
The beauty of our list is that all 14 MMA Junkie staff members, who’ve spent so many years covering the sport, submitted individual top 10 lists. No discussion, no debate, no one person’s bias determined our final rankings. We all had a say in this. From there, it was a matter of mathematics – add up points for each fighter ranked and divide by 14 to determine the final rankings.
For reaction to our top 10, watch the roundtable discussion video above with MMA Junkie’s John Morgan and Dan Tom, and MMA Junkie Radio’s “Gorgeous” George and “Goze.”
Below is a ranking of all 26 fighters included, as well as notes about our list.
26 different fighters were included in at least one staff member’s top 10
8 different fighters were included in only one ranking
Individual No. 1 rankings: Jon Jones (7), Demetrious Johnson (3), Georges St-Pierre (2), Daniel Cormier (1), Ronda Rousey (1)
Cormier was the only fighter to be included in each of the 14 rankings.
Jones and Conor McGregor each were excluded from one staff member’s list.
Of 8 fighters included in only one ranking, Cain Velasquez was highest (No. 3); Eddie Alvarez was lowest (No. 10).
INDIVIDUAL RANKINGS
Mike Bohn, senior reporter
1. Jon Jones
2. Georges St-Pierre
3. Jose Aldo
4. Demetrious Johnson
5. Anderson Silva
6. Conor McGregor
7. Max Holloway
8. Tony Ferguson
9. Khabib Nurmagomedov
10. Daniel Cormier
Dave Doyle, senior editor
1. Demetrious Johnson
2. Daniel Cormier
3, Jon Jones
4. Anderson Silva
5. Georges St-Pierre
6. Cris Cyborg
7. Jose Aldo
8. Khabib Nurmagomedov
9. Conor McGregor
10. Eddie Alvarez
Matt Erickson, assistant managing editor
1. Daniel Cormier
2. Demetrious Johnson
3. Amanda Nunes
4. Conor McGregor
5. Max Holloway
6. Patricio Freire
7. Ronda Rousey
8. Georges St-Pierre
9. Ryan Bader
10. Jose Aldo
Brian Garcia, MMA Junkie Radio host
1. Georges St-Pierre
2. Jon Jones
3. Daniel Cormier
4. Henry Cejudo
5. Demetrious Johnson
6. Khabib Nurmagomedov
7. Stipe Miocic
8. Amanda Nunes
9. Max Holloway
10. Ryan Bader
George Garcia, MMA Junkie Radio host
1. Jon Jones
2. Georges St-Pierre
3. Daniel Cormier
4. Khabib Nurmagomedov
5. Demetrious Johnson
6. Amanda Nunes
7. Cris Cyborg
8. Stipe Miocic
9. Conor McGregor
10. Henry Cejudo
Farah Hannoun, reporter
1. Jon Jones
2. Ronda Rousey
3. Conor McGregor
4. Demetrious Johnson
5. Khabib Nurmagomedov
6. Daniel Cormier
7. Amanda Nunes
8. Max Holloway
9. Stipe Miocic
10. Henry Cejudo
Ken Hathaway, senior video editor
1. Jon Jones
2. Amanda Nunes
3. Ronda Rousey
4. Max Holloway
5. Conor McGregor
6. Daniel Cormier
7. Georges St-Pierre
8. Anderson Silva
9. Khabib Nurmagomedov
10. Cris Cyborg
Simon Head, reporter
1. Demetrious Johnson
2. Daniel Cormier
3. Jon Jones
4. Amanda Nunes
5. Donald Cerrone
6. Georges St-Pierre
7. Conor McGregor
8. Douglas Lima
9. Cris Cyborg
10. Michael Bisping
Nolan King, reporter
1. Jon Jones
2. Daniel Cormier
3. Amanda Nunes
4. Demetrious Johnson
5. Max Holloway
6. Stipe Miocic
7. Georges St. Pierre
8. Jose Aldo
9. Conor McGregor
10. Khabib Nurmagomedov
John Morgan, lead staff reporter
1. Jon Jones
2. Conor McGregor
3. Ronda Rousey
4. Georges St-Pierre
5. Daniel Cormier
6. Demetrious Johnson
7. Amanda Nunes
8. Jose Aldo
9. Michael Bisping
10. Donald Cerrone
Simon Samano, managing editor
1. Demetrious Johnson
2. Georges St-Pierre
3. Jon Jones
4. Daniel Cormier
5. Khabib Nurmagomedov
6. Amanda Nunes
7. Tony Ferguson
8. Conor McGregor
9. Ronda Rousey
10. Max Holloway
Danny Segura, reporter
1. Ronda Rousey
2. Jon Jones
3. Cain Velasquez
4. Georges St-Pierre
5. Demetrious Johnson
6. Jose Aldo
7. Cris Cyborg
8. Conor McGregor
9. Khabib Nurmagomedov
10. Daniel Cormier
Abbey Subhan, video editor
1. Georges St-Pierre
2. Conor McGregor
3. Jon Jones
4. Daniel Cormier
5. Amanda Nunes
6. Joanna Jedrzejczyk
7. Frankie Edgar
8. Anderson Silva
9. Carlos Condit
10. Ronda Rousey
Dan Tom, fight analyst
1. Jon Jones
2. Jose Aldo
3. Khabib Nurmagomedov
4. Dominick Cruz
5. Demetrious Johnson
6. Conor McGregor
7. Ronda Rousey
8. Daniel Cormier
9. Max Holloway
10. Tony Ferguson
Conor McGregor, Ronda Rousey and Jon Jones are among those selected by MMA Junkie as the greatest fighters of the decade.
The 2010s, arguably the most important decade in the history of mixed martial arts, is coming to a close. One reason why the years 2010 to 2019 have been so pivotal to the sport is the sheer talent that exists across all divisions – men and women, from flyweight (which didn’t even exist until February 2012) to heavyweight. Simply put, the number of great fighters to grace cages and rings across the world never has been higher.
Here at MMA Junkie, we’ve put together a composite ranking of the top 10 fighters of the past decade. All 14 staff members submitted personal top-10 lists to create our overall list. Rest assured: We took this seriously.
Without further ado, our complete list:
10. Max Holloway
[jwplayer OiSwEOOD-RbnemIYZ]
Decade resume
Record: 21-5
UFC featherweight champion: June 3, 2017-Dec. 14, 2019
13-fight winning streak
Key victories over Anthony Pettis, Jose Aldo (twice), Brian Ortega, Frankie Edgar
Georges St-Pierre’s achievements in the 2010s were remarkable and set his status to being arguably the greatest of all time.
The 2010s, arguably the most important decade in the history of mixed martial arts, is coming to a close. One reason why the past 10 years have been so pivotal to the sport is the sheer talent that exists across all divisions – men and women, from flyweight (which didn’t even exist until February 2012) to heavyweight. Simply put, the number of great fighters to grace cages and rings across the world never has been higher.
Here at MMA Junkie, we’ve put together a staff-wide, composite ranking of the top 10 fighters of the past decade, which we’ll reveal Monday-Friday until Dec. 27. Today, we reflect on No. 4: Georges St-Pierre.
****
[autotag]Georges St-Pierre[/autotag] entered the decade already a superstar, but it was what he did in the last 10 years that pushed his status to greatest of all time.
The longtime welterweight king entered 2010 with a bang. St-Pierre (26-2 MMA, 20-2 UFC) already was champion in one of the toughest weight classes in the UFC. He was riding a six-fight winning streak and was 12-1 in his past 13 bouts. The list of opponents who fell short to him prior to 2010 was more than impressive. St-Pierre topped the likes of Jason Miller, Frank Trigg, Sean Sherk, B.J. Penn (twice), Matt Hughes (twice), Matt Serra and Jon Fitch.
In his last fight before entering 2010, St-Pierre established himself as one of the biggest names in the sport. The Canadian defended his title yet again in the biggest pay-per-view event at that time, UFC 100, which was headlined by a gigantic rematch between Brock Lesnar and Frank Mir. St-Pierre defeated the very dangerous Thiago Alves in a dominant decision.
It’s impossible to deny St-Pierre was more than established before this last decade, but the man was far from done.
In the last 10 years, St-Pierre took seven trips to the octagon and each time he left with a victory, a belt wrapped around his waist, and always a little something extra for the record books.
In 2010, St-Pierre answered the call twice and overcame polar-opposite challenges. He beat knockout artist Dan Hardy and decorated wrestler Josh Koscheck to prove again his uniquely well-rounded game.
The following year, St-Pierre only fought once, but that title fight had the magnitude of several pay-per-views combined.
Against Jake Shields, who was on a 15-fight winning streak and was the Strikeforce middleweight champion prior to vacating the belt and signing with the UFC, St-Pierre defended his belt in the headlining act of UFC 129.
The event stands today as the biggest UFC event in North America. St-Pierre picked up a dominant decision win in front of a home crowd of 55,000 Canadians. It was a massive and historic event that not only shined light on the magnitude of St-Pierre’s stardom, but also the growth of the sport.
But a true champion is not only tested inside the cage. He’s also put on trial outside of it. Following the monumental win over Shields, St-Pierre was forced to face challenges that would end most athletes’ careers.
St-Pierre was scheduled to defend his title against Carlos Condit (but originally against Nick Diaz – it’s a long story) at UFC 137 in 2011, but was forced to withdraw due to knee injury. He then tried to come back in a bout against Diaz in early 2012 at UFC 143, but a torn ACL had the champion back on the sidelines. It was a shocking discovery to a fanbase that had many questioning the future of the champion.
Instead, Condit ended up fighting and defeating Diaz in the main event of UFC 143 to become the UFC interim welterweight champion and set himself as the clear No. 1 contender in the division upon St-Pierre’s return.
With no tuneup fight following rehab for his torn ACL, St-Pierre came back to his home city of Montreal in late 2012 to take on Condit in an effort to unify the welterweight titles. The story within the 25-minute war that earned a “Fight of the Night” bonus that night couldn’t have been a clearer reflection of St-Pierre’s career comeback at the time.
Much like the rest of his career as champion, St-Pierre showed dominance through his world-class wrestling and completely controlled Condit early on in the fight. But in Round 3, things took an unexpected turn. Condit connected clean with left head kick that sent St-Pierre wobbling to the canvas. Hurt, but with the heart of a champion, St-Pierre fought back to avoid getting finished and won the last two rounds. It was a huge test for his career.
From there, St-Pierre defended his belt two more times against Nick Diaz in a grudge match and Johny Hendricks, who at the time had the MMA world enchanted with his knockout power. After his decision victory over Hendricks, which many found to be controversial, St-Pierre decided to vacate his belt and take a break from the sport.
He came back four years later and won another UFC belt in a new weight class. At UFC 217, St-Pierre choked out middleweight champion Michael Bisping to join the select few who have held UFC titles in two different weight classes. It was a colossal accomplishment that set him as an all-time great.
St-Pierre hasn’t fought since.
What’s remarkable about St-Pierre’s achievements this past decade is that they were really done in just five years, given his time away from the sport due to injury and the four-year break he took from MMA. Yet, despite being absent for a good chunk of the decade, the longtime welterweight king remains one of the biggest names in combat sports and one of the most revered fighters today.
It’s impossible to talk about the 2010s without mentioning Georges “Rush” St-Pierre, who is No. 4 on MMA Junkie’s Fighters of the Decade list.