It wasn’t Texas’ night. Despite turning in one of the guttiest performances of the year, the Ohio State Buckeyes were just too much for the Longhorns in the Cotton Bowl college football semifinal. Ohio State seemed in control all night, but Texas hung around and had the game tied in the 4th quarter. It wasn’t enough.
There are a lot of reasons Texas lost. QB Quinn Ewers was inconsistent … again. The running game was poor … again. The defense, who kept Texas in the game, broke down at critical moments. The Horns simply made too many mistakes to win against an elite team like OSU.
2024 will be remembered as a season if missed chances. Texas could have won the SEC in its first season. But it didn’t. Texas could have won this game and advanced to a national title game they would’ve been favored in. But they didn’t.
The “what ifs” will haunt this team and Longhorns fans for years to come.
Ohio State has gotten off to fast starts in the postseason where the Buckeyes have borderline put the game away in the first quarter. It looked to be happening again. OSU stopped the Longhorns’ first drive then took the ball 64-yards on 10 plays for the first TD of the game. It seems odd, but the game was teetering on a blowout then.
But while the Texas offense punted on four straight drives, the UT defense stood tall. The Texas defense forced four punts by the OSU offense and gave the Horns offense a chance to finally get something going.
As good as Quinn Ewers has been at Texas, he’s had a lot of bad plays in big games. Sometimes he seems brilliant. Other times he seems lost. His performance in the Cotton Bowl is a microcosm of his career.
He made good reads on the two touchdown drives and his flip pass on 3rd and 10 on the second touchdown drive was amazing improvisation. But that’s mixed with plays like the scoop and score on 4th and goal. Or tipped passes. Or overthrows. Or seeing ghosts with borderline self-sacks in the first quarter.
Quinn has done good things at Texas. But he’s not a champion. Not in college at least. Maybe he’ll fair better in the NFL.
It is weird to criticize the defense that single-handily kept Texas in the game for most of the first half. But the touchdown by Ohio State late in the first quarter simply can not happen. Ever.
Texas’ offense fought the entire first half to put points on the board. The finally did on a Ewers to Jaydon Blue TD pass. But the first play from scrimmage for the Buckeyes, with just :13 seconds on the clock, Texas allowed a swing pass from Will Howard to TreVeyon Henderson to go 75-yards to the house.
You can not allow that to happen and expect to win championships.
The running attach was marginally better against the Buckeyes than it was against Arizona State in the Peach Bowl or Georgia in the SEC Championship Game. But it wasn’t near good enough to help the Longhorns offense sustain drives in the Cotton Bowl. UT had just 58 yards rushing on 29 carries. The total was hurt by a minus-18 yards rushing by Ewers due to sacks. But even 76 yards rushing isn’t enough.
UT had a couple big runs, but whether it’s play calling or lack of execution, it is something Texas must address in the offseason.
When Texas lost CJ Baxter and Christian Clark for the season in fall camp, there was a fear it could ruin UT’s season. In the end, it may have. Both players should be good to go in 2025, thankfully.
Whatever Quinn Ewers does next season, it seems like a certainty that he won’t be back at Texas. The Longhorns will turn to super recruit Arch Manning in 2025 and it will be fun to see what he brings to the table when he’s the full time starter.
Manning will probably be pretty green at first and make his share of mistakes. But he also has the athleticism and arm strength to make up for it. Some thing Ewers didn’t always possess.
Arch’s first game? At Ohio State in the Horseshoe next August.