Auburn or Gus Malzahn? The Athletic answers who makes playoff first

Auburn or Gus Malzahn: Who will make the College Football Playoff first?

Since its inception in 2014, Auburn has yet to make the College Football Playoff. The Tigers’ closest call came in 2017 when a victory in the SEC Championship Game would have put them in the final four.

After eight seasons under Gus Malzahn, the Tigers are now led by Bryan Harsin while Malzahn landed a job at UCF, a perennial Group of Five power.

So, with that in mind, someone named Brian S. (and no, it wasn’t me) wrote into The Athletic’s ($) mailbag to ask who makes the playoff first between the Tigers and their old coach. Steward Mandel answered the question.

Fascinating question. Tough one to answer, though, given we don’t know when it’s going to start. Will Malzahn still be at UCF in 2026? Will Bryan Harsin still be at Auburn? Who the heck knows?

The safe bet, though, is Auburn, just because the Tigers are going to have more margin for error. For UCF to make the Playoff, it’s probably going to have to both win the AAC and, most years, be ranked higher than any of the other Group of 5 champions. Whereas Auburn could go 9-3, finish third in the SEC West and, depending on what that 9-3 looks like, make the CFP as an at-large team.

Over the past 40 years, Auburn has not gone more than four years without at least one nine-win season. The Tigers have been highly erratic and yet highly predictable. Whereas I can’t begin to predict what UCF’s trajectory will be under Malzahn.

Who knows, maybe a matchup between Auburn and a Malzahn-led UCF is in the future for the playoffs. That would be some storyline.

‘Auburn is like a safe haven’: Takeo Spikes on influx of Georgia talent to the Plains

Takeo Spikes is just one of many Auburn stars to come from the state of Georgia.

[mm-video type=video id=01f79y5cw1qm2a4n3grb playlist_id=none player_id=none image=https://images2.minutemediacdn.com/image/upload/video/thumbnail/mmplus/01f79y5cw1qm2a4n3grb/01f79y5cw1qm2a4n3grb-05cc6588379684c45b3dbeaa8205d4af.jpg]

[Editor’s note: This article is part of the series “Talking with Takeo,” in which Auburn Wire looks back at Tigers legend Takeo Spikes’ early life, playing under Friday night lights, his recruitment, years at Auburn, favorite college moments, the Bryan Harsin hire, being passed on by the Falcons, his NFL career and much more. Come back each Wednesday for another installment. The series is part of a partnership between our colleagues at Campus Lore and the NFLPA.]

For as long as anyone can remember, Auburn has gone into the state of Georgia and landed some of the Peach State’s biggest players.

The list is quite astonishing. Derrick Brown, Tray Blackmon, Montravius Adams, Carl Lawson, Owen Pappoe. That’s half of Auburn’s highest-ranked signees of all time. They all hail from Georgia.

So too, does Takeo Spikes, who left Sandersville, Georgia, for the Plains in 1995 after finding the environment welcoming.

“Auburn is like a safe haven,” Spikes told Auburn Wire. “And speaking from my experience, the campus, the little town of Auburn, the school makes up the town. There’s so many people there who actually care.”

Auburn linebacker Takeo Spikes makes a tackle during the 1997 Florida game. (USA TODAY Sports)

Although Auburn isn’t a large city, the negative recruitment that Spikes heard of “you’re in the middle of nowhere” made no sense to him.

“Even though you come from different places, some guys come from bigger cities. Some guys come from smaller cities. They found a way to be able to say, ‘Look,’ other people talk about, ‘if you come here, there’s nothing to do.’

Toomer’s Corner is alive with activity after No. 6 Auburn beat No. 1 Alabama, 26-14, at Jordan-Hare Stadium on Nov. 25, 2017. (Adam Hagy-USA TODAY Sports)

“What else are you going to be doing if you go to any other school? That was their (Auburn coaches) way of neutralizing that.”

Nothing to do? Well, we are quite certain that the student-athletes arriving from all over can find myriad activities, but as Spikes points out, the life of a student-athlete doesn’t include much free time.

Instead, Spikes tells potential recruits that once you arrive in Auburn, the whole town rallies around you.

“One thing that we can promise you is, the whole community will get behind you in your academics and the entire community will get behind you in football and also on a personal level with just life,” he said.

“So I think not only did they talk that, but they made you feel that as you were having the conversation. So that’s what made it so easy to be able to go there.”

The trip from some parts of Georgia to Auburn can be extremely short, including in talent-rich Columbus. The state capital, Atlanta, is just an hour and a half up I-85. The close proximity leads to a large portion of the Auburn student body coming from Georgia and one of the most vicious rivalries in college football between the Tigers and Georgia Bulldogs.

Auburn defensive lineman Maurice Swain Jr. tackles Georgia Bulldogs running back Sony Michel during the second half at Sanford Stadium on Nov. 12, 2016. (Dale Zanine-USA TODAY Sports)

So close, in fact, that Spikes has an idea for consideration.

“So technically, I know it’s in Alabama, but we really can be claiming it could be the west side of Georgia.”

We aren’t sure how Auburn fans would feel about switching states, but as long as the talent keeps arriving on the Plains, we’ll continue to enjoy watching some of Georgia’s heroes spurn the red and black for orange and navy blue.

Looking for optimism, Auburn fans? 247Sports gives one reason to believe

The combination of running back Tank Bigsby and the arrival of new head coach Bryan Harsin is one reason for Auburn fans to be optimistic.

Auburn fans’ expectations might be a little down heading into the first season of the Bryan Harsin era in 2021. I mean, when was the last time that the majority would pick eight wins to be a successful season?

There are reasons for optimism for the Tigers, though, and one of them has been pointed out by the good people at 247Sports. As you would expect, it involves running back Tank Bigsby.

Bryan Harsin is the perfect choice for tailback Tank Bigsby, whose new coach likes to run the football and be stubborn in his approach to a workhorse mentality. Harsin routinely produced 1,000-yard rushers at Boise State and knows Auburn has a player it can build the offense around in 2021. Quarterback Bo Nix is playing under his third play-caller in three seasons, so he’s going to need some help in the run game and Bigsby is one of the SEC’s best. With enough carries, Bigbsy is a player who could rush for 1,200 or more yards.

Yes, Bigsby returns for his sophomore season after rushing for 834 yards on just 138 attempts last season and expects to be even better. A large amount of the Auburn offense, especially early on, will rely on his legs to keep opposing defenses honest and not just stack the box and make Nix beat them.

Auburn’s pass offense? Pro Football Focus thinks it is going to be bad this season

Pro Football Focus predicts Auburn’s passing game to be among the worst in the SEC during the 2021 college football season.

A lot of focus this offseason and into the start of the schedule is on Bo Nix and his progression as both a passer and leader for the Auburn offense under new head coach Bryan Harsin and offensive coordinator Mike Bobo.

Likely to be the starter for the third straight season, Nix is still looking to break out for the Tigers after a mediocre sophomore season in which he threw just 12 touchdowns to seven interceptions.

According to Pro Football Focus, that trend continues this season for Auburn’s passing game and Nix.

The bad news is that Auburn will likely have one of the worst passing offenses in the SEC this year. Running back Tank Bigsby, the nation’s top returning back in our 2021 preseason rankings, can only carry the entire offense so far. The Tigers ranked fourth-to-last in the SEC in successful pass play rate in 2020. Their top three wide receivers from that group all took off for the NFL, too, leaving quarterback Bo Nix, who owns a middling 66.2 passing grade for his career, with no proven option to throw to.

The departures of Seth Williams, Eli Stove and Anthony Schwartz has left a void in receivers that Nix has had a bond with over the past two seasons. During the annual A-Day Spring Game, the quarterback seemed to find Elijah Canion the most, including on a touchdown pass in the back of the end zone.

Everything Bryan Harsin had to say after Auburn’s A-Day Spring Game

Auburn head coach Bryan Harsin spoke after the A-Day Spring Game on Saturday.

Opening statement …

“First, I just want to acknowledge our fans. That was great to have them out there. It was good to see people in the stands. You could feel it. It was an environment that we just can’t recreate in practice and something that was discussed with our players, just as our perform or prepare to perform, remember that there’s going to be that factor. So, today it was great for our guys to be in there. It was great to see the fans and have their interaction on the field. I think our guys appreciated that. I know it helped us. I know at times it also allows us a chance to be able to learn from just the performance that we need to have as we get out there in front of people and go to execute.

“There’s plenty of things that we did do well today as far as stuff the coaches have been hitting and emphasizing with each group and each unit, and some things we got to work on, which is great. We got a practice on Monday, so we’ll get a chance to come back to and bring things up and then talk about what we’re doing moving forward when we get to this time where finals are happening, guys have a chance to take a little bit of a break, and then we’ll come back in June and get started. So, there’s a lot of things that are going to be happening with this next week and moving forward. Then we all know about June 1 and having campuses open back up and opportunities for camps and opportunities with visits.

“So, a lot of things, but today the focus was coming out, operate and execute and seeing these guys just go out, play smart, play hard, have fun and just kind of who’s playing the game. The only way you get better is playing the game. We saw, at least from going back and watching the tape, I saw some solid execution with our blue offense. I thought the blue defense played well. Our second offense did not move the ball very well or very consistently. I think that’s because the defense had been playing really around the football fast. Special teams, we got our work in and those were all just a tempo; it was not live today. We wanted to get our specialists some work. They executed that. We wanted to get the communication from each sideline, get guys on and off. As simple as it may have looked, that’s hard to do. So, I appreciate our coaches and players who walked through that this morning; they had a chance to focus on those types of things, and it all went well.

“And just to be in a game-like atmosphere. We had TV timeouts, we had officials out there, we’ve got media on the sidelines. So, just creating that environment, giving them a chance to get a taste of that as we move into that next phase and start getting ready for the summer. So, with that, we’ll open up for questions.”

Players absent at A-Day …

“Both guys (Alec Jackson and T.D. Moultry), they’re part of the team right now. They just weren’t out there today. We move forward. Those guys have been a part of what we’re doing, and today they were not. Those are things we’re still working through. Neither one of those guys (inaudible) at this point, so don’t make it any bigger than it is. They just weren’t out there today for different reasons.”

On Bo Nix’s play …

“He made good decisions. That was one of the things. We’ve seen Bo’s got escapability, and we know he can throw it, but I thought he made good decisions. He checked the ball down. We had some deeper throws that were called, but they weren’t open, so he checked it down and found the underneath throw. He made good decisions in the red zone; there were chances to possibly scramble and throw one, but he pulled it down and ran it and was able to get us in a first-down situation. We had the turnover; we had the fumble. I thought we were driving well, but we had a couple fumbles in there, and those hurt us. You got to be able to hang onto the ball, so we’ve got to go back and work through those. But overall, his efficiency in making decisions was one. I thought the other thing is he—you wouldn’t know this—but getting us into the right play; there were some check plays and some different things that were called that he needs to make decisions on. We changed the tempo up several times, so he’s got to be able to communicate that. So, there’s really several things in there that I thought Coach Bobo did a really good job of challenging him and making him operate. That’s what you want to see from your quarterback. You just want to see him operate all the different things.

“Then in the scrimmage, it may not even be that much in a real game—you can kind of have a plan for the game, but in the scrimmage, you’re taking everything from the 13 practices we’ve had, and you have it all in one plan, and so you’re just recalling different things. He was able to do that. Ultimately, the ability to make great decisions—he made some really good throws; I thought he had a couple that we needed to come down with. Guys around him got to be able to make plays, and there’s some opportunities that we could’ve done that, and we ran some wrong routes. And he’s got the beat on where he wants to go with the ball and we didn’t run the right route. And again, nobody sees that from the stands, we know it as coaches and we know it as players and you’re not quite sure what’s happening but there was some poor execution in those areas and he was able to just move on. He moved on to the next play. That one didn’t go well? He moved onto the next play we convert a second or third down and move the ball and we’re able to score.

“I think one of the things Bo has is he’s a weapon. When you get out there and run you can see he’s able to extend plays and make plays and he did that today. So I felt like it was solid. When guys around him are playing well — and it’s not just that position — and guys around him are playing well and we’re running the ball effectively, we’re making catches I think we’re capable of making, then our quarterback’s going to play really well and he’s going to play excellent at times. But that’s really about everybody on the offensive side helping that position and creating opportunities for the quarterback.

“Overall solid. I’m going to go back and watch it, there’s going to be plenty of things that we nit-pick and that’s the one thing about that group. I think coach Bobo’s done a good job with that group. That’s one thing you should do with that position, really every position, is really analyze it and evaluate every little detail. Break it down and then work on what you have to to fix it.”

On play of the receivers…

“Well, I would say solid as well. I think today we had some opportunities. We made plays, I know that. There were some really good plays made by the receivers. Even in the run game there were some really good blocks that those guys have been working on. It’s hard to block some of these guys on defense — they’ve seen the plays and they’re also good, our defense does a good job getting off blocks. I think our defensive coaches have taught that really well so our guys have to work hard at the receiver position. But we had some opportunities where we run the right route, put ourselves in the right position, I think we’re going to have a better play. So those are the things — and everybody makes the mistakes, they make the mental errors, we’re going to have some of those that come up — we need to be more consistent at that position and I think right now we’re going to be going through focusing on that as we get into summer time. So between now and when those guys come back in June there’s going to have to be a lot of work done from those guys of just understanding and just really seeing a lot of the things we can improve on and just doing that from the entire summer and through fall camp and continuing that through the season.

“The wide receivers are asked to do a lot. You see them moving around, they’re in different positions, different alignments. So they have to study, they have to prepare, they have to be students of the game to do what we’re asking them to do.”

Bryan Harsin on Jordan-Hare Stadium: ‘This should be the toughest place to play in the country’

Auburn head coach Bryan Harsin wants Jordan-Hare Stadium to be the hardest place to play in all of college football.

We all know what it is like when Jordan-Hare Stadium becomes electric. The stadium starts to shake a little bit, the upper deck feels like it is going to cave in and opposing offenses can’t hear each other nor themselves think.

New Auburn head coach Bryan Harsin wants that to be the norm during his tenure as he told the team on Saturday that “this should be the toughest place to play in the country.”

We agree.

Bryan Harsin on A-Day: ‘We all hope that Jordan-Hare is full capacity’

New Auburn head coach Bryan Harsin wants Tigers fans to show up in groves for the annual A-Day Spring Game on April 17.

With his first spring practice on the Plains arriving in a week, new Auburn head coach Bryan Harsin is hoping that Tigers fans show up to the stadium to watch their team during the annual A-Day spring game.

In fact, he wants the stadium and campus to be rocking like it does during the fall.

“We all hope that Jordan-Hare is full capacity and that we can get that experience with our fan base — we can have Tiger Walk, we can do all the things that make Auburn football so special,” Harsin said on the Talking Tigers podcast with Andy Burcham. “I feel like the excitement and that momentum really from our fans and people that support our program and are part of Auburn football — all that momentum makes a difference. It creates the culture. It creates the recruiting success. It creates the development of our team because we have the momentum; we have that energy and excitement behind what we’re doing. We can’t do that alone, so we need everybody to be a part of that.”

There is a lot of work for Harsin, his coaching staff and their new team to do before getting to the game on April 17. A lot of question marks surround the Tigers as they begin practice including shoring up the offensive line, who exactly will stand out at wide receiver and, of course, fixing what ails Bo Nix.

“I think the 15 practices in spring are maybe the most valuable practices you get in an entire year,” Harsin said. “It sets the stage for your whole entire summer because in the summertime, that’s where the greatest development comes for a particular player — their strength, their speed, their football intelligence. All the things they’re preparing to execute during a season happens in the summer. You fine-tune that in fall camp, but where does it all come from? It comes from the spring.”

Auburn begins practice on Monday, March 15.

Bryan Harsin on A-Day: ‘We all hope that Jordan-Hare is full capacity’

New Auburn head coach Bryan Harsin wants Tigers fans to show up in groves for the annual A-Day Spring Game on April 17.

With his first spring practice on the Plains arriving in a week, new Auburn head coach Bryan Harsin is hoping that Tigers fans show up to the stadium to watch their team during the annual A-Day spring game.

In fact, he wants the stadium and campus to be rocking like it does during the fall.

“We all hope that Jordan-Hare is full capacity and that we can get that experience with our fan base — we can have Tiger Walk, we can do all the things that make Auburn football so special,” Harsin said on the Talking Tigers podcast with Andy Burcham. “I feel like the excitement and that momentum really from our fans and people that support our program and are part of Auburn football — all that momentum makes a difference. It creates the culture. It creates the recruiting success. It creates the development of our team because we have the momentum; we have that energy and excitement behind what we’re doing. We can’t do that alone, so we need everybody to be a part of that.”

There is a lot of work for Harsin, his coaching staff and their new team to do before getting to the game on April 17. A lot of question marks surround the Tigers as they begin practice including shoring up the offensive line, who exactly will stand out at wide receiver and, of course, fixing what ails Bo Nix.

“I think the 15 practices in spring are maybe the most valuable practices you get in an entire year,” Harsin said. “It sets the stage for your whole entire summer because in the summertime, that’s where the greatest development comes for a particular player — their strength, their speed, their football intelligence. All the things they’re preparing to execute during a season happens in the summer. You fine-tune that in fall camp, but where does it all come from? It comes from the spring.”

Auburn begins practice on Monday, March 15.

USA TODAY ranks Bryan Harsin, Gus Malzahn hirings as top this offseason

USA TODAY Sports ranks Auburn’s hiring of Bryan Harsin this offseason as one of the best in college football.

It took some time for Auburn to find its new head coach but they found a good one in Bryan Harsin who the Tigers hired away from Boise State.

USA TODAY Sports’ Paul Myerberg definitely thinks highly of the hire as he has it as the second-best hiring of this offseason.

Harsin had options over the years but waited patiently for the right opportunity, following the trajectory of a career that has always taken a calculated approach to the next move. His program at Boise State (2014-20), where he won 78% of his games but never fully escaped Chris Petersen’s shadow, developed the most important positions on the field: quarterbacks, offensive tackles and edge rushers. As long as the standard for success isn’t unseating Nick Saban and Alabama from atop the SEC, Harsin is a very good fit.

Now, about that unseating Nick Saban and Alabama thing. Isn’t that the goal of any SEC coach, especially the one at Auburn?

Yet it wasn’t just Harsin who was named on the list. In fact, the guy he replaced — Gus Malzahn — was ranked the best hire of the offseason by Myerberg.

WATCH: A look inside new Auburn coach Bryan Harsin’s day

Take a look into new Auburn head coach Bryan Harsin’s typical day as it starts early in the morning with workouts.

[jwplayer sSpPH7QS-er0jUifI]

If you need a little motivation to help get you through the rest of the week then look no further to this video sneak peek into Bryan Harsin’s day.

In the video posted by Auburn Football to Twitter, Harsin arrives to Auburn’s practice facilities at 5:30 Monday morning. From there we see Auburn’s strength workouts in the weight room. It’s HYPE in there, Coach Harsin’s not only coaching these guys, he’s working out alongside them.

PS: I got chills when I saw the ‘Auburn Men That Can Play’ sign.

The video continues with segments from Harsin’s interview with Paul Finebaum before returning to conditioning exercises with the team at 3:30, and yes, he’s putting in work there too.

Near the conclusion of the video Harsin says, “If we are going to play for championships, everything we do matters.”

Bring on spring practice!