Oklahoma Sooners win over Alabama and Kentucky’s win over Ole Miss the issue, not the College Football Playoff committee.
The first weekend of the 12-team College Football Playoff should have been a celebration of more meaningful football in December. Instead, it was filled with teeth gnashing.
Indiana and SMU lost playoff games to Notre Dame and Penn State in pretty decisive fashion. The resulting narrative was that the College Football Playoff committee got it wrong when they omitted SEC darling Alabama, Lane Kiffin’s Ole Miss, and the hottest team in the country, the South Carolina Gamecocks.
SMU and Indiana didn’t belong, as “SEC fans” said. They were frauds, said Paul Finebaum. But the committee wasn’t the problem; Oklahoma and Kentucky were.
There’s a saying in mixed martial arts: “Don’t leave it in the hands of the judges.”
Alabama, Ole Miss, and South Carolina let their resumes get to the scorecards. Though they may have had some good moments in 2024, their losses were too much to overcome.
Alabama, Ole Miss, and South Carolina each had three losses, and they expected the committee to overlook their shortcomings because they play in the SEC. In Alabama, they expected the committee to overlook the team’s 21-point loss to an Oklahoma team that finished 6-6. Kiffin and Ole Miss wanted the CFP to ignore the Rebels’ loss at home to a Kentucky team that won just one SEC game.
Despite their strong end to the season, South Carolina couldn’t be put in the playoff if the committee was going to leave out Alabama and Ole Miss due to head-to-head losses to the Crimson Tide and the Rebels.
Alabama and Ole Miss each lost a pair of games to unranked opponents. Win just one more game, and it’s not even a question. If Alabama beats Oklahoma or Vanderbilt, they’d be in the playoff. If Ole Miss beats Kentucky or Florida, they’d be in the playoff.
But they didn’t, so they really only have themselves to blame.
Oklahoma’s rushing attack and defensive performance kept Alabama out of the College Football Playoff. The Sooners’ dominating win over the Crimson Tide was too much for the committee to overlook.
So, while SEC fans, Lane Kiffin, Paul Finebaum, and ESPN take to their platforms to criticize the College Football Playoff committee, they should instead take aim at Alabama and Ole Miss for losing to teams they shouldn’t have.
The lesson here is to win your games—especially those against unranked opponents.
Contact/Follow us @SoonersWire on X, and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Oklahoma news, notes, and opinions. You can also follow John on X @john9williams.