PFT says Commanders treated QB prospects like ‘lab rats’ during interviews

More nonsense from from Washington’s favorite critic.

Pro Football Talk blasted the Commanders on Friday.

The Commanders had entertained multiple players, including four quarterbacks, earlier in the week. It was a job interview, and apparently, Josh Harris and the Commanders were really out of line, according to Mike Florio and Myles Simmons.

“I think it is imperative to bring in these guys (quarterbacks) one at a time, know everything you can about them, get them all in with you. And that is where this has kind of gone off the rails for the Commanders. Because I’m hearing belief that maybe Jayden Daniels is not all that interested now in going to the Commanders,” Florio said during Friday’s installment of “PFT Live.”

Simmons replied: “You can pick up another asset (not picking Daniels and trading down), but is that going to be worth it if you are playing games and you don’t get the exact quarterback that you sensibly have fallen in love with throughout this draft process? To me, that would not make much sense. But, there are a lot of things about the way the Commanders have gone about, let’s call it, the last week that have not made much sense to me.”

Added Florio: “Here is the other thing I’ve picked up from somebody that I trust immensely, who is very plugged into the ownership scene. Josh Harris? A lot more involved than they thought he would be. … They brought them all in on the same day because that’s the day Mr. Harris was available to see them. That’s the only plausible explanation for having them there.

“Here is the danger, the David Tepper danger. This is when the owner is involved in any way. … At the end of the day, if you get it wrong, you better get it wrong with the guy the boss wanted. Your worst-case scenario is, the boss wanted this guy, and you went with that (other) guy, and that guy stinks. … Your long-term job prospects are best suited by giving the boss what you think the boss wants, and it all comes down to how vocal the boss is.

“You are the No. 2  guy. The people who know what they are doing, have Jayden Daniels as the clear No. 2 guy. So, when you have your visit to this team, that wants you supposedly, and the day is diluted by the three other quarterbacks being there. At some level you are going to be pissed. … There’s red flags there, and it all flows back to how the Commanders have handled it. It’s not anything about Jayden Daniels. It’s how the Commanders have handled Jayden Daniels.”

Wow, has it not yet occurred to Florio that comparing Harris to Tepper is extremely unfair to Harris? If Harris proves himself to be a Tepper, then yes. But for now, doesn’t that seem like attacking Harris prematurely?

Second, do Florio and Simmons fail to comprehend the Commanders have not presented any signs whatsoever that Daniels is obviously their guy?

Third, they are flat-out wrong because several analysts also think Drake Maye should be the second selection. The situation is not as simple as Florio and Simmons erroneously believe it to be.

Fourth, are any of the other quarterbacks who visited complaining about the process? So how can Florio and Simmons logically conclude it has to be the Commanders at fault in how they handled Daniels this week?

Simmons then proceeded to say twice the Commanders’ process was “disrespectful” to the prospective quarterbacks, expressing, “I am confused by this approach.”

Though Adam Peters and Lance Newmark stated there were both individual meetings and group time, this simply does not satisfy Florio and Simmons. Florio then called it “the strategy the Commanders concocted; I know people and am a student of the human condition. It’s disrespectful, it’s disrespectful to all of them.”

Florio then said the Commanders were treating the quarterbacks “like lab rats in a weird sort of way. … Let’s just put them in a room together and see how they act. Maybe one will kill the other three, and that will clearly be the right choice for us. … There is an element of evil scientist that comes through this, that is just offputting to me as an outsider.”

Florio then called it “this weird power-trip [expletive].”

Here is the video of their entire discussion:

 

 

Commanders 2024 NFL draft value growing larger

The higher Washington picks in the 2024 NFL draft, the more options that will be available, including trading down.

Week 14 was a gift to the Commanders… a very large gift.

In Week 14 the Patriots, Bears, Jets, Giants and Titans all won.

How much did this help the Commanders?

Well, for starters, they are now the only NFL team sitting with only 4 wins. The Bears, Jets, Giants and Titans all won their fifth game over the weekend. Meanwhile, the Patriots increased their win total from two to three.

Don’t overlook the Cardinals. Arizona was 1-8, then quarterback Kyler Murray returned.  Don’t misunderstand; Murray has not performed exceptionally. He’s completed 60% of his passes, and his TD/INT ratio is only 3:2.  Yet, he has been good enough that the Cardinals are 2-2 in his four games. They “could” finish better than the Commanders as well.

Most Commanders fans will think the major issue is the Commanders might pick third or fourth in next April’s NFL draft. Well, that’s true, they might. It is also true the value of their pick, if it is third or fourth could be very valuable.

For instance, if the new GM and head coach like Sam Howell enough, they may feel the wiser route to take in the 2024 draft could be to draft the best player available, like, say, Penn State offensive tackle Olu Fashanu or Ohio State receiver Marvin Harrison Jr.

In addition, they might actually take the highest trade offer they receive for the pick, trade down and accumulate an extra draft choice or two.

I recall the 1981 draft, and Redskins general manager, Bobby Beathard, had the 9th pick and traded down all the way to 20th. He knew what he was doing, he chose Mark May, an offensive tackle, and May played 9 seasons and 123 games, starting 115 as part of “the Hogs.”

Also, in that 1981 draft, Beathard made two other trades, and in return, the Redskins had gained future Hall of Fame guard/center Russ Grimm, starting cornerback Vernon Dean and running back Joe Washington.

So, the higher the draft position, the higher the value the pick possesses. Being in the 3rd or 4th position also results in more draft capital to lure others to trade up with you.

It will also lure candidates to be your new head coach or general manager as well.