2008: Chargers 23, Colts 17 (OT)
Fifty years after the Baltimore Colts won the first overtime game in league history by the same score over the New York Giants for the NFL title, Indianapolis wasn’t so fortunate. It was victimized by Darren Sproles, who rushed 23 times for 105 yards, caught five passes for 45 yards, had 106 yards on four kickoff returns and 72 on three punt returns. Given more playing time because of LaDainian Tomlinson’s groin injury, Sproles ran 22 yards for the winning score 6:20 into overtime.