Giants vs. Redskins: Week 16 staff picks and predictions

The Giants Wire staff offers their picks and predictions ahead of a Week 16 game between the New York Giants and Washington Redskins.

The New York Giants (3-11) will take on the Washington Redskins (3-11) at FedEx Field in a game featuring two of the top rookie quarterbacks — Daniel Jones and Dwayne Haskins.

Experts are evenly split on the game — 5:5 — with most of those expecting a one-score contest that comes down to the wire.

How does the Giants Wire staff see this Week 16 battle shaking out? Here’s a look at our picks and score predictions:

Dan Benton: Redskins 24, Giants 23

Maybe I am just trying to convince myself the Redskins will win this game because it really seems like such a Giants thing to do to go out and win the one game they really need to lose when they’ve lost 11 others. And don’t think for a second that they don’t want to win — the players are not tanking and will give it their all on Sunday. Still, I think (see: hope) the Redskins ultimately walk away victorious.

John Fennelly: Redskins 23, Giants 17

Washington has played much better football in the second half under interim coach Bill Callahan and the Giants — as Saquon Barkley said this week — are looking forward to going home. They’ve already said their public goodbye to Eli Manning, so there’s not much left to play for. The coaches are probably gone and everyone is looking at these last two games as an end rather than a beginning.

Doug Rush: Redskins 24, Giants 20

Daniel Jones returns to the lineup after missing the last two weeks with an ankle sprain.

The last time Jones played the Redskins, he got the second win of his NFL career, and before this past Sunday, it was the last game the Giants had won until the win against the Miami Dolphins.

This is a much different Redskins team the Giants saw back in September. One where they didn’t have any victories at that point and were on the verge of getting their head coach fired, which did happen.

The Redskins are essentially competing with the Giants for draft location in the 2020 NFL Draft, as both teams are 3-11 and one has a better shot at a better pick if they lose the game.

With the Redskins playing slightly better and at home, plus with the Giants getting a win this past week to send Eli Manning off on his way for his Giants career, the Giants may come crashing back down to earth and to a loss on Sunday.

Tyler Henry: Redskins 24, Giants 21

At this point in the season, it’s hard to imagine the Giants stacking back-to-back wins. I think Dwayne Haskins will be out for revenge against the team that passed on him in favor of Daniel Jones. Division games are always close and given the fact that the first one between the Redskins and Giants was a blowout, it makes me believe that this one is going to come down to the wire. It kind of feels like a letdown game coming this weekend. I think given the draft position implications surrounding this game, this game could get a little wild. Just a gut feeling but I think the Giants will blow a late lead in this one.

Pat Ragazzo: Giants 33, Redskins 28

In the battle for Chase Young, it would be wise for one of the teams to lose in order to steal the No. 2 pick in the draft. Whoever is in line to select Young at this spot in the draft will likely be getting a player who will wreak havoc on opposing quarterbacks in the NFC East for years to come. The Redskins have the fourth-worst run defense and the Eagles just ran all over them (157 yards) as the Giants just did the same (138 yards) to the Dolphins last week.

Despite Dwayne Haskins coming off his best performance of his young career (19-of-28, 261 yards, two touchdowns), Daniel Jones is leaps and bounds ahead of him in the developmental phase and I don’t see him getting out dueled. I like the Giants pulling this one out, but unfortunately jeopardizing their candidacy in the Chase Young sweepstakes.

Kevin Hickey: N/A

N/A

Mike Moraitis: Giants 24, Redskins 23

The Giants will welcome Daniel Jones back in Week 16 in a game that the team would be better off losing. At this point it’s all about draft positioning, and the Redskins sit one spot behind the Giants in the 2020 NFL Draft.

Ideally, the Giants lose this game to help keep their position that could land them Chase Young in April, but with the way things have gone this season, that won’t happen because everything has gone wrong. In a battle between two bad teams, the one with slightly more talent, the Giants, will emerge victorious and ruin their chance at the star pass-rusher they so desperately need.

Serena Burks: Redskins 24, Giants 17

Daniel Jones is still learning how to call protections and Saquon Barkley doesn’t get going. It’s more of the same on both sides of the ball, which means the tape the Redskins watched is exactly what they’ll see.