This is the online version of our morning newsletter, The Morning Win. Subscribe to get irreverent and incisive sports stories, delivered to your mailbox every morning.
A wildly long weekend of college football action came to an end Monday night when an explosive Ole Miss team blew out Louisville, 43-24, in Atlanta.
While Ole Miss’ win was impressive, a lot of people will be taking away something else from this game – the fact that college football’s targeting rule is still a total a mess.
Four players were ejected in the first half for targeting calls that mostly seemed like football players making football moves. We almost saw a double-targeting call on what was a very dangerous hit by two Louisville defenders on Rebels quarterback Matt Corral. That double hit was definitely a lot more malicious than the others and deserved the swift ejection that came with the flag.
Many people on social media went crazy over most of the calls, and rightfully so – the punishment seems to be really darn harsh for what can often be a bang-bang play where there isn’t any intent by the defender to hit his opponent with the crown of his helmet.
This rule was put into place for the right reasons – to protect the health and safety of these college athletes. Nobody is arguing about making sure these players stay safe and healthy.
But the penalty does usually seem a bit harsh.
Joel Klatt, Fox Sports’ lead college football analyst, was one of many tweeting about the rule Monday night and his suggestion seems to make sense – 15 yards for your first targeting penalty, then an ejection if you get called for a second. Also, if your first targeting hit is really bad then you get tossed for that one. That all seems to make sense to me.
The problem with Targeting? It is officiated wildly inconsistent & yet carries the most punitive consequences!
must be addressed!!
We need to only eject in egregious and malicious occurrences.
Targeting 1 (15 yards)
Targeting 2 (15 yards & ejection)— Joel Klatt (@joelklatt) September 7, 2021
Former ESPN star Mike Golic offered pretty much the same suggestion as Klatt.
Ole Miss player got tossed for targeting,by rule it was, for safety reasons you need to see what you hit, he did lead with top of helmet..but stop stop stop ejecting them, 15yd penalty and play on, or at make it 2 targeting and you’re ejected, like 2 techs in BB. Just my opinion
— Mike Golic (@golic) September 7, 2021
I’m all for player safety. We all are. But these plays need to be looked at in different ways, much like the NBA handles its flagrant fouls – one very strict punishment shouldn’t cover all of them.
There needs to be a little more leeway for the referees to make a decision to not throw a kid out of the game for something that wasn’t meant to be malicious.
Something needs to change.
Quick hits: Yankees’ top prospected tossed after home run… Michael Irvin’s very lively ‘First Take’ debut… Astros fans rightfully rip ump… And more.
– Anthony Volpe, theYankees No. 1 prospect, got ejected from a minor league game as he crossed home plate after hitting a home run, which is something you don’t see every day.
– Michael Irvin made his debut on ESPN’s yelling show ‘First Take’ on Monday and people had lots of jokes about how much yelling he did.
– Astros fans crushed umpire Joe West after his brutal strike call ended a 9th-inning rally in San Diego on Sunday.
– This little kid’s reaction to his mom getting him a foul ball at a Padres game was so awesome.
– You need to see this incredible heads up play that Mets pitcher Marcus Stroman made over the weekend. Could be the play of the year.
[mm-video type=video id=01feyknn27ch01hbsfge playlist_id=01f09p3bf720d8rg02 player_id=none image=https://images2.minutemediacdn.com/image/upload/video/thumbnail/mmplus/01feyknn27ch01hbsfge/01feyknn27ch01hbsfge-803a14911f848457d4e4d1b784488813.jpg]