Best and worst PFF grades from Panthers’ preseason win over Bills

Bryce Young and Jack Plummer delivered for the Panthers in Saturday’s preseason finale.

The Carolina Panthers wrapped up their 2024 preseason with a pretty exciting showing against the Buffalo Bills on Saturday.

We saw quarterback Bryce Young orchestrate a beautiful opening drive in his summer debut, undrafted rookie Jack Plummer explode for 278 passing yards and a handful of other youngsters try to make their case for the team’s initial 53-man roster.

But what did Pro Football Focus see?

Here are the best and worst PFF grades for Carolina in their 31-26 victory:

Best of the offense

Bryan M. Bennett/Getty Images

1. TE Jesper Horstead: 95.2
2. QB Jack Plummer: 90.4
3. WR Terrace Marshall Jr.: 87.4
4. TE Feleipe Franks: 83.5
5. QB Bryce Young: 82.2

Young and Plummer combined for 370 passing yards and three touchdowns.

Horsted ended as the game’s leading receiver, reeling in a pair of catches for 63 yards. Marshall Jr. added three receptions, 39 yards and an impressive score of their own.

Worst of the offense

Mark Konezny-USA TODAY Sports

29. WR Jonathan Mingo: 54.7
30. WR Michael Strachan: 54.3
31. RG Mason Brooks: 53.7
32. LT Tyler Smith: 44.5
33. WR Xavier Legette: 42.0

Legette was charged with a drop on his first and only target of preseason play.

Best of the defense

Tina MacIntyre-Yee/Democrat and Chronicle / USA TODAY NETWORK

1. DE Jayden Peevy: 89.7
2. OLB Luiji Vilain: 86.3
3. S Nick Scott: 83.2
4. ILB Shaq Thompson: 80.7
5. S Jordan Fuller: 71.7

Vilain notched four total tackles and half a sack.

Worst of the defense

Gregory Fisher-USA TODAY Sports

30. OLB Derrick McLendon: 43.3
31. CB Chris Wilcox: 42.9
32. DT Shy Tuttle: 41.5
33. CB Troy Hill: 36.9
34. CB Quandre Mosely: 28.2

As a trio, Wilcox, Hill and Mosely allowed five receptions and 40 yards over six targets.

[lawrence-related id=702268,702246,702250]