College football analyst says Caleb Williams ‘is in a tier to himself’

One college football analyst at The Athletic says Drake Maye and other top QBs don’t belong in the same tier with Caleb Williams.

It’s true that Caleb Williams is the heavy favorite to be the No. 1 pick at the 2024 NFL draft in under 11 months. No one doubts that assertion. Yet, the distance between Caleb Williams and the next-best quarterback in the 2024 draft class is a point of debate.

For Stewart Mandel, The Athletic’s college football editor and a longtime college football commentator, it’s a Grand Canyon-sized gulf.

“I know Caleb and Drake Maye are being grouped together in the early 2024 NFL draft talk, but Williams is in a tier to himself,” Mandel wrote. “He produced nearly 5,000 yards of offense, 42 touchdowns and just five interceptions last year. I put him among the elite of the elite to come through college recently — i.e., the Trevor Lawrence and Joe Burrow class.”

Caleb Williams is unquestionably brilliant. On paper, he does seem like a can’t-miss prospect with a Burrow-like ability to transform whatever NFL franchise he ultimately joins. There are other talented quarterbacks in the class, but the can’t-miss label is indeed a description only Caleb seems to warrant. It’s a compelling line of thought on a special, generational football player.

[lawrence-auto-related count=1 tag=696092235]