2 delicious Girl Scout Cookie flavors are heading for retirement after 2025, which is rough

This is sad if you love these flavors.

As the resident Girl Scout Cookie enthusiast here at For The Win, I was floored by the news on Tuesday morning.

People exclusively reported this: “Two popular flavors, Girl Scout S’mores and Toast-Yay!, will be available for the last time this year before being retired for the 2026 cookie season.”

Oh no! We’re talking about two cookies in my top-five of the best Girl Scout Cookies, ranked — Toast-Yay! came in at No. 5 and the S’mores flavor was No. 3.

No more S’mores! I say Toast-Boo to this decision as well. Sorry for the puns, but it’s how I’m coping. Definitely going to order these two this year.

[lawrence-auto-related count=3 tag=676440]