Was Justin Jefferson’s catch the NFL’s greatest of all time? We debate it.

Was it better than Odell Beckham Jr.’s? The helmet catch? Santonio Holmes’ catch?

With one hand, Justin Jefferson instantly put himself into the NFL’s all-time greatest catches highlight reel.

On a 4th-and-18 and facing one of the NFL’s elite defenses in the Buffalo Bills, the Minnesota Vikings wideout went up and grabbed a Kirk Cousins throw that seemed to have been initially in the hands of Cam Lewis.

Nope. Jefferson came down with it. And the Vikings eventually won in overtime thanks in part to that unreal catch.

But is it the greatest catch you’ve ever seen in NFL history? Some people thought so on Twitter, and For The Win staffers spent some time debating that very topic. Here are our takes: