The NFL’s 25 best postseason players from the Super Bowl era

Maybe one day Patrick Mahomes or, who knows who else (Joe Burrows even? Heh. Too soon? Too soon?) might join this list, but for now, let’s go with these 25. Some were clear choices while others you might dispute for someone else, but it’s obviously …

Kurt Warner

(JEFF HAYNES/AFP/Getty Images)

Warner led the St. Louis Rams’ The Greatest Show on Turf to a victory in Super Bowl XXXIV over the Titans with an MVP-worthy effort (414 yards and two TDs). Warner threw for over 300 yards in six of his 13 playoff starts, including all three of his Super Bowl appearances.