Art Schilichter
Once considered a local hero, Art Schlichter turned into one of the biggest busts and was busted numerous times for gambling and other issues after his NFL career. He was winless in six starts for the Baltimore and Indianapolis Colts. Schlichter was so bad and unreliable, the Colts actually drafted John Elway first overall a year after drafting the Buckeye fourth. Schlichter made six starts, all losses. At last report, he was incarcerated in South Carolina, looking at a release date in 2020.