ESPN’s Mel Kiper Jr grades 2020 Saints draft with a ‘C+’

ESPN draft analyst Mel Kiper Jr. didn’t mind the prospects picked by the New Orleans Saints so much as the process behind acquiring them.

[jwplayer Vv1h2jbQ-ThvAeFxT]

How do you grade the New Orleans Saints performance in the 2020 NFL Draft? The Saints seem to always enter the draft prepared to wheel and deal their draft picks so that they can maneuver the board, targeting players they feel have a better chance of success than other prospects. That of course means trading away picks not just in this year’s event, but the upcoming NFL draft.

We can count ESPN’s Mel Kiper Jr. among the crowd that had a mixed reaction to the Saints’ draft haul, though he’s more critical of their strategy. Kiper graded the Saints with a C+, one of eight teams to receive that rating, tut-tutting New Orleans for how few picks they made and their continued free-spending nature with future draft capital:

I’m high on center Cesar Ruiz (24), whom I ranked as the clear top interior offensive lineman in this class, and he has some experience at guard. He could end up there with last year’s second-round pick, Erik McCoy, playing so well at center as a rookie. One thing that bothers shorter quarterbacks like Drew Brees is interior pressure, and New Orleans is trying to shore that up as it goes all-in for 2020. I have other needs higher for the Saints — particularly wide receiver — but I do like Ruiz.

The Saints used trades for their other three picks, including adding next year’s third-rounder, to move up to get outside linebacker Zack Baun (74) and tight end Adam Trautman (105). Baun is an interesting fit in Dennis Allen’s defense; is he a defensive end or a versatile linebacker? I thought he’d be great as an OLB in a 3-4. Either way, it’s good value for Baun, who is my No. 31 overall player. The 6-foot-5 Trautman, my second-ranked tight end, caught 70 passes last season and is really just a jumbo wide receiver at this point, but that could be useful in Sean Payton’s offense.

The flip side to Kiper’s argument is that the Saints lack many places where rookies will hope to compete right away. While New Orleans went into the draft wanting to improve the interior of its offensive line and lacking a healthy, young starting-quality linebacker, there weren’t many other opportunities for a first-year player to get on the field.

Sure, adding a wide receiver or cornerback would have been nice. But how many targets would a third wideout get (assuming they could outplay Tre’Quan Smith in training camp, which isn’t a sure thing) behind Michael Thomas and Emmanuel Sanders, with Alvin Kamara and Jared Cook also in play?

The Saints already know which two corners are going to dominate the snaps played — in Marshon Lattimore and Janoris Jenkins — so picking one early would have meant investing in an insurance policy rather than an upgrade. With Drew Brees entering the final days of his playing career, the Saints are gambling that short-term improvement is the better play. We’ll just have to watch and see if their bet pays off.

[lawrence-related id=12352]

[vertical-gallery id=32704]

Saints draft grades for picking Cesar Ruiz in the first round

The New Orleans Saints received grades from media outlets after picking Michigan center Cesar Ruiz in the first round of the 2020 NFL Draft.

[jwplayer NLoBP6t7-ThvAeFxT]

The first round of the 2020 NFL Draft is in the books, and draft grades are flying in from all around the media landscape. And so far, the reaction to the New Orleans Saints picking Michigan center/guard Cesar Ruiz is overwhelmingly positive. We graded the pick well ourselves, but it’s nice to see such a validating response from draft experts.

We’ll start out with some thoughts from our colleagues. K.D. Drummond over at Touchdown Wire gave the Saints an A grade, adding that Ruiz brings a wealth of experience — he snapped the ball 919 times for the Wolverines last year. Our own Luke Easterling at Draft Wire rated the pick with a B+, writing:

As a prospect, there’s plenty to like about Ruiz. He’s athletic and physical, with the intelligence every NFL coach and quarterback needs at his position. He’s also just 20 years old, giving him limitless upside.

He has experience at guard, so he could start his career there in New Orleans. No matter where he lines up, he’s going to be a fantastic addition to this offense.

The Ringer’s Danny Kelly was another draft expert who liked the pick, praising the Saints for investing in better protection for Drew Brees, and grading the move with a B+. Kelly noted that it’s a little confusing to guess how things might shake out with Erik McCoy entrenched at center, but he expects Ruiz, the highest-graded interior lineman on his board to start right away.

Meanwhile, Vinnie Iyer of Sporting News was slightly more lukewarm, grading the move with a B. While he’s a fan of Ruiz’s talents, he doesn’t anticipate the rookie playing much until right guard Larry Warford is out of the picture (maybe not until 2021, when his contract runs out).

And the lowest grade, by far, came from Bleacher Report’s Mike Tanier. While he’s high on Ruiz’s prospects, Tanier isn’t sure that the rookie is ready to start right away, much less taking over from a quality center in Erik McCoy. He graded the match with a B-, which is still a great mark considering how poorly the Saints have drafted in other years.

While he was just as perplexed by the fit in context of who the Saints already have, Pete Prisco of CBS Sports spoke highly of Ruiz’s projection in the longer view. He graded the Ruiz pick with an A. The Saints were one of just six teams to earn an A-grade from him in the first round. His explanation:

I love this player. Would go to the Pro Bowl for seven or eight years as a center. But where is he going to play for the Saints? I thought he’d be a great center, but he’ll probably play right guard for them. Good player, but strange pick by the Saints.

If the lowest grade the Saints earned for picking Ruiz was a B-, then they’re off to a pretty good start in this year’s draft. It’ll be fascinating to see how things shake out along the offensive line with him in the fold, but we still have six more rounds of draft picks to get through. stay tuned.

[vertical-gallery id=32397]