The Saints added Syracuse punter Nolan Cooney to go up against Penn State’s Blake Gillikin in the search for a Thomas Morstead replacement.
[mm-video type=video id=01f4n4qkg35rn48ttn58 playlist_id=01eqbyahgz6p2j3xp7 player_id=none image=https://images2.minutemediacdn.com/image/upload/video/thumbnail/mmplus/01f4n4qkg35rn48ttn58/01f4n4qkg35rn48ttn58-0eda78519e84cd12d2175f83d498ae2d.jpg]
Blake Gillikin spent his rookie year learning everything he could behind longtime Saints punter Thomas Morstead, and now he’ll have to put his skills and knowledge to the test in a training camp competition for the right to replace the fan-favorite specialist. The Saints moved quickly after the 2021 NFL draft to bring in Syracuse punter Nolan Cooney, one of the nation’s best, who went through a pro day workout with the Saints’ special teams coach earlier this spring.
Of course Gillikin was an accomplished punter in his own right. So how do the two of them compare? Let’s look at some stats putting Gillikin’s 2019 season at Penn State against Cooney’s numbers with the Orange in 2020:
- Cooney punted 74 times for 3,314 yards in 11 games, averaging 44.8 yards per punt with 3 touchbacks and 24 landing inside the opposing 20-yard line. 25 of his punts traveled 50-plus yards and 14 traveled out of bounds, while 22 were fair catches. 26 of his punts were returned for 170 yards, resulting in a net yards per punt of 41.7, while 9 were downed by his teammates. He posted a long of 64 yards and had no punts blocked.
- Gillikin punted 62 times for 2,615 yards in 13 games, averaging 42.2 yards per punt with 4 touchbacks and 32 landing inside the opposing 20-yard line. 12 of his punts traveled 50-plus yards and 7 traveled out of bounds, while 16 were fair catches. 20 of his punts were returned for 34 yards, resulting in a net yards per punt of 39.7, while 15 were downed by his teammates. He posted a long of 72 yards and had one punt blocked.
That’s a lot of volume numbers, so let’s condense it into percentages to better summarize the data.
| Stat |
2020 Nolan Cooney |
2019 Blake Gillikin |
| Punts per game |
6.7 |
4.8 |
| Gross yards per punt |
44.8 |
42.2 |
| Net yards per punt |
41.7 (-3.8) |
39.7 (-2.5) |
| 50+ yard % |
33.7% |
19.3% |
| Inside the 20 % |
32.4% |
51.6% |
| Touchbacks % |
4.1% |
6.5% |
| Out of bounds % |
18.9% |
11.3% |
| Fair catches % |
29.7% |
25.8% |
| Punts returned % |
35.1% |
32.3% |
| Downed by team % |
12.2% |
24.2% |
It’s worth noting that Gillikin punted for four years at Penn State whereas Cooney held the job for just his final season at Syracuse; if we look at Gillikin’s career numbers, we’ll see that his numbers generally improved: he punted 4.6 times per game with his gross yards per punt rising to 43.0 and his net falling to 38.8 (a 4.2 yard difference); 22.6% traveled 50-plus yards and 41.8% landed inside the 20 but 9.2% were touchbacks and 6.3% went out of bounds. 26.4% fair catches but 32.6% returned and 21.3% downed by teammates. And, yes, that’s a big jump in sample size (239 career punts).
Still, it’s enough to suggest that while Cooney may have a bigger leg, Gillikin has been more accurate with his ball placement. Gillikin may have had a better supporting cast, too — he saw fewer punts returned and his teammates downed his punts twice as often as Cooney’s.
We also can’t ignore that Gillikin’s offense asked him to punt significantly less often than Cooney did. There are other standards we don’t have access to like hang time that will be used to judge both punters in training camp, and ultimately that’s what it will come down to.
At the end of the day, the Saints have two promising candidates that shouldn’t be out of work for long in this league. It’s about as an ideal a succession plan as could be hoped for.
[listicle id=45089]
