Donald Trump’s plan to unite PGA Tour-LIV Golf may have started last week in Florida

One month after LIV’s inaugural event, Trump told PGA Tour golfers to, “take the money now.”

Donald Trump recently golfed with PGA Tour commissioner Jay Monahan in Florida and sat next to Yasir Al-Rumayyan, the head of Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund, at a UFC event, perhaps initiating his plan to help unite the PGA Tour and LIV Golf.

Trump, the president elect, recently said he believes it would take “the better part of 15 minutes” for him to get a deal done between the two tours that have been negotiating for 18 months in an attempt to combine commercial businesses and rights into a new for-profit company.

Trump, an avid golfer and golf fan, hosted Monahan at Trump International Golf Club in West Palm Beach, Florida, on Friday, one day before sitting between Al-Rumayyan and Elon Musk at the UCF event at Madison Square Garden in New York City.

A PGA Tour spokesperson confirmed Friday’s golf outing to the Washington Post.

“President-Elect Trump has always been a champion of the game of golf and Commissioner Monahan was honored to accept his invitation to play at Trump International. The President-Elect and the Commissioner share a love for the game and the Commissioner enjoyed their time together.”

The Post reported the round was initiated by Trump.

Trump’s victory increased hope for LIV, which is financed by the PIF, and the PGA Tour could resolved their differences and end the rivalry that has fractured golf.

Rory McIlroy, the third-ranked golfer in the world, believes Trump’s return to the White House will be good for the sport.

“I think that clears the way a little bit,” McIlroy told reporters at the DP World Tour’s Abu Dhabi HSBC Golf Championship soon after Trump was declared the winner of the election.

McIlroy won the DP World Tour Championship in Dubai on Sunday.

Trump aligned with LIV from the start

Trump’s adversarial relationship with the PGA Tour led to his becoming an advocate of LIV, which was started in 2022 by Greg Norman.

“He might be able to (get a deal done),” McIlroy, the four-time major winner said about Trump. “He’s got Elon Musk, who I think is the smartest man in the world, beside him. We might be able to do something if we can get Musk involved, too.

“Yeah, I think from the outside looking in, it’s probably a little less complicated than it actually is. But obviously Trump has a great relationship with Saudi Arabia. He’s got a great relationship with golf. He’s a lover of golf. So, maybe. Who knows?”

Trump told the Sirius XM podcast “Let’s Go!” he believes it would take him “the better part of 15 minutes” to get a deal done.

“I’m really going to work on other things, to be honest with you,” Trump said. “I think we have much bigger problems than that. But I do think we should have one tour and they should have the best players in that tour.”

McIlroy said this summer among the reasons the sides cannot agree are half the players on both sides do not want an agreement and the U.S. Department of Justice.

The DOJ is headed by the U.S. attorney general, who reports directly to the president and is a member of the president’s Cabinet.

LIV just completed its third year. During that time it has played six events on Trump properties, including three at Trump National Doral outside of Miami. Trump frequently has played in the LIV pro-ams at his courses.

One month after LIV’s inaugural event, Trump told PGA Tour golfers to, “take the money now.”

Rory McIlroy says Donald Trump’s election win ‘clears the way’ for PGA Tour-PIF deal

“But obviously Trump has a great relationship with Saudi Arabia. He’s got a great relationship with golf.”

Could Donald Trump’s return to the White House in Washington D.C. pave the way for a unification of men’s professional golf? Rory McIlroy thinks so.

McIlroy has previously stated the U.S. Department of Justice could be an obstacle to the PGA Tour’s talks with the PIF. With Trump’s imminent return to office, that may not be the case.

“Given today’s news with what’s happened in America, I think it clears the way a little bit,” McIlroy said Wednesday while speaking to reporters ahead of the DP World Tour’s Abu Dhabi HSBC Championship. “So we’ll see.”

Reports surfaced over the weekend about a deal being agreed to between the PGA Tour and Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund, though McIlroy said he was unaware of anything being done. However, with the United States presidential election in the rearview mirror, McIlroy believes the civil war in men’s professional golf could be near its end.

McIlroy was asked about Trump’s comments recently from a podcast where the president-elect said he could strike a deal between the sides in 15 minutes and that all of the best players need to be together.

“He might be able to. He’s got Elon Musk, who I think is the smartest man in the world, beside him. We might be able to do something if we can get Musk involved, too,” McIlroy stated.

“I think from the outside looking in, it’s probably a little less complicated than it actually is. But obviously Trump has great relationship with Saudi Arabia. He’s got a great relationship with golf. He’s a lover of golf. So, maybe. Who knows? But I think as the President of the United States again, he’s probably got bigger things to focus on than golf.”

McIlroy also noted PGA Tour commissioner Jay Monahan was in Saudi Arabia last week meeting with PIF governor Yasir Al-Rumayyan, and Monahan is briefing the Tour’s transaction committee Wednesday night.

“So maybe some news comes out of that.”

With a top-two finish this week, McIlroy can claim the DP World Tour’s season-long race for the sixth time in his career, which would tie Seve Ballesteros for the second most all-time.

Report: PGA Tour’s Jay Monahan and PIF’s Yasir Al-Rumayyan meet again in Saudi Arabia

Monahan has been in Saudi Arabia this week attending the Future Investment Initiative.

PGA Tour Commissioner Jay Monahan and PIF’s Yasir Al-Rumayyan, which bankrolls the LIV Golf League, are meeting again this week in person.

Monahan has been in Saudi Arabia this week attending the Future Investment Initiative, an annual conference run by the PIF in Riyadh. Bunkered.co.uk first reported the story, noting his attendance along with other PGA “team members.”

Monahan and Al-Rumayyan played in a foursome at the DP World Tour’s Alfred Dunhill Links Championship, a pro-am event in Scotland, recently, their first public meeting since the televised handshake back announcing a framework agreement in June 2023. Monahan declined to comment on the state of negotiations, which have dragged on since June 2023, which ended the legal battle between the Tour and LIV Golf.

More from our Eamon Lynch: A PGA Tour-Saudi deal is closer, but opportunists will have time to take advantage while real fans wait

Bunkered also noted that the two leaders will be together at a pro-am outing Thursday night in conjunction with the Ladies European Tour’s Aramco Ladies Team Series Event, and are expected to play together again under floodlights at Riyadh Golf Club. LIV Golf CEO Greg Norman reportedly will be in attendance, too, as the venue is scheduled to host LIV Golf’s Promotions event in December.

Lynch: The PGA Tour’s best fix for the Presidents Cup? Sell the International team and get out of the way

It would at least end the charade that the Presidents Cup is a global vehicle by actually making it so.

Some storylines recycle through golf’s ecosystem with the dreary predictability of a Patrick Reed lawsuit filing. The now annual Tiger Woods comeback is one, with attendant speculation about whether a man more compromised than, well, a Patrick Reed lawsuit, can actually win again. Rory McIlroy’s yearly tilt at the Masters is too, invariably followed with commentary about pressure and perspective (neither of which is induced by a Patrick Reed lawsuit). Another tried-and-true narrative has been making the rounds again this week: What can be done to salvage the Presidents Cup?

The biennial contest pitting the United States against an International team (drawn from everywhere bar Europe) is often entertaining but seldom competitive. The Internationals’ only win was in 1998. They have now suffered 10 consecutive defeats — culminating in last weekend’s 18 ½ to 11 ½ loss at Royal Montreal. It was a whupping, no matter how many soft-pedalers say things were closer than the scoreline implies.

Debates over how to address the imbalance can be as animated as the actual matches. Suggestions include reducing the number of points contested to accommodate the lack of depth on the International bench (that has already been tried, going from 34 points to 30 in ’15); shortening the duration (from four days to three); changing the format (by making it a co-ed event with top women golfers); and binning it entirely.

One potential change that hasn’t gotten due consideration is this: ownership.

The Presidents Cup belongs to the PGA Tour. It was created in the waning hours of Deane Beman’s tenure as commissioner and first staged under his successor, Tim Finchem, who was eager to mooch whatever revenue he could from the enthusiasm around team golf generated by the Ryder Cup. The Tour decides who captains both teams, who is eligible to play on both teams, and where the competition will take place. Golfers who defected to LIV — like Cameron Smith, Joaquin Niemann and Abraham Ancer — are ineligible, making what was a tough task nigh on impossible for the International team, though to be fair they were waxed with even more impressive line-ups before LIV.

Last year, the ex-player and now board member of PGA Tour Enterprises, Joe Ogilvie, sent his fellow Tour members a letter outlining the impact of accepting private investment, which happened months later. He listed a number of assets the Tour owned and mused on their worth and growth potential. He included the Presidents Cup and mentioned it again in a subsequent appearance on Golf Today. The event, Ogilvie seemed to be suggesting, had unrealized value. Which raises a delicate question: In whose hands?

If the Tour sold half of the Presidents Cup — and accepted having no influence over the International side — then new owners could establish fresh eligibility criteria, select captains, install dedicated management, assign resources, create a P&L and assume decision-making authority, including for overseas media rights and negotiations with venues outside the U.S. In short, do exactly what Europe does with the Ryder Cup.

Would that make things more competitive? It couldn’t hurt. And it would at least end the charade that the Presidents Cup is a global vehicle by actually making it so. Of the last five international venues, two were 30 miles from the U.S. border in Montreal and two more were in Melbourne, Australia — a marvelous city, but not exactly groundbreaking for those trying to evangelize golf around the world.

Perhaps the Strategic Sports Group chaps have run the numbers to arrive at a valuation of the Presidents Cup’s International component, but it’s surely nine figures and with better potential for long-term returns than any nine-figure LIV contract that expires after a few years. So who could buy it?

The most obvious candidate — and least appealing for those concerned with mundanities like human rights — is the Public Investment Fund of Saudi Arabia. But there are plenty of alternatives who are invested in golf and who preach a gospel of global growth.

One such man, South African billionaire Johann Rupert, is hosting the Dunhill Links Championship in St. Andrews this week. There’s Pawan Munjal, CEO of Hero MotoCorp and a familiar figure to fans through his relationship with Woods. Or Mexican tycoon Ricardo Salinas, who brought a WGC tournament to his homeland. Perhaps Abdullah Al Naboodah, an Emerati investor deeply involved with the DP World Tour, or Korean industrialist Jin Roy Ryu, who underwrote the ’15 Cup in Seoul. Heck, even Chinese-Thai businessman Chanchai Ruayrungruag, a colorful eccentric who purchased Wentworth Golf Club a decade ago and proceeded to oust many of its members. (I once attended an evening at which he elbowed China’s premier opera soprano aside on a Beijing stage so he could sing himself, the sound of which surely had every cat owner within earshot wondering if their pet was being garroted.)

That’s all to say there’s no shortage of astute businessmen who are confessed fanatics about golf and who might see value in an established platform with 30 years of history and a solvent partner in the PGA Tour. Unshackling the International side may be the best move to positively impact the Presidents Cup both as a competition and a commercial property, while simultaneously paying more than lip service to the goal of globalizing the sport in a meaningful manner.

One of those aforementioned golf-crazed billionaires ought to send Jay Monahan a copy of Richard Bach’s bestseller Jonathan Livingston Seagull and highlight his oft-quoted line: “If you love something, set it free.”

Dunhill Links effect provides hope in quest for golfing peace between PGA Tour, LIV Golf

Jon Rahm: “I won’t let myself believe anything until it is actually true. I hope so.”

Whatever you wanted to do at the Alfred Dunhill Links Championship, it was a lovely day to do it.

You may, for instance, have fancied seeing what all the fuss was about by following the PGA Tour commissioner, Jay Monahan, and the Saudi Public Investment Fund governor, Yasir Al-Rumayyan, as they were plonked in the same group of the Pro-Am affair at Carnoustie.

Then again, most casual observers peering on would probably have had no idea who these two gentlemen were, despite us mouth-frothing golf writers eagerly billing their appearance together as something akin to 007 playing with Auric bloomin’ Goldfinger.

In the on-going quest for peace in our golfing time, though, the cordial clatter and batter about the links has been viewed as another step in the right direction for a men’s professional game that remains so fractured, it just about needs a cast and splint.

While South Africa’s veteran campaigner Darren Fichardt set a scintillating pace at Kingsbarns with an 11-under 61, another South African, the Dunhill Links supremo Johann Rupert, was just as enthused by the genial scene involving two of global golf’s most powerful figures.

“I have known Jay (Monahan) for a very long time, and I have got to know his Excellency (Al-Rumayyan) as well and they both only have the best interests of golf at heart,” suggested Rupert. “We need to keep on having days like today. Golf is supposed to be a maker of friends.

“We have a war going on in Ukraine and a terrible situation in the Middle East and another war going on in Sudan and we argue about golf? Surely all we want to do is see the best players in the world playing together.”

In the grand scheme of life and all that. It’s not a bad old life, meanwhile, when you’re playing three of Scotland’s best links courses in beautiful autumnal weather.

Fichardt certainly enjoyed it. The 49-year-old posted his lowest competitive round since 2001 as he took advantage of the inviting, benign conditions and delivered a lively card which featured nine birdies and two eagles.

“That was sweet,” he said with a beam as a bright as a halogen headlamp after finishing a stroke ahead of Australia’s John Cameron.

“I had a really poor three-putt on my second hole and I was like ‘oh, my goodness, it’s going to be a grind today’. But then I made something like a 100-foot putt for eagle on the next hole and the train just kept on going.”

Scotsman David Law is well aware that he needs to get going too. While his compatriot, Scott Jamieson, opened with a fine nine-under 63 at Kingsbarns, Law finished just a shot behind him after a 64 over the same course.

At a lowly 141st on the Race to Dubai rankings, Law is running out of time in his battle keep his DP World Tour card.

With its whopping prize fund, though, the Dunhill Links has been the saviour of many a struggling Scot down the seasons and Law, a winner on the tour back in 2019, is hoping he too can give himself a timely tonic on home turf.

“I’m aware of the situation that I’m in,” said Law of his perilous position. “I need a big week, and this one is a fantastic opportunity. I know the golf I need to play, and this score was very pleasing.”

Jamieson, who had missed five of his last six cuts, revelled in a return to his native land and conjured an eagle and seven birdies in a neatly assembled round.

“What’s not to love?,” smiled the 40-year-old. “You’ve got Scotland, the sun is out, no wind. It’s pretty much the perfect day, isn’t it?”

Robert MacIntyre, who is partnering his dad, Dougie, in the pro-am team contest, opened with a five-under 67 at Carnoustie and was joined on that mark by Fifer, Connor Syme.

Most of the star attractions were over at Carnoustie with Rory McIlroy, who is teaming up with his old man Gerry, posting a three-under 69. “Definitely room for improvement there for both of the McIlroys,” he said with a wry grin.

Jon Rahm, the most high-profile defector to the LIV Golf series that is bankrolled by the aformentioned Al-Rumayyan, got up and running with a seven-under 65.

As for those on-going peace talks? “I feel like we’ve all gone down that road before and been mistaken,” said a cautious Rahm. “I won’t let myself believe anything until it is actually true. I hope so.”

We all live in hope, eh?

Yasir Al-Rumayyan, Jay Monahan paired together for pro-am at 2024 Alfred Dunhill Links as golf’s civil war continues

This will be the first time the two (and Guy Kinnings) are at the same event since the game’s civil war began.

LIV Golf’s Yasir Al-Rumayyan, PGA Tour Commissioner Jay Monahan and DP World Tour Chief Executive Officer Guy Kinnings are all expected to be at this week’s Alfred Dunhill Links Championship, a DP World Tour event contested over three of the most famous venues in golf: St. Andrews, Carnoustie and Kingsbarns, according to The Telegraph.

And in fact, Al-Rumayyan and Monahan are scheduled to play together in the pro-am, paired with PGA Tour-friendly Billy Horschel and Dean Burmester.

This will be the first time all three, Kinnings included, are at the same event since the game’s civil war began.

Three weeks ago, officials from the PGA Tour and Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund met in New York. The two parties are allegedly working on finalizing terms of a deal that would inject more than $1 billion from the PIF into PGA Tour Enterprises, the newly created for-profit entity launched earlier this year.

The field for the Dunhill Links is loaded with some of the biggest names in golf, including Rory McIlroy, Jon Rahm, Brooks Koepka, Tyrrell Hatton, Shane Lowry, Robert MacIntyre, Patrick Reed, Louis Oosthuizen and Billy Horschel.

It’s hard to imagine a better spot for all golf’s biggest players to come together.

Lynch: A PGA Tour-Saudi deal is closer, but opportunists will have time to take advantage while real fans wait

Even if deal terms emerge in the coming weeks, a long and bumpy road lies ahead.

“There are four types of men in the world: lovers, opportunists, lookers-on and imbeciles,” wrote the 19th-century French philosopher Hippolyte Taine. “The happiest are the imbeciles.” All are well represented in the chaos prevailing in men’s professional golf.

The imbeciles — usually more irate than happy — can be found in the drool-speckled ranks of LIV Golf’s social media trolls, but not exclusively. How else to explain a decision to hold the most recent meeting between the PGA Tour and the Saudi Arabian Public Investment Fund in New York City on September 11? PIF governor Yasir Al-Rumayyan wasn’t present, and so didn’t face the fraught question of whether to attend the 9/11 memorial ceremony that his government contributed so much to bringing about.

What of the lovers, opportunists and lookers-on?

The latter is the largest group, the PGA Tour’s journeymen, veterans and staff who aren’t deemed important enough to be updated on matters that will greatly impact their working lives. (There’s arguably a subcategory of lookers-away, former fans who are disengaging from golf, due at least in part to the division and diluted product.) Opportunists, meanwhile, are laboring to exhaustion.

Strategic Sports Group has been opportunistic — not in the pejorative sense — by investing $1.5 billion in a sport that is under-leveraged. The Saudis too, by identifying what makes golf penetrable for sportswashing: players who don’t have contracts but do have a delusional notion of their market worth. The DP World Tour can also be included. It benefitted from a lucrative alliance when the PGA Tour needed to scope the rising Saudi tide, and now does little to quash speculation that it might be an alternative for the PIF if a deal isn’t reached with the Americans. And of course, Greg Norman, who finally roped a dope willing to finance his grievances, and whose insistence that LIV is thriving has as much credibility as tales of canine suppers in Springfield, Ohio.

More from Eamon Lynch: Jay Monahan won’t talk about a Saudi deal, but one comment showed how things have shifted in his favor

But none have been more opportunistic than PGA Tour golfers. They’ve secured previously unimaginable pay for working in an underperforming product, grabbed control in a governance shakeup amid the aftershocks of the Framework Agreement, and are playing power games by creating their own marketing events, safe in the knowledge that the Tour lacks the leverage over members that it enjoyed during the imperial commissariat of Tim Finchem.

The game is ripe with the stench of every man for himself.

So what of the lovers? That’s you, golf fans. And right now, the thing you love is making it awfully tough to maintain your affection, even for those who aren’t overly troubled by the prospect of Saudi investment being mainstreamed. How long before a new normal is established and the political and economic narratives diminish in this sport?

Talk to enough people familiar with the state of negotiations between the PGA Tour and the PIF and it’s clear progress is happening, but uncertainty remains. Not least the timeframe governing a Department of Justice review of any agreement. Assuming that the presidential election doesn’t lead to a stubby Cheeto thumb being placed on the scale, that process could take more than a year. In hopes of hastening it, the Tour has constantly updated Justice officials on what they’re considering and addressed any concerns raised. But it’s unclear if the parties could seek some manner of preliminary green light from the DOJ in advance of an announcement, nor even how detailed deal terms must be to pass muster. Two things can be assured: players will not go backward on what they’re earning and LIV will be repackaged rather than retired, since regulators would likely see the alternatives as anticompetitive.

Despite Rory McIlroy’s public suggestion that the onus is on PGA Tour officials to get moving, it’s the PIF that will most impact whether a deal is realized. A Justice Department review will almost certainly involve requests for discovery materials similar to those the Saudis refused to submit during antitrust litigation, and which they’ve declined to hand over to a U.S. Senate committee for a year. Sources close to the negotiations say there’s clear intent by the PIF to avoid establishing a transparency precedent that might shine a light on its other investments in the U.S., known and stealth. So what level of compliance will prove sufficient for the U.S. government? It won’t get 100 percent, but how far shy of that will it settle for?

Which is to say that even if deal terms emerge in the coming weeks — not implausible, based on people I’ve talked to — a long and bumpy road lies ahead. Which promises to leave lovers waiting, imbeciles slabbering and lookers-on idling, all while giving opportunists more time to better angle themselves to the trough.

Who ends up shortchanged with the lack of PGA Tour-PIF information? Just the fans

By not answering questions about the split and efforts to reunite men’s golf, Monahan adds to the frustration.

PGA Tour Commissioner Jay Monahan delivered his annual State of the Tour address Wednesday before the first round of the Tour Championship, the season-ending event in Atlanta.

Monahan talked about innovations the Tour is making in production of Tour events, talked about players being more engaged as equity in the Tour and how strong the Tour’s schedule is with a balance of signature events and full-field events.

But the question that many golf fans wanted answered remained unanswered: When is men’s professional golf going to be united again after two years of the split between the PGA Tour and the LIV Tour?

It’s not that reporters didn’t ask plenty of questions about how negotiations are going with the Saudi Arabian Public Investment Fund. It’s not like reporters didn’t ask about what negotiations are taking place 15 months after the initial announcement of a framework agreement with the PIF, if there is a deadline for negotiations or if the Tour has decided on a path for players to return from the LIV Tour if their contracts with the PIF come to an end. It’s just that tour officials provided no answers to those questions.

Monahan and those around him simply skirted the issue, mostly falling back on the idea of not wanting to negotiate in public and saying that the negotiations are complex and will proceed at their own pace. Those answers might be fine for a boardroom, but it is not great when you are trying to convince fans to continue to watch a product that is not as strong as it was a year ago.

The Tour might dispute that statement, but then again the Tour a year ago had Jon Rahm as a member before he moved to LIV. Bryson DeChambeau isn’t on the PGA Tour anymore, either, and he happens to have won the U.S. Open in June. The PGA Tour has elite players who are having terrific years, like Scottie Scheffler, Xander Schauffele and Rory McIlroy. But the Tour would be stronger with Rahm and DeChambeau and maybe one or two other LIV players.

Fans need more information

I still run into people who say they are far less interested in the PGA Tour since the split with LIV that started in 2023. Too many people are still saying they watch less golf than they have in the past. They are not watching LIV golf, either, if you believe the minuscule television ratings for that tour. One or two people I talk to say they just don’t watch PGA Tour golf at all anymore, limiting their viewing to the major championships. Ratings for PGA Tour events seemed to crater early in the year but have rallied this summer. That still doesn’t mean the Tour is thriving with some fans after the LIV split.

By not answering questions about the split and efforts to reunite men’s golf, Monahan adds to the frustration of some fans. Most fans don’t care about tour equity ownership for the golfers or increased purses or changes in title sponsors. They do care about which golfers are playing in a given week. Monahan and his staff did nothing to clear any of that up.

It’s possible that the PGA Tour is burning the midnight oil in negotiations, that emails and text messages are flying back and forth between Ponte Vedra Beach, Fla. and Saudi Arabia. It’s possible that the PGA Tour in 2026 – it’s likely too late for changes in 2025 – is being shaped right now.

But the fans can’t know that without better answers than, “We don’t want to negotiate in public.” And the fans deserve at least some information about where their sport is headed, at least if the fans are being asked to continue their allegiance to the sport. Fans might not be investing money into the tour like the Strategic Sports Group or the title sponsors of each tournament. But they are being asked to invest their time in watching the sport and their emotions in rooting for top players.

The PGA Tour needs to pay off that investment with more detailed information about the future of the sport.

Larry Bohannan is the golf writer for The Desert Sun. You can contact him at (760) 778-4633 or at larry.bohannan@desertsun.com. Follow him on Facebook or on Twitter at @larry_bohannan. Support local journalism. Subscribe to The Desert Sun.

Lynch: Jay Monahan won’t talk about a Saudi deal, but one comment showed how things have shifted in his favor

Jay Monahan’s groundhog days lack lobster, piña coladas and escapades worthy of frisky marine mammals.

ATLANTA — ”I was in the Virgin Islands once. I met a girl. We ate lobster, drank piña coladas. At sunset we made love like sea otters,” Bill Murray rants about the repetitiveness of his existence in the movie “Groundhog Day.” “That was a pretty good day. Why couldn’t I get that day over and over and over?”

Jay Monahan’s groundhog days also lack lobster, piña coladas and escapades worthy of frisky marine mammals. Instead, his involve press conferences in which he repeatedly declines to answer questions about the one subject folks wish to hear from him on: the state of negotiations with the Saudi Arabian Public Investment Fund. Wednesday brought another of those at East Lake Golf Club during the commissioner’s press briefing at the Tour Championship, the transcript of which will show considerable overlap with his last one, at the Players Championship in March, and with his appearance here last year. That Monahan has actually offered more detail on the talks than his PIF counterpart, Yasir Al-Rumayyan, counts for naught since MBS’s bag man doesn’t make himself available for questions and is held to different standards in many matters, not least transparency and accountability.

There were several topics Monahan was eager to discuss — his themes were “engagement, momentum and innovation” — but the focus was, predictably, on what he didn’t say. Or more accurately, what he wouldn’t say.

“As it relates to any details of the conversations that we’re having with the Public Investment Fund, I’m not going to disclose details. I’m not going to get into specifics.”

“I’m not going to negotiate details in public or disclose details or specifics. All I can say is that conversations continue, and they’re productive.”

“When you get into productive conversations, that enhances the likelihood of positive outcomes, and that enhances the spirit of those very conversations. I think that’s where things stand.”

The fact that Monahan won’t talk doesn’t mean there isn’t something to talk about. There’s a difference between being evasive and simply not being expansive. Sources familiar with the current state of the PIF discussions suggest there’s occasional activity but that any particulars are being laboriously lawyered. It’s also apparent that Monahan concerns himself with just one constituency: the Tour’s Policy Board, or more specifically, the player-directors on that body. He knows that unilateral decisions are beyond his remit as commissioner thanks to the trilateral commission that created the controversial Framework Agreement. He’s clearly uninterested in the two precincts most vocal about wanting to see action on a deal: golf media (thirsty for new material), and LIV players (desperate to be insulated from the consequences of their decisions).

That Monahan isn’t hearing a clamor for progress from his own members indicates how the balance of power has subtly shifted in the Tour’s favor.

Conventional wisdom has long held that a delay in reaching a deal is disadvantageous to the Tour, that time allows LIV more opportunity to poach players, that time bleeds out the Tour’s product, that time amplifies discontent among fans, sponsors and partners.

But one comment that passed largely unnoticed in Monahan’s prepared remarks hinted at a shifting reality. “We now have the structure and the resources we need to define the future of professional golf on our terms and the significant support of a world-class group of investors,” he said, referring to Strategic Sports Group, which injected $1.5 billion into the Tour in January.

Humorist Will Rogers once described diplomacy as the art of saying “nice doggie” until you find a rock. In SSG, Monahan found his rock. It provided him something the Tour didn’t have a year ago: $1.5 billion worth of options.

To be sure, there are weeks when the PGA Tour’s product struggles to breathe, but by comparison, LIV’s is in hospice care. It has an audience that could be comfortably accommodated in one of East Lake’s hospitality suites (as long as there’s wifi for online trolling), zero market traction, expensive contract renewals looming, all while being hostage to capricious internal politics in Riyadh. Monahan can be forgiven for thinking his hand is strengthened as time passes.

Only when a PIF deal is announced does the clock start ticking on the inevitable and time-consuming Department of Justice review as to whether it’s anti-competitive. Monahan must know that the DOJ will almost certainly demand PIF turn over the same discovery materials it refused to submit during the original antitrust litigation against the PGA Tour, and which it won’t give to a U.S. Senate subcommittee. Why would the Tour break into a sprint when running a marathon in which its only competitor has more hurdles and potholes to navigate?

For all the times he chose to remain circumspect today on the prospects of a deal, Monahan gamely tried to lay out a vision for the Tour’s future. There’s a plan to address fan frustrations (though it’s not readily apparent how he can or will ameliorate broadcaster angst over ratings slumps). It remains to be seen what improvements or innovations his “Fan Forward” strategy will actually deliver, but its existence at least signals awareness that the Tour’s most pissed-off constituency is being heard, something Monahan promised to address back in March.

“We’re moving forward at speed and focused on what we can control, because that’s what we owe to our fans,” the commish said.

He didn’t announce $1.5 billion worth of innovation though, which raises intriguing questions about the Tour’s future ambitions or acquisitions with its nest egg. That too would be a sensitive subject, and questions he probably plans to leave unanswered at his next “State of the Tour” press conference, seven months from now.

Lynch: The Open exposes the risk in building golf around superstars who don’t show up

Depth equals strength, not dilution.

TROON, Scotland — It’s been almost 40 years since the debut of the musical “Chess,” and while it was ostensibly about, well, chess, and set mostly in Thailand, one lyric has currency at the 152nd Open on the dilapidated west coast of Scotland.

One night in Bangkok makes the hard man humble
Not much between despair and ecstasy
One night in Bangkok and the tough guys tumble

This might be the only time you’ll ever see Troon cross-referenced with Bangkok, but this week has been a pointed reminder of how capricious and cruel elite-level professional golf can be. Many players who arrived at Royal Troon in form have already departed, while some long thought washed up are still working. The young and studly are licking their wounds, the old and infirm are applying heating pads to loosen up for their weekend tee times.

Because links golf is seldom played, and the weather is more impactful than at any other major, it’s easy to write off results in golf’s oldest championship as anomalies, blips not reflective of the norm, a self-contained sideshow that lacks real meaning for the broader game. Players can have that luxury of compartmentalizing — and probably need it — but the decision-makers currently shaping the future of the game don’t, and they ought to be paying attention to what’s happening 4,000 miles east of Ponte Vedra Beach (and 3,000 east of Fenway).

British OpenLeaderboard | Photos | How to watch

Because this Open is testament to the danger of constructing a product that’s rigged in favor of a small cohort of star players who then don’t actually deliver on the promise that’s been sold.

That’s the essence of sport, of course. Buying a ticket to a Lakers game doesn’t guarantee a fan will see LeBron James in full flight, nor even at all. But the odds are good that when the result is final, the star will be center stage. By comparison, golf is predictable only in its unpredictability.

A few things can be wagered on with certainty. Like Scottie Scheffler being in the mix, or Shane Lowry’s performance improving as the weather deteriorates, or John Daly missing the weekend (or going AWOL earlier in many cases). But the Open has showcased ample stories that seemed so improbable as the week began.

Take Daniel Brown, a little-known English professional whose 61st place finish at last week’s Genesis Scottish Open was his only made cut in more than four months. On Saturday, he played in the final group of a major — his first-ever major. Yet he showed up on Sky Sports’ set five hours before his tee time — evidence of a willingness to contribute, a lack of entitlement or a need to market himself, depending on your disposition. His countryman, Matt Wallace, missed the cut last week and during an emotional interview seemed about as low as a golfer can get. But he’s still here, and still working.

Matteo Manassero, the former child prodigy of European golf, who fell into an abyss that included stops on the Alps mini-tour, only to earn his way back to his first Open in a decade, is still just 31 years old. “Things also can turn around quickly,” the Italian said after making his first major cut since the 2016 U.S. Open.

2024 British Open
Ludvig Aberg reacts on the 18th green during day two of The 152nd Open Championship at Royal Troon. The World No. 4 missed the cut. (Andrew Redington/Getty Images)

Darren Clarke also hasn’t made a major cut since ’16, the last time the Open was at Royal Troon. But as Northern Ireland’s most celebrated golfer flew to Portugal for a vacation after missing the cut, Rory McIlroy’s former mentor is chugging along in his 32nd appearance. Clarke loves this event, but the 2011 champion confessed on Friday evening that 2025 might be his last, tempted to sign off at Royal Portrush, close to where he grew up.

“I know I’ve earned my spot in the field until I’m 60,” he said, “but I’d hate to think that I was stopping some 19 or 20-year-old lad from living his dream.”

Nor is Clarke the only regular from the geriatric circuit who survived the carnage of Troon. When Alex Cejka last appeared on the first page of a major leaderboard, George W. Bush still had two years left in the White House, while Padraig Harrington’s irrepressible love of the game keeps him working when most of his contemporaries left for the broadcast booth or the bar.

The walk-on actors are delivering their lines in this production. What of the leading men?

Ten of the top 20 players in the Official World Golf Ranking are gone, blown off course and out of town by the challenging conditions. Major winners, runners-up and contenders dispatched without ceremony, including DeChambeau. McIlroy. Aberg, Hovland and Woods. The PGA Tour could have filled a charter jet Friday night from the ranks of winners this season who are surplus to requirements in Scotland.

That potential passenger manifest ought to be read carefully by Jay Monahan and SSG group’s John Henry, who are ultimately responsible for shaping and financing the Tour’s future. Depth equals strength, not dilution. The capriciousness of golf needs to be embraced because it can’t be litigated away in a misguided attempt to engineer a sport around a handful of superstars — a questionable strategy anyway when fans suspect that many of them aren’t quite the charitable, puppy-loving good guys they were promised. The few guys who sell tickets — really a precious few — can’t be guaranteed a spot at the trophy ceremony unless you’re willing to thoroughly bastardize the concept of meritocracy. Some weeks (even some of the biggest weeks) just turn out to be more about the Davids than the Goliaths, and the best weeks are about both. This is one of the best.

If they want predictability in the product, only one man in the field at Royal Troon delivered it. John Daly was a WD, as he was at the PGA Championship, and numerous times previously. It’s been a dozen years since he last played the weekend in a major, 14 years since he finished inside the top 50, 19 since he broke the top 20, and 29 since he had a top 10. But even that show has only two years left to run.