Why is a handicap so important? See how the USGA has made it easier than ever to get one

Those with handicaps play more rounds, spend more on golf, and consider themselves to be passionate about the game.

(Editor’s note: This is the first of a four-part series explaining the mission of the United States Golf Association, all in advance of the U.S. Women’s Open, the U.S. Open, the U.S. Adaptive Open and the U.S. Amateur. The USGA, which governs the game of golf in Mexico and the United States, serves a number of functions. What exactly is the USGA? Why is the organization important? This series delves into these questions and others. This initial article looks at handicapping, which the USGA provides, and how it helps to unify players.)  

Ever since the World Handicap System was established on Jan. 1, 2020, the USGA has been on a mission to make obtaining a handicap easy and accessible.

“Four months ago, it wasn’t that easy,” said Steve Edmonson, the USGA’s managing director of handicapping and course rating.

That may have something to do with the fact that the number of golfers with handicaps – 2.86 million in 2021 – has been static for the better part of the last two decades. But the USGA has instituted several popular features to the Golf Handicap Information Network (GHIN), a service offered by the USGA to allied golf associations worldwide. By addressing the wants of its users, the GHIN app continues to push boundaries and the USGA is bullish that the percent of card-carrying handicap golfers will increase 50 percent — to 75 percent of golfers — said Gareth Londt, the USGA’s managing director of product, data and technology.

New system makes it easier

Beginning in February, any golfer in the U.S. can sign up for a Handicap Index by visiting USGA.org/getahandicap. Previously, you had to find your state and regional golf association. In Ohio alone, there are five state and regional associations to consider. The USGA will now direct users to the appropriate AGA.

Moreover, new golfers are issued a handicap faster, needing only to post scores for 54 holes in either nine- or 18-hole increments. Previously, the USGA didn’t issue a handicap; it was issued instead by a golf club. It was a fragmented structure. Now the USGA has a national pulpit to promote handicaps that beforehand it lacked.

“There’s no excuse,” Londt said. “Everyone has an internet browser, everyone has a mobile phone, and everyone is connected through the world wide web. Three clicks and you can have a handicap. There’s no longer the need to get off your sofa and get in a car and drive to a green-grass facility. You can do it while you are watching the U.S. Open.”

In a 12-week period and without heavy promotion, 30,000 golfers already have registered for a handicap.

Jack Nicklaus and Arnold Palmer
Jack Nicklaus and Arnold Palmer look over a scorecard during a practice round in 1974. Photo by Associated Press

The USGA’s GHIN product has some competitors but of the 58 Allied Golf Associations, only two don’t use GHIN products. The USGA licenses the handicap indexes to the AGAs for a nominal fee (free to juniors) and those AGAs are allowed to mark up costs based on their perceived market value in their own community.

The USGA also set a high watermark of no more than $80 across the US (in some states it costs less). The money generated from handicapping is intended to fuel local programs that engage golfers.

The history of handicaps

The USGA’s adoption of the handicap system dates to Oct. 11, 1911, the year of the first Indianapolis 500, back when Cy Young wasn’t an award but a pitcher who had just notched his 511th and final victory. The handicap system has become one of golf’s great distinctions, whereby participants of different skill – whether male or female, young or old, and even from separate tees – can compete fairly and equitably. In no other sport is it feasible for players of all skill level to play on equal footing.

In golf, a handicap is a measure of a player’s potential. For some, it is proof of progress, for others of incompetence and the deterioration of skill. It is a golfer’s photo I.D., allowing admittance to local, regional and national competition.

The system has continued to evolve ever since and received its latest reboot in 2020. Golfers no longer have to wait two weeks for their updated index. Now it is updated on a daily basis or faster than one can lose a sleeve of balls. Last year, it added hole-by-hole scoring via mobile devices while you play, which reveals how many drives hit the fairway, how many putts per round and other stats that can be tracked.

More recently, a distance-measuring device and green-reading materials that were banned at the elite level through a new Model Local Rule, but comply with the game of golf and can be beneficial to the recreational game are gaining in usage. (A free piece and an extended version for golfers who want to upgrade are available.)

2021 U.S. Amateur
Young fans watch the action on the 7th hole during the round of 16 at the 2021 U.S. Amateur at Oakmont Country Club in Oakmont, Pa. on Friday, Aug. 13, 2021. (Jason Miczek/USGA)

In early June, the USGA will be adding an Apple watch function that will allow golfers to see front-middle-back yardages to the green and allow golfers to input their hole-by-hole scores and record stats. It will be especially appreciated at clubs that don’t allow phones on the course. What do golfers want most? Surveys conducted with their customers indicate it’s data. While there are numerous products that do this, the USGA is anxious to provide these features in one app.

The USGA has poured $100 million in handicapping over the last 5 years – inclusive of WHS and GHIN –with the lion’s share directed to the GHIN/innovation/technology side. The handicap index is a key cog in the USGA’s effort to unify the game.

Handicaps equal engagement

A survey conducted by Jon Last of Sports & Leisure Research Group, which provides custom research and market analysis, found that those with handicaps significantly out-index those without across key demographics, engagement with golf and related behaviors. For instance, those with handicaps play more rounds, spend more on golf, follow the game more closely and consider themselves to be “passionate” about golf.

As a result, the USGA is motivated to grow the number of golfers with handicaps. But there are still too many golfers who don’t have a handicap because they believe they don’t compete in tournaments, they aren’t good enough or don’t play enough.

Part of the plan is to demystify why a handicap is needed in the first place, and that begins with changing the nomenclature that a handicap is only needed by elite golfers to play in competitions.

“There’s a perception that you have to be a good player or competing in competitions,” said Edmondson. “That’s just not true.”

The USGA knows that the average handicap for a male is 14.1 and 27.7 for a female. Ninety percent of golfers with handicaps are male. It is pouring resources into attracting a new audience, particularly with women – the move to 54.0 as the max handicap embraces high-handicap females – juniors and public golfers.

2021 U.S. Girls' Junior
Bailey Davis react to her tee shot on the 16th hole during the quarterfinals at the 2021 U.S. Girls’ Junior at Columbia Country Club in Chevy Chase, Maryland, on Friday, July 16, 2021. (Kathryn Riley/USGA)

Edmondson said he sees an opportunity to look at off-course play and promote the importance of handicaps beyond competitive means. In the not-too-distant future, the USGA will debut a “Play Games” feature, which will integrate match play, Stableford scoring and other USGA-approved formats.

“It’s all interconnected to get more people to use the app and grow the community,” Edmondson said. “You need a handicap to be part of the community.”

[listicle id=778165409]

[mm-video type=playlist id=01es6rjnsp3c84zkm6 player_id=none image=https://golfweek.usatoday.com/wp-content/plugins/mm-video/images/playlist-icon.png]

Golf handicaps: Just how good are your favorite celebrities and athletes?

Thanks to the USGA’s Golf Handicap and Information Network (GHIN), we were able to compile these celebrity and athlete handicaps.

Golf is an incredibly difficult sport to play, even for the professionals at times.

That said, if you’ve ever watched events like the Pebble Beach Pro-Am or the American Century Celebrity Golf Championship out in Lake Tahoe, chances are you were surprised at the level of celebrity talent. That begs the question: Just how good are they out on the course?

Thanks to the USGA’s Golf Handicap and Information Network (GHIN), we were able to compile a list of the handicaps of some of your favorite celebrities and athletes.

Here’s how they hit ’em. (Note: Handicaps are as of Nov. 2, 2020)

Schupak: My love/hate relationship with golf’s handicap system

Golf’s handicap system is one of golf’s great distinctions, but the new World Handicap System will never be an exact science.

I have a confession to make.

I have a love/hate relationship with golf’s handicap system, which is new and improved in 2020.

Apparently I dropped to a 6.6 from a 6.8 without hitting a shot with the recent implementation of the World Handicap System, but in general I love that it allows me to play – in theory – a fair match with my dad, a 13.1, even though we’re not playing the same tees and I can finally beat him straight up some of the time. And I love love love (have I made that clear enough) that it allows me to have a prayer of a chance against my wife, a 3.5 who is the stick in the family.

Handicapping is one of golf’s more important institutions – a system that enables players of different skills to compete fairly with each other. In no other sport is it feasible for players of all skill level to play on equal footing. Good luck stepping into the batter’s box to face the 100-mph fastball of New York Yankees closer Aroldis Chapman. But with the right number of strokes and summoning our “A” game, we all could give World No. 1 Brooks Koepka a run for his money.

As with most things with the sport, we have the Scots to thank for this concept. According to the history books, there are written references to handicapping as early as 1687. In Great Britain, the first governing authority to establish a nationwide system was the Ladies Golf Union.

The USGA formulated the basis of the handicapping system used today at a meeting on Oct. 11, 1911, at Baltusrol Golf Club. The system has continued to evolve ever since and received its latest reboot on Jan. 1. You can read about all the changes here.

I love that we’ve left the Dark Ages and no longer have to wait two weeks to find out how much damage that fluke low round is going to do to our index. Now our handicap indexes are updated faster than I can lose a sleeve of balls. That alone makes the introduction of the World Handicap System a winner in my book.

But there’s still a lot I don’t like. Topping that list is getting pencil-whipped at the first tee. I hate anyone who says, “I’m about a 15.” You either know your handicap or you don’t. It’s sad how few golfers actually have an official handicap. It’s easier than ever to get started, so do yourself a favor and get one – that’s my public service announcement for handicaps. It’s kind of like driving a car without a license. You wouldn’t do that, would you? If you want to play a match with strokes, you should have a handicap, plain and simple; otherwise, let’s stick to playing straight up.

Interestingly, when I brought up my hatred of “the about guy” to my wife, she mentioned that I sometimes am guilty of doing this, and I guess I’m guilty as charged. Allow me to explain.

I play a lot of what you’d call “hit n’ giggle” golf – scrambles and best-ball games where you try to get home in two on a par 5 or go for broke on the drivable par 4 or take some crazy angle off the tee because there’s nothing to lose. Sometimes you just pick up or don’t bother hitting that knee-knocker after your partner is in. It speeds up play.

Also, playing three or six holes before the sun goes down is my jam, a reward for a hard day’s work.

In short, I play a bunch of golf that for one reason or another never gets factored into calculating my handicap. So, sometimes in the first tee negotiation with my wife I will say I’m “about a 9” even though I know full well I’m a 7. I’m just trying to factor in those uncounted rounds and make it a fair fight.

Which brings me to another thing I hate about the handicap system: It is never going to be an exact science.

Dean Knuth, the Pope of Slope (which is one of my favorite golf nicknames) who helped invent slope rating in 1987 for the USGA, already says the new system is flawed.

If he’s right, that’s unsettling because my wife treats the handicap index as if it’s the 11th Commandment – thou must follow the handicap. This summer, until GHIN corrected this madness, I was getting only 1 per side. Here’s the thing: Beating her getting only one shot felt twice as good as getting 2, though it won’t stop me from groveling for 3.

The handicap system is a very un-American concept, dare I say, bordering on Marxist in nature. It rewards mediocrity and penalizes the people who have worked hard to be good at the game and those who are most committed to improvement. There seem to be too many golfers content to remain a 20 handicap and clean up at the club’s member-guest.

I’m not even going to touch on the systemic cheating that goes on in the club scrambles and pro-ams I play in other than to say to the teams that turn in scores that would make Korea’s Kim Jong-il blush: Really? Do you need to win that badly? Did your parents not hug you as a child?

Other than that, I love the handicap system. Long live net birdie – as long as I’m the one stroking.

Editor’s note: Adam Schupak has a long history of calling out, “Four for three!” as a putt falls. The editorial staff of Golfweek tries to not hold that against him.