Studs and duds from Chargers’ preseason loss to Cowboys

Taking a look at the best and worst performers from the Chargers’ preseason loss to the Cowboys.

The Chargers fell to 0-2 in the preseason after a 32-18 loss to the Cowboys Saturday night.

While the game was overall a sloppy affair, there were still a few individual players who made their mark on the game.

Here are the studs and duds from Saturday’s game: 

Stud: WR Joshua Palmer

After a quiet week last week, Palmer balled out on Saturday. His chemistry with Easton Stick was off to start the game, as Stick’s interception came on a play targeting the second-year receiver. Once the offense trotted back onto the field, it was the Canadian’s time to shine. Palmer hauled in a 41-yard reception on the next drive, adding another 26-yard catch later on, to get the Chargers into field goal range. On the next drive, Palmer took a screen 18 yards to the house for his lone touchdown of the game. He looks like a legitimate threat as the team’s third wide receiver and will only get more opportunities as the defense is forced to account for Keenan Allen and Mike Williams, neither of whom have taken a snap in the preseason.

Dud: CB Brandon Sebastian

Sebastian got picked on all day, frequently ending plays out of position or on the ground. It’s a second consecutive tough week for the undrafted free agent corner, who also had a pass interference that wiped out a JT Woods interception against the Rams. With Ja’Sir Taylor and Deane Leonard manning the fifth and sixth cornerback spots as of now, Sebastian seems like a long shot to even make the practice squad at this point.

Stud: EDGE Jamal Davis II

With Ty Shelby and Emeke Egbule both out due to injury this week, it was Davis’ chance to distance himself in the competition for the fourth edge rusher spot, and distance himself he did. The former CFL player looked like a physical force in the run game, shedding blocks for stops at the line multiple times throughout the game. He’s far from refined as a pass rusher, but the intensity and physicality he plays with cannot be ignored. It’s also worth noting that Davis looked like a sure tackler; despite Egbule’s seven pressures last week, he also missed four tackles. Davis’ proficiency in that area could be the difference between making the team and not.

Dud: OT Zack Bailey

Given the opportunity to start at left tackle over Foster Sarell, Bailey looked lost for most of the game. He gave up the pressure that led to Easton Stick’s interception to open the game, then went anonymous until the fourth quarter. Moved to the right side of the line, Bailey gave up two sacks of Chase Daniel, a major factor as to why the Chargers could not move the ball. It certainly looks as though Sarell will be taking his second team tackle job back next week, while Bailey now likely faces a nail-biting next few days hoping his name is not among the wave of cuts due by this Tuesday.

Stud: WR Michael Bandy

If Bandy doesn’t make the final roster, there will be a full-blown riot among the fan base. After hauling in seven receptions for 73 yards and a touchdown in last week’s game, Bandy followed it up with an eight reception, 69-yard performance, adding a garbage-time touchdown late in the fourth quarter. Bandy once again looked like a seasoned veteran against zone coverage, finding soft spots play after play after play. At this point, Bandy is forcing the Chargers to keep six wide receivers because he is not getting through waivers onto the practice squad. 

Dud: WR Joe Reed

With Bandy again looking like an NFL-caliber player, it was up to Reed to match him as he did against the Rams. However, the 2020 fifth-round pick was only targeted once in the passing game after a 4-catch, 61-yard performance last week. Reed also had a few hiccups on special teams, including a bobbled kick return in the fourth quarter that left the Chargers with a disadvantageous field position. With DeAndre Carter firmly entrenched as the team’s returner and Bandy handling punt returns this week, it looks more and more like Reed is playing catch-up in the battle for a roster spot.

Stud: DL Carlo Kemp

Kemp was all over the field in the second half, beginning with a pass deflection that probably should have been an interception late in the third quarter. As the fourth quarter got rolling, Kemp fought his way through blocks to pressure Cowboys QB Ben DiNucci, who fumbled the ball as he scrambled away from the threat. After recovering, DiNucci found a receiver, who Kemp tracked down at the line of scrimmage. Later that drive, Kemp found himself unblocked and made his way across the formation for a run stop at the line. It was a stellar performance for a player who was in the USFL this spring, and you’d certainly think that he’s upped his chances of making the practice squad with a showing like that.

Dud: Special teams

Giving it to the whole unit here because things looked as sloppy as ever. It seems that even new coordinator Ryan Ficken hasn’t found a way to cure the Chargers curse just yet, as just about everything but the field goal team looked out of sorts in this one. We touched on Reed’s miscue on the fourth-quarter kickoff return. LA also allowed Cowboys returner KaVontae Turpin, to run back a kickoff and a punt return for touchdowns in this one, the latter coming after rookie Deane Leonard missed a tackle at the catch point. Turpin is an excellent returner with undeniable NFL talent, but that only hammers home the point that the special teams unit will need to improve to avoid putting the rest of the team in difficult spots, as they did today.

Breaking down the Chargers’ undrafted free agent signings

Following their eight selections in the 2022 NFL draft, the Los Angeles Chargers signed 14 undrafted free agents.

Following their eight selections in the 2022 NFL draft, the Chargers signed 14 undrafted free agents.

Here’s the full list followed by a quick breakdown for each player.

QB Brandon Peters, Illinois

Peters is a sixth-year senior who began his career at Michigan as a four-star recruit. Injuries took their toll and resulted in a transfer to Illinois, where he started for three seasons. In 2021, he went 91 of 169 for 1,170 yards, 7 TDs, and 4 interceptions in nine games played. Peters has an above-average arm that he’s willing to take chances with, but he’s an early bailer from the pocket when the rush threatens to get near.

RB Kevin Marks Jr., Buffalo

Marks was long the complementary back to Commanders RB Jaret Patterson at Buffalo. 2021 was his lone season as a starter, with 414 yards and 5 TDs on 108 carries in 9 games to his name. While his testing numbers are average across the board, he does have the straight-line speed and quick feet to keep defenders honest. Marks is a back who’s always looking to hit a home run, and his development will center around teaching him that singles and doubles are worth just as much.

RB Leddie Brown, West Virginia

A former four-star recruit, Brown made 2020’s All-Big 12 first team after a 1,010-yard season. He followed that up with 1,065 in 2021, becoming just the 12th Mountaineer to log back-to-back 1,000-yard seasons. What relegated him to the ranks of the undrafted is a lack of speed – his 4.64 40 is in just the 42nd percentile for running backs. Brown is a throwback rusher who lacks dynamism but will drag tacklers for miles before finally hitting the dirt. He’s also a potential fullback convert if he can show value on special teams.

WR Trevon Bradford, Oregon State

With 151 career receptions for 1,904 yards and 14 TDs as well as 26 kick returns for 263 yards, the 5’9” Bradford joins the Bolts as a potential developmental slot receiver and kickoff return specialist. He lacks the size to win outside on a consistent basis but possesses sturdy hands and build-up speed that makes him more of a deep threat than his pedestrian 4.52 40 would suggest. He’s also one of the better ball trackers down the field from this draft class.

TE Stone Smartt, Old Dominion

One of the best names in this year’s class, Smartt started his career as a quarterback, first at Riverside City College and then in 2019 at Old Dominion. When the Monarchs’ season was canceled in 2020, Smartt used the opportunity to move to wide receiver, logging 17 receptions for 167 yards in 2021. Now, the 6’4”, 226 pound Smartt will move to tight end, where his 4.62 40, 4.19 shuttle, and 40” vertical provide some optimism about his developmental potential.

TE Erik Krommenhoek, USC

Krommenhoek had 39 career receptions for 335 yards and 3 touchdowns across 23 games. This type of production usage should clue you in to the fact that he’s spent most of his career as a blocker. He’s more than eager to engage in that phase of the game, whether it be stacking defensive linemen or climbing to the second level to decleat linebackers. He’s a stiff route runner who’s still working on finding the soft spots in zones the way that successful NFL TEs with similar athletic profiles are able to. There’s room for his frame to add more muscle, which could up his power as a blocker a bit.

OT Andrew Trainer, William & Mary

Trainer has walked a winding road to Los Angeles. Originally committed to Virginia as a tight end, the 6’7” Trainer flipped to Illinois when Cavaliers coach Mike London was fired. The Illini shifted him to offensive tackle and he chose to transfer to William & Mary, where London was his coach. As a 2021 All-CAA selection at left tackle, it’s fair to call Trainer an FCS standout despite his complete lack of buzz as a prospect. It’s a developmental depth play at tackle for the Chargers.

C Isaac Weaver, Old Dominion

Weaver is a 6’6”, 310-pound lineman who jumped at elite levels but lacks either speed or agility. He’s played every offensive line position except right tackle, but I have him down at center, where his lack of quicks won’t get him exposed as much as it will at other spots. I have some questions about his power, but perhaps those can be remedied with the aid of an NFL strength program. With a prototypical size for the line and plenty of potential to grow, Weaver is an intriguing take for Los Angeles.

EDGE Ty Shelby, UL Monroe

A bit undersized at 6’4”, 249 lbs, Shelby makes up for his stature with speed (98.8th percentile 10-yard split) and power (83rd percentile on the bench). While starting 19 games over 44 appearances, Shelby racked up 146 total tackles, 25 for loss, 12 sacks, and a forced fumble. Shelby has compared his own play to that of Chargers star Joey Bosa, and now he’ll work for an opportunity to learn from the four-time Pro Bowler full-time.

LB Tyreek Maddox-William, Rutgers

A five-time Academic All-Big Ten selection, Maddox-Williams started in every game in 2018 and 2019 before being supplanted in the opening lineup for his final two seasons. In 48 career games as a Scarlet Knight, he logged 193 total tackles, 14.5 for loss, 2 sacks, 7 pass deflections, and 2 forced fumbles. He’s an instinctual linebacker with plenty of experience in coverage who struggles to stack and shed blockers due to a lack of functional strength.

CB Brandon Sebastian, Boston College

Despite poor 40 and agility testing, Sebastian’s highlight reel from Boston College is rife with examples of speed adequate enough to shut windows and close on receivers. That closing ability led to 8 interceptions, 4 of which came in 2021, and a whopping 29 pass deflections over 43 games as an Eagle. It’ll be all about reigning in that aggressiveness while maintaining his on-ball production as a pro.

S Raheem Layne, Indiana

Indiana’s 2019 Special Teams Player of the Year, Layne moved from cornerback to safety during spring practice prior to the 2020 season. An injury then wiped out his entire campaign, leaving him with just 12 career games as a safety, all from 2021. With 147 tackles, 1 interception, 7 pass deflections, and 2 forced fumbles in his 50 career games, Layne was only an average producer. His toughness, willingness to adapt and special teams ability could nonetheless be a path to a roster spot.

S Skyler Thomas, Liberty

Thomas started his career at Washington State, where he had 152 tackles and 6 interceptions over three seasons. He opted out of the 2020 season and then transferred to Liberty, where he had 55 tackles and 2 interceptions in 2021. He’s a versatile defensive back with the ability to play inside or outside at corner as well as his natural position of safety. With a 4.52 40 under his belt, it’s clear Brandon Staley and co. are prioritizing speed on the back end of this Chargers defense.

K James McCourt, Illinois

A three-year starter at kicker, McCourt is the eighth-most accurate kicker in Illinois program history with a career line of 37-for-52. 8 of those makes came from 50+ yards, an Illini program record. He also has the cool under pressure needed from kickers, as evidenced by his game-winner to complete an upset over #6 Wisconsin in 2019. While he may not crack Los Angeles’ opening roster, the Chargers may be keeping McCourt’s number on speed dial in case Dustin Hopkins goes down during the season.