OPINION: T.J. Finley isn’t the answer for Bryan Harsin and Auburn

Auburn Wire writer River Wells makes his case against quarterback T.J. Finley — and the “continuity” he provides at the position.

Much is often made about the concept of consistency.

Consistency and continuity are important — it’s comfortable, after all, and having steady performance year in and year out is what often makes the best of programs in any sport. Getting to the point where you can have that in your program is a desire that every coach covets.

But first, you have to get to that point. Coach [autotag]Bryan Harsin[/autotag] shouldn’t feel comfortable right now, and the last thing he needs is to play it safe and go for continuity over risking potential. And if the reports that he likes [autotag]T.J. Finley[/autotag] to start at Auburn have any weight to them, he’d be making exactly the type of decision that is going to get him fired at the end of the year.

Harsin seems to like the continuity that Finley brings to the team, and he praised his ability to “operate” his offense during scrimmages. But experience means nothing when that experience didn’t produce good results, and the unfortunate fact of the matter is that Finley has failed to produce in starting scenarios across his career.

His injury in 2021 should be kept in mind, but even so, he’s never completed over 60 percent of passes in his career and had averaged less than a touchdown per game in both rushing and passing. He wasn’t much of a threat on the ground at LSU either, averaging just 1.2 yards per carry and only scoring a single touchdown.

Consistency is very important, but consistently poor play gets you nowhere, and Harsin has to abandon the idea of comfortable continuity to save his job. He needs to take a risk, and playing transfers Zach Calzada or Robby Ashford or four-star prospect Holden Geriner have a much higher potential to produce results than Finley would this year.

If Finley is named the starter, expect more of the same we’ve seen of him in the past two years and the Auburn offense to flounder without the production through the air it needs from its quarterback.

This season for Auburn football isn’t like any other, and Harsin needs to realize that to truly change his fate.

[mm-video type=video id=01gaw9e2v9y11e4xf3dw playlist_id=01eqbyzb4ahnasj2m3 player_id=01eqbvp13nn1gy6hd4 image=https://images2.minutemediacdn.com/image/upload/video/thumbnail/mmplus/01gaw9e2v9y11e4xf3dw/01gaw9e2v9y11e4xf3dw-cd4ebdcad83a2681d9988d36d6313320.jpg]

[vertical-gallery id=51984]

Auburn fans need to treat TJ Finley fairly

Auburn fans are continuously disgruntled with the quarterback position.

Auburn fans are continuously disgruntled with the quarterback position.

TJ Finley, Auburn’s backup quarterback, saw action in the second half of a 60-20 blowout over Akron. Finley completed two passes for 22 yards. He also scored on a one-yard touchdown run.

Some fans took to social media to express their displeasure with Finley’s performance in the blowout.

Zac Blackerby of the Locked on Auburn podcast broke down on his latest episode why some fans on social media need to tamp down their expectations for TJ Finley in settings like the one he was in on Saturday night.

“A lot of people discredit TJ Finley quickly by saying that ‘this never really was a quarterback battle’ or that ‘TJ Finley looked lost out there,’ and I dont think thats fair to TJ Finley, because the game was over,” Blackerby said. “It’s a different mindset. Bo Nix had access to the opening script as far as playcalls go. He had access to the full playbook, Mike Bobo was calling a game trying score points while Bo was in. It’s just a different offensive mentality at that stage of the game. (Nix) had his starters around him, Finley did not. Let’s not act like Finley is some incompetent quarterback.”


Stream college football games from the SEC, Big 12, The American, and more on ESPN+


[listicle id=22395]

Contact/Follow us @theauburnwire on Twitter, and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Auburn news, notes, and opinion.

Is Bo Nix going to be the starter against Akron?

Is it no longer Bo Time?

Is it no longer Bo Time?

Nix has reportedly been struggling in each of Auburn’s fall scrimmages and might be falling behind in camp. TJ Finley has reportedly looked more accurate and not as mistake-prone as Nix. Demetris Davis did not participate in the second scrimmage, but he was one of the few bright spots offensively in the first.

Could we possibly see Finley or Davis starting Week 1?

Lindsay Crosby of Newstalk WANI joined Zac Blackerby on the “Locked on Auburn” podcast to share his opinion on Bo Nix’s future at Auburn.

With as much change as they have put into this offense, as far as completely changing how we do things, and not changing the offensive line personnel, I think that means (the coaching staff) understands that Bo’s mobility gives us the best chance to win. He’s been on campus and around these coaches a lot more than TJ Finley. He’s had a lot more opportunities to learn the playbook. Now, am I 100% sure that Bo will finish the season as the starter? No. I’m not. I can see a possibility where through poor performance (from Nix), TJ Finley takes over. I think one way or another, this is the final season that Bo Nix starts at Auburn.

If he has a really good to great season, obviously he goes pro. But if he has just an “OK” season, I think we’re going to see some sort of change made in the offseason because I don’t think Bryan Harsin is going to accept “just OK” out of a third-year quarterback in the SEC. One way or another, this is the last season he starts for Auburn.

[listicle id=21051]

Contact/Follow us @theauburnwire on Twitter, and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Auburn news, notes, and opinion.